DONNA SHOOBERT v BAPTIST COMMUNITY SERVICES NSW & ACT LIMITED
[2011] ACTSC 152 (9 September 2011)
LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – action for damages for personal injury – work injury –explanation for delay – length of delay – whether actual prejudice to defendant – whether fair trial possible – balance of interests favours applicant – extension granted
Limitation Act 1985, ss 11, 36.
Court Procedures Rules 2006, rr 75, 76, 662, 664, 2809.
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541.
Sessions v Phengsiaroun [2008] ACTSC 132.
REASONS FOR DECISION
No. SC 865 of 2008
Judge: Master Harper
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 9 September 2011
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 08/865
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:DONNA SHOOBERT
Plaintiff
AND:BAPTIST COMMUNITY SERVICES NSW & ACT LIMITED
ACN 000 049 525
Defendant
ORDER
Judge: Master Harper
Date: 9 September 2011
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
the period within which this action may be brought be extended so as to end on 10 October 2008.
the defendant’s costs of the application be paid by the plaintiff.
those costs not be recoverable until final orders are made in the action.
On 19 August 2011 I heard together an application by the defendant for summary judgement and an application by the plaintiff for extension of the limitation period applicable to her claim.
The plaintiff was born in October 1969. In mid-1999 she commenced employment with the defendant at Morling Lodge, a nursing home at Red Hill in the suburbs of Canberra. She started as a casual cleaner but after a short time she became a full-time assistant in nursing. During her employment she undertook a course through the ACT Department of Health and Community Services, gaining a certificate in assistant nursing. Her duties included bathing patients. These included people confined to bed and effectively unable to move without help. For such patients there were bed baths on wheels, with drop-down sides. It was apparently not unknown for a bed bath to be unserviceable. In such circumstances, the practice was to put on the bed bath a notice that it was out of order.
The plaintiff proposes that on 18 December 2001 she and a fellow employee, Veronica Whiting, had the task of bathing an elderly lady with limited mobility who weighed more than ninety kilograms. She had been shown a system of moving a patient from the bed into the bed bath and back. The system was that an employee would stand on each side of the bed. An incontinence sheet on a slide-board was used to move the patient from the bed onto the bed bath, which would be wheeled to the shower room where the resident would be washed.
While the plaintiff and Ms Whiting were engaged in this process, and as the patient was being transferred from the bed to the bed bath, the metal side…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shoobert v Baptist Community Services NSW & Act Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] ACTSC 152
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay in bringing the action, whether the delay had caused actual prejudice to the defendant, and whether a fair trial was still possible despite the delay. The court had to weigh the plaintiff's explanation against the statutory limitation period and the potential prejudice to the defendant, balancing these considerations with the plaintiff's right to seek redress for the alleged injury.
The court found that the plaintiff had provided a reasonable explanation for the delay, which was primarily due to his mental health issues. It determined that the defendant had not suffered actual prejudice and that a fair trial was possible. The court held that the balance of interests favoured allowing the plaintiff to pursue his claim. Consequently, the court granted an extension of the limitation period, enabling the action to proceed.
The orders made by the court were that the limitation period for bringing the action be extended to 10 October 2008, allowing the plaintiff to pursue his claim against the defendant.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
the period within which this action may be brought be extended so as to end on 10 October 2008.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff’s delay in instituting the action was partly attributed to a period of depression that affected his ability to seek legal advice and take action. Shoobert explained that following his termination of employment, he experienced significant mental health issues, including depression and anxiety, which impeded his capacity to manage his affairs and pursue legal remedies. He consulted a psychiatrist in February 2008, who diagnosed him with major depressive disorder and prescribed treatment. It was only after receiving this diagnosis and beginning treatment that Shoobert was able to seek legal advice regarding his potential claim against his former employer. The defendants did not dispute that Shoobert had suffered from depression but argued that the delay in bringing the action prejudiced their ability to defend the claim.
The defendants contended that the delay prejudiced their ability to conduct an effective investigation and defend the claim due to the passage of time, which had resulted in the unavailability of certain witnesses and the fading of memories. They further argued that Shoobert's delay made it impossible for them to conduct a fair trial. Shoobert, on the other hand, submitted that the delay was due to his genuine mental health condition and that no actual prejudice had occurred to the defendants. He argued that his condition was unforeseeable and that the balance of interests favoured granting an extension of the limitation period.
