SIMES v MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION
[2004] SASC 84
Full Court: Prior, Debelle and Bleby JJ
PRIOR J: I agree with Bleby J. The appeal should be dismissed.
DEBELLE J: I have had the advantage of reading the reasons of Bleby J. I agree with them. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed.
BLEBY J: The Water Resources Act (the “Act”) 1997 is a code relating to the use of water resources, including underground water, in this State. Section 7(1) restates the common law right, subject to other provisions of the Act and in particular to the remaining provisions of s 7, of a person who has lawful access to a “watercourse, lake or well”. That is qualified, however, by the fact that a licence under the Act is required to take water from a prescribed watercourse, lake or well or to take surface water from a surface water prescribed area.
Most of the State’s significant water resources are prescribed under the Act, and therefore require a licence before they can be used. The amount of water that may be taken from a prescribed water resource depends on the relevant water allocation endorsed on the licence. It is not necessary for present purposes to describe how the water allocation on a licence is determined. For a person without existing use rights the allocation is determined by the Minister in accordance with the requirements of s 35.
Some of the State’s underground water resources have only relatively recently been proclaimed. Before that, subject to complying with legislation regulating the drilling of wells, there was no regulation of the amount of water that could be taken from an underground well.
The appellant owns land at Kangarilla in what is known as the Upper Willunga Catchment Area (“the Area”). In 1985 a bore was sunk on the appellant’s land. From 1991 the appellant had used underground water from the bore for the irrigation of pasture and vines. At that time wells in the area were not prescribed wells.
On 24 December 1998 all existing wells in the area became prescribed wells.
The appellant has not been granted a licence to take water from his bore, and accordingly he has no water allocation from the bore. This appeal concerns his alleged right to a water allocation as at 24 December 1998, the date of the relevant proclamation of the wells in the area as prescribed wells.
Control of the use of underground water in the Area began under the Water Resources Act 1990, an Act repealed by the Act. By s 40 of that Act the Minister was empowered to prohibit or restrict the taking of water from a watercourse, lake or well in the case of inadequate supply or over-use of water. On 1 April 1993 the then Minister introduced a moratorium on the taking of water from water resources in the area in amounts which exceeded the then existing use at the date of the notice. A similar provision enabling…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Simes v Minister for Environment and Conservation No. Scciv-... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] SASC 84
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether the appellant was entitled to a water allocation under section 36 of the Water Resources Act. The appellant argued that he was an "existing user" within the meaning of section 36 and therefore entitled to a water allocation calculated in accordance with that section. The court had to examine the meaning of "existing user" and whether the appellant's failure to apply for a licence within six months of the well becoming a prescribed well precluded him from being considered an existing user.
The court concluded that the appellant was not an existing user within the meaning of section 36 at the time of his application for a licence and water allocation, as he had not applied within the specified time frame. The court rejected the appellant's argument that different functions of the term "existing user" within section 36 required varying interpretations of the time limit. The court held that the language of the Act allowed for only one construction, and the appellant's failure to apply within the specified time frame meant he was not an existing user and had no right to a water allocation calculated in accordance with section 36.
The court also dismissed the appellant's reliance on section 33 of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993, which allows the court to excuse a failure to comply with a requirement of any Act or other law. The court held that section 33 could not be used to change the substantive effect of the Water Resources Act, as it would require the Minister to consider the appellant's application under section 36 where the Act plainly required it to be considered under section 35. The appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed, and the Environment, Resources and Development Court's decision was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi