NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: Southern Health Service & Ors. v. Smith [2001] NSWCA 369
FILE NUMBER(S):
40365/00
HEARING DATE(S): 6 June 2001
JUDGMENT DATE: 18/10/2000
PARTIES:
Southern Health Service - first appellant
Dr. Barbara Graham - second appellant
Dr. G.J. Cocker - third appellant
Dr. M. Hassan - fourth appellant
Geoffrey Wayne Smith - respondent
JUDGMENT OF: Powell JA Hodgson JA Greg James J
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 5362/98
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Williams DCJ
COUNSEL:
Mr. S. Walmsley SC for appellants
Mr. M. Cranitch SC with Mr. G. Wilson for respondent
SOLICITORS:
Colin Biggers & Paisley, Sydney for appellants
Nevill & Edwards, Sydney for respondent
CATCHWORDS:
TORT - Negligence - Damages - Appeal - Failure to allow for vicissitudes - Whether balanced by other errors - Whether new trial should be ordered. ND.
LEGISLATION CITED:
DECISION:
See par.53 of judgment
JUDGMENT:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEALCA 40365/00
DC 5362/98
POWELL JA
HODGSON JA
GREG JAMES J
Thursday 18th October 2001.
SOUTHERN HEALTH SERVICE & ORS. V. SMITH
Judgment
POWELL JA: As the essential facts which have given rise to this appeal are set out in the Judgment which has been prepared by Hodgson JA, which Judgment I have read in draft, it is not necessary for me to repeat them here.
I regret to say that I regard William DCJ’s Judgments, insofar as they deal with the matters which have been debated on the hearing of the appeal, as unsatisfactory.
Past Economic Loss
Australia
Save that, in his first Judgment Williams DCJ recorded (RAB 54) that that loss “(had) been assessed in round figures at $6,0000.00”, and, later (RAB 58), that that sum “(had) not been mathematically disputed”, his Honour did not record his reasons for adopting that sum as the appropriate sum to be allowed.
The only evidence directed to past economic loss in Australia which was given on the hearing was as follows:
a.the Respondent’s evidence that, although continuing to work as a lodge liaison officer, he was not able to continue to work as a ski instructor in Australia;
b.the Respondent’s evidence that this caused a loss of $400.00 per week before tax;
c.the Respondent’s income tax assessment for the financial year 1996-1997 (Black AB 190) and a “Tax Calculation” for the financial year 1997-1998 (Black AB 186) which revealed a taxable income in the former year of $15,897.00 and in the latter year of $13,064.00, and tax assessed in the former year of $2,099.40 and tax calculated in the latter year of $1,532.80, a difference in the nett income after tax for those two years of $2,266.40. No figures for the financial year 1998-1999 or for the period from 1 July 1990 to the date of hearing were tendered.
This evidence, in my view, provided a very flimsy basis for an assessment of $6,000.00 for past economic loss.
United States
In his second Judgment, Williams DCJ wrote (RAB 62):
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Health Service v Smith and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWCA 369
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in calculating future economic loss, particularly concerning the allowance for vicissitudes of life and the deduction of necessary expenses. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the primary judge had adequately accounted for the conventional 15% deduction for vicissitudes in relation to future economic loss in Australia, and whether the calculation of future economic loss in the USA had properly deducted expenses necessary to earn that income. The court also had to assess whether the primary judge's assessment of the respondent's future earning capacity, particularly in the USA, was supported by evidence and whether there was an inconsistency in the judge's findings regarding the duration of the respondent's potential working life.
The court found that the primary judge's judgment was fundamentally flawed, particularly in the calculation of damages. The appellants argued that the primary judge failed to deduct a conventional 15% for vicissitudes from the future economic loss in Australia, and that the calculation of future economic loss in the USA did not adequately account for expenses. The respondent contended that the multiplier used for Australian future economic loss was appropriate given his intention to work until an advanced age, and that the calculation for USA economic loss was reasonable. However, the court identified an irreconcilable inconsistency between the primary judge's view on the respondent's likely continued work at Vail and the duration implied by the multiplier used for Australian economic loss.
Consequently, the court upheld the appeal, set aside the verdict and judgment of the primary judge, and ordered a new trial limited to the assessment of damages. The costs of the appeal were awarded to the appellant, with the costs of the first trial to abide the outcome of the retrial.
Orders
Orders of the court
See par.53 of judgment
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In relation to future economic loss, concerning activities in Australia, Mr. Walmsley SC for the appellant submitted that the trial judge should have deducted the conventional figure of 15 per cent for vicissitudes from the amount of $31,364.00. He referred to Wynn v. NSW Insurance Ministerial Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 485. He submitted that the circumstance that the judgment contained no mention of allowance for vicissitudes was indicative of error. A possible explanation for this could be found in the Black Book p.89, recording an exchange which could have left his Honour under the misapprehension that vicissitudes had already been taken into account in arriving at the relevant multiplier. In relation to economic loss concerning activities in the USA, Mr. Walmsley submitted that the trial judge’s calculations were based on a weekly figure of A$304.00, arrived at without deducting expenses necessary to earn that income: see James Hardie & Co. Limited v. Roberts (1999) 47 NSWLR 425 at 440. He submitted that the full deductions claimed in the USA tax returns should have been taken off as expenses; but alternatively, if the claimed deductions in respect of rent and food were not treated as expenses, then at least the deductions in relation to air fares, equipment, costs, and other expenses such as telephone expenses and health club dues, should have been taken off. If one took those expenses as amounting to about US$3,500.00 per annum, this would reduce the weekly figure from A$304.00 to about A$200.00. Taking the trial judge’s multiplier of 665.2, this would give a figure of $132,040.00. Furthermore, Mr. Walmsley submitted, the trial judge failed to take into account vicissitudes in relation to future economic loss from activities in the USA. Accordingly, 15 per cent should be deducted from the figure of $132,040.00, and also from the gratuities figure of $92,462.00 adopted by the trial judge. In relation to past USA economic loss, expenses of about $5,000.00 should be deducted from the $20,000.00 awarded in relation to the year lost from USA activities, giving a figure of $15,000.00. For the respondent, Mr. Cranitch SC pointed out, in relation to future economic loss concerning activities in Australia, that the trial judge’s multiplier 787.9 was that appropriate in relation to earnings to age sixty-five, whereas the respondent had given evidence that he had calculated at forty, before the incident occurred, that he had a good thirty years ahead of him. That evidence was not challenged, and was apparently accepted by the trial judge. The appropriate multiplier for working to age seventy would be 922.2, and 15 per cent from that would give 783.87, approximating to the figure adopted by the trial judge. No error in the result was shown. Mr. Cranitch submitted, in relation to future economic loss concerning USA activities, that it was not shown that A$304.00 per week was arrived at without deductions for expenses. In any event, he submitted, this Court could not find that this was not a reasonable estimate of the respondent’s earning capacity.