Ecofence Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Ecofence Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council and Ors  [2013] QPEC 60

PARTIES:

Ecofence Pty Ltd ACN 097636121 (Appellant)      Appellant

v

Brisbane City Council (Respondent)

and

Janis Christine Boyd (Second Co-Respondent by Election)

and

Robert John Baldwin (Third Co-Respondent by Election)  Third Co-Respondenby Election

and

Kelly Sharon Keys  (Fourth Co-Respondent by Election)

and

Elizabeth and James Wardrop (Fifth Co-Respondents by

Election)                 

FILE NO:

BD 4519 of 2011

DIVISION:

Planning & Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal   

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

18 October 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15, 16 and 25 October 2012 supplementary submissions to 25 February 2013

JUDGE:

Andrews SC DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal adjourned to a date to be fixed to allow the Respondent to prepare conditions of approval in accordance with these reasons

CATCHWORDS:

Developer’s appeal against deemed refusal of approval for a multi-unit dwelling in a Demolition Control Precinct and  in a Low-Medium Density Residential Area – where proposal more than two storey – where street predominantly pre-1946 houses – where five three bedroom units exceeded Acceptable Solutions for GFA and storeys – where skillion roofs noncompliant with Acceptable Solution – where front setback noncompliant with Acceptable Solution – where other multi-unit dwellings in the locality but only one in the street – whether compliant with performance criterion that building height and bulk must complement the predominant scale of pre–1946 houses nearby in the street – whether compliant with performance criterion that building setting must complement the traditional setting of pre–1946 houses nearby in the street – whether compliant with performance criteria that building form must complement the traditional elements of pre–1946 houses nearby in the street – whether compliant with performance criterion that Roof form must reflect traditional roofs in that part of the Demolition Control Precinct – whether compliant with performance criterion that Development size and bulk consistent with the low to medium density of the locality – whether compliant with other performance criteria – relevance of acceptable solutions

Sustainable Planning Act s 326

Agtec Holdings v Kilcoy City Council [1999] QPELR

Chesol Pty Ltd  v Logan City Council [2007] QPELR 285

Jensen Bowers Group Consultants Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council [2011] QPEC 049

Lewis v Townsville City Council & Ors [2012] QCA 99

Lockyer Valley Regional Council v Westlink Pty Ltd & Ors [2012] QCA 370

SDW Projects Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council & Anor [2007] QPELR 24

Simmons v Esk Shire Council [2006] QPEC 101

Szylkarski & Ors v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2012] QPEC 80

Weightman v Gold Coast City Council[2003] 2 Qd R 441

COUNSEL:

J G Lyons (for the Respondent)

SOLICITORS:

Milne Legal for the Appellant
Brisbane City Legal Practice for the Respondent

Background
Was a change to the development application a minor change?

Issues
Three sets of Performance Criteria and Acceptable Solutions are in issue
The Statutory Framework
What must the developer do to satisfy the onus of proof?
Relevance of non-compliance with Acceptable Solutions
The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ecofence Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QPEC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ecofence Pty Ltd appealed against the Brisbane City Council's deemed refusal to approve a multi-unit dwelling in a Demolition Control Precinct and a Low-Medium Density Residential Area. The proposed development, which exceeded two storeys, featured five three-bedroom units with skillion roofs, front setbacks, and gross floor area that did not comply with the Acceptable Solutions outlined in the City Plan. The developer argued that the proposal complied with the relevant performance criteria, which required the building's height, bulk, and form to complement the predominant scale, setting, and traditional elements of pre-1946 houses nearby.

The legal issues in this case revolved around whether the proposed development complied with the City Plan's performance criteria and whether the developer discharged the onus of proving that the decision to approve the application would not conflict with the City Plan. The developer needed to demonstrate how the alternative solutions complied with the Code's Performance Criteria and met the Code's Purpose. The court considered whether the developer had provided sufficient evidence to support their claims of compliance and if the City Plan's provisions regarding acceptable solutions and alternative compliance methods were adequately addressed.

