Simplot Australia Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Simplot Australia Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCA 1115

File number(s): VID 59 of 2022
Judgment of: HESPE J
Date of judgment: 22 September 2023
Catchwords: TAXATION – goods and services tax – exemption – whether certain frozen food supplied and imported by the applicant was “of a kind” “marketed as a prepared meal”
Legislation:

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 13-10, 38-2, 38-3, 38-4, Schedule 1

Evidence Act1995 (Cth) s 79

Cases cited:

Cascade Brewery v Commissioner of Taxation [2006] FCA 821; (2006) 153 FCR 11

Clean Investments Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 80; (2001) 105 FCR 248

Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar [2011] HCA 21; (2011) 243 CLR 588

JMB Beverages Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2009] FCA 668; (2009) 73 ATR 191

Lansell House Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2011] FCAFC 6; (2011) 190 FCR 354

Lansell House Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 329; (2010) 76 ATR 19

MacKiewicz v KAL Holdings Pty Ltd [1999] WASCA 84

Miller v MacKnight [1945] J.C. 107

Mills v O’Donoghue (1908) 10 WAR 81

Olive v Carroll [1941] VLR 37

Stevens v Kabushiki Kaisha Sony Computer Entertainment [2005] HCA 58; (2005) 224 CLR 193

Taxation, Commissioner of (Cth) v Chubb Australia Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 557

Uber BV v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2017] FCA 110; (2017) 247 FCR 462

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Taxation
Number of paragraphs: 142
Date of hearing: 27–28 March 2023
Counsel for the Applicant Mr C M Sievers
Solicitors for the Applicant Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Respondent  Mr M O’Meara SC and Mr S Ure
Solicitors for the Respondent ATO Dispute Resolution

ORDERS

VID 59 of 2022
BETWEEN:

SIMPLOT AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HESPE J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 SEPTEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.Unless either party applies within seven (7) days for a different order as to costs, the applicant pay the respondent’s costs to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

HESPE J:

BACKGROUND

  1. The central issue in this proceeding is whether certain frozen food products supplied and imported by the applicant in the tax period from 1 July 2021 to 31 July 2021 are GST-free. A supply of “food” is GST-free pursuant to s 38-2 of the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) (GST Act).An importation is a non-taxable importation if it would have been a supply that was GST-free: s 13-10(b). A supply is not GST-free if it is a supply of food of a kind specified in the third column of the table in clause 1 of Schedule 1 of the GST Act: s 38-3(c) of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simplot Australia Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Simplot Australia Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation, the Federal Court was called upon to determine whether certain frozen food products supplied and imported by the applicant were exempt from goods and services tax (GST) as they were "of a kind marketed as a prepared meal". The dispute centred on the interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and the nature of the products in question. The Court was tasked with interpreting the statutory language and considering the evidence presented, particularly the expert testimony of Mr. Field, to ascertain whether the products fell within the category of "prepared meals" exempt from GST.

The central legal issue was whether the frozen food products supplied and imported by the applicant, specifically the VeggieRice products, were of a kind marketed as prepared meals. This required the Court to examine the statutory language of the GST Act, the context of the statutory scheme, and the extrinsic materials available to discern the legislative intent. Additionally, the Court had to evaluate the evidence provided by Mr. Field, particularly his identification of alternative products and their similarity to the products in question, to determine if they could be considered substitutes that would assist in classifying the products as "prepared meals".

The Court found significant shortcomings in the evidence of Mr. Field. The questions posed to Mr. Field did not align with the statutory inquiry, which focuses on the seller's activities and the marketing of products as prepared meals. Mr. Field's approach was consumer-focused rather than seller-focused, which was not pertinent to the statutory question. Consequently, the Court did not find Mr. Field's identification of alternative products or their similarity to the products in question to be useful in resolving the statutory issue. The Court relied on Mr. Field's report only for its description of the products and their packaging, not for his identification of a genus of foods.

