[2015] HCATrans 127
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Melbourne No M22 of 2015
B e t w e e n -
INDERJIT SINGH
Plaintiff
and
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Defendant
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Second Defendant
Application for order to show cause
NETTLE J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT MELBOURNE ON THURSDAY, 21 MAY 2015, AT 9.38 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
HIS HONOUR: Could you call the matter outside, please?
COURT OFFICER: No appearance, your Honour.
HIS HONOUR: Thank you, Madam Registrar.
MR A. ALEKSOV: Your Honour, I appear for the first defendant. (instructed by Sparke Helmore Lawyers)
HIS HONOUR: Thank you.
MR ALEKSOV: There is nothing I would wish to add to our written submissions.
HIS HONOUR: Thank you, Mr Aleksov.
MR ALEKSOV: Unless I can assist your Honour further.
HIS HONOUR: On 29 March 2011, the plaintiff applied for a Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) Subclass 485 (Skilled‑Graduate) visa. To be eligible for the visa he had to satisfy the criteria set out in clause 485 of Schedule 2 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) of which one was that he have “competent English”. On 22 May 2012, the delegate of the Minister refused to grant the visa because it was determined that the plaintiff did not have competent English.
On 8 June 2012, the plaintiff applied to the Migration Review Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision and, on 12 September 2013, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on the basis that there was no evidence that the plaintiff had competent English.
On 15 October 2013, the plaintiff applied to the Federal Circuit Court for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision and, on 1 September 2014, Judge Hartnett dismissed the application after concluding that the grounds set out in the application did not raise an arguable case for the relief which was claimed.
On 25 September 2014, 10 days out of time, the applicant applied for leave to appeal to the Federal Court and, on 16 February 2015, her Honour Justice Gordon refused to extend time because her Honour determined that there would be no utility in the matter proceeding any further.
On 5 March 2015, the applicant filed an application in this Court for an order to show cause why certiorari should not go to quash the judgment and orders of Justice Gordon and why mandamus should not go to compel the Minister to reassess the applicant’s application for visa. The grounds of application are:
“1.If the Court determines that vitiating error has been demonstrated, then the plaintiff is entitled to the declaratory relief from court costs and get 485 visa grant or give permission to further studies with 572 subclass;
2.A delegate behalf of the Minister has taken and misused section 65 of the Act without giving appellant to comment on his exceptional circumstance beyond his control how he has lodged the 485 visa application;
3.Writ of certiorari of Federal Court decision made on…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] HCATrans 127
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the decisions of the Federal Circuit Court and the Federal Court constituted jurisdictional error, thereby warranting the grant of certiorari and mandamus. The plaintiff contended that the Migration Review Tribunal had applied the incorrect legislative instrument when assessing his English competency, and that the lower courts had erred in failing to identify this error. Specifically, the plaintiff argued that the Tribunal referred to IMMI 09/703 when the applicable instrument was IMMI 12/018, leading to a jurisdictional error in the assessment of his visa eligibility.
The High Court, in dismissing the application, reasoned that while Justice Gordon had correctly identified that both the Tribunal and the Federal Circuit Court had referred to the incorrect legislative instrument, this did not amount to a jurisdictional error. The Court applied the principle of *falsa demonstratio non nocet cum de corpore constat*, meaning a false description does not harm when the body is clear. Despite the incorrect reference to the instrument, the substance of the law applied by the Tribunal remained the same under both IMMI 09/703 and IMMI 12/018. Both instruments required the applicant to demonstrate competent English, which was defined by regulation 1.15C. The plaintiff did not satisfy the English competency requirements under the correct definition, and it was not contended that he could. Therefore, the error identified was not a jurisdictional error, and the conclusion of Justice Gordon that there would be no utility in proceeding with an appeal was upheld. The application was dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Singh then applied to the Federal Court for leave to appeal the Federal Circuit Court's decision, but this application was made 10 days out of time. On 16 February 2015, Justice Gordon of the Federal Court refused to extend time for the appeal, determining that there would be no utility in the matter proceeding any further. Singh subsequently filed an application in the High Court for an order to show cause why certiorari should not go to quash the judgment and orders of Justice Gordon, and why mandamus should not go to compel the Minister to reassess Singh's application for a visa. The core of Singh's complaint was that the Migration Review Tribunal had erred in applying the incorrect test of English competency. However, Justice Gordon had noted that while the Tribunal and the Federal Circuit Court had erred in identifying the applicable legislative instrument, the substance of the law as applied was correct, and the application was ultimately dismissed with costs.
The matter of Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection originated when the plaintiff, Inderjit Singh, applied for a Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) Subclass 485 visa on 29 March 2011. The delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection refused the application on 22 May 2012, determining that Mr Singh did not have competent English. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr Singh applied to the Migration Review Tribunal for review, which affirmed the delegate’s decision on 12 September 2013. He then sought judicial review in the Federal Circuit Court, but his application was dismissed on 1 September 2014 by Judge Hartnett, who concluded that the grounds of the application did not raise an arguable case for the relief claimed. Subsequently, Mr Singh applied to the Federal Court for leave to appeal on 25 September 2014, 10 days out of time. Justice Gordon of the Federal Court refused to extend the time for the appeal on 16 February 2015, determining that there would be no utility in the matter proceeding further. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr Singh applied to the High Court on 5 March 2015 for an order to show cause why certiorari should not go to quash the Federal Court's judgment and why mandamus should not compel the Minister to reassess his visa application.
