Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter [2025] FCA 451  

File number(s): NSD 1608 of 2024
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 7 May 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for joinder of individual to proceeding – service of originating application and other documents outside the jurisdiction pursuant to r 10.42 and r 10.44 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules) – application for substituted service upon first respondent and prospective second respondent pursuant to r 10.24 and/or r 10.49 of the Rules – orders made
Legislation:

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.34, 9.05, 10.24, 10.42, 10.43, 10.44, 10.45, 10.49, Div 10.6

Federal Court Legislation Amendment Rules 2022 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Commissioner of Taxation v Zeitouni (2013) 306 ALR 603; [2013] FCA 1011

Connelly (liquidator), in the matter of CIMC Rolling Stock Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) v One Rail Australia (FLA) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2021] FCA 1183

Ford, in the matter of Careers Australia Group Ltd (in liq) v Mansfield [2022] FCA 173

John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1; [2010] HCA 19

Ligon 158 Pty Limited (in liq) v Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (Special Purpose Liquidator) [2025] FCA 3

Park v Tschannen [2016] FCA 137; (2016) 341 ALR 452

Victoria v Sutton (1998) 195 CLR 291; [1998] HCA 56

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 56
Counsel for Applicant:  Mr S D Puttick
Solicitor for Applicant:  Ashurst

ORDERS

NSD 1608 of 2024
BETWEEN:

SHIELD HOLDINGS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (NOW KNOWN AS ACN 078 881 035 PTY LIMITED) ACN 078 881 035

Applicant

AND:

ANDREW BINETTER

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HALLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 MAY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Joinder of Samantha Ellen Kelliher

1.Pursuant to r 9.05(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules), Samantha Ellen Kelliher be joined as the second respondent to the proceeding.

Overseas service

2.Pursuant to r 10.44 of the Rules, leave be granted to the applicant to serve the following documents on each of the first respondent and the second respondent in the United States of America:

(a)applicant’s genuine steps statement dated 12 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(b)affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 11 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(c)exhibit AW-1 to the affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 11 November 2024;

(d)affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 2 December 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(e)the interlocutory application dated 1 April 2025 and filed in these proceedings; and

(f)sealed copies of all orders made in this proceeding, including these orders made pursuant to the interlocutory application,

(together, Supplementary Documents).   

Substituted service

3.Pursuant to r 10.24 and/or alternatively r 1.34 and r 10.49 of the Rules, leave be granted to the applicant to serve the:

(a)originating…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 451
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter, the Federal Court was tasked with resolving issues related to the joinder of a party, the service of documents outside the jurisdiction, and the substituted service of documents. Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd, a company in liquidation, sought to join Samantha Ellen Kelliher as a second respondent and to serve various documents on Mr Binetter and Ms Kelliher, both residing in the United States. The application also sought orders permitting the substituted service of documents on the respondents.

The legal issues before the court included whether Shield could properly join Ms Kelliher as a second respondent and whether the service of documents outside Australia and the substituted service of documents complied with the Federal Court Rules 2011. The court had to consider the procedural requirements and the fairness in serving the documents on the respondents, who were outside the jurisdiction.

The court found that Shield was entitled to join Ms Kelliher as a second respondent, as her inclusion was necessary for the complete disposal of the matter. It also held that the proposed methods of service and substituted service complied with the rules and were fair under the circumstances. The court was satisfied that the documents would reach the respondents effectively, thereby upholding the principle of natural justice. Consequently, the court granted the orders sought by Shield, allowing the joinder of Ms Kelliher and the service of documents as requested.

Orders

Orders of the court

Joinder of Samantha Ellen Kelliher

1. Pursuant to r 9.05(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules), Samantha Ellen Kelliher be joined as the second respondent to the proceeding.

Overseas service

2. Pursuant to r 10.44 of the Rules, leave be granted to the applicant to serve the following documents on each of the first respondent and the second respondent in the United States of America:

(a) applicant’s genuine steps statement dated 12 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(b) affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 11 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(c) exhibit AW-1 to the affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 11 November 2024;

(d) affidavit of Alan Walker affirmed on 2 December 2024 and filed in this proceeding;

(e) the interlocutory application dated 1 April 2025 and filed in these proceedings; and

(f) sealed copies of all orders made in this proceeding, including these orders made pursuant to the interlocutory application,

(together, Supplementary Documents).

