LJSS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

LJSS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 3960 (29 November 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/5274

Re:LJSS

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndKBNY

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member R. West

Date:29 November 2023

Place:Melbourne

The decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 28 June 2021 affirming the decision of the authorised objections officer dated 6 April 2021 that the Applicant and the Other Party each had 50% care of their child N from 3 December 2019, effective from 23 June 2020 (Initial Determination), is varied such that:

(a)the Initial Determination is revoked effective 28 February 2020;

(b)a determination is made under s.50(1)(a) and s.50(2) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) that from 1 March 2020 to 31 August 2020 the Applicant had 20% care and the Other Party had 80% care of the child N, effective 23 June 2020 (Second Determination);

(c)the Second Determination is revoked effective 31 August 2020; and

(d)a determination is made under s.50(1)(a) and s.50(2) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) that from 1 September 2020 to 31 August 2021 the Applicant had 50% care and the Other Party 50% care of the child N, effective 1 September 2020.

...............................[sgd].........................................

Member R. West

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT ASSESSMENT – on remittal from the Federal Court – application for review – child care percentage – alleged change of percentage – appeal from decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – care period affected by COVID restrictions – decision varied.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Child Support Registrar v BKCZ [2023] FCA 1109
Child Support Registrar v DQFY [2023] FCA 601
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, Re (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
F v LP 1 [2015] AATA 321
LJSS v Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 1319
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Parent B [2013] AATA 562
Polec v Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339
QWKW and Child Support Registrar [2021] AATA 2060

SHQY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 930

Secondary Materials

Guides to Social Policy: Child Support Guide (version 4.75, updated 6 November 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member R West

29 November 2023

This matter concerns the reconsideration of an application to review a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 28 June 2021 on remittal from the Federal Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LJSS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3960
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The dispute centred on the percentage of care each parent had for their child, N, and specifically, the commencement date of a 50:50 care arrangement and the principal care arrangements during the COVID-19 lockdown period in Victoria between March and November 2020. The father contended that the 50:50 care arrangement commenced on 29 November 2019, while the mother asserted it began on 1 February 2020. Furthermore, the mother claimed principal care during the March to November 2020 lockdown, a claim disputed by the father who argued he had principal care during this time.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine the precise date from which the 50:50 care order became effective and to ascertain which parent had principal care of N during the COVID-19 lockdown period from March to November 2020. These determinations were crucial for calculating the child support payable under the relevant legislation.

The Tribunal, on remittal from the Federal Court, was required to re-determine the application. The Federal Court had set aside a previous AAT decision due to an error of law concerning the making of subsequent care determinations without first revoking earlier ones. The Tribunal, guided by the principles established in *Child Support Registrar v BKCZ*, determined that it would conduct a fresh redetermination of the application. This involved considering all material before the Tribunal, including evidence that came into existence or events that occurred after the original decision, up to the time of the redetermination hearing. The Tribunal confirmed it would not be bound by previous findings but would consider the record of the prior hearing and allow parties to present further relevant evidence.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case pertains to a dispute between the Father and the Mother regarding the care of their child N, as well as the related child support assessment. The Father and the Mother had separated, and their relationship had led to a series of legal proceedings concerning the care of their child and the corresponding child support obligations. The matter was initially assessed by the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which determined that both parents should have 50% care of the child effective from 23 June 2020. This decision was subsequently reviewed by the General Division of the Tribunal, which varied the AAT's decision. The Mother appealed this second decision to the Federal Court, which found an error of law and remitted the case back to the Tribunal for redetermination.

The principal factual disputes between the parties revolved around the commencement date of the Mother's compliance with the Court Order and the care of the child during the COVID-19 lockdown period. The Father claimed that the Mother began complying with the Court Order on 29 November 2019, while the Mother asserted that she did not comply until 1 February 2020. Additionally, the Mother argued that she had primary care of the child from March to November 2020 due to the COVID-19 lockdown restrictions imposed by the Victorian Government. In contrast, the Father maintained that he had primary care during this period. The Father presented various documents and evidence to support his claims, including a care diary, screenshots of text messages, and a table of income and expenses. The Mother provided her own evidence and counterarguments to dispute the Father's claims.

