Sony Computer Entertainment Aust Pty Ltd v Jakopcevic

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sony Computer Entertainment Aust Pty Ltd v Jakopcevic [2001] FCA 1520

SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 077 583 183) & ANOR v BARRY JAKOPCEVIC & ORS

N 113 OF 2001

LINDGREN J
24 OCTOBER 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 113 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA
PTY LIMITED (ACN 077 583 183)
FIRST APPLICANT

KABUSHIKI KAISHA SONY COMPUTER ENTERTAINMENT
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

BARRY JAKOPCEVIC
FIRST RESPONDENT

DOMINIQUE JAKOPCEVIC
SECOND RESPONDENT

CHRISTIAN FABRE
THIRD RESPONDENT

ANTHONY “FRANK” GUTHRIE
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 OCTOBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

[In these orders “the Sony Trade Marks” means the second applicant’s registered Trade Marks No 642678 (the word mark “PlayStation”) and No 642679 (a device mark comprising a stylised representation of a vertical letter “P” and a horizontal letter “S” intertwined).]

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The first and second respondents have, and each of them has, infringed the Sony Trade Marks and each of them by offering to sell and selling without the licence of the second applicant, to an agent of the first applicant:

(i)        on 4 June 2000;

(ii)       on 20 October 2000;

(iii)      on 26 October 2000;

(iv)      on 15 November 2000;

(v)       on 3 January 2001; and

(vi)      on 5 February 2001

CD-ROMs containing software:
(a)       in which were stored electronically representations of marks; and

(b)       by reference to marks

that are substantially identical to the Sony Trade Marks. 

2.The fourth respondent has infringed the Sony Trade Marks by offering to sell and selling without the licence of the second applicant, to an agent of the first applicant:

(i)        on 20 October 2000;

(ii)       on 26 October 2000;

(iii)      on 15 November 2000;

(iv)      on 3 January 2001; and

(v)       on 5 February 2001

CD‑ROMs containing software

(a)       in which were stored electronically representations of marks; and

(b)       by reference to marks

that are substantially identical to the Sony Trade Marks. 

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

3.Each of the first, second and fourth respondents whether by himself, herself, his or her servants or agents or otherwise, be restrained from infringing the Sony Trade Marks and each of them by:

(a)without the licence of the second applicant, supplying or offering to supply in Australia any computer game player or any software, including any CD-ROM or packaging containing any such software, which bears, or in which is stored electronically, any representation of either of the Sony Trade Marks or any mark substantially identical with or deceptively similar to either of them or in relation to which any mark substantially identical with or deceptively similar to either of them is otherwise used;

(b)without the licence of the second applicant, procuring or inducing any other person to do any of the acts specified in subparagraph 3(a).

4.Each of the first, second and fourth respondents deliver up to the applicants, on oath, the affidavit to be filed with the Court by 7 November 2001, all…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sony Computer Entertainment Aust Pty Ltd v Jakopcevic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Sony Computer Entertainment Aust Pty Ltd brought proceedings against several individuals and entities involved in the alleged production and distribution of counterfeit software. The defendants were accused of producing and selling CD-ROMs that infringed on Sony's intellectual property rights, specifically their trade marks. The case revolved around the evidence gathered from various sources, including the execution of an Anton Piller order at the premises of one of the defendants, which led to the seizure of numerous counterfeit CD-ROMs and computer files. The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the Trade Marks Act 1995 and the enforcement of intellectual property rights. The court had to determine whether the defendants were indeed involved in the production and distribution of counterfeit software, and if Sony was entitled to injunctive relief to prevent further infringement of their trade marks.

The court found that the evidence presented by Sony was compelling and established a strong case for the infringement of their trade marks. The execution of the Anton Piller order revealed a significant amount of counterfeit CD-ROMs and other evidence of a widespread operation. The court also accepted the expert testimony of Norman Napiza, who was able to recover deleted computer files that provided further evidence of the defendants' involvement in the production and distribution of counterfeit software. Based on this evidence, the court found that the defendants were indeed infringing on Sony's trade marks and granted the requested injunctive relief, prohibiting them from supplying or offering to supply any computer game player or software that bore representations of the Sony Trade Marks without the appropriate license. The court also ordered the defendants to deliver up all counterfeit CD-ROMs in their possession and pay the applicants' costs of the proceeding.

