Rankin v State Electoral Office

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TRIBUNAL

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

RANKIN v STATE ELECTORAL OFFICE

[2008] SAEOT 13

Reasons for Ruling of Her Honour Judge Trenorden, Member Ms A Bachmann and Member Mr D Shetliffe

29 October 2008

DISCRIMINATION LAW

Application to amend Particulars of Complaint including relief sought.

Equal Opportunity Act 1984, referred to.

RANKIN v STATE ELECTORAL OFFICE
[2008] SAEOT 13

Background

  1. The Tribunal has before it an application by the complainant, Mr Rankin, to further amend the Particulars of Complaint.  That application has been opposed by the respondent, the State Electoral Office.

  2. The complaint made to the Commissioner for Equal Opportunity was in the following terms:

    Electoral Commission has in place a policy to prevent individuals with an impairment to vote without the assistance of another in South Australia.  This also occurs during Federal Elections.  Mr Rankin’s case involves vision impairment.  Would like to be provided with a means of lodging an independent vote.  Having a friend or relative to vote for him does not guarantee that his vote is given according to his instructions.

    The Canberra model provides computer assistance voting.  It has a special keyboard and speaks.

    He has spoken to the Electoral Commission about this some time ago without success.

    Mr Rankin states that he is able to read e-mails and word attachments as he has voice software installed on his computer.

  3. Mr Rankin is visually impaired.  He made the complaint on 14 March 2006, that is shortly before the 2006 general election for the South Australian Parliament.

  4. We understand his complaint (set out above) is that he was discriminated against because of his visual impairment, in that the policy of the Electoral Commission would prevent him from lodging an independent vote.  Further, he sought to be provided with the means to vote independently through a computer assisted voting system.

  5. On 6 March 2007, Mr Rankin was advised by the Commissioner for Equal Opportunity, that she had decided not to enquire into his allegations because, in her opinion, his complaint was lacking in substance.  As was his right, Mr Rankin requested the Commissioner to refer his complaint to this Tribunal.

  6. On 25 March 2008, Mr Rankin dictated, and with assistance filed, a document entitled “Further and Better Particulars” in this Tribunal.  The assistance was provided by the Deputy Registrar of the District Court.  The document contained a Statement of Complaint, Particulars of Complaint and the Relief/Orders Sought.

  7. The Statement and Particulars of the Complaint are as follows:

    STATEMENT OF COMPLAINT

    The State Electoral Commission will not provide to a blind or vision impaired voter the means to lodge a private and secret vote, via the means of computer assisted voting i.e the Federal model as utilized in the 2007 Federal Election.

    PARTICULARS OF COMPLAINT

    1/  Due to the unavailability of electronic voting I wasn’t prepared to utilize electoral staff to assist to make a private vote and thus was disenfranchised from my constitutional right to lodge a private and secret vote like any other member…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rankin v State Electoral Office and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SAEOT 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Equal Opportunity Tribunal was presented with an application by Mr Rankin to amend his Particulars of Complaint against the State Electoral Office. Mr Rankin's initial complaint was that the policy of the State Electoral Office prevented him, as a person with a vision impairment, from casting a private and secret vote. He sought the provision of computer-assisted voting as a means to independently lodge his vote. The Tribunal considered whether to allow Mr Rankin to amend his complaint to include alternative arguments regarding the provision of braille ballot papers and to seek compensation for the alleged discrimination.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Rankin could amend his complaint to include arguments not originally presented and whether he could seek compensation as part of his relief. The Tribunal had to determine if the proposed amendments were permissible under the Equal Opportunity Act and whether such amendments would prejudice the respondent, the State Electoral Office. Additionally, the Tribunal needed to consider whether the relief sought, including compensation, was within its jurisdiction.

The Tribunal ruled that the amendment allowing for arguments regarding braille ballot papers should not be permitted as it introduced a new matter not part of the original complaint referred to the Tribunal. However, the Tribunal found that Mr Rankin could amend his complaint to seek an order for the State Electoral Office to pay him compensation. This amendment did not prejudice the respondent and aligned with the Tribunal's powers under the Equal Opportunity Act. The Tribunal granted leave to amend the Particulars of Complaint to include the sought order for compensation.

Accordingly, the Tribunal made an order allowing Mr Rankin to amend his complaint to include an order for the Commissioner to pay compensation to him. This decision ensured that Mr Rankin could pursue his claim for compensation while maintaining the integrity of the Tribunal's process by not allowing the introduction of new arguments outside the scope of the original complaint.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established