The case came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in two tiers. Initially, the Social Services and Child Support Division of the AAT affirmed a decision that both parents had 50% care of the child from 3 December 2019. The Mother subsequently applied for a review of this decision by the General Division of the AAT, which conducted a hearing and issued a decision on 23 May 2022. Dissatisfied with the second-tier decision, the Mother appealed to the Federal Court. On 9 June 2023, the Federal Court set aside the second-tier decision and remitted the matter to the AAT for redetermination according to law. This was based on the Court's finding that the AAT had erred in law by making care determinations without revoking earlier ones. Following this, the AAT invited submissions from the parties on the scope of the redetermination, ultimately deciding to make a fresh determination of the application, considering the record of the previous hearing, allowing new evidence, and conducting a further hearing to receive additional evidence and submissions from the parties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There were two principal issues of dispute between the parties relevant to the Tribunal’s deliberations:(a)The Father asserted that the Mother commenced to comply with the Court Order from 29 November 2019, but the Mother asserted that she commenced complying from 1 February 2020; and(b)The Mother asserted that she had principal care of N during the period from March to November 2020 during the COVID lockdown period when various restrictions were imposed by the Victorian Government to deal with the COVID pandemic. The Father asserted that during this period he had principal care of N.Father’s evidence The Father lodged various documents in the initial proceedings:[17](a)his care diary recording the time N spent with each parent;(b)screen shots of SMS messages;(c)a residential tenancy agreement;(d)a list of rental payment; and(e)a table of income and expenses.[17] T28 at pp.73-138. The Father also gave evidence in the initial proceedings but did not produce further evidence at the Hearing. The record of the initial proceedings contains the following evidence from the Father:(a)The Father said that after the parties separated in May 2018, he went overseas for around 3 months returning in August 2018. He said that after he returned, he was denied care of N by the Mother and in October 2019 he applied to the Court for an order that he have 50:50 care. He said the Court Order granting him 50:50 care was made on 23 October 2019, but the Mother initially did not comply and the matter returned to Court on 29 November 2019 when the judge directed the Mother to comply. The Father said that the Mother commenced complying with the Court order from 29 November 2019 but there was a short transition period and his 50% care of N commenced from 3 December 2019.(b)The Father said that he arranged collection of N from the Mother’s house by sending her a text message. Copies of text messages commencing on 26 November 2019 for the period to 17 August 2020 were included in the T Documents[18] and further copies of various screenshots of text messages were included with the Father’s written submissions.(c)The Father said that N was mostly in his care during the period of restrictions imposed because of the COVID pandemic, including periods of lockdown, from March to November 2020. He said he was working from home during this period and was very flexible. He disputed the Mother’s statement that he was too busy to care for N and asserted that he was better able to support N with her remote learning.[18] T28 at pp.83-138 and further screenshots filed with leave of the Tribunal after the hearing. The Father produced a care diary for the period October 2019 to August 2021 in the form of a computer spreadsheet which he said he updated each day.[19] The spreadsheet indicates that:(a)50:50 care in accordance with the Court Order commenced from 3 December 2019; and (b)the number of days N spent with the Father compared to the Mother in the period March to August 2020 was March (24:5), April (21:8), May (22:9), June (28:2), July (28:3) and August (20:10), a total of 143:37. [19] T35 at pp.153-162.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 28 June 2021 the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the Objection Decision in determining that the Father and Mother each had 50% care of their child N from 3 December 2019 effective from 23 June 2020 (AAT1 Decision).[6][6] T2. On 3 August 2021 the Mother applied to the General Division of the Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of the AAT1 Decision (Second Tier Review).[7][7] T1. A hearing of the Second Tier Review was conducted by the Tribunal on 22 March 2022 (AAT2 Hearing) and a decision handed down on 23 May 2022 (AAT2 Decision).[8] [8] LJSS v Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 1319. On 7 September 2022 the Mother lodged an appeal from the AAT2 Decision to the Federal Court under s.44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act). On 9 June 2023, Justice Kenny made orders by consent (Consent Order) setting aside the AAT2 Decision and remitting the matter to the Tribunal to be re-determined according to law, on the basis that: The First Respondent accepts that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (General Division) made an error of law in its decision dated 23 May 2022 in finding that the second and third care determinations under subsection 50(2) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (Act) could be made without first revoking (either expressly or impliedly) the first and second determinations under section 54F or section 54H of the Act, pursuant to paragraph 50(1)(b) of the Act. Redetermination on Remittal On 25 July 2023 the Tribunal invited submissions from the parties in relation to the nature and scope of the redetermination pursuant to the Consent Orders and the proper basis for the conduct of the redetermination. The Tribunal has had regard to the decision in Child Support Registrar v BKCZ (‘BKCZ’) in which His Honour Justice Thomas made clear that in reviewing a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal in relation to the percentage of care under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Assessment Act) the Tribunal is to determine the questions before it by reference to the material before the Tribunal and is not limited to the material before the original decision maker. This includes information which may come into existence, or events that may occur, after the date of the original decision and up to the time of the Tribunal hearing.[9][9] [2023] FCA 1109 at [30]. The Tribunal also notes s.44(6)(b) of the AAT Act which relevantly provides:If the Federal Court of Australia makes an order remitting a case to be heard and decided again by the Tribunal: (a) …; and(b) …--the Tribunal may, for the purposes of the proceeding, have regard to any record of the proceeding before the Tribunal prior to the appeal (including a record of any evidence taken in the proceeding), so long as doing so is not inconsistent with the directions of the Court. Having considered the submissions of the parties and having regard to BKCZ and the provisions of s.44(6)(b) of the AAT Act, the Tribunal determined that on remittal the Tribunal would make a fresh determination of the application, and confirmed with the parties that it:(a)would not be bound by any findings in the initial proceeding, but (b)would, subject to any submissions of the parties, have regard to the record of the AAT2 Hearing, including the evidence admitted in that proceeding; and(c)would allow the Applicant and/or the Other Party to call further evidence relevant to the matters at issue; and(d)would conduct a hearing for the purpose of receiving any further evidence and to hear submissions from the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court was tasked with determining the redetermination of the child care percentage after a remittal from the Federal Court. The court commenced by clarifying the legal principles underpinning the redetermination process. It held that the Tribunal should approach the redetermination with a fresh perspective, not bound by prior findings, while also considering the record of the previous proceedings to the extent it was not inconsistent with the court's directions. This approach was grounded in the decision of Child Support Registrar v BKCZ, where Justice Thomas emphasised that the Tribunal, in reviewing decisions related to child care percentages under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, is not limited to the material before the original decision maker but can consider new information and events up to the time of the Tribunal hearing. Furthermore, section 44(6)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 was cited to support the Tribunal's authority to consider the previous record so long as it did not conflict with the court's directions.

