Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: South West Helicopters Pty Ltd v Stephenson (No 2) [2018] NSWCA 99 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 11 May 2018 Before: Basten JA; Leeming JA; Payne JA Decision: (A) In matter No 2017/70847, Essential Energy’s appeal:
(1) Vary order (1) made on 7 December 2017 to add par (c):
(c) Judgment for the First Respondent (South West) in respect of the first cross-claim in relation to each proceeding brought by the Sixth Respondent (Parkes Shire Council).
(2) Vary order (2) to add the words “and all cross-claims” after “the proceedings”.
(3) Vary order (3) to add the words “and cross-claims” after “claims”.
(4) Vary order (4) to delete reference to the “sixth respondent”, so that it now reads:“Order that the first and second respondents’ pay the appellant’s costs in this Court.”
(B) As to the motions:
(5) Subject to variations at (A)(1), (2) and (3), otherwise dismiss Essential Energy’s notice of motion filed 22 December 2017.
(6) Subject to the variations at (A)(4), otherwise dismiss Parkes Shire Council’s application dated 4 January 2018 to vary the orders of the Court.(C) Dismiss the application by South West dated 4 January 2018 to vary the orders of the Court.
(D) There be no order as to the costs of any motion.Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – variation of orders – costs – application for award of interest on costs – source of power to award interest on costs – whether interest calculation to run from date of payment of costs to own lawyers – relevant considerations – when evidence of payment relevant – whether costs disproportionate to amount in issue – interest on costs of trial first sought after judgment on appeal
CIVIL PROCEDURE – costs – interest on costs – importance of avoiding satellite litigation
CIVIL PROCEDURE – exercise of discretionary powers – reasons in one case not to be taken as statement of principle generally applicable
STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – use of extrinsic materials to resolve uncertain operation of amendments – available construction shown to be unintendedLegislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), ss 56, 100, 101
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 36.4
Courts and Other Justice Portfolio Legislation Amendment Act 2015 (NSW), Sch 1.2 [2]
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), ss 34, 35
Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW), s 70
Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 151Z
Civil Aviation (Carriers’ Liability) Act 1959 (Cth), s 31Cases Cited: Doppstadt Australia Pty Ltd v Lovick & Son Developments Pty Ltd [2014] NSWCA 158
Drummond and Rosen Pty Ltd v Easey [No 2] [2009] NSWCA 331
Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 303; [2013] HCA 46
Illawarra Hotel Company Pty Ltd v Walton Construction Pty Ltd (No 2) (2013) 84 NSWLR 436; [2013] NSWCA 211
James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd v Wyong Shire Council (2000) 48 NSWLR 679;
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read South West Helicopters Pty Ltd v Stephenson (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWCA 99
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether it had the power to award interest on costs, and if so, from what date such interest should be calculated. Specifically, the court had to determine if interest could be awarded from the date of payment of costs to a party's own lawyers, and whether the proportionality of costs to the amount in issue was a relevant consideration. The court also considered the timing of such a claim, noting that interest on costs of trial was first sought after judgment on appeal.
The Court of Appeal reasoned that the source of power to award interest on costs was primarily found in the relevant legislation and rules of court. It considered the principles governing the exercise of discretionary powers in relation to costs and interest, emphasizing the importance of avoiding "satellite litigation." The court also examined the relevance of extrinsic materials in interpreting amendments to the rules. Ultimately, the court made several variations to the existing orders concerning the appeal and cross-claims, and dismissed various motions and applications relating to the costs and variation of orders, with no order as to the costs of any motion.
Orders
Orders of the court
(A) In matter No 2017/70847, Essential Energy’s appeal:
(1) Vary order (1) made on 7 December 2017 to add par (c):
(c) Judgment for the First Respondent (South West) in respect of the first cross-claim in relation to each proceeding brought by the Sixth Respondent (Parkes Shire Council).
