South Australia Police v Hill

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Criminal)

SOUTH AUSTRALIA POLICE v HILL

[2022] SASCA 22

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, the Honourable Justice Lovell, the Honourable Justice Livesey, the Honourable Justice Doyle and the Honourable Justice Blue)

22 March 2022

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - PLEAS - GENERAL PLEAS - PLEA OF GUILTY - WITHDRAWAL AND RESTORATION OF PLEA

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - ASSAULT - CIRCUMSTANCES OF AGGRAVATION AND AGGRAVATED ASSAULTS

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - CRIMINAL LIABILITY AND CAPACITY - DOUBLE JEOPARDY

The respondent was charged by Police with assault of the complainant aggravated because he was (formerly) in a relationship with her, and contravening a term of an intervention order for her protection in a manner involving physical violence or the threat of physical violence, committed on 16 December 2019.

The respondent was later charged by Police with assault of the complainant aggravated because he was (formerly) in a relationship with her and/or used an offensive weapon, and contravening a term of an intervention order for her protection, committed on 29 March 2020.

The respondent pleaded guilty to each of these four counts (together with other counts). The Magistrate ruled that each pair of counts involved impermissible double charging. The Magistrate granted permission to the respondent to withdraw his guilty pleas to two of the counts and dismissed them. The Magistrate imposed a single penalty in respect of the remaining counts.

The Police appeal against the orders permitting the respondent to withdraw his guilty pleas to, and dismissing, the two counts on the ground that the Magistrate erred in ruling that each pair of charges involved impermissible double charging.

The appeal raises two issues. First, does subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) create a single offence or multiple offences? Secondly, does a conviction for an offence of contravening a condition of an intervention order, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence, preclude a conviction for the substantive offence when the substantive offence is aggravated by another circumstance and vice versa?

Held by the Court (allowing the appeal):

1(Per Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA) Subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) creates a single offence albeit with differential maximum penalties depending on the existence of circumstances of aggravation (at [143] per Lovell and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA (Doyle JA agreeing)).

(Per Kourakis CJ) It is not necessary to decide whether subsection 20(3) creates one or two offences depending on the existence of circumstances of aggravation (at [19] per Kourakis CJ).

2(Per Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA) A conviction for contravening an intervention order condition, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence, does not preclude a conviction for the substantive offence or vice versa (at [172] per Lovell and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA; at [178] per Doyle JA).

(Per Kourakis CJ) A conviction for contravening an intervention…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Australia Police v Hill and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASCA 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The South Australia Police appealed to the Court of Appeal against a Magistrate's decision to dismiss two charges against the respondent, Russell Hill. The dispute concerned whether the respondent could be convicted of both an aggravated assault and the contravention of an intervention order arising from the same conduct, with the Magistrate having ruled that such a course would constitute impermissible double charging. The appeal was referred to the Court of Appeal due to the significant public importance of the issues raised.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine two primary legal questions. Firstly, whether subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) creates a single offence or multiple offences, depending on the existence of circumstances of aggravation. Secondly, the Court had to consider whether a conviction for contravening an intervention order, where the conduct also constitutes a substantive offence, precludes a conviction for that substantive offence, particularly when the substantive offence is aggravated by another circumstance, and vice versa.

A majority of the Court (Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA, and Blue AJA) held that subsection 20(3) creates a single offence, with differential maximum penalties depending on the presence of aggravating circumstances. They further determined that a conviction for contravening an intervention order, where the conduct comprises a substantive offence, does not preclude a conviction for the substantive offence, or vice versa. Kourakis CJ, while not definitively ruling on the single versus multiple offence question, agreed that a conviction for contravening an intervention order does not preclude a conviction for the substantive offence, even if aggravated.

Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal. Subject to hearing the parties, the Court ordered that convictions be recorded on the two counts that had been dismissed by the Magistrate, without altering the sentence already imposed by the Magistrate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held by the Court (allowing the appeal):

1 (Per Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA) Subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) creates a single offence albeit with differential maximum penalties depending on the existence of circumstances of aggravation (at [xxx] per Lovell and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA (Doyle JA agreeing)).

(Per Kourakis CJ) It is not necessary to decide whether subsection 20(3) creates one or two offences depending on the existence of circumstances of aggravation (at [xxx] per Kourakis CJ).

2 (Per Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA) A conviction for contravening an intervention order condition, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence, does not preclude a conviction for the substantive offence or vice versa (at [xxx] per Lovell and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA; at [xxx] per Doyle JA).

(Per Kourakis CJ) A conviction for contravening an intervention order condition, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence aggravated by another circumstance, does not preclude a conviction for the substantive offence or vice versa (at [xxx] per Kourakis CJ).

3 (Per Kourakis CJ, Lovell, Doyle and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA) The appeal should be allowed and, subject to hearing the parties, a conviction recorded on the two counts dismissed by the Magistrate with no alteration to the sentence imposed by the Magistrate under section 26 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (at [xxx] per Lovell and Livesey JJA and Blue AJA (Kourakis CJ and Doyle JA agreeing)).

