Singh v Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Singh & Ors v Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc [2022] QSC 151

PARTIES:

GURMEET SINGH

(first applicant)

SATINDER PAL SINGH

(second applicant)

HARMINDER SINGH

(third applicant)

v
BRISBANE SIKH TEMPLE (GURDWARA) INC

(respondent)

FILE NO/S: BS 10910 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application to appoint receiver

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

19 July 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 July 2022

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDER:

The application to appoint a receiver made in paragraph 2 of the application filed on 17 March 2022 is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

ASSOCIATIONS AND CLUBS – INCORPORATED ASSOCIATIONS – MEMBERS – where the decision of the respondent’s management committee to reject 2,151 applications for membership was found to be void and of no effect – where the respondent’s management committee was directed to consider the rejected applications for membership in accordance with the respondent’s Constitution and according to law – where the respondent’s management committee reconsidered the rejected applications for membership – where the applicants alleged a number of defects in the reconsideration process – whether the Court should appoint a receiver to the respondent for the purposes of undertaking a further reconsideration process, convening a general meeting to vote on the election of the respondent’s management committee, and making decisions about the process and procedures to be adopted for the general meeting – whether such an appointment which will cost the respondent in excess of $200,000 is just and convenient – whether such an appointment is necessary when applicants for membership can appeal the rejection of their applications to a general meeting

Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld), s 72, s 73
Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), s 12

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld)

Fordyce v Ryan [2017] 2 Qd R 240; [2016] QSC 307, cited
Lamers v Arvind Pty Ltd [No 2] [2019] WASC 491, cited
McLean v McKinlay [2004] WASC 2, cited
National Australian Bank Ltd v Bond Brewing Holdings Ltd [1991] 1 VR 386, cited
Sengthong v Lao Buddhist Society of NSW Incorporated [2016] NSWSC 1408, cited
Singh & Ors v Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc [2021] QSC 290, cited
Singh & Ors v Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc [2022] QSC 17, cited

COUNSEL:

L Copley for the applicants

G Coveney and R Tooth for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Agnew Litigation & HR Pty Ltd for the applicants

Enyo Lawyers for the respondent

  1. The respondent is incorporated under the Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld). The applicants are members of the respondent.

  2. Disputes have arisen over the rejection by the respondent’s management committee of applications for membership of the respondent.  On 24 September 2021 Jackson J restrained the holding of an annual general meeting arising from decisions made by the management committee on 30 August 2021 to reject a large number of applications for membership.[1]

  3. On 25 February 2022 Kelly J declared that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Singh and others brought proceedings against the Brisbane Sikh Temple (Gurdwara) Inc, challenging the rejection of their applications for membership. The applicants sought a number of orders, including an order appointing a receiver to the Temple for various purposes. The primary judge considered the applicants' application to appoint a receiver, which they sought to do for the purpose of undertaking a further reconsideration process, convening a general meeting to vote on the election of the Temple's management committee, and making decisions about the process and procedures to be adopted for the general meeting. The judge considered the arguments of both parties and weighed the costs and benefits of appointing a receiver against the availability of the appeal process. The judge was not satisfied that the appointment of a receiver was necessary and dismissed the application. The judge considered that the existence of an appeal process to challenge an erroneous rejection of an application for membership was an important reason why they were not satisfied that the appointment of a receiver was necessary. The judge concluded that the existence of an appeal process meant that it was not just and convenient, or necessary, to appoint a receiver.