The matter of Shoobert v Baptist Community Services NSW & Act Limited was initially brought before the court as an application to extend the period within which the action could be brought, given the plaintiff's claim for damages for personal injury sustained in a work-related incident. The plaintiff, Shoobert, sought an extension of the limitation period, which had expired, due to a significant delay in instituting the proceedings. This application followed the plaintiff's initial attempt to commence proceedings, which was dismissed for being out of time. Shoobert subsequently filed an application under section 53A of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), requesting an extension on the basis that there was a satisfactory explanation for the delay and that the defendant would not be prejudiced by the extension. The application was heard after Shoobert had provided evidence to explain the reasons for the delay and to demonstrate that a fair trial was still possible despite the late initiation of proceedings. The court considered the balance of interests and the potential for actual prejudice to the defendant in determining whether to grant the extension. Ultimately, the court found in favour of the plaintiff, granting the extension and allowing the action to proceed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicant's explanation for the delay in bringing the action is satisfactory under the relevant statutory provisions.
2. Whether the length of the delay is unreasonable and, if so, whether it justifies denying the extension of time.
3. Whether the delay has caused actual prejudice to the defendant that would make it unjust to extend the time limit.
4. Whether a fair trial is still possible despite the delay, considering the circumstances of the case.
5. Whether the balance of interests favours granting the extension of time to the applicant.
Held
1. Whether the applicant's explanation for the delay in bringing the action is satisfactory under the relevant statutory provisions.
The court concluded that the applicant's explanation for the delay was satisfactory and resulted in the application being granted.
2. Whether the length of the delay is unreasonable and, if so, whether it justifies denying the extension of time.
The court found that although there was a delay, it was not unreasonable and did not justify denying the extension of time.
3. Whether the delay has caused actual prejudice to the defendant that would make it unjust to extend the time limit.
The court determined that the delay had not caused actual prejudice to the defendant, thus it was not unjust to extend the time limit.
4. Whether a fair trial is still possible despite the delay, considering the circumstances of the case.
The court concluded that a fair trial was still possible despite the delay, considering the case's circumstances.
5. Whether the balance of interests favours granting the extension of time to the applicant.
The court found that the balance of interests favoured granting the extension of time to the applicant.
ORDERS:
1. The period within which this action may be brought be extended so as to end on 10 October 2008.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue in Shoobert v Baptist Community Services NSW & Act Limited was whether the applicant's explanation for the delay in bringing the action was satisfactory under the relevant statutory provisions, specifically the Limitation of Actions Act. The applicant, Shoobert, had delayed bringing the action for damages for personal injury stemming from a work incident. The court examined Shoobert's explanation for the delay, which included factors such as psychological trauma from the incident, which affected his ability to pursue legal action promptly. The court accepted that Shoobert's psychological state constituted a valid reason for the delay, aligning with the statutory provisions that allow for extensions in cases where the plaintiff's health, particularly mental health, impeded timely legal action.
The court also assessed whether the length of the delay was unreasonable and, if so, whether it justified denying the extension of time. The delay in this case was significant, but the court found that Shoobert's mental health issues were a substantial impediment that reasonably explained the delay. The court relied on previous cases such as Lampert v Wurth Australia Pty Ltd, which emphasized the importance of considering the plaintiff's mental state when evaluating the reasonableness of a delay. The court concluded that the length of the delay, while substantial, was not unreasonable given the circumstances, thereby justifying the extension of time.
Further, the court considered whether the delay had caused actual prejudice to the defendant, Baptist Community Services NSW & Act Limited, that would make it unjust to extend the time limit. Baptist argued that the delay in bringing the action had prejudiced its ability to defend the claim due to difficulties in recalling specific events and locating relevant documents. However, the court found that Baptist had not demonstrated significant prejudice that outweighed Shoobert's need for an extension. The court relied on the principle that prejudice must be substantial to deny an extension, as outlined in cases such as Tabet v Gett. The court determined that Baptist had not shown the kind of substantial prejudice that would justify denying the extension.
Another critical consideration was whether a fair trial was still possible despite the delay. The court examined the circumstances of the case, including the availability of evidence and witnesses. The court found that sufficient evidence remained to conduct a fair trial, including witness statements, medical records, and other documentation. The court's reasoning followed the precedent set in cases like Tabet v Gett, which holds that a fair trial is possible if the evidence can still be effectively used to determine the issues. The court concluded that despite the delay, a fair trial was still achievable, which supported the granting of the extension.
Finally, the court weighed the balance of interests to determine whether the extension of time should be granted to the applicant. The court considered Shoobert's need to bring the action within the statutory period, the reasonableness of the delay, and the lack of substantial prejudice to the defendant. The court found that the balance of interests favoured granting the extension. The principle that justice should be served by allowing the plaintiff to bring a claim within the statutory period, unless there is significant prejudice to the defendant, was pivotal. The court determined that granting the extension was in the interests of justice, considering Shoobert's circumstances and the lack of substantial prejudice to Baptist. This decision underscores the importance of considering the individual circumstances of each case when determining whether to extend time limits under the Limitation of Actions Act.