Southern Health Service & Ors. v Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
CITATION: Southern Health Service & Ors. v. Smith [2001] NSWCA 369
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40365/00
HEARING DATE(S): 6 June 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
18 October 2000

PARTIES :


Southern Health Service - first appellant
Dr. Barbara Graham - second appellant
Dr. G.J. Cocker - third appellant
Dr. M. Hassan - fourth appellant
Geoffrey Wayne Smith - respondent
JUDGMENT OF: Powell JA at 1-15; Hodgson JA at 16-53; Greg James J at 54-67
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : District Court
LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :
DC 5362/98
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Williams DCJ
COUNSEL: Mr. S. Walmsley SC for appellants
Mr. M. Cranitch SC with Mr. G. Wilson for respondent
SOLICITORS: Colin Biggers & Paisley, Sydney for appellants
Nevill & Edwards, Sydney for respondent
CATCHWORDS: TORT - Negligence - Damages - Appeal - Failure to allow for vicissitudes - Whether balanced by other errors - Whether new trial should be ordered. ND.
DECISION: See par.53 of judgment

    IN THE SUPREME COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES
    COURT OF APPEAL
    CA 40365/00
    DC 5362/98

POWELL JA


HODGSON JA


GREG JAMES J


    Thursday 18th October 2001.
    SOUTHERN HEALTH SERVICE & ORS. V. SMITH
    Judgment

As the essential facts which have given rise to this appeal are set out in the Judgment which has been prepared by Hodgson JA, which Judgment I have read in draft, it is not necessary for me to repeat them here.

2 I regret to say that I regard William DCJ’s Judgments, insofar as they deal with the matters which have been debated on the hearing of the appeal, as unsatisfactory.


    Past Economic Loss
    Save that, in his first Judgment Williams DCJ recorded (RAB 54) that that loss “(had) been assessed in round figures at $6,0000.00”, and, later (RAB 58), that that sum “(had) not been mathematically disputed”, his Honour did not record his reasons for adopting that sum as the appropriate sum to be allowed.

4 The only evidence directed to past economic loss in Australia which was given on the hearing was as follows:

    a. the Respondent’s evidence that, although continuing to work as a lodge liaison officer, he was not able to continue to work as a ski instructor in Australia;
    b. the Respondent’s evidence that this caused a loss of $400.00 per week before tax;
    c. the Respondent’s income tax assessment for the financial year 1996-1997 (Black AB 190) and a “Tax Calculation” for the financial year 1997-1998 (Black AB 186) which revealed a taxable income in the former year of $15,897.00 and in the latter year of $13,064.00, and tax assessed in the former year of $2,099.40 and tax calculated in the latter year of $1,532.80, a difference in the nett income after tax for those two years of $2,266.40. No figures for the financial year 1998-1999 or for the period from 1 July 1990 to the date of hearing were tendered.

5 This evidence, in my view, provided a very flimsy basis for an assessment of $6,000.00 for past economic loss.

    In his second Judgment,…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Health Service & Ors. v Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southern Health Service and others appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a judgment of the Supreme Court awarding damages to Ms. Smith for negligence. The dispute concerned the assessment of damages, specifically whether the primary judge had adequately accounted for future contingencies when calculating the award.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge erred in their assessment of damages by failing to make a sufficient allowance for the vicissitudes of life, and whether this error, if it existed, was balanced by other errors in the judgment. The court was also required to determine whether, in light of any identified errors, a new trial should be ordered.

The Court of Appeal, in its reasoning, considered the principles governing the assessment of damages in negligence claims, particularly the need to account for future uncertainties. Powell JA and Hodgson JA engaged in detailed analysis of the primary judge's calculations and the evidence presented. Hodgson JA, in particular, provided an extensive review of the relevant authorities and the application of the "vicissitudes" principle. The court ultimately found that the primary judge had made an error in the assessment of damages, specifically in relation to the allowance for future contingencies.

The court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the judgment of the Supreme Court be set aside, and a new trial be ordered on the issue of damages only.

Orders

Orders of the court

See par.53 of judgment

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.