ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 95 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 605

Citation: ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 605
Parties: SHOREFORM (QLD) PTY LTD ACN 115 107 250 v MILLENNIUM COAL PTY LTD ACN 089 566 021 and PEABODY AUSTRALIA MINING PTY LTD ACN 002 818 699
File number: NSD 2347 of 2011
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 23 June 2015
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – provision by applicant of concrete formwork services – applicant a sub-subcontractor – subcontractor insolvent and not a party to the proceedings – whether contract between applicant and either or both respondents – claim that either or both respondents estopped from denying the existence of one or more binding contracts for the provision of the formwork services – claim of misleading or deceptive
 or unconscionable conduct on the part of respondents – alternative quantum meruit claim by applicant for payment by respondents
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 69, 131
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51AC, 52, 87
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 56
Cases cited:

400 George Street (Qld) Pty Ltd v BG International Ltd [2010] QSC 66
400 George Street (Qld) Pty Ltd v BG International Ltd [2010] QCA 245; [2012] 2 Qd R 302
Seapeace Ltd v Meridian Marine Sales Ltd [1997] FCA 1482
ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 326
Sunbird Plaza Pty Ltd v Maloney [1988] HCA 11; (1988) 166 CLR 245
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315

O’Donovan J and Phillips J, Modern Contract of Guarantee (Lawbook Co, 2013) at [3.420] and [3.430]
Seddon N, Seddon on Deeds (Federation Press, 2015) at [2.30]

Date of hearing: 31 March-4 April, 15 April, 19-21 May, 24-26 June, 18 August 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 205
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr F Corsaro SC with Mr D Mahendra
Solicitor for the Applicant: Fraser Clancy Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr NJ Kidd SC
Solicitor for the Respondents: McCullough Robertson Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2347 of 2011

BETWEEN:

SHOREFORM (QLD) PTY LTD ACN 115 107 250
Applicant

AND:

MILLENNIUM COAL PTY LTD ACN 089 566 021
First Respondent

PEABODY AUSTRALIA MINING PTY LTD ACN 002 818 699
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 JUNE 2015

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.Costs be reserved.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2347 of 2011

BETWEEN:

SHOREFORM (QLD) PTY LTD ACN 115 107 250
Applicant

AND:

MILLENNIUM COAL PTY LTD ACN 089 566 021
First Respondent

PEABODY AUSTRALIA MINING PTY LTD ACN 002 818 699
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE:

23 JUNE 2015

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 605
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of ShoreForm (Qld) Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd (No 4), the plaintiff, ShoreForm, sought damages for breach of contract, an alternative quantum meruit claim, and compensation under the Trade Practices Act for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct or unconscionable conduct on the part of the respondents, Millennium and Peabody. The dispute arose from a series of contracts and subcontracts for the provision of concrete formwork services at the Millennium mine, with ShoreForm acting as a sub-subcontractor to the primary subcontractor. The legal issues the court had to decide included whether there was a binding contract between ShoreForm and either or both of the respondents, whether the respondents were estopped from denying the existence of such contracts, and whether the respondents had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or unconscionable conduct.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed examination of the documentary evidence and the testimonies of the parties' representatives. The court found that the representations made to ShoreForm by the respondents were not likely to have occurred as pleaded, primarily based on the contemporaneous documents and the evidence presented. The court also determined that certain documents were inadmissible under the Evidence Act as they constituted settlement negotiations and were hearsay. Consequently, the application was dismissed, and costs were reserved pending any future contentions regarding the allocation of costs.

