Simmons v Esk Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Simmons v Esk Shire Council [2006] QPEC 101

PARTIES:

MARTIN SIMMONS

Appellant

V

ESK SHIRE COUNCIL

Respondent

And

BRUCE & JUNE YOUNG, DONNA SWEEDMAN, STEVE & GAI NIELSEN, BRUCE & JUDY SHIRLEY, J & V FLANAGAN, BARRY & MARY BUSTEED, ROBERT BOULT, REV. ROBERT ANFORTH, CHALSEY BLANCE, C&G BEHRENDORFF, K C&S E DUFF, JOHN & CHRIS FRISKE, PETER & LYNNE MARSHALL, G & K MULLER, NORMA DEACON, JOHN MURPHY, JILLIAN PEARSON, CRAIG SCHULTE, DR IAN WILSON, M WILSON AND WEST MORETON LANDCARE GROUP INC.

Co-respondents by Election

FILE NO/S:

BD 116 OF 2005

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Developer appeal against refusal of development application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

26 September 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4-8 September 2006

JUDGE:

Judge Robin, QC

ORDER:

(made 22 September 2006) Appeal dismissed, application refused

CATCHWORDS:

Integrated Planning Act 1997 s 4.1.52(2)(a) – Local Government (Planning and Environment) Act 1990 s 4.13(5A) –

Developer appeal against refusal of a 2004 development application for material change of use for a “poultry farm” – proposed use permissible by consent of Council – by a “minor change”, proposal was reduced from 5 tunnel-ventilated sheds of 40,000 birds to 3 – issues included acceptability of odour and particulate emissions creating health concerns (local residents depended on roof-collected rainwater for drinking) – precautionary principle invoked – whether arrangements proposed for impounding polluted surface run-off on the site would be effective was contentious – proposed use was rural, rather than industrial – conflict with 1992 strategic plan which called for protection of “existing” character and amenity of rural areas – appellant did not show that impacts could be acceptably managed – proposal did not comply with 2005 planning scheme separation distances for the use (which it categorised as “intensive animal industry”), nor with corresponding separation distances applicable in adjacent local government areas having boundaries close to the site.

COUNSEL:

Mr Haydon for the Appellant

Mr Ure for the Respondent

Mr Everson for Co-respondents by Election

SOLICITORS:

Anderssen Lawyers for the Appellant

King & Company for the Respondent

MA Kent & Assoc. for Co-respondents by Election

  1. Development proposals to facilitate the production of meat by modern intensive methods, such as beef feed lots, piggeries and poultry farms are likely to be contentious if there are potential or apprehended impacts on neighbours – or uses of neighbouring sites.  But for a dedicated (unformed) road, an immediate neighbour of the appellant developer’s site would be Sonshine Ranch.  It is effectively represented in this appeal by one of the co-respondents by election, Mr Boult, and said in the adverse submission to be “a not-for-profit community camp site …[able to] accommodate 132 persons and provide services and activities to children during school camps and many other community groups”.  Minden State School is about one kilometre away, just across the Warrego Highway.  Nearer neighbours locally resident are the Nielsens, the Friskes and the Flanagans (each of whom contributed a witness) and the Youngs (precluded by logistical difficulties from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simmons v Esk Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QPEC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Simmons v Esk Shire Council, the applicant, Simmons, appealed against the council's decision to refuse a 2004 development application for a material change of use of land for a poultry farm. The proposed use of the land was permissible with the consent of the council, but the proposal involved a minor change to the number of sheds, reducing the capacity from 5 tunnel-ventilated sheds of 40,000 birds to 3. The refusal was contested due to concerns about the potential odour and particulate emissions, particularly as the local residents relied on roof-collected rainwater for drinking. The precautionary principle was invoked, raising questions about the effectiveness of the proposed arrangements for managing polluted surface run-off on the site.

The court had to decide whether the developer had demonstrated that the proposed use of the land for a poultry farm could be managed without unacceptable impacts on the environment and the local community. The court considered whether the applicant had shown that the potential health concerns could be addressed, and if the proposed use complied with the separation distances specified in the 2005 planning scheme and the corresponding distances in adjacent local government areas. The court also had to consider whether the proposal complied with the 1992 strategic plan, which called for the protection of the existing character and amenity of rural areas.

The court found that Simmons did not adequately demonstrate that the potential impacts of the proposed poultry farm could be managed to an acceptable level. The proposed use of the land did not comply with the separation distances specified in the 2005 planning scheme and the corresponding distances in adjacent local government areas. Additionally, the court found that the proposed use was in conflict with the 1992 strategic plan, which aimed to protect the existing character and amenity of rural areas. The court concluded that Simmons had not shown that the potential impacts of the proposed poultry farm could be managed to an acceptable level, and therefore dismissed the appeal and refused the development application.

The final orders made on 22 September 2006 were that the appeal was dismissed and the development application was refused. The council's decision to refuse the development application was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

(made 22 September 2006) Appeal dismissed, application refused

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.