Smith v J&C Whyte Family Trust & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



SMITH v J&C WHYTE FAMILY TRUST & ANOR (Appeal) [2016] ACAT 132

AA 26/2016 (XD 1158/2015)

Catchwords:             APPEAL – civil dispute - appeal dealt with as new application arising from admission of new evidence – product purchased not supplied – fundamental breach of contract – order for costs consequent upon obstruction before the tribunal – order for costs consequent upon contravention of an order of the tribunal

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 48, 82

Legislation Act 2001 s 142

Cases cited:               Appellants v Council of the Law Society of the ACT and Legal   Practitioner [2011] ACTSC 133

The Auburn Municipal Council v Ivanoff (1964) 10 LGRA 258

Bell v De Castella and Rob De Castella’s Smartstart For Kids Ltd [2013] ACAT 66

Boon v Maher (1980) 7 NSWLR 232

Carew-Neill v Bower [2016] ACAT 54
CIC Australia Ltd v ACT Planning and Land Authority and Ors [2013] ACTSC 96
Williams Love & Nicol Lawyers Pty Ltd v Wearne [2016] ACAT 123

Tribunal:         Presidential Member G McCarthy

Date of Orders:  29 November 2016

Date of Reasons for Decision:         29 November 2016

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY           )        AA 26/2016

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                )  (XD 1158/2015)

BETWEEN:

GARRY SMITH

Appellant

AND:

J&C WHYTE FAMILY TRUST TRADING AS MITCHELL SERVICE CENTRE

First Respondent

ENGINE REBUILDERS CANBERRA PTY LTD

Second Respondent

TRIBUNAL:  Presidential Member G McCarthy

DATE:29 November 2016

ORDER

  1. Within 35 days, the first respondent pay the appellant $7,865.58 comprised of:

    (a)     $5,690.16 by way of damages for breach of contract.

    (b)     $140 for the original application filing fee.

    (c)     $499 for the appeal application filing fee.

    (d)     $1,536.42 interest.

  2. Within 28 days, the second respondent pay the first respondent $7,865.58.

  3. Within 28 days, the second respondent pay the appellant $1,053.99

    ………………………………..

    Presidential Member G McCarthy

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. For reasons that follow, this appeal was dealt with as a new application.[1]

  2. The appellant, Mr Garry Smith, owns a Ford motor car. It was manufactured in May 1991.[2] In mid August 2012, concerned about a bad rattle, Mr Smith took his car to the workshop of the first respondent, the trustee of the J&C Whyte Family Trust, which carries on a business known as Mitchell Service Centre (MSC).

    [2] Certificates of registration

  3. The engine was found to be worn. Among other problems, it had a bent pushrod valve on one cylinder. Someone at MSC advised Mr Smith that the ‘bottom end’ of the engine had been previously reconditioned, could not be rebuilt a second time and that his best (or only) option was to replace the bottom end. Mr Smith accepted that advice.

  4. I was told at the appeal hearing that the ‘bottom end’ is a generic term used in the automotive industry to mean the engine block (or casting) and all its ‘internals’ meaning the pistons, rotating parts, bearings and the sub-assembly, but not the engine’s cylinder heads…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v J&C Whyte Family Trust & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Smith v J&C Whyte Family Trust & Anor involved a civil dispute concerning the sale of a product that was not supplied by the first respondent to the appellant. The matter was initially heard by a tribunal which determined that the first respondent had breached the contract. The second respondent was found to have obstructed the tribunal process, leading to the imposition of costs. Both respondents appealed the tribunal’s decision, but later sought to admit new evidence which resulted in the appeal being treated as a new application. The appellant sought costs for the obstruction and the contravention of the tribunal’s order.

The legal issues before the court included whether the first respondent had fundamentally breached the contract by failing to supply the product and whether the second respondent had obstructed the tribunal process and contravened a tribunal order, thereby warranting costs. The court also had to determine the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded.

The court found that the first respondent had indeed breached the contract by not supplying the product, which constituted a fundamental breach. It was also determined that the second respondent had obstructed the tribunal process and contravened an order of the tribunal. Consequently, the court upheld the tribunal’s decision on liability and costs. The court ordered the first respondent to pay the appellant $7,865.58 within 35 days, which included damages for the breach of contract, filing fees, and interest. The second respondent was ordered to pay the first respondent the same amount within 28 days and also to pay the appellant $1,053.99 within 28 days.

The court’s final orders required the first respondent to compensate the appellant for the breach of contract and related costs, while the second respondent was directed to reimburse the first respondent and also pay the appellant for the costs associated with the tribunal process and the contravention of the tribunal’s order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 35 days, the first respondent pay the appellant $7,865.58 comprised of:

(a) $5,690.16 by way of damages for breach of contract.

(b) $140 for the original application filing fee.

(c) $499 for the appeal application filing fee.

(d) $1,536.42 interest.

2. Within 28 days, the second respondent pay the first respondent $7,865.58.

3. Within 28 days, the second respondent pay the appellant $1,053.99

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.