DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Smith v Moore & Anor [2014] QDC 273
PARTIES:
AARON CHRISTOPHER SMITH
(Plaintiff)
v
ANDREW JAMES BLIGH MOORE
(First Defendant)
AND
AAI LIMITED (ABN 48 005 297 807)
(Second Defendant)
FILE NO/S:
DIS 831/13
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Trial
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
3 December 2014
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
3-5th November 2014 inclusive
JUDGE:
Ryrie DCJ
ORDER:
1. Judgment for the Plaintiff in the sum of $66,962.45
2. The parties are to provide written submissions (maximum 6 pages) as to costs after the expiration of 28 days from the date of publication of this judgment unless the parties otherwise agree.
CATCHWORDS:
DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – assessment of damages pursuant to the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld)
Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (Qld) s 52
Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld) ss 55, 61, 62
Civil Liability Regulation 2014 (Qld) s 2(b), sch 7
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v McCarthy [2012] QCA 312 – applied
Heywood v Commercial Electrical Pty Ltd [2013] QCA 270 - applied
Malec v J C Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638 - applied
Medlin v State of Queensland (1995) 182 CLR 1 - appliedCOUNSEL:
P. Rashleigh (for the plaintiff)
K. Howe with C. Job (for the 1st and 2nd defendants)
SOLICITORS:
McInnes Wilson Lawyers (for the plaintiff)
Quinlan Miller & Treston Lawyers (for the 1st and 2nd defendants)
Introduction
Mr Smith, the plaintiff in this matter, claims damages for personal injuries and consequential loss suffered by him as a result of a motor vehicle accident which occurred on 8th May 2011. Mr Smith had been riding his pushbike along Boundary Road in West End when a motorist, without looking, opened his parked car driver’s side door into Mr Smith’s path. Mr Smith swerved unsuccessfully to avoid collision, and was thrown from his bike over the handlebars whereupon he landed on the road. Mr Smith was 26 years old at the time of the accident. He is presently 29 years of age.
Liability being admitted, quantum with respect to damages was the only contest at trial.
It is accepted by the 2nd defendant that the plaintiff suffered an injury to his left index finger. The 2nd defendant does not accept however that the plaintiff suffered an injury to his lumbar spine as pleaded, or at all. The 2nd defendant accepts that Mr Smith has suffered some loss and damage as a consequence of the 1st defendant’s negligence. However, the 2nd defendant does not accept that any such loss and damage should include an assessment of any amount for future economic loss and/or impairment of earning capacity in respect of either alleged injury or for that matter, any amount for any future care or treatment.
The Law
The 2nd defendant, being the relevant CTP insurer of the motor…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Moore and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] QDC 273
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's reasoning focused on the principles outlined in the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), specifically Section 55, which mandates that future economic loss assessments must be made by reference to the facts of the particular case. The court recognised the difficulty in precisely calculating future economic loss and highlighted the need for a global assessment based on the unique circumstances of the plaintiff. The court also noted that even if Mr Smith's earning capacity was diminished, it had to be demonstrated that this would likely result in financial loss. The court found that Mr Smith's injuries would impact his ability to perform the core duties of his previous occupation as an aircraft maintenance engineer, and thus, he would likely suffer a financial loss if he were unable to return to that occupation.
After considering the evidence and submissions from both parties, the court awarded Mr Smith $66,962.45 in damages. The court determined that while Mr Smith had aspirations for future employment and earnings as a registered valuer, the impact of his injuries on his ability to perform as an aircraft maintenance engineer warranted compensation. The court also noted the importance of considering Mr Smith's intentions to support his family financially in the future. The court ordered the parties to submit written submissions on costs within 28 days of the judgment's publication, unless otherwise agreed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Judgment for the Plaintiff in the sum of $66,962.45
2. The parties are to provide written submissions (maximum 6 pages) as to costs after the expiration of 28 days from the date of publication of this judgment unless the parties otherwise agree.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Finally, the 2nd defendant referred to the wages which Mr Smith is in fact currently earning as a valuer full time and what in effect he may be able to earn if he remains working in the valuation industry especially upon obtaining registration. The 2nd defendant points to the fact that Mr Smith is exceeding at his work as a valuer and has good prospects of remaining employed in that industry and that Mr Smith aspires to be a registered valuer and therefore will be able to earn more once he gets the necessary qualifications. In other words, he will probably have available to him a more lucrative job in the future and the finger injury suffered will have no impact at all on him being able to perform his current work in the future. The 2nd defendant’s ultimate submission was that even though it is accepted that Mr Smith has suffered a finger injury as a consequence of the subject accident with ongoing residual impairment, it cannot be demonstrated that it may or will be productive of any financial loss. The plaintiff, on the other hand, submits that it was always the intention of Mr Smith to undertake his degree in order to give him some flexibility in respect of his future earning capacity. The plaintiff intention was, it was submitted, that he eventually wanted to be able to contract in both industries by setting up his own companies to facilitate that. The plaintiff submits that if Mr Smith could have returned to aircraft maintenance engineering work full time in the future as he planned, he could have earned anywhere in the order of $117,000 per annum compared to his current wage as a valuer of $65,000 per annum including super. The plaintiff submits that in addition to that expectation, Mr Smith had always wanted to return to doing weekend work in the aircraft industry as evidenced by his return to it part time while studying as well as his indication to do that work again in November 2011 and February 2012 to Ms Bolton. It was submitted that the plaintiff also wanted to bear some of the future financial burden in respect of his family as it developed. The plaintiff submitted that there was ample evidence to support a finding that the finger injury which Mr Smith has suffered will have an impact on his ability to now performing the core duties associated with that of an aircraft maintenance engineer. The plaintiff seeks in the order of $180,000 to $200,000 assessed on a global basis or alternatively, $180,000 to $630,000 or so if assessed with any calculable precision. Given the various imponderables which I have already referred to at length as it relates to this particularly case, it is immediately apparent and would be trite to say that any assessment for future economic loss simply cannot be precisely calculated to any defined weekly loss. Section 55 of the CLA therefore is relevant in these circumstances. It provides: It is trite law to say that any future economic loss assessment if made must be determined by reference to the facts of the particular case at hand and not through simple regard to other decisions in which courts have made awards of damages in broadly similar circumstances. Accordingly, it follows that an examination of the facts of the case at hand is necessary when determining any assessment or otherwise.[3] It is also trite to say that even if it is found to be that a plaintiff has suffered a diminution of his or her earning capacity as a result of the injury, it nevertheless must still be shown, on the balance of probabilities, that it will or may be productive of financial loss before any award can be made.[4] [3]Heywood v Commercial Electrical Pty Ltd [2013] QCA 270 [53]. [4]Medlin v State of Queensland (1995) 182 CLR 1.