The final orders of the court included a permanent injunction against the defendants from infringing on Sony's trade marks, the delivery of all counterfeit CD-ROMs in their possession, and the payment of costs by the defendants to Sony. The court also granted leave to Sony to tax the costs and ordered that they be paid forthwith after taxation. The proceedings were stood over for further directions regarding the outstanding issues of pecuniary relief. This case highlights the importance of enforcing intellectual property rights and the court's willingness to grant relief to protect such rights when appropriate evidence is presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. Each of the first, second and fourth respondents whether by himself, herself, his or her servants or agents or otherwise, be restrained from infringing the Sony Trade Marks and each of them by:

(a) without the licence of the second applicant, supplying or offering to supply in Australia any computer game player or any software, including any CD-ROM or packaging containing any such software, which bears, or in which is stored electronically, any representation of either of the Sony Trade Marks or any mark substantially identical with or deceptively similar to either of them or in relation to which any mark substantially identical with or deceptively similar to either of them is otherwise used;

(b) without the licence of the second applicant, procuring or inducing any other person to do any of the acts specified in subparagraph 3(a).

4. Each of the first, second and fourth respondents deliver up to the applicants, on oath, the affidavit to be filed with the Court by 7 November 2001, all and any CD-ROMs containing software for use with computer game players in which are stored electronically representations of marks that are identical with, substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to the Sony Trade Marks or either of them in his or her possession, power or control, save for all items removed from 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne during the execution on 13 February 2001 of the Orders of Lindgren J made 9 February 2001 and 12 February 2001.

5. The first, second and fourth respondents pay the applicants’ costs of this proceeding to date on a party and party basis.

6. Pursuant to Order 62 rule 3(2) of the Federal Court Rules, the applicants have leave to tax the costs the subject of this Order.

7. Such costs be paid forthwith after taxation.

8. The provisions of Order 62 rule 36A of the Federal Court Rules do not apply.

9. The proceedings stand over to 14 November 2001 at 9.30 am before Lindgren J for further directions regarding the outstanding issues of pecuniary relief.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Again, Mr Gladman subsequently placed the CD-ROMs in an envelope which he sealed and, on this occasion, despatched to Allens.FURTHER EVIDENCE The above account is sufficient to indicate the general nature of the six purchases. Evidence of what occurred subsequently satisfies me that all the CD-ROMs bought by Mr Gladman bore counterfeits of the Sony Trade Marks. There was further evidence linking the individuals concerned with the home of Barry and Dominique at 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne. I will summarise that evidence from the written submissions of counsel for the applicants, which I accept. A search of 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne revealed that Barry was its owner. On 26 October 2000 the First Man visited 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne after delivery of the CD-ROMs and the white Mazda 929 registered number ONJ 593, which had been used in the 4 June 2000 delivery, was parked outside. On 5 December 2000 the white Mazda 929 registered number ONJ 593 was driven from the 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne premises. On 3 January 2001 the same white Mazda 929 was parked outside those premises and the First Man drove the Brown Car to make the delivery to Mr Gladman. On 12 February 2001, when execution of the Anton Piller order was unsuccessfully attempted, the Brown Car registered number FYH 959 was driven past 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne. On the same day, within those premises, there was an attempt to delete business records from the computer files there, to which I refer in more detail below. On 13 February 2001, when the Anton Piller order was successfully executed, Barry, after contact with his then solicitor, consented to the inspection of his home. Hundreds of CD-ROMs in plastic cases were seized there, together with other compelling evidence that a major business activity was being undertaken in the form of the production and selling of infringing CD-ROMs. The main hard-drives of the computers were seized. Norman Napiza, a specialist in the field of “computer forensics”, was subsequently able to recover computer files from analysis of an image taken of hard-drives which were recovered from the house at 10 Grace Street, Cranbourne on 13 February 2001. Included were deleted files relating to the use of an “ICQ messaging system”, which is a free on-line messaging system which provides a method of communicating over the Internet, similar to e-mail messages or on-line ‘chat-rooms’, except that the messages are relayed from user-to-user directly, negating the need for the user to log into a chat-room service. According to Mr Napiza’s affidavit, when a person installs an ICQ computer program on the person’s computer and registers with the ICQ server, the person is allocated a Unique Identification Number (“UIN”) which will appear as a prefix to any message sent by the user. Each message sent or received by the user on the ICQ system will also have a copy stored on an ICQ Message Log. In the message log, the exchange between each user is labelled by reference to the UIN of each user. Mr Napiza states that this log is integrated into the ICQ application and is usually viewed when the ICQ application is run.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

Full text does not contain this section.