Shire of Manjimup v Cheetham

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   SHIRE OF MANJIMUP   -v- CHEETHAM [2010] WASCA 225

CORAM:   BUSS JA

NEWNES JA
MAZZA J

HEARD:   13 AUGUST 2010

DELIVERED          :   29 NOVEMBER 2010

FILE NO/S:   CACV 143 of 2009

BETWEEN:   SHIRE OF MANJIMUP 

Appellant

AND

SANDRA ALICE CHEETHAM
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :SCOTT DCJ

Citation  :CHEETHAM -v- SHIRE OF MANJIMUP [2009] WADC 169

File No  :CIV 2233 of 2007

Catchwords:

Negligence - Duty of care of occupier - Occupiers' Liability Act 1985 (WA) - Respondent fell into culvert at night while crossing holiday site - Respondent was using torch - Whether appellant negligent in failing to erect barricade around culvert - Whether contributory negligence by respondent in failing to keep proper lookout

Legislation:

Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA)
Civil Liability Amendment Act 2003 (WA)
Occupiers' Liability Act 1985 (WA), s 5(1), s 5(4)

Result:

Appeal against finding of negligence by appellant dismissed
Appeal against finding that no contributory negligence by respondent allowed
Liability apportioned two-thirds to appellant and one-third to respondent

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr J Eller

Respondent:     Mr R V Lonnie

Solicitors:

Appellant:     John Eller

Respondent:     Ian Watson Lawyer

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v Zaluzna [1987] HCA 7; (1987) 162 CLR 479

British Fame (Owners) v Macgregor (Owners) [1943] AC 197

Cheetham v Shire of Manjimup [2009] WADC 169

Department of Housing and Works v Smith [No 2] [2010] WASCA 25; (2010) 265 ALR 490

Homestyle Pty Ltd v Perrozzi [2007] WASCA 16; (2007) 33 WAR 209

Modbury Triangle Shopping Centre Pty Ltd v Anzil [2000] HCA 61; (2000) 205 CLR 254

Mount Isa Mines Ltd v Pusey (1970) 125 CLR 383

Neill v NSW Fresh Food & Ice Pty Ltd (1963) 108 CLR 362

Pennington v Norris [1956] HCA 26; (1956) 96 CLR 10

Phillis v Daly (1988) 15 NSWLR 65

Shire of Gingin v Coombe [2009] WASCA 92

State of New South Wales v Fahy [2007] HCA 20; (2007) 232 CLR 486

Tressider v Austral Stevedoring and Lighterage Co Pty Ltd [1968] 1 NSWR 566

Vairy v Wyong Shire Council [2005] HCA 62; (2005) 223 CLR 422

Wyong Shire Council v Shirt [1980] HCA 12; (1980) 146 CLR 40

  1. BUSS JA:  On 18 March 2003, the respondent broke her right leg when she tripped and fell into a culvert at the holiday and camping area in Manjimup known as Windy Harbour.

  2. In the Windy Harbour grounds is a playground which is bordered by a spoon drain.  Water run‑off from the playground collects in the drain and, by gravity, flows into the culvert and then into a drainpipe located under an unsealed road. 

  3. The appellant administers and operates the Windy Harbour grounds.

  4. The respondent commenced proceedings in the District Court against the appellant.  She alleged that the appellant was the occupier of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shire of Manjimup v Cheetham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASCA 225
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Shire of Manjimup v Cheetham [2010] WASCA 225 concerns a dispute between the Shire of Manjimup and a holiday site visitor, Cheetham, who fell into an unguarded culvert on the site. Cheetham sought damages for personal injury sustained from the fall. The appeal was focused on two main issues: first, whether the Shire was negligent in not erecting a barricade around the culvert, and second, whether Cheetham was contributorily negligent for not keeping a proper lookout while using a torch. The District Court found the Shire negligent and rejected the claim of contributory negligence. The Shire appealed these findings.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal regarding negligence but upheld the appeal on the issue of contributory negligence. The Court found that Cheetham was partially at fault for the accident, apportioning liability two-thirds to the Shire and one-third to Cheetham. The Court held that Cheetham was partially responsible for failing to properly look out for the culvert while using a torch. This decision significantly reduced Cheetham's potential damages. The Court's reasoning emphasised the importance of apportionment of liability in mixed outcomes, highlighting the need for a nuanced approach in determining costs.

