Somasundaram v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TRIBUNAL

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

SOMASUNDARAM v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2012] SAEOT 3

Judgment of Her Honour Judge Cole

17 October 2012

DISCRIMINATION LAW

Matter referred from Equal Opportunity Commission - complainant alleges discrimination on the grounds of race - preliminary questions.

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA), referred to.
Janus v Lifeline Upper Spencer Gulf Inc (1991) EOC 92-382; Hills v State of South Australia (2001) EOC 93-145; Hills v State of South Australia (2002) 82 SASR 102; Patrick v State of South Australia [2007] SAEOT 2; Rankin v State Electoral Office [2008] SAEOT 13; Dye v Commonwealth Securities Limited (No. 2) [2010] FCAFC 118, considered.

SOMASUNDARAM v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2012] SAEOT 3

  1. By notice received on 21 January 2011, the Acting Commissioner for Equal Opportunity (“the Commissioner”) referred to the Equal Opportunity Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), pursuant to s 95B of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (“the Act”), a complaint of Dr Somasundaram (“the complainant”).  This is a decision in relation to a series of preliminary points which have been raised in the matter.

  2. The complainant is a psychiatrist.  He came to Australia from Sri Lanka, which was his country of birth.  In his complaint to the Commissioner, dated 28 May 2010 but stamped as having been received by the Commissioner on 1 June 2010, the complainant related that he obtained his specialist qualification in psychiatry in Sri Lanka in 1985 (MD psych) and undertook one year of post graduate training in the UK.  Ultimately, the complainant obtained a MRC Psych in the UK in 1999.  Meanwhile, he worked as a consultant psychiatrist in Northern Sri Lanka and held the position of Senior Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Jaffna, Sri Lanka.

  3. The complainant said in the complaint that he was appointed in April 2006 to the Glenside Campus Mental Health Service as a consultant psychiatrist at level 3, having obtained the British FRC Psych in February 2005, which was a pre-requisite for his registration in Australia as a psychiatrist.  The complaint recorded that the complainant gained his Australian FRANZCP in February 2007, which was a pre-requisite for specialist registration with the Medical Board of South Australia.  The complaint said:

    …But with the FRANZCP and Medical Board of South Australia specialist recognition, my past “relevant experience” should have been taken into account in my appointment at the subsequent annual cycle in April, 2007 when my contract was renewed.  However, this was not done and I feel that this is discriminatory of foreign graduates most of whom come here from 3rd world developing countries.

  4. The complainant also said, in his complaint:

    I have approached our Human Resources (15/5/08); Prof Norman James, Clinical Director (19/8/08); Dr Eli Rafalowicz, Executive Director (3/3/09); Sam Contarino, Human Resources Manager (24/3/09 – 6/7/09); Derek Wright, Director Mental Health Operations and Margaret Honeyman, Chief Psychiatrist (15/7/09 – 5/11/09) and South Australian Salaried Medical Officers Association (SASMOA) (25/3/10 – 10/5/10).  Basically, they have reiterated that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Somasundaram v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SAEOT 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Somasundaram v State of South Australia involves a complaint by Dr Somasundaram, a psychiatrist who emigrated from Sri Lanka, alleging discrimination on the grounds of race by his employer, the State of South Australia. The Equal Opportunity Tribunal was asked to determine several preliminary legal questions arising from the complaint. The central issue was whether the complaint was made within the statutory time limit, and if not, whether the Tribunal had the authority to extend that time. Other questions included whether the complainant was bound by the initial particulars of the complaint and whether the Tribunal was bound by the Commissioner's characterisation of the complaint in the Notice of Referral.

The court found that the Act did not provide for complaints to be brought directly to the Tribunal. Complaints must be made to the Commissioner, and only the Commissioner can refer a complaint to the Tribunal. The respondent argued that the complaint was out of time because the alleged discrimination occurred in April 2007, and the time for lodging a complaint with the Commissioner had expired in October 2007. However, the court held that the Act did not provide for the Tribunal to review the handling of a complaint by the Commissioner regarding the timing of the complaint. Once the Commissioner referred the complaint to the Tribunal, the Tribunal's jurisdiction was activated, and the issue of timing was irrelevant.

The court also addressed whether the Tribunal was bound by the particulars of the complaint as expressed by the Commissioner in the Notice of Referral, and concluded that it was not. The Tribunal's jurisdiction was confined to the complaint filed by the complainant, but the particulars of the complaint could be amended to the extent necessary to more precisely identify the issues arising from the complaint. The court found that the particulars of the claim now pleaded were within the Tribunal's jurisdiction.

The outcome of this case clarifies the process for making complaints under the Equal Opportunity Act and the limited role of the Tribunal in reviewing the Commissioner's handling of complaints. The decision also provides guidance on the level of particularity required in the initial complaint and the extent to which the particulars of the complaint can be amended during the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established