Ultimately, the Court concluded that the statutory language must be construed according to its ordinary meaning, without invoking the concept of "basic food" or attempting to discern a legislative purpose beyond the text. The Court dismissed the applicant's application and ordered that unless either party applied within seven days for a different order regarding costs, the applicant would pay the respondent’s costs to be taxed if not agreed. This decision underscores the importance of aligning the statutory interpretation with the plain meaning of the words used in the legislation and the specific context of the seller's activities.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. Unless either party applies within seven (7) days for a different order as to costs, the applicant pay the respondent’s costs to be taxed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Simplot Australia Pty Limited, the applicant, sought a review of a decision by the Commissioner of Taxation that determined certain frozen food products supplied and imported by the applicant were not exempt from goods and services tax (GST). The products in question were VeggieRice Products which the applicant marketed under headings such as "Drive new Consumption Occasions —Providing solutions for consumers to increase their vegetable intake" and "NEW Birds Eye Meal Bases". These products were marketed with benefits such as being an easy solution to reducing carb intake and increasing vegetable intake, being pre-prepared with no chopping or processing, and being versatile with a long shelf life. The applicant provided evidence in the form of a customer communication for Woolworths and expert evidence from Mr Field. However, the Court found significant difficulties with Mr Field’s evidence, particularly in how he identified products that consumers might purchase as substitutes for the VeggieRice Products and in his analysis of these products’ similarity to the VeggieRice Products.

The matter was brought before the court as an application for review of a decision by the Commissioner of Taxation. This decision had already been subject to review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which upheld the Commissioner's decision. The applicant then sought further review in the court, arguing that the Commissioner’s decision was incorrect in law. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties and examined the evidence provided, including the customer communication and expert evidence, before making its determination.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A customer communication dated 17 June 2021 prepared by the applicant for Woolworths showed the VeggieRice Products under a heading “Drive new Consumption Occasions —Providing solutions for consumers to increase their vegetable intake”. On a separate page the two products appeared on a page entitled “NEW Birds Eye Meal Bases” with the following identified “Consumer Benefit[s]”:✓ Easy solution to reducing carb intake and increasing vegetable intake✓ Pre-prepared no chopping or processing and different to what is available in fresh/shelf✓ Versatile base and cooking methods, with a long shelf life“Expert” evidence of Mr Field There were significant difficulties with the evidence of Mr Field. The difficulties arise from the form of the questions asked, the nature of his experience, the methods he adopted and the opinions he expresses. The first question asked of Mr Field was to identify products which a consumer might wish to purchase as substitutes for each of the Products. As discussed further below at paragraph [105], the statutory question looks to the kinds of foods marketed as prepared meals and thereby looks at the activities of the seller. Mr Field was asked to approach the identification of a genus of products by reference to the conduct of consumers. That is not the statutory question. The alternative products identified by Mr Field through the eyes of a consumer that could be purchased in substitution for the Products included air dried broccoli and “cauli rice”, frozen soybeans, and a plain pre-cooked pasta product without sauce. Mr Field’s approach to the question asked of him was to walk around a supermarket and identify products he thought consumers would purchase as substitutes for the Products. Mr Field’s professional background is in product development. It is not clear how this exercise involved any specialist knowledge of Mr Field. Even if it were possible to consider that one might have an expertise in supermarket shopping, Mr Field was not such an expert. It may be accepted that a person may have expertise in marketing. But Mr Field did not give a report on how the products he identified were marketed beyond describing their packaging. The second question asked of Mr Field was taking each of the products he had identified as alternatives, to identify the extent to which each of those alternative products were similar to the Products in terms of their nature, quality and adaptation. Given the difficulties with the basis on which Mr Field had identified the alternative products, the Court was not assisted by the extent to which Mr Field considered each of those alternative products were similar to the Products in terms of their nature, quality and adaptation. The third question asked of Mr Field was the extent to which any of the features of the Products and of the alternative products he had identified indicate that each of the Products and the alternative products were intended to be consumed as a meal or were likely to be consumed as a meal. Mr Field was instructed that a “meal” is an ordinary English word and simply means that which is taken at or provided for one occasion of eating.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the VeggieRice Products supplied and imported by the applicant were “of a kind” and “marketed as a prepared meal” for the purposes of the exemption from GST.
2. Whether the statutory context and extrinsic materials provide any assistance in determining the meaning of "basic food for human consumption" under the GST Act.
3. Whether the Court should rely on the report of Mr Field to assist in the resolution of the statutory question.

