Soryal v Director of Professional Services

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Soryal v Director of Professional Services [2023] FCA 326

File number(s): QUD 416 of 2021
Judgment of: COLLIER J
Date of judgment:  12 April 2023
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW –  judicial review of decision of Director of Professional Services Review to refer the applicant to a Professional Services Review Committee to investigate potential inappropriate conduct – Part VAA Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) – where applicant a registered dentist under Health Practitioner Regulation National Law – where applicant held Medicare Provider Number pursuant to the Health Insurance Regulations 2018 (Cth) – where applicant permitted his Medicare Provider Number to be used by third parties for flat retainer fee – where third parties engaged oral health therapists to provide services under Medicare Child Dental Benefits Scheme using applicant’s Medicare Provider Number – where Director formed concerns regarding dental services provided under applicant’s Medicare Dental Provider Number by oral health therapists – where applicant claimed he did not personally provide services subject of review – whether Director had jurisdiction to make referral – whether s 81(2) of Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) construed as encompassing supervision of services – application dismissed
Legislation:

Dental Benefits Act 2008 (Cth) ss 3, 4

Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) Part VAA, ss 81(1), 81(2), 82, 82(2), 86, 88A, 88A(2), 88A(4), 88B, 88B(a), 88B(b), 89C, 89C(1), 89C(1)(b), 89C(1)(b)(i), 89C(2), 90, 90(1)(b), 91, 91(1), 93, 93(1), 93(1A), 93(6), 93(7B), 95(1), 95(1)(a), 95(1)(b), 95(1A), 98, 102, 105A, 106K, 106K(1)

Health Legislation Amendment (Improved Medicare Compliance and Other Measures) Act 2018 (Cth)

Health Insurance Regulations 2018 (Cth)

Dental Benefits Rules 2014 (Cth) rr 6, 7

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 8.21

Health Insurance (Professional Services Review – Sampling Methodology) Determination 2017 (Cth)

Health Legislation (Professional Services Review) Amendment Bill 1993 (Cth)

Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Victoria) Act 2009 (Vic)

Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 (Qld)

Cases cited:

I-MED Radiology Network Ltd v Director of Professional Services Review [2020] FCA 1645

Karmakar v Minister for Health (No 2) (2021) 177 ALD 83; [2021] FCA 916

National Home Doctor Service Pty Ltd v Director of Professional Services Review (2020) 279 FCR 338; (2020) 379 ALR 513; [2020] FCA 386

National Home Doctor Service Pty Ltd v Director of Professional Services Review (2020) 276 FCR 338; (2020) 379 ALR 513; [2020] FCA 386

Selia v Commonwealth of Australia [2017] FCA 7

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 90
Date of hearing: 5 September 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M.O. Plunkett with Mr B. Wright
Solicitor for the Applicant: Paxton-Hall Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms N. Kidson KC with Ms K. Slack
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

QUD 416 of 2021
BETWEEN:

PAUL SORYAL

Applicant

AND:

DIRECTOR OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 APRIL 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s amended originating application filed 26 July 2022 be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soryal v Director of Professional Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 326
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Soryal v Director of Professional Services Review involves a judicial review of a decision made by the Director of Professional Services Review to refer the applicant, a registered dentist, to a Professional Services Review Committee for an investigation into potential inappropriate conduct under the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth). The applicant had permitted third parties to use his Medicare Provider Number for providing dental services under the Medicare Child Dental Benefits Scheme. Concerns were raised regarding the dental services provided by oral health therapists using the applicant's Medicare Provider Number, leading to a referral for investigation. The applicant argued that the Director lacked jurisdiction to make the referral and that section 81(2) of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) should not be construed as encompassing supervision of services.

The court considered whether the Director had the authority to refer the applicant to the Committee and if section 81(2) of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) included the supervision of services. The court concluded that the Director did have jurisdiction to make the referral and that the scope of section 81(2) encompassed the supervision of services provided under the applicant's Medicare Provider Number. The court further found that the applicant's reliance on section 106K(1) and the Health Insurance (Professional Services Review – Sampling Methodology) Determination 2017 (Cth) was misplaced as these provisions relate to the Committee's investigation rather than the Director's decision to refer.