In determining the costs of the appeal, the Court exercised its discretion under the Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA) and Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). Given that Cheetham was substantially successful on the liability issue but not on the appeal, the Court ordered costs to reflect the mixed outcome. The Court awarded Cheetham two-thirds of the trial costs and one-third of the appeal costs. The Court concluded that while Cheetham was substantially successful, the reduction in damages due to contributory negligence warranted a proportionate adjustment in costs.

The final orders of the court apportioned costs to reflect the apportionment of liability, with Cheetham receiving two-thirds of the trial costs and one-third of the appeal costs. This decision underscores the importance of the discretion exercised by the Court in determining costs in cases with mixed outcomes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: On 29 November 2010, the court delivered judgment in this appeal: Shire of Manjimup v Cheetham [2010] WASCA 225. At that time, orders were made dismissing the appeal on liability but allowing the appeal on contributory negligence. The parties sought an opportunity to make submissions on the appropriate orders as to costs and directions were given for the filing and service of written submissions. Pursuant to the directions, the orders as to costs are to be determined on the papers. The parties have each since filed submissions on costs. The appeal arose out of an accident at premises controlled by the appellant. The respondent, who was staying in a cottage on the premises, was injured when she fell into an unguarded culvert at night. The respondent brought proceedings against the appellant in the District Court alleging that the accident was caused by the appellant's negligence. The quantum of damages was agreed at $36,500 and the trial proceeded on the issue of liability alone. The appellant denied that it was negligent and, in the alternative, pleaded contributory negligence on the part of the respondent. The primary judge found that the accident was caused by the appellant's negligence and dismissed the appellant's claim of contributory negligence. The appellant appealed against both findings. Three of its four grounds of appeal concerned the finding of negligence against it. The remaining ground concerned contributory negligence. As we have mentioned, the appeal against the finding that the appellant was negligent was dismissed but the appeal in relation to contributory negligence was upheld. On the appeal, liability was apportioned two‑thirds to the appellant and one‑third to the respondent. The appellant says that the costs of the appeal should reflect the apportionment, that is, two‑thirds to the respondent and one‑third to the appellant. It submits that while it was unsuccessful on the three grounds of appeal relating to liability, its success on the issue of contributory negligence meant that the respondent's entitlement to damages was significantly reduced. On the trial costs, the appellant submits there should be no order as to costs. The respondent sought to establish that the appellant was wholly liable for the accident. She has been unsuccessful, liability having now been apportioned on appeal. The respondent submits that the respondent was substantially successful on the appeal and costs should follow the event. The issue of contributory negligence was ancillary to the appeal and it would be unfair to reduce the respondent's costs by one‑third. On the costs of the trial, the respondent submits that the order for costs in her favour should not be disturbed. Even in light of the decision of this court, the respondent was substantially successful at trial. The court has a general discretion as to the costs of proceedings before it: Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA) s 37. Ordinarily, the court will order that the successful party recover their costs of the proceedings: Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 66 r 1. But in the exercise of its discretion the court may apportion costs where one party has succeeded on some issues but failed on others. However, there can never be any hard and fast rule and each case must depend upon its own particular circumstances. Where there is a mixed outcome in proceedings, the exercise of the discretion as to costs will often depend upon matters of impression and evaluation; mathematical precision is illusory: Dodds Family Investments Pty Ltd v Lane Industries Pty Ltd (1993) 26 IPR 261; Amaca Pty Ltd v Moss [2007] WASCA 162(S) [6].