Held
1. The court held that the VeggieRice Products supplied and imported by the applicant were not "of a kind" and "marketed as a prepared meal" for the purposes of the exemption from GST.
2. The court held that the statutory context and extrinsic materials do not provide any assistance in determining the meaning of "basic food for human consumption" under the GST Act. The words must be construed in accordance with their ordinary meaning.
3. The court held that the report of Mr Field should not be relied on to assist in the resolution of the statutory question due to significant difficulties with the evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court has relied upon the report of Mr Field solely for its description of the Products and their packaging. The Court does not accept that Mr Field identified a genus of foods to which the Products belonged in a manner that assists the resolution of the statutory question or that the genus he so identified was based on his specialised training or experience. CONSIDERATIONObservations on the statutory scheme In JMB Beverages Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2009] FCA 668; (2009) 73 ATR 191, Edmonds J (at [63]–[64]) considered that the language of the GST Act, statutory context and extrinsic materials gave “every indication” of “a legislative purpose to exempt from GST, ‘basic food for human consumption’” and went on to say at [65]: The notion of ‘basic’ food pertains to food that is fundamental to sustenance, or rudimentary, having few or no attributes, beyond the ordinary or essential elements necessary to achieve that purpose: see the definition of ‘basic’ in the Oxford English Dictionary: ‘Providing or having few or no amenities, accessories, functions, etc, beyond the ordinary or essential; of or designating the lowest standard acceptable or available; rudimentary.’ On one level, the idea of basic food inevitably devolves into a merit category (see G S Cooper GS and R J Vann, “Implementing the Goods and Services Tax” (1999) 21 Sydney Law Review 337 at 349) in that, caught up in that notion is the presumption that it is likely to encompass food which is fresh, natural or unprocessed: see the Further Supplementary Explanatory Memorandum (Senate) to the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Bill 1998 (Cth) at cl 1.2, that ‘… supplies of fresh fruit and vegetables by a primary producer will be GST-free.’ This is evident from Sch 1 as to the ‘Food that is not GST-free’, and Sch 2 as to the ‘Beverages that are GST-free’. For example, items such as certain prepared foods, snack foods, confectionary, ice cream and biscuits are not GST-free. As to beverages neither soft drinks, (including flavoured mineral waters) nor cordials, are GST-free. An examination of the statutory context of item 4 of clause 1 of Schedule 1 does not, in my view, reveal a coherent policy that is of assistance in the present case. One might speculate that the forms of the specific carve outs from the rule that food is GST-free were the product of compromise and lobbying. In Stevens v Kabushiki Kaisha Sony Computer Entertainment [2005] HCA 58; (2005) 224 CLR 193, McHugh J stated at [126]: Much modern legislation…is the product of intensive lobbying, directly or indirectly, of Ministers and parliamentarians.In such circumstances there is a danger to attempt to construe the items by reference to some supposed legislative purpose rather than solely by reference to the text. There is, for example, no clear rationale as to why soup marketed as a prepared meal should be GST-free but other types of food not. It is not clear why food sold unrefrigerated in vacuum‑sealed or canned form is not GST-free but the same sort of food (eg Irish stew) sold in frozen form is subject to GST. The issue for determination in this case is not assisted by reference to a concept of food being “sufficiently basic”. Rather the words are to be construed in accordance with their ordinary meaning.