The court applied these principles to the specifics of this case by confirming that the Tribunal would not be constrained by prior findings but would consider the evidence and submissions from the previous hearing. It also allowed for the introduction of new evidence relevant to the issues at hand. This decision was consistent with the need for a comprehensive and unbiased reassessment of the facts, ensuring that all pertinent information was considered in reaching a new determination.

Addressing the issue of the date from which the Mother commenced complying with the Court Order, the court noted the conflicting assertions by the parties. The Mother claimed compliance from 1 February 2020, while the Father asserted compliance from 29 November 2019. The court did not definitively resolve this dispute but set the stage for further evidence and argument on this matter during the redetermination. This approach aligns with the principle of giving each party an opportunity to present their case fully, ensuring that all relevant evidence is considered in the redetermination process.

Regarding the period from March to November 2020 when COVID-19 restrictions were in place, the court acknowledged the differing assertions by the parties about who had principal care of N. The Mother claimed she had principal care during this period, while the Father asserted that he did. The court recognized the need for a fresh examination of this period, allowing for new evidence and arguments to be presented, thereby ensuring that the redetermination would be based on the most current and comprehensive information available.

Finally, the court outlined how it would approach the redetermination of the percentage of care under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989. It emphasized that the Tribunal would conduct a fresh determination, not bound by prior findings, and would consider all relevant evidence and submissions from the parties. This approach ensures that the redetermination is fair, thorough, and based on the most up-to-date information, reflecting the statutory requirement for a careful and unbiased assessment of child care percentages.