SHQY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SHQY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 930 (20 April 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/2130

Re:SHQY

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndXYCB

OTHER PARTY

Tribunal:Mr Rob Reitano, Member

Date:20 April 2021

Place:Sydney

DECISION

I set aside the decision of AAT1 and in its place I revoke the care determination made on 7 August 2007 with effect from 27 October 2011 and determine that the father had 50% of the care of the child from 28 October 2011 until 31 July 2019 and the mother had 0% of the care of the child in that period.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – period of care - notice of change of percentage of care - revocation of determination of care – whether new determination of care should be made – date of effect of any new determination – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) s 5, 49, 50, 54A, 54B, 54F, 54G, 54H

Child Support (Registration and Collections) Act 1988 (Cth) s 87AA

CASES

Polec & Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339

Shi v Migration Agents Review Authority [2008] HCA 31

Frampton and La Ponder (Child Support) [2015] AATA 321

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Child Support Guide (22 March 2021)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

20 April 2021

  1. In March 2019 SHQY (mother) became aware that XYCB (father) had in October 2011 notified the Child Support Agency (Agency) that the percentage of care between she and the father concerning their child (child) had changed from equal care of the child to one where the father had complete care of the child, because the mother had left the child with him when she left for New Zealand on 28 October 2011.

  2. The Agency, acting upon that advice and after making enquiries, changed the percentage of care for each parent from 50% each to one where the father had 100% care of the child.

  3. After 28 March 2019, when the mother discovered what had happened following her departure for New Zealand, she sought to undo the debt she had accumulated for payments in respect of the care of the child by pursuing an objection to the decision to change the percentage of care with the Agency, then with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Social Services & Child Support Division) (AAT1) and now with the Tribunal on review.

  4. The main issue concerns the percentage of care to be allocated to each of the parents of a child for the purpose of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (Act).

  5. I have decided to set aside the decision of AAT1 and in its place…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SHQY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 930
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a decision by the Child Support Registrar. The dispute arose from an application by the mother to review a decision concerning the percentage of care for the child. The mother had departed for New Zealand in October 2011, leaving the child, who was six years old, in the care of the father. The paternal grandmother subsequently invited the father and child to live with her, which they did until mid-2019 when the father moved out, and the child remained with the grandmother. The grandmother had been providing the child's day-to-day care since late 2011, attending to his basic needs and schooling, and consulting the father on significant decisions.

The Tribunal was required to determine the date of effect of any new determination of care percentage, particularly in light of the mother's objection to a previous care percentage decision. The central legal issue was whether section 87AA of the *Child Support (Registration and Collections) Act 1988* (Cth) applied to the mother's objection, and consequently, the date from which any revised care percentage should take effect. This involved considering whether the mother had been properly served with notice of the original care percentage decision.

The Member found that section 87AA(1) of the *Collection Act* did not apply because the objection was not lodged more than 28 days after notice of the care percentage decision was served. The evidence indicated that the mother had not been served with, or given notice of, the care percentage decision. The letter of 15 March 2019 was determined to be a recalculation of child support payable, not the care percentage decision itself. The Tribunal emphasised that the lack of formal service meant the mother was not in a position to know she had a limited time to exercise her review rights, and that decisions regarding care percentages have significant financial consequences.

The Tribunal set aside the Registrar's decision and substituted a new decision. The effect of this substitution was that the mother's objection was allowed, and a new determination of care percentage would be made. The date of effect of this new determination was to be determined in accordance with the relevant provisions of the *Child Support (Registration and Collections) Act 1988* (Cth), taking into account the circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On 9 April 2020, an application was to the Tribunal to review the decision of AAT1.THE FACTS A great deal of the narrative of the facts that I recount below is taken from the evidence given by the father’s mother, that is the child’s paternal grandmother (grandmother), who gave evidence after a summons to give evidence was issued to her at the request of the mother. The father did not participate at all in the proceedings despite having notice of them, as was his right. He too was summonsed to give evidence, but after the grandmother gave evidence it was agreed that it was not considered necessary for him to give evidence. Before dealing with the facts as narrated by the grandmother, I should note some things more generally about the grandmother’s evidence. The grandmother gave evidence helpfully, frankly, and truthfully. She answered questions directly and succinctly. It was suggested that the grandmother’s evidence was ‘biased’, by which I gather it was intended to convey that she fashioned her answers in a way that was partial to the father’s (her son’s) interests. That suggestion was never made when the mother’s representative was permitted to question her. There is, in any event, no sound basis at all for such a suggestion given what I have said about the way she presented and the fact that at least some of her evidence was, on its face, inimical to her son’s interests. On 28 October 2011, the mother boarded a plane to New Zealand. She sent a text message to the grandmother which said: ‘I’m on a plane. I’m going to New Zealand. Look after my boy’. It was then apparent, and if it were not it soon became so, that the mother was moving to New Zealand and arrangements would need to be made for the care of the child who was six years of age. At that time, the child was living with his father. About a month after the mother left for New Zealand the grandmother asked the father and the child to move in with her. The father took up that invitation and moved into his mother’s house with his son. The father and the child lived with the grandmother in the grandmother’s home until sometime in about the middle of 2019 when the father moved out, and the son remained living with the grandmother. During the period that the father was living with the grandmother and the child, he would live with them ‘90% of the time’ according to the grandmother, leaving for short periods of time (of maybe a month at a time) for various reasons and later returning. This was the explanation the grandmother gave for having said more recently in a text to the mother that the father had lived with her ‘on and off’ since the mother’s departure for New Zealand. I believe her both for the reasons I have already set out. Since about the end of November 2011 the grandmother has had day to day care of the child attending to his basic care needs, such as ensuring he is fed and washed, taking him to school and to the doctor and so on. She described herself as having assumed the role of the child’s mother. She would consult the father about decisions concerning the child, such as what school he would attend, although the father had the final say in such matters. Before the father moved out, he would take the child on outings and to friend’s places when necessary. The father was the disciplinarian because the grandmother was ‘a softie’.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 87AA of the Child Support (Registration and Collections) Act 1988 (Cth) (Collection Act) provides:Date of effect of objections relating to care percentage decisions that are allowed(1) If:(a)a person lodges, under section 80A, an objection to a care percentagedecision; and(b)the objection is lodged more than 28 days or, if the person is a resident of areciprocating jurisdiction, 90 days after notice of the care percentage decision was served; and(c)the Registrar decides (the review decision), under section 87, to allow the objection in a way that has the effect of varying the determination to which the care percentage decision relates, or substituting a new determination;the date of effect of the review decision is the day on which the person lodged the objection.(2) If the Registrar is satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented the person from lodging the objection within the period referred to in paragraph (1)(b), the Registrar may determine that subsection (1) applies as if:(a)in a case where the person is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction--the reference to 90 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate; or(b)otherwise--the reference to 28 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate.(3) If:(a)the Registrar decides to make a determination under subsection (2) in relation to a person; or(b)the Registrar decides not to make such a determination in relation to a person;the Registrar must give written notice of the decision to each person affected by the decision.(4) The notice must:(a)set out the reasons for the decision; and(b)include a statement to the effect that, if the person is aggrieved by the decision, application may be made, subject to this Act and the AAT Act, to the AAT for review of the decision.(5) A contravention of subsection (4) in relation to a decision does not affect the validity of the decision. Section 87AA(1) of the Collection Act does not have any application in the circumstances because the objection in this case was not ‘lodged more than 28 days…after the care percentage decision was served.’ The care percentage decision was not ever served. The mother’s statements in the ‘Objecting to a Child Support Decision’ form that she emailed to the Agency, in particular the reasons she gives in the attachment, are only consistent with the fact that she was not served with or (and it is not relevant) given notice of any such decision. Further, the letter of 15 March 2019 is not ‘the care percentage decision’, but as it says, merely a recalculation of the amount of child support that was payable. The matter is not one of mere technicality. Service of the actual percentage of care decision would objectively have placed the mother in a position to know that she had 28 days to exercise her rights of review. The decision about a change to a percentage of care, as this case illustrates, may be a very significant one with significant financial consequences to a person affected by it. It should not depend upon a person finding out in some less than clear and less than formal way about the fact of that decision having been made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established