In summary, the court rejected ShoreForm's claims on the basis of insufficient evidence to support the existence of binding contracts or the alleged conduct by the respondents. The dismissal of the application and the reservation of costs reflect the court's stance on the presented evidence and the legal arguments advanced by the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The monetary claim was for damages for breach of contract on the part of Millennium or Peabody; in the alternative, ShoreForm claimed payment by Millennium and Peabody on a quantum meruit basis; and, in the further alternative, ShoreForm sought damages or compensation under s 87 of the Trade Practices Act in respect of Millennium’s or Peabody’s alleged misleading or deceptive conduct or unconscionable conduct.Background Millennium owned the Millennium mine. Excel Coal Ltd (Excel Coal), later called Peabody, the second respondent, was the parent company of Millennium. On 28 January 2005, Australian Coal Technology Pty Ltd (Australian Coal Technology) agreed with Millennium to supply a coal handling and preparation plant, referred to as “a coal preparation plant and materials handling facility”, at the Millennium mine. By letter dated 10 June 2005, Commercial Concrete Constructions Pty Ltd (CCC) submitted a tender to erect formwork, fix steel reinforcement and to place and finish concrete in relation to the reclaim tunnel concrete works at the Millennium mine. CCC stated as its proposed contractor for the formwork ShoreForm Pty Ltd, its principal Tony Saba. Australian Coal Technology entered into a subcontract dated 24 June 2005 with CCC, including for the supply of concrete works in the reclaim tunnel forming part of the coal handling and preparation plant. CCC entered into a contract with ShoreForm Pty Ltd in late June 2005 under which ShoreForm Pty Ltd agreed to supply the formwork and related services for the reclaim tunnel. From late July 2005, CCC and ShoreForm Pty Ltd proceeded on the basis that Commercial Concrete Constructions (Qld) Pty Ltd (CCCQ) and ShoreForm were the parties to this contract in place of CCC and ShoreForm Pty Ltd. The Millennium mine was not the only coal mine in Queensland where Australian Coal Technology, CCCQ and ShoreForm were undertaking work: they were also working from time to time at the Newlands coal mine, owned by Xstrata Coal. ShoreForm was registered on 4 July 2005. Mr Saba was the sole director and was the holder of the single share issued. ShoreForm had its registered office in Queensland and was established for the purposes of the work in Queensland. Mr Saba was also a director of ShoreForm Pty Ltd from 2004 to 2008. Both companies were engaged in the business of supplying concrete and formwork services but only ShoreForm, the company registered in Queensland, was involved in work at the Millennium mine. Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd (Millennium CHPP) was formed as a new Millennium subsidiary. Millennium came to regard the management of the work at the Millennium mine by Australian Coal Technology as unsatisfactory. Amongst other things, Australian Coal Technology was late in paying subcontractors. On 30 December 2005, Millennium, Millennium CHPP and Australian Coal Technology entered into heads of agreement for the novation of the contract between Australian Coal Technology and Millennium and all subcontracts relating to the construction of the coal handling and preparation plant, to Millennium CHPP with effect from 15 January 2006, subject to the continuing obligations of Australian Coal Technology set out in the heads of agreement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondents submitted that item G and the part of the letter referring to the offer of compromise were inadmissible under s 131 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (the Evidence Act) as evidence of a settlement negotiation. They also submitted that that part of the letter and item G were hearsay because they were not a business record as proceedings against Excel Coal seeking recovery were in contemplation and the material was prepared in contemplation of legal proceedings. The respondents submitted that the particular difficulty with the document was that it purported to set out the number of man hours spent on the site between January and April 2006. ShoreForm submitted that this material had already been admitted and referred to paragraphs 230-232 of Mr Saba’s affidavit of 29 November 2012. ShoreForm also submitted that the letter did not comprise a step in the negotiation of a dispute but was rather a without prejudice offer which could be withdrawn. There was no joint privilege because there had been no negotiation. Further, ShoreForm submitted, there was no evidence to ground the respondents’ submission that the “representation … was prepared … for the purpose of conducting, or for or in contemplation of or in connection with, an Australian … proceeding” within the meaning of s 69(3)(a) of the Evidence Act. In my opinion, the document itself had not already been admitted as the status of the documents in the tender bundle had been expressly reserved at the time that Mr Saba’s affidavit was read. Next, the document is admissible as a business record as I am not satisfied that the representation was prepared for or in contemplation of or in connection with an Australian proceeding within s 69(3)(a). As to the s 131 objection, it seems to me that the document falls within the terms of s 131(1)(a) and evidence of the document is therefore not to be adduced. In my view, whether or not there is a dispute is a question of fact, being a question affected by the terms of s 131(5)(a). If I am wrong in that conclusion, I have not found it necessary to consider item G as proving the hours worked by the employees there listed, in the absence of primary documentary material. Damages In light of my findings on liability, it is not necessary to deal with the question of damages.Conclusion The application is to be dismissed. I will reserve costs in case either party wishes to contend that costs should not follow the event.