Substituted service

3. Pursuant to r 10.24 and/or alternatively r 1.34 and r 10.49 of the Rules, leave be granted to the applicant to serve the:

(a) originating application lodged on 11 November 2024 and accepted for filing on 12 November 2024 in this proceeding;

(b) notice to person served outside Australia dated 1 April 2025 addressed to the first respondent, being Form 26A, which is required to be served pursuant to r 10.43B of the Rules;

(c) statement of claim dated 12 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding; and

(d) Supplementary Documents,

(together, Binetter Documents),

by

(e) placing a copy of the Binetter Documents for the first respondent in a sealed envelope and leaving them at the office address of Chris Ardagna of Pitcher Partners Legal NSW Pty Ltd at Level 16, Tower 2, 201 Sussex Street, Sydney NSW 2000;

(f) sending a copy of the Binetter Documents to the email address of Chris Ardagna (being chris.ardagna@pitcher.com.au);

(g) placing a copy of the Binetter Documents for the first respondent in a sealed envelope and leaving them at the office address of Malcolm Stewart and Sadhika Menon of Speed and Stracey Lawyers at Level 8, 1 Chifley Square, Sydney NSW 2000;

(h) sending a copy of the Binetter Documents to the email addresses of Malcolm Stewart and Sadhika Menon of Speed and Stracey Lawyers (being MalcolmS@sslaw.com.au, mstewart@sslaw.com.au, and Sadhikam@sslaw.com.au, respectively);

(i) sending a copy of the Binetter Documents to the email address binetter@me.com; and

(j) sending a copy of the Binetter Documents to the email address samanthak222@gmail.com.

4. Pursuant to r 10.24(c) and/or alternatively r 10.49(c) of the Rules, the Binetter Documents are taken to have been served on the first respondent at the end of the seventh business day after the documents were provided pursuant to Order 3(g) of these orders.

5. Pursuant to r 10.24 and/or alternatively r 1.34 and r 10.49 of the Rules, leave be granted to the applicant to serve the:

(a) originating application lodged on 11 November 2024 and accepted for filing on 12 November 2024 in this proceeding;

(b) notice to person served outside Australia dated 1 April 2025 addressed to the second respondent, being Form 26A, which is required to be served pursuant to r 10.43B of the Rules;

(c) statement of claim dated 12 November 2024 and filed in this proceeding; and

(d) Supplementary Documents,

(together, Kelliher Documents),

by:

(e) placing a copy of the Kelliher Documents for the second respondent in a sealed envelope and leaving them at the office address of Chris Ardagna of Pitcher Partners Legal NSW Pty Ltd at Level 16, Tower 2, 201 Sussex Street, Sydney NSW 2000;

(f) sending a copy of the Kelliher Documents to the email address of Chris Ardagna, being chris.ardagna@pitcher.com.au;

(g) sending a copy of the Kelliher Documents to the email address samanthak222@gmail.com; and

(h) sending a copy of the Kelliher Documents to the email address binetter@me.com.