The judge concluded that the appointment of a receiver is a remedy to be exercised with great caution. The power should not be exercised unless the Court is convinced of its necessity. The applicants had raised serious questions about the correctness or competence of decisions made by the management committee in the course of the reconsideration process. However, many factual matters remained in dispute, and the applicants had not commenced a proceeding that sought as relief declarations that all or some of the management committee's reconsideration decisions were void or of no effect. Instead, having consented to the reconsideration process order by Jackson J on 4 April 2022, they now sought to take the reconsideration process out of the hands of the management committee and place it in the hands of a court-appointed receiver. The appointment of a receiver would cost the respondent at least $200,000. The judge concluded that the appointment of a receiver was not necessary given the availability of the appeal process.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application to appoint a receiver made in paragraph 2 of the application filed on 17 March 2022 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The existence of an appeal process to challenge an erroneous rejection of an application for membership is an important reason why I am not satisfied that the appointment of a receiver is necessary. The appointment of a receiver is a remedy to be exercised with great caution. The power should not be exercised unless the Court is convinced of its necessity. An alternative process to remedy alleged erroneous decisions made by the management committee during the reconsideration process exists. Its existence means that I am not convinced that it is just and convenient, or necessary, to appoint a receiver. Conclusion The applicants have not sought directions under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) to enforce compliance with the 4 April orders or to cure alleged non-compliance with them. They have not commenced a proceeding that seeks as relief declarations that all or some of the management committee’s reconsideration decisions are void or of no effect. Instead, having consented to the reconsideration process order by Jackson J on 4 April 2022, they now seek to take the reconsideration process out of the hands of the management committee and place it in the hands of a court-appointed receiver. The appointment of a receiver will cost the respondent at least $200,000. The applicants have raised serious questions about the correctness or competence of decisions made by the management committee in the course of the reconsideration process. The respondent’s secretary has responded to many of those allegations, and many factual matters remain in dispute. A few decisions are accepted by the secretary as having been wrong and are subject to recommendations to be made at the next meeting of the management committee to correct them and to accept an application. I am not in a position to resolve, and I have not been asked to resolve, the remaining factual matters in dispute that have been the subject of voluminous affidavit evidence. No proceeding in this Court seeks a final determination of those disputed questions of fact. That the Sikh Temple finds itself in this predicament is a matter of regret. It has been said that there are factions in the Sikh community. Given the objectives of the respondent it is unfortunate, to say the least, that its assets and the energies of persons who subscribe to its beliefs have been expended on litigation rather than the objects for which the Temple was established. My function is not to mediate a dispute. It is to decide a particular application that has arisen because of the significant dissatisfaction the applicants have over the conduct of the reconsideration process ordered by this Court. The organisation’s Constitution provides an appeal process by which a person whose application for membership has been rejected may appeal to a general meeting. That appeal process has not been availed of by any of the many 880 persons whose applications were rejected by the management committee on the basis that their applications did not comply with the Constitution’s requirements. Nor have there been appeals by any of the 565 persons whose applications were initially approved for membership but who, for some reason, did not pay the membership fee and whose applications were then rejected at meetings of the management committee in May. In circumstances in which appeal rights have not been exercised, I am not convinced that it is appropriate to appoint a receiver.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The consent orders further provided for the timing of nominations from eligible members who wished to nominate for the management committee and for the convening of a general meeting of the members of the respondent within 30 days of the close of nominations. The reconsideration process A large volume of affidavit material was read before me about the reconsideration process. The applicants allege various irregularities in the process. The respondent rejects these allegations. It is sufficient for present purposes to outline the outcome of the reconsideration process and the substance of the complaints. More than 700 applicants were approved for membership as ordinary members and already had paid the membership fee. A further 565 applicants were initially approved for membership, but, according to the respondent, failed to pay the membership fee following a request to do so and had their applications rejected at management committee meetings in May 2022. Next, 880 applications were rejected as having failed to comply with requirements of clauses 5 and 6 of the Constitution. The management committee’s reasons included the following:(a)the application did not contain the full information prescribed by the membership form;(b)the membership form was either unsigned or the signature did not appear to match the signature on the accompanying statutory declaration; or(c)no statutory declaration was provided as part of the application. The applicants allege that the management committee failed to notify a large number of the rejected applicants as to whether their application was accepted or rejected and failed to properly direct about payment. The applicants also dispute that the 880 applicants who were rejected had failed to provide the required information, signature or statutory declaration, as alleged by the respondent. The applicants’ affidavit material includes information obtained from a survey of applicants for membership as well as direct evidence about the submission of the required application for membership and supporting statutory declaration. In response, the secretary of the respondent explains the basis upon which the applications were assessed and reiterates that, contrary to the applicants’ evidence, statutory declaration forms were not lodged with the relevant applications. It is unnecessary to elaborate about these factual disputes. I am not invited to make, and I am not in a position to make, findings about whether, for example, the required statutory declaration was submitted, as required, and was lost at some stage in the complicated process of determining so many applications. Similarly, I am not invited to resolve, and I am not in a position to resolve, why 565 applicants, whose applications were initially approved for membership, failed to pay. Possibilities abound. An address appearing on the application form may be out of date. Communications may have been sent to the wrong address or email address. Some applicants may have lost interest in becoming members and may not want to pay $100 to an organisation which spends a large amount of its income on lawyers.The application to appoint a receiver