In his application, Mr Singh contended that there was a jurisdictional error in the Federal Court’s decision, specifically that the Tribunal had applied the wrong legislative instrument in determining his English competency. The Federal Court had noted that while the Tribunal had erred in identifying the applicable instrument, the error did not amount to a jurisdictional error as the substance of the law applied was correct. Consequently, Mr Singh's application to the High Court sought to challenge this conclusion, arguing for declaratory relief, quashing of the Federal Court's decision, and mandamus to compel the Minister to reassess his visa application. However, the High Court ultimately dismissed the application, finding no merit in the jurisdictional error argument and awarding costs against Mr Singh.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Migration Review Tribunal made a jurisdictional error in identifying the correct legislative instrument for assessing English competency.
2. Whether the Federal Circuit Court erred in failing to detect the jurisdictional error made by the Migration Review Tribunal.
3. Whether the Federal Court erred in concluding that an appeal on the basis of the identified error would be inutile.
4. Whether the error identified by the Federal Court in its refusal to extend time to appeal was a jurisdictional error.
5. Whether the correct legislative instrument was applied to determine the plaintiff's English competency.
Held
1. Whether the Migration Review Tribunal made a jurisdictional error in identifying the correct legislative instrument for assessing English competency. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not make a jurisdictional error as it had asked itself the correct question despite referring to the wrong instrument. The result was that the requirement for competent English remained the same under each instrument.
2. Whether the Federal Circuit Court erred in failing to detect the jurisdictional error made by the Migration Review Tribunal. The court concluded that the Federal Circuit Court did err by adopting the Tribunal's analysis of the relevant instrument, but it did not lead to a different outcome. The result was that the application was dismissed.
3. Whether the Federal Court erred in concluding that an appeal on the basis of the identified error would be inutile. The court concluded that there would be no utility in granting an extension of time in which to appeal as the substance of the law as applied was correct. The result was that the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.
4. Whether the error identified by the Federal Court in its refusal to extend time to appeal was a jurisdictional error. The court concluded that the error was not a jurisdictional error as the requirement for competent English remained the same under each instrument. The result was that the application was dismissed.
5. Whether the correct legislative instrument was applied to determine the plaintiff's English competency. The court concluded that the applicable legislative instrument was IMMI 12/018, whereas the Tribunal and the Federal Circuit Court had proceeded on the basis that the applicable legislative instrument was IMMI 09/073. The result was that the application was dismissed with costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered whether the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) made a jurisdictional error in identifying the correct legislative instrument for assessing the plaintiff's English competency. The plaintiff argued that the MRT failed to identify the correct instrument, IMMI 12/018, instead relying on IMMI 09/073. However, the Court found that the error did not result in a jurisdictional error as the substance of the law applied was correct. Both instruments required the applicant to demonstrate competent English, defined as achieving a minimum score in either an IELTS or Occupational English test. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had asked itself the correct question despite referring to the wrong instrument, following the principle falsa demonstratio non nocet cum de corpore constat.
The Court also examined whether the Federal Circuit Court erred in failing to detect the jurisdictional error made by the MRT. The Federal Circuit Court had adopted the Tribunal's analysis of the relevant instrument, but the Court found no error in this regard. The Tribunal's error did not affect the substance of the decision because the requirement for competent English was the same under both instruments. The Federal Circuit Court correctly identified that the substantive law applied was correct, and thus, there was no jurisdictional error in the Court's decision.
Further, the Court reviewed whether the Federal Court erred in concluding that an appeal on the basis of the identified error would be inutile. Justice Gordon of the Federal Court noted that the Tribunal had erred in identifying the applicable legislative instrument and that the Federal Circuit Court had erred by adopting the Tribunal’s analysis. However, the Federal Court found that the error was not a jurisdictional error and that there would be no utility in proceeding with the appeal. The Court upheld this conclusion, finding that the error did not affect the outcome as the substantive requirements for English competency were the same under both instruments.
The Court then addressed whether the error identified by the Federal Court in its refusal to extend time to appeal was a jurisdictional error. The Court found that the error was not jurisdictional because it did not affect the substance of the decision. The requirement for competent English remained the same regardless of the instrument applied, and the plaintiff did not satisfy the test under either instrument. Therefore, the error did not result in a jurisdictional defect, and the Federal Court's decision not to extend time for appeal was correct.
Finally, the Court considered whether the correct legislative instrument was applied to determine the plaintiff's English competency. The Court found that the substantive law applied was correct, and the requirement for competent English was the same under both instruments. Despite the error in identifying the correct instrument, the outcome did not change because the plaintiff did not meet the English competency requirement under either instrument. The Court concluded that the substantive decision was correct, and the error did not affect the outcome. Therefore, the Court dismissed the application and upheld the decisions of the MRT, the Federal Circuit Court, and the Federal Court.
In summary, the Court found that the errors made by the MRT and the Federal Circuit Court did not amount to jurisdictional errors as the substance of the decision remained correct. The Federal Court correctly concluded that an appeal on this basis would be inutile, and the Court upheld this decision. The correct legislative instrument was effectively applied, and the outcome did not change as the plaintiff did not meet the English competency requirement under either instrument. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an error in identifying the correct legislative instrument does not amount to a jurisdictional error if the substantive law applied remains correct and the outcome is unaffected.