6. Pursuant to r 10.24(c) and/or alternatively r 10.49(c) of the Rules, the Kelliher Documents are taken to have been served on the second respondent at the end of the seventh business day after the documents were provided pursuant to Order 5(e) of these orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that the interlocutory orders sought by Shield should be made.B. BACKGROUND As pleaded in the statement of claim, Shield is a proprietary company that was incorporated in New South Wales on 12 June 1997, deregistered on 1 November 2020, reinstated on 8 April 2024 and upon reinstatement, and was wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). This proceeding is concerned with the validity of a deed of release dated 12 November 2018 (Deed of Release) by which Shield purportedly released certain “Debtors” from the repayment of “Loans” and any other “Claims” which Shield may have against one or more “Debtors”. “Debtors” under the Deed of Release is alleged to mean the first respondent (Mr Binetter), Samantha Ellen Kelliher, and various “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield, Mr Binetter, and Ms Kelliher were parties to the Deed of Release and it otherwise purported to operate as a deed poll in favour of the “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield alleges that Mr Binetter, as Shield’s sole director and company secretary, caused Shield (purportedly) to enter into the Deed of Release. Shield alleges that Mr Binetter breached general law and statutory duties he owed to Shield, in causing Shield to enter the Deed of Release in the circumstances pleaded in the statement of claim filed on 12 November 2024. Shield seeks a declaration that, to the extent the Deed of Release purports to release claims which Shield had or may have against Mr Binetter, Ms Kelliher and other “Debtors”, it is void and unenforceable and/or is to be read down or severed; and orders in equity rescinding the deed poll granted by Shield in favour of the “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield also seeks a declaration in equity and/or under s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth) that Mr Binetter breached his duties to Shield by causing Shield to grant releases to Mr Binetter and the other “Debtors”. Shield does not allege any wrongdoing by Ms Kelliher and no relief is sought directly against Ms Kelliher. The matters giving rise to this proceeding are the subject of various other proceedings in this Court, including proceeding NSD 1023 of 2022 (2022 Proceedings). On 5 April 2024, Alan Walker of WLP Restructuring was appointed as liquidator of Shield pursuant to orders made in the 2022 Proceedings. On 11 November 2024, Shield lodged the originating application in this proceeding, which was accepted for filing on 12 November 2024. On 9 January 2025, after hearing argument on 5 different dates between 13 June 2024 and 20 September 2024, Cheeseman J delivered reasons and made orders in the 2022 Proceedings appointing John Sheahan as a special purpose liquidator of Shield: Ligon 158 Pty Limited (in liq) v Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (Special Purpose Liquidator) [2025] FCA 3. Mr Binetter actively participated in the hearings before her Honour and was represented by senior counsel, instructed by Pitcher Partners Legal NSW Pty Ltd (Pitcher Partners).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As pleaded in the statement of claim, Shield is a proprietary company that was incorporated in New South Wales on 12 June 1997, deregistered on 1 November 2020, reinstated on 8 April 2024 and upon reinstatement, and was wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). This proceeding is concerned with the validity of a deed of release dated 12 November 2018 (Deed of Release) by which Shield purportedly released certain “Debtors” from the repayment of “Loans” and any other “Claims” which Shield may have against one or more “Debtors”. “Debtors” under the Deed of Release is alleged to mean the first respondent (Mr Binetter), Samantha Ellen Kelliher, and various “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield, Mr Binetter, and Ms Kelliher were parties to the Deed of Release and it otherwise purported to operate as a deed poll in favour of the “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield alleges that Mr Binetter, as Shield’s sole director and company secretary, caused Shield (purportedly) to enter into the Deed of Release. Shield alleges that Mr Binetter breached general law and statutory duties he owed to Shield, in causing Shield to enter the Deed of Release in the circumstances pleaded in the statement of claim filed on 12 November 2024. Shield seeks a declaration that, to the extent the Deed of Release purports to release claims which Shield had or may have against Mr Binetter, Ms Kelliher and other “Debtors”, it is void and unenforceable and/or is to be read down or severed; and orders in equity rescinding the deed poll granted by Shield in favour of the “Covenant Beneficiaries”. Shield also seeks a declaration in equity and/or under s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth) that Mr Binetter breached his duties to Shield by causing Shield to grant releases to Mr Binetter and the other “Debtors”. Shield does not allege any wrongdoing by Ms Kelliher and no relief is sought directly against Ms Kelliher. The matters giving rise to this proceeding are the subject of various other proceedings in this Court, including proceeding NSD 1023 of 2022 (2022 Proceedings). On 5 April 2024, Alan Walker of WLP Restructuring was appointed as liquidator of Shield pursuant to orders made in the 2022 Proceedings. On 11 November 2024, Shield lodged the originating application in this proceeding, which was accepted for filing on 12 November 2024. On 9 January 2025, after hearing argument on 5 different dates between 13 June 2024 and 20 September 2024, Cheeseman J delivered reasons and made orders in the 2022 Proceedings appointing John Sheahan as a special purpose liquidator of Shield: Ligon 158 Pty Limited (in liq) v Shield Holdings Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (Special Purpose Liquidator) [2025] FCA 3. Mr Binetter actively participated in the hearings before her Honour and was represented by senior counsel, instructed by Pitcher Partners Legal NSW Pty Ltd (Pitcher Partners). On 6 February 2025, Shield was served with other related proceedings that had been commenced by Ligon 158 Pty Limited (in liquidation) against Mr Binetter (as the first respondent), Ms Kelliher (as the second respondent), and Shield (as the third respondent) in proceeding SAD 205 of 2024 (Ligon Proceedings).