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal raises two issues of general public importance. First, does subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) (the Act) create a single offence or multiple offences? Secondly, does a conviction for an offence of contravening a condition of an intervention order, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence, preclude a conviction for the substantive offence when the substantive office is aggravated by another circumstance and vice versa? For this reason, the appeal was referred by a single judge to the Court of Appeal. Background On 2 October 2019 a final intervention order was made against the respondent for the protection of AB. The first term of the intervention order was that the respondent not assault, threaten, harass or intimidate AB. Other terms included that the respondent not follow AB or enter or remain within 50 metres of the boundary where she resides. On 16 December 2019 the respondent and AB met at Hollywood Plaza. The respondent became aggressive and AB left. He followed her. Her grabbed her arm, her hair and her neck; pushed her down the street; and bit her on the arm. The grabbing, pushing and biting comprised the assault the subject of count 1, which was aggravated because the respondent was or was formerly in a relationship with the victim.[77] This conduct also comprised the contravention of the intervention order by assault involving physical violence or the threat of physical violence the subject of count 2.[77] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) section 5AA(1)(g). On 29 March 2020 the respondent was present with AB at her residence. He became aggressive and she left and went into another room. He followed her. He threw a mobile phone at her, hitting her on the arm; threw a boot at her, hitting her; grabbed her by the neck and dragged her into the bedroom; and grabbed her by the throat and headbutted her. The throwing, grabbing, dragging and headbutting comprised the assault the subject of count 3, which was aggravated because the respondent was or was formerly in a relationship with the victim[78] and he used an offensive weapon.[79] This assault also comprised the contravention of the intervention order the subject of count 4.[78] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) section 5AA(1)(g).[79] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) section 5AA(1)(b). On 21 December 2020 the respondent pleaded guilty to the four counts, together with the other counts. Upon the prosecutor reading out the facts of charge in relation to the December 2019 offending, the Magistrate expressed the view that counts 1 and 2 gave rise to issues of double jeopardy and invited written submissions by the parties. On 29 January 2021 the Magistrate invited the prosecutor to read out the facts of charge in relation to the March 2020 offending and then expressed the view that counts 3 and 4 also gave rise to issues of double jeopardy. The Magistrate gave ex tempore reasons for ruling that each pair of counts involved impermissible double charging. The Magistrate required the prosecution to elect on which count in each pair to proceed. The prosecutor refused to elect. The Magistrate granted permission to the respondent to withdraw his guilty pleas to counts 1 and 4 and dismissed those charges.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The consequences of the jury’s adjudication extending to the circumstance of aggravation are not limited to sentencing. Even though not expressly addressed by s 5AA of the CLCA, those consequences must extend also to the application of the principles of double jeopardy. It follows that yet again it is not necessary for this Court to decide whether s 5AA of the CLCA creates one or several offences. Whichever is the case, the consequence of the mandatory requirement to plead the circumstances of aggravation and of the consequential extension of the jury’s adjudicative function to determine the existence of a pleaded circumstance of aggravation means that for all practical purposes the verdict returned by the jury on a charge of an offence in its aggravated form operates in the same way as a verdict on a charge of a different offence.Conclusion I would allow the appeal and join in making the orders proposed by Blue AJA. LOVELL, LIVESEY JJA AND BLUE AJA: Russell Hill, the respondent, was charged by South Australia Police, the appellant, with assault of AB, aggravated because he was (formerly) in a relationship with her (count 1),[73] and contravening a term of an intervention order for the protection of AB in a manner involving physical violence or the threat of physical violence to her (count 2),[74] committed on 16 December 2019.[73] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) subsection 20(3).[74] Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) section 31(2aa)(b). The respondent was later charged by the Police with the assault of AB, aggravated because he was (formerly) in a relationship with her and/or he used an offensive weapon (count 3),[75] and contravening a term of an intervention order for the protection of AB (count 4),[76] committed on 29 March 2020.[75] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) subsection 20(3). This count was count 1 on a different information but has been renumbered for ease of reference.[76] Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) section 31(2). This count was count 6 on a different information but has been renumbered for ease of reference. The respondent pleaded guilty to each of these four counts (together with other counts). The Magistrate ruled that each pair of counts involved impermissible double charging. The Magistrate granted permission to the respondent to withdraw his guilty pleas to counts 1 and 4 and dismissed those counts. The Magistrate imposed a single penalty in respect of the remaining counts. The Police appeal against the orders permitting the respondent to withdraw his guilty pleas to, and dismissing, counts 1 and 4 on the ground that the Magistrate erred in ruling that each pair of charges involved impermissible double charging. The appeal raises two issues of general public importance. First, does subsection 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) (the Act) create a single offence or multiple offences? Secondly, does a conviction for an offence of contravening a condition of an intervention order, where the contravening conduct comprises a substantive offence, preclude a conviction for the substantive offence when the substantive office is aggravated by another circumstance and vice versa? For this reason, the appeal was referred by a single judge to the Court of Appeal. Background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.