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In light of my findings on liability, it is not necessary to deal with the question of damages.Conclusion The application is to be dismissed. I will reserve costs in case either party wishes to contend that costs should not follow the event.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the evidence of Mr Saba that CCCQ left the Millennium site on or about 10 February 2006 and for a ten day period ShoreForm remained on site and continued to work at the direction of Mr Toneguzzi, I accept and prefer the evidence of Mr Ramadan of ShoreForm who was on site and stated that CCCQ was itself on site throughout the period after Mr Toneguzzi told ShoreForm to finish up and remained on the site when ShoreForm did in fact finish up on or about 20 February 2006. I also find that ShoreForm’s timesheets in that period were signed by CCCQ’s supervisor on the site.Consideration of global submissions as to the representations ShoreForm submitted that it was likely that the alleged representations were made, for a number of reasons. First, ShoreForm submitted, the respondents had a keen desire that work continue as normal on the Millennium project. Second, there was a real likelihood that in the period prior to the novation the individuals who were said to have made the representations would not in the period 4 to 18 January 2006 have been aware of the terms of the novation or that the documentation had not been formalised or finalised, and would not have known or would not have concerned themselves as to whether ShoreForm was a subcontractor to Australian Coal Technology or a sub-subcontractor, and would not have had any reason prior to 4 January 2006 to distinguish between subcontractors and sub-subcontractors. Third, ShoreForm pointed to Excel Coal’s half-year results reports published in February 2006, which stated that the matter was Excel Coal’s number one priority, and to the presence of a potential joint venture partner at the 4 January 2006 meeting. ShoreForm pointed to Millennium CHPP’s need to get control of the job prior to Australian Coal Technology going into liquidation to ensure the progress on the job was not interrupted. ShoreForm also pointed to the entirety of the discovered documents in the tender bundle as confirming the likelihood that the representations were made. ShoreForm also referred to what it said was the remarkable consistency between ShoreForm’s pleadings and Mr Saba’s evidence. ShoreForm submitted that the proposition that the respondents would not have given the assurances alleged was so far removed from reality that the Court would reject it outright given (a) the critical nature of the work being performed by ShoreForm; (b) the respondents’ keen desire that work continue as normal; (c) ShoreForm’s threat to suspend work; (d) the threats to suspend work by others on site; and (e) the assurances given by the respondents to other contractors, employees, suppliers and subcontractors on site. In my opinion, these matters, individually or collectively, do not displace the conclusions which arise from a consideration of the detail of the objective circumstances, particularly the contemporaneous documents, and the evidence of what was said to the representatives of ShoreForm, especially Mr Saba. Where appropriate, I have taken into account the matters relied on by ShoreForm in assessing the documentary and affidavit and oral evidence, especially the oral evidence of Mr Saba. For example, I accept that the respondents had a keen desire that work continue as normal on the Millennium project and I accept the critical nature of the work being performed by ShoreForm, but I do not accept that none of those alleged to have made the pleaded representations to ShoreForm would have known whether ShoreForm was a subcontractor to Australian Coal Technology or a sub-subcontractor and none of them would have had any reason to distinguish between subcontractors and sub-subcontractors. Neither do I accept that there was a remarkable consistency between ShoreForm’s pleadings and Mr Saba’s evidence or that “the entirety of the discovered documents in the tender bundle” confirmed the likelihood that the representations as pleaded were made. Indeed, a consideration of the relevant contemporaneous documents strongly supports the conclusion that the representations as pleaded were not made. Threats by ShoreForm to suspend work did not, in my opinion, lead to the making of the representations as pleaded. I do not accept the submission on behalf of ShoreForm that the very fact that Millennium made payments to CCCQ supported ShoreForm’s case and made it likely that the respondents’ assurances were made to ShoreForm. In my opinion, the mere fact of payment to CCCQ followed from the novation whereby Millennium or Millennium CHPP stood in place of Australian Coal Technology in its contractual relationship with CCCQ. Neither was it established that payments were made by Millennium or Millennium CHPP to CCCQ, or to other subcontractors with Australian Coal Technology, contrary to the contractual arrangements between CCCQ, or the other subcontractors, and Australian Coal Technology.