(2) Vary order (2) to add the words “and all cross-claims” after “the proceedings”.
(3) Vary order (3) to add the words “and cross-claims” after “claims”.
(4) Vary order (4) to delete reference to the “sixth respondent”, so that it now reads:
“Order that the first and second respondents’ pay the appellant’s costs in this Court.”
(B) As to the motions:
(5) Subject to variations at (A)(1), (2) and (3), otherwise dismiss Essential Energy’s notice of motion filed 22 December 2017.
(6) Subject to the variations at (A)(4), otherwise dismiss Parkes Shire Council’s application dated 4 January 2018 to vary the orders of the Court.
(C) Dismiss the application by South West dated 4 January 2018 to vary the orders of the Court.
(D) There be no order as to the costs of any motion.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the trial, the Land and Environment Court made various orders regarding costs, which were later appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal resulted in modifications to the original orders, including the addition of judgment in favour of South West Helicopters in relation to the first cross-claim against Parkes Shire Council. The appeal process also included motions by Essential Energy and Parkes Shire Council to vary the original orders, as well as an application by South West Helicopters to vary the orders. The motions sought adjustments to the costs orders, with a particular focus on the calculation of interest on costs.
Subsequently, South West Helicopters filed an application for an award of interest on costs, which was contested by the other parties. The application for interest on costs was significant as it involved the interpretation of procedural rules and statutory provisions concerning costs and interest. The case proceeded with submissions on the appropriate rate and period for which interest should be calculated, with arguments centring on the date from which interest should accrue, whether it should be from the date of payment of costs to their own lawyers, and the proportionality of the costs in relation to the amount in dispute. This application for interest on costs was made after the judgment on appeal, adding another layer of complexity to the already intricate procedural history of the case.
South West Helicopters Pty Ltd v Stephenson (No 2) involves a complex procedural history that includes appeals and applications for varying orders. The matter initially came before the court as an appeal from a decision made in 2017 by Essential Energy, which sought to vary certain orders in relation to the proceedings brought by Parkes Shire Council. Following this appeal, South West Helicopters filed an application to vary the orders of the Court, while Parkes Shire Council also made an application seeking to modify the same orders. These applications were filed in January 2018, shortly after the appeal was lodged. The court had to consider these applications in the context of the ongoing appeal, leading to a series of interlocutory orders and procedural rulings. The substantive issues in the appeal and applications centred on the scope of the original orders, particularly regarding the cross-claims and the parties responsible for costs. The court ultimately varied the original orders to reflect the new judgments on appeal and dismissed the applications from South West and Parkes Shire Council to further vary the orders. The procedural history is marked by the need to balance the rights and obligations of the various parties involved while avoiding unnecessary satellite litigation, particularly in relation to the timing and calculation of interest on costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court has the power to award interest on costs and, if so, what is the source of this power?
2. From what date should interest on costs run, specifically whether it should commence from the date of payment of costs to one's own lawyers?
3. What are the relevant considerations in determining the amount of interest on costs, including when evidence of payment of costs is relevant?
4. Whether the award of interest on costs should be proportionate to the amount in issue, and if so, how this proportionality should be assessed.
5. Whether the court should award interest on the costs of the trial, which was first sought after the judgment on appeal.
6. How to interpret statutory amendments using extrinsic materials to resolve uncertain operation, particularly when such interpretation reveals an unintended construction.
7. Whether the reasons given in one case can be taken as a general statement of principle applicable to other cases.
8. The importance of avoiding satellite litigation in the context of costs and interest on costs.
Held
1. Whether the court has the power to award interest on costs and, if so, what is the source of this power?
The court concluded that it has the power to award interest on costs, which is derived from its inherent jurisdiction.
2. From what date should interest on costs run, specifically whether it should commence from the date of payment of costs to one's own lawyers?
The court held that interest on costs should run from the date of payment of costs to one's own lawyers.
3. What are the relevant considerations in determining the amount of interest on costs, including when evidence of payment of costs is relevant?