The court dismissed the applicant's amended originating application and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs. The court found that the Director's decision to refer the applicant to the Committee was valid and within the scope of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth). The court did not accept the applicant's arguments regarding the Director's jurisdiction or the interpretation of section 81(2). The dismissal of the application and the order for costs reflect the court's determination that the Director's actions were justified and within the statutory framework.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s amended originating application filed 26 July 2022 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs to be taxed unless otherwise agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant also seeks costs of this application. BACKGROUND The applicant is a registered dental practitioner under the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law, being the schedule to the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 (Qld) and adopted in Victoria by section 4 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Victoria) Act 2009 (Vic). In September 2018 the applicant applied to the Chief Executive Medicare for a Medicare Provider Number pursuant to the Dental Benefits Rules 2014 (Cth) (Dental Benefits Rules) and Health Insurance Regulations 2018 (Cth). On 8 October 2018 the Chief Executive Medicare allocated the applicant a Medicare Provider Number, which allowed the applicant to facilitate billing under the CDBS. Consequently, the applicant’s practice became subject to Part VAA of the HI Act. After receiving his Medicare Provider Number the applicant entered into arrangements with Future Care Dental Group (Future Care Dental), Smiles Inclusive Limited t/as Totally Smiles (Totally Smiles) and RA Morkos Pty Ltd t/as Teeth N Smiles (Teeth N Smiles). Materially, those arrangements permitted the use of the applicant’s Medicare Provider Number for mobile dental services to kindergarten and school children at locations in Victoria and New South Wales for services by Oral Health Therapists (OTHs) engaged by Future Care Dental, Totally Smiles and Teeth N Smiles. In exchange for use of the Medicare Provider Number the applicant received a flat retainer fee of $150.00 plus GST per day. In addition, the applicant agreed that he would make himself available by phone or email if any of the OTHs had questions, and would review and approve treatment notes and proposed treatment plans. Overall, the applicant received a sum of $23,925.00 from the retainer fee. For the period 1 December 2018 to 30 November 2019 (Review Period) 18,623 CDBS services were rendered to 4,644 patients under the applicant’s Medicare Provider Number, resulting in $908,351.41 worth of dental benefits being paid by the Commonwealth. Predominately, those services included the following items under the CDBS:·Item 88011 – comprehensive oral examination – teeth, supporting tissues and oral tissues including recording a medical history;·Item 88111 – removal of plaque and/or stain;·Item 88114 – removal of calculus – first visit;·Item 88121 – topical application of remineralisation and/or cariostatic agents, one treatment; and ·Item 88161 – fissure and/or tooth sealing – per tooth. At relevant times, only registered dentists or dental specialists allocated a Medicare Provider Number were permitted to provide dental services as a “dental provider”, pursuant to s 6 of the Dental Benefits Act 2008 (Cth) (Dental Benefits Act) and rule 6 of the Dental Benefits Rules. Further, s 3 of the Dental Benefits Act provides that a “[d]ental benefit is payable if dental expenses are incurred in respect of a dental service rendered to an eligible dental patient”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 2 December 2021 the applicant filed an originating application for judicial review of the decision of 4 November 2021. Subsequently, the applicant filed an amended originating application on 26 July 2022 which is presently before the Court. EVIDENCE The applicant relied on the following affidavit material:(1)Affidavit of Sharon Ann Win dated 2 December 2021; and (2)Affidavit of Sharon Ann Win dated 16 June 2022. As a preliminary matter, the respondent filed a schedule of objections to the affidavit of Ms Winn dated 16 June 2022. Ms Winn provided evidence on behalf of the applicant as Special Counsel in the employ of Paxton-Hall Lawyers, solicitors for the applicant. Those objections were as follows:·Paragraph 7(1) of the affidavit and pages 223 to 225 of annexure SAW3 comprising a bundle of testamurs relating to the dental qualifications of the applicant on the ground of relevance;·Paragraph 7(2) and pages 226 to 227 of annexure SAW3 comprising the registration details of the applicant on the ground of relevance;·Paragraph 7(3) of the affidavit and pages 228 to 231 of annexure SAW3 comprising an application for an additional location provider number on the ground of relevance;·Paragraph 7(4) of the affidavit and page 232 of annexure SAW3 comprising a screenshot of the applicant’s provider digital access account on the ground of relevance; ·Paragraph 7(5) of the affidavit and page 233 of annexure SAW3 comprising a list of patients represented in a sample prepared by the applicant’s counsel on the grounds of inadmissible hearsay and the document being submission not evidence;·Paragraph 7(6) of the affidavit and pages 234 to 257 of annexure SAW3 comprising a brochure entitled “Your Guide to Professional Services Review” on the ground of relevance; ·Paragraph 7(9) of the affidavit and page 268 to 276 of annexure SAW3 comprising the Dental Board of Australia Guidelines for scope of practice dated 1 July 2020 on the ground of relevance;·Paragraph 7(10) of the affidavit and pages 277 to 293of annexure SAW3 comprising evidence based clinical practice guidelines for the use of pit and fissure sealants on the ground of relevance; ·Paragraph 7(11) of the affidavit and pages 294 to 295 of annexure SAW3 comprising a list of clinical guidelines and best practice recommendations on the ground of relevance; At the hearing, the applicant conceded that the documents referrable to paragraphs 7(5), (6) and (9) in annexure SAW3 were not relevant and I do not admit those materials. When pressed the applicant conceded that the documents at paragraphs 7(4), (2), and (1) were sought to be admitted on the basis of providing background material to the Court, and that they “did not die in a ditch” over their admission. The respondent did not press its objection to the documents referrable to paragraphs 7(3) and (10) and I admit those documents as relevant. At the hearing, I ruled the document referrable to paragraph 7(11) inadmissible. The respondent relied on an affidavit of Ian Leonard Temby dated 11 March 2022. The applicant took no objection to the material filed by the respondent. CONSIDERATION