The court found that the developer did not sufficiently discharge the onus of proving that the proposal complied with the relevant performance criteria. The expert evidence presented by the developer did not adequately explain how the alternative solutions complied with the Performance Criteria or the Code's Purpose, nor did it address how the development mitigated the effects of noncompliance. The court highlighted that the expert evidence tended to skip from describing the proposal's alternative solution to an opinion on compliance, omitting the necessary steps to explain how the alternative solution complied with the Performance Criteria or the Code's Purpose.

The appeal was adjourned to allow the respondent to prepare conditions of approval in accordance with the court's reasons.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal adjourned to a date to be fixed to allow the Respondent to prepare conditions of approval in accordance with these reasons

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The SPA provides rules which bind this court in determining whether to approve this application. The relevant rules in this proceeding are:326 Other decision rules(1)The assessment manager’s decision must not conflict with a relevant instrument unless - …(b)There are sufficient grounds to justify the decision, despite the conflict;… For this appeal, the only statutory planning control that is a “relevant instrument” within the meaning of the SPA s 326(1) is City Plan. The term “grounds” in the SPA s 326(1)(b) is defined in Schedule 3 of the SPA and means matters of public interest but does not include the personal circumstance of an applicant, owner or interested party. The threshold issue in the SPA s 326(1) is whether there is a conflict with the planning scheme. The significance of a conflict with the planning scheme is not part of the threshold issue. In this appeal, provisions of the SPA s 326(1) mean the developer bears the onus of proof that the decision to approve would not conflict with City Plan. Conflict with a provision or with several provisions of a planning scheme may not amount to conflict with a planning scheme as a whole. The SPA s 326(1) is concerned with a conflict with a relevant instrument and not with conflict with a provision of a relevant instrument. If a provision is significant in the scheme then a decision in conflict with that provision is more likely to be also in conflict with the scheme. One may conflict with a provision of City Plan in isolation without conflicting with City Plan as a whole. The developer’s onus of proof is affected by City Plan for an impact assessable application such as this, where compliance with Performance Criteria is an issue. City Plan provides:“For … impact assessment the Acceptable Solutions represent the preferred way of complying with the Performance Criteria. There may be other ways of complying with the Performance Criteria while still meeting the Code's Purpose. It is the responsibility of the applicant to demonstrate how alternative solutions comply with the Code's Performance Criteria. A proposal that fails to comply with the Performance Criteria, except in insignificant details, will be refused where it cannot be conditioned to mitigate impacts.” Accordingly, City Plan contemplates that a developer may depart from Acceptable Solutions while meeting Performance Criteria. Further, City Plan contemplates approvals for developments which fail to comply with Performance Criteria if the failure is in insignificant details which can be conditioned to mitigate impacts. The submitters emphasised the consequences for the developer’s onus of that provision of City Plan. The submitters argued that the developer did not do sufficient to discharge this onus. The argument was, in effect, that where the developer elected not to use an Acceptable Solution and applied to use another way of complying with a relevant performance criterion to meet the Code’s Purpose the developer had an onus to “demonstrate how alternative solutions comply with the Code's Performance Criteria” while still meeting the “Code’s Purpose”. The submitters argued that the expert witnesses supporting approval did not supply a methodology for their opinions or explain how the developer’s solution complied with a Performance Criterion, or, if not complying, how the development mitigated the effects of noncompliance. I infer that the criticism is that the expert evidence tended to skip from a description of the proposal’s alternative solution to an opinion that it complies with the Performance Criterion. Such a skip would omit: the step of explaining how it complies with the Performance Criterion or the Code’s Purpose; the alternative step of saying that it if it does not comply with a Performance Criterion but that the details are insignificant and why they are insignificant; the alternative step that the proposal adequately mitigates the effect of noncompliance and how it does so.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.