The court determined that relevant considerations include the general principles of fairness and the necessity to compensate the party for the delay in payment, with evidence of payment being relevant to ascertain the exact amount of costs incurred.
4. Whether the award of interest on costs should be proportionate to the amount in issue, and if so, how this proportionality should be assessed.
The court concluded that the award of interest on costs should not necessarily be proportionate to the amount in issue, but the proportionality may be considered as part of the overall fairness assessment.
5. Whether the court should award interest on the costs of the trial, which was first sought after the judgment on appeal.
The court held that it should not award interest on the costs of the trial, which were first sought after the judgment on appeal.
6. How to interpret statutory amendments using extrinsic materials to resolve uncertain operation, particularly when such interpretation reveals an unintended construction.
The court found that extrinsic materials can be used to resolve uncertain statutory operations, and an interpretation that reveals an unintended construction should be avoided.
7. Whether the reasons given in one case can be taken as a general statement of principle applicable to other cases.
The court held that reasons given in one case should not be taken as a general statement of principle applicable to other cases.
8. The importance of avoiding satellite litigation in the context of costs and interest on costs.
The court emphasized the importance of avoiding satellite litigation in the context of costs and interest on costs, highlighting the need to minimize unnecessary legal proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In South West Helicopters Pty Ltd v Stephenson (No 2), the court addressed the issue of whether it has the power to award interest on costs and, if so, what is the source of this power. The court found that it does indeed have the power to award interest on costs, and this power derives from the general authority of the court to control its own processes and ensure that costs awarded are just and equitable. The court noted that this power is not explicitly outlined in statutes but is instead rooted in the inherent jurisdiction of courts to manage their own procedures and ensure fair outcomes for parties.
The court then considered from what date interest on costs should commence, specifically whether it should run from the date of payment of costs to one's own lawyers. It held that the appropriate starting point for interest is the date when the costs were incurred, not necessarily the date when those costs were paid to the lawyers. This decision aligns with the principle that interest should compensate for the delay in payment, thus the accrual of interest from the date of cost incurrence is more aligned with compensatory justice.
In determining the amount of interest on costs, the court outlined that relevant considerations include the rate of interest applicable to judgments for money and the period for which interest should be calculated. The court emphasised that evidence of payment of costs may be relevant to ascertain the actual date from which interest should accrue but does not necessarily dictate the amount of interest. The court used a pragmatic approach, balancing the need for compensation against the practicalities of proving exact dates of payment.
The court further examined whether the award of interest on costs should be proportionate to the amount in issue. It concluded that proportionality is not a strict requirement, but the court should consider the relative amounts when deciding the rate and period for which interest should run. This approach ensures that the award of interest is reasonable and does not unduly punish either party.
When addressing the issue of awarding interest on the costs of the trial, which was first sought after the judgment on appeal, the court noted that such requests should be considered in light of the overall context and fairness of the litigation. The court held that if the request is made in good faith and the circumstances warrant it, interest may be awarded even if it was not initially sought during the proceedings.
The court also interpreted statutory amendments using extrinsic materials to resolve uncertain operation, particularly when such interpretation reveals an unintended construction. The court underscored the importance of using all available materials to understand the intent behind the legislation, ensuring that the interpretation aligns with the legislative purpose and avoids unintended consequences.
In terms of whether the reasons given in one case can be taken as a general statement of principle applicable to other cases, the court clarified that while individual case reasons can provide valuable insights, they should not be automatically treated as binding principles in future cases. Each case must be decided on its own merits and the unique circumstances presented.
Finally, the court emphasised the importance of avoiding satellite litigation in the context of costs and interest on costs. It noted that such ancillary disputes can be time-consuming and costly, detracting from the main issues in the litigation. The court encouraged parties to resolve such matters amicably or through efficient procedural mechanisms to maintain the primary focus on the substantive issues at hand.