Minister for Environment and Conservation v Simes

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v SIMES

[2007] SASC 248

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Bleby and The Honourable Justice Sulan)

4 July 2007

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - WATER - WATER MANAGEMENT - WATER USAGE RIGHTS

Refusal of Minister to grant water (taking) licence – Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) – Minister’s decision set aside on appeal to Environment, Resources and Development Court – Issue of licence dependent on water allocations – Whether water allocation could be made consistently with the relevant Water Allocation Plan – Consideration of legislative scheme of Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) – Consideration and proper construction of the Water Allocation Plan – Appeal allowed – Order of the ERD Court set aside.

Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) s 36; s 46; s 101; Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) Clause 54, Schedule 4; s 74; s 75; s 76; s 77; s 78; s 79; s 80; s 81; s 124; s 126; s 128; s 146; s 150; s 151; s 152; s 155; s 156, referred to.
Ward v Williams (1955) 92 CLR 496; Finance Facilities Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1971) 127 CLR 106; Julius v Bishop of Oxford (1880) 5 App Cas 214, applied.
Simes v Minister for Environment and Conservation [2006] SAERDC 90, not followed.
Simes v Minister for Environment and Conservation [2003] SAERDC 75; Simes v Minister for Environment and Conservation (2004) 88 SASR 174; Michelmore v Minister for Environment and Conservation (2004) 137 LGERA 306, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Consistent with"

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v SIMES
[2007] SASC 248

Full Court:      Doyle CJ, Bleby and Sulan JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I agree with the orders proposed by Bleby J.  There is nothing that I wish to add to his reasons.

    BLEBY J:

    Introduction

  2. By application dated 4 February 2002, the respondent applied to the Minister for a water licence, seeking a water (taking) allocation based on the area of his land situated within the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells Area. The application was made under the Water Resources Act 1997 (SA). The applicant claimed entitlement as an existing user. The Minister refused the application on the basis that an allocation could not be made consistently with the water allocation plan for the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells Area (“the WAP”) because the respondent was not an existing user. The WAP had been adopted by the Minister on 6 November 2000.

  3. As result of an unsuccessful purported appeal to the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the ERDC”)[1] and an unsuccessful appeal to this Court,[2] the respondent’s application was remitted to the Minister for the respondent to make further submissions as to how an allocation could be made (to him) consistently with the Plan. In those proceedings the Court held that the respondent was not an existing user because, although he had lawfully been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Environment and Conservation v Simes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Minister for Environment and Conservation v Simes, the respondent's application for a water (taking) licence under the Natural Resources Management Act 2004 (SA) was refused by the Minister, on the basis that the maximum annual quantity of water available for allocation in the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells Area from 1 July 2003 had already been fully allocated. The refusal was set aside by the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERDC). The Minister appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal was dismissed.

The issue before the Court was whether the refusal of the application was lawful and in accordance with the Water Allocation Plan (WAP). Specifically, the Court needed to determine whether the allocation of water could be made consistently with the WAP, given that the total volume of water, determined on a sustainable basis to be available for allocation, had not been allocated.

The Court considered the relevant provisions of the NRM Act and the WAP. It noted that the WAP only permitted water to be allocated to existing licence holders, but it also noted that the premise underlying the Plan was that, after 1 July 2003, 6,600ML of water would be available for allocation in the area, and accordingly that 95ML was presently unallocated. The Court concluded that an allocation of 23ML to the respondent would be in harmony with the WAP, and therefore consistent with the Plan. The Court held that it would not appear to be in the public interest that an application for a water allocation be refused when the total volume of water, determined on a sustainable basis to be available for allocation, had not been allocated.

The Court dismissed the appeal and allowed the decision of the ERDC. The Court held that the Minister's decision to refuse the application was not in accordance with the WAP, and that the refusal was unlawful. The Court ordered that the decision of the ERDC be affirmed, and that the Minister grant the respondent's application for a water (taking) licence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

None of the operative provisions in respect of the period from 1 July 2003 are cast in terms of granting additional allocations other than to existing licence holders. They only provide the formulae for how allocations are to be determined and how allocations from that date are to be expressed, and then only in relation to licences already endorsed with an allocation.The decision of the ERDC The Minister had refused the respondent’s application for a licence on the following grounds:1.The Minister took the view that the WAP only permitted water to be allocated to a person who held a licence in existence at the date of the adoption of the Plan; and2.The Minister understood at the time that the maximum annual quantity of water available for allocation in the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells Area from 1 July 2003 (6,600ML) had already been fully allocated. On 13 July 2006, after the refusal of the application, the Minister concluded an audit of licensed water allocations within the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells Area and determined that 6,504.852ML of water had been allocated to licensees. This was less than the maximum available for allocation in accordance with the WAP. In the proceedings before the ERDC the Minister did not seek to uphold the refusal on the basis that the maximum quantity of water available had been fully allocated. The Court proceeded on the basis that approximately 95ML of the resource was unallocated. The Court noted the relevant provisions of the NRM Act and summarised the first four Parts of the WAP. It considered, in my view correctly, that by the language of Part 5 water could only be allocated to existing licence holders, but it considered that the premise underlying the Plan and the allocation provisions was that, after 1 July 2003, 6,600ML of water would be available for allocation in the area, and accordingly that 95ML was presently unallocated. In discussing whether an allocation would be consistent with WAP[20] the Court concluded that the allocation must be “in harmony with” the Plan. The Court concluded:Given the right that inheres in an allocation of water pursuant to a water licence under the NRM Act, it would not appear to be in the public interest that an application for a water allocation be refused when the total volume of water, determined on a sustainable basis to be available for allocation – all other needs having been taken into account - has not been allocated. The needs of dependent ecosystems having been taken into account, which the Plan allows for, it follows that an allocation to an applicant who does not presently hold a licence, in the amount of 23 ML as sought by the appellant, would be in harmony, and therefore consistent with the Water Allocation Plan. An allocation of this magnitude is compatible and consistent with the Water Allocation Plan, and is possible having regard to the volume available for allocation and the volume that presently has been allocated. In the circumstances, where the needs of dependant ecosystems have been assessed and catered for, such an allocation would be consistent with the objects of the Act referred to earlier in these reasons.[21][20] See NRM Act ss 146(3)(a) and 152(1)(a).[21] Simes v Minister for Environment & Conservation [2006] SAERDC 90 at [26].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established