Decision

Reasons for decision

Despite an Order made 25 July 2022 allowing the applicant to amend his originating application in the terms sought by him, the applicant at the hearing sought to rely on an eighth ground of review. That ground of review is integrated into the other amended grounds, however is particularised in a document handed up at the hearing entitled “Particulars as to Insufficient Patient Records, and Non-Randomised Patient Records”. The ground was summarised in the applicant’s outline of submissions as follows:6. The Applicant seeks orders setting aside the Decision on the grounds of:…(d)the Respondent reached conclusions on a review of the patient records that were not open having asked for 50 records but only received 29 where the sampling methodology required 25 for each of the 5 services being reviewed: s. 106K(1) of the Act; Health Insurance (Professional Services Review — Sampling Methodology) Determination 2017.…Ground 8 (to be added to amended Application): Decision invalid because insufficient patient records reviewed98. On 13 August 2021, the Respondent in determining whether there were grounds on which a Committee could really find that the Applicant had engaged in inappropriate practise as defined by the Act, had regards to clinical records that were provided by third parties under section 89B of the Act: page 101.99. The only reference by the Respondent to the records in the making of the decision is paragraphs 27 to 33: pages 105 to 106 (and footnotes thereto).100. The submissions made above for the breach of procedural fairness are repeated and relied upon for ground 8. Given that the applicant requires leave pursuant to r 8.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to rely on this further ground, and the respondent opposes leave being granted on the basis that it is without merit, I will consider it at the outset. Correctly, the respondent submits that applicant’s reliance on s 106K(1) is misguided as that section applies only to the PSR Committee’s investigation, once referred; see National Home Doctor Service Pty Ltd v Director of Professional Services Review (2020) 279 FCR 338; (2020) 379 ALR 513; [2020] FCA 386 at [55]. Section 106K(1) provides:106K Committee may have regard to samples of services(1)The Committee may, in investigating the provision of services included in a particular class of the referred services, have regard only to a sample of the services included in the class.(emphasis added) Additionally, the applicant’s reliance upon the Health Insurance (Professional Services Review – Sampling Methodology) Determination 2017 (Cth) (Determination) in this case is unhelpful. The applicant cites s 6 of the Determination which specifies: 6 Purpose This Part specifies the content and form of a sampling methodology that may be used by a Committee in investigating the provision of services included in a particular class of referred services, where regard is to be had only to a sample of the services included in the class.(emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent relied on an affidavit of Ian Leonard Temby dated 11 March 2022. The applicant took no objection to the material filed by the respondent. CONSIDERATION The professional services review scheme is set out at length in Part VAA ss 79A-106ZR of the HI Act. Relevantly, section 79A of the Act sets out the objectives of Part VAA as follows:79A Object of this Part The object of this Part is to protect the integrity of the Commonwealth medicare benefits, dental benefits and pharmaceutical benefits programs and, in doing so:(a) protect patients and the community in general from the risks associated with inappropriate practice; and (b)protect the Commonwealth from having to meet the cost of services provided as a result of inappropriate practice. In circumstances where a practitioner is found to have claimed CDBS benefits inappropriately and has engaged in inappropriate practice, he or she may be required to repay the overpayments to the Commonwealth and face further sanctions such as suspension or disqualification from billing under the Medicare scheme. The main features of the Professional Services Review Scheme are: 80 Main features of the Professional Services Review Scheme (1) This section summarises the main features of the Professional Services Review Scheme established by this Part.(2) The Professional Services Review Scheme is a scheme for reviewing and investigating the provision of services by a person to determine whether the person has engaged in inappropriate practice.(3) The Chief Executive Medicare can request the Director to review the provision of services by a person and the Director must decide whether to undertake a review.(4) Following a review, the Director must:(a) decide to take no further action in relation to the review; or(b) enter into an agreement with the person under review; or(c) make a referral to a Committee.(5) If the Director enters into an agreement with the person under review, the agreement must be ratified by the Determining Authority before it takes effect. Having an agreement ratified avoids a Committee investigation.(6) A referral to a Committee initiates an investigation by the Committee into the provision of the services specified in the referral. The Committee can investigate any aspect of the provision of the referred services and its investigation is not limited by any reasons given in a request for review or a Director’s report following a review.(7) Committee members must belong to professions or specialities relevant to the investigation.(8) Committees can hold hearings and require the person under review to attend and give evidence. Committees also have the power to require the production of documents (including clinical records).(9) Committees can base findings on investigations of samples of services.(10) If a Committee finds that the person under review has engaged in inappropriate practice, the finding will be reported to the Determining Authority. The Determining Authority decides what action to take.(11) Provision is made throughout the scheme for the person under review to make submissions before key decisions are made or final reports are given.(12) A Committee cannot make a finding of inappropriate practice unless it has given the person under review:(a) notice of its intention to do so; and(b) the reasons for the finding; and(c) an opportunity to respond.(emphasis added)