Sheridan and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Sheridan and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2017] AATA 17 (12 January 2017)

Division

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2015/5479

Re

William Sheridan

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

Date 12 January  2017
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]...................................................................

Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

Catchwords

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS — claim for diabetes mellitus (type 2)—accepted condition of lumbar spondylosis—whether such condition caused the Applicant’s obesity—whether diabetes caused by lumbar spondylosis—no connection—decision affirmed

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) ss 29,120(4),120B(3)

Cases

McKenna v Repatriation Commission (1999) 86 FCR 144

Secondary Materials

Guide to the Assessment of Rates of Veterans’ Pensions

Amendment Statement of Principles concerning diabetes mellitus No 89. of 2014 (Cth)

Statement of Principles concerning diabetes mellitus No 90. of 2011(Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member

12 January 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mr Sheridan, applies under the Veterans Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act) to review the Respondent’s decision dated 30 October 2014 (the reviewable decision). The reviewable decision, inter alia, refused the claim Mr Sheridan made on 21 May 2014 for diabetes mellitus (type 2), hip problems and knee problems to be accepted under the Act as attributable to his defence service.

  2. Subsequently, the reviewable decision was affirmed by the Veterans Review Board (VRB) on 21 November 2014 which, following the acceptance of other disabilities, including lumber spondylosis, increased pension from 60% to 80% of the General Rate.

  3. On 20 October 2015 Mr Sheridan applied for review by this Tribunal.

  4. At the hearing held on 8 December 2016, the Applicant was represented by Mr John Horan, independent advocate. The Respondent was represented by Mr Ken Rudge, departmental advocate.

  5. The only witness called at the hearing was the Applicant himself. No medical evidence was called. No witnesses were called by the Respondent. The T- documents were placed into evidence.

    Contentions

  6. Mr Sheridan contends that his condition of diabetes mellitus (type 2) is attributable to his defence service and should be accepted under the Act

  7. The Applicant argues his condition is attributable to his service as a result of his limited exercise capability due to his accepted disability of lumbar spondylosis. Lumbar spondylosis was accepted under the Act with effect from 14 September 2009. I note that earlier, Mr Sheridan appears to have considered his diabetes as being attributable to heavy smoking during his defence service even though he gave up smoking in 1984, some 32 years ago.

  8. Mr Sheridan contends that his limited exercise ability, due to lumbar spondylosis, caused an increase in his weight to the extent that he eventually became morbidly obese.

  9. Added to this now is a further accepted condition of osteoarthritis of the right ankle. This was accepted on 6 September 2016, long after the VRB decision, with effect from 25 April 2016.

  10. Despite the Applicant’s ankle now also being an accepted condition, the Respondent contends that the Applicant does not satisfy any Statement of Principle made under the Act and in consequence is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sheridan and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Sheridan against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding his claim for diabetes mellitus (type 2). The applicant’s defence service occurred between 1972 and 1975. The central dispute revolved around whether the applicant’s accepted condition of lumbar spondylosis, and a related ankle injury, had caused his obesity, which in turn led to his type 2 diabetes. The case was heard by Dr Damien Cremean, Senior Member.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant satisfied the criteria set out in the Statement of Principles (SOP) concerning diabetes mellitus No. 90 of 2011, as amended by Instrument No. 89 of 2014. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the applicant’s type 2 diabetes was defence-caused, which required establishing a connection between the condition and his defence service on the balance of probabilities. This involved assessing whether the applicant was overweight for at least five years before the clinical onset of diabetes, or unable to undertake physical activity greater than three METs for at least ten years before its onset, as defined by the SOP.

The Tribunal considered the applicant’s argument that his lumbar spondylosis and ankle injury had limited his ability to exercise, leading to weight gain and subsequent morbid obesity, thereby causing his diabetes. However, the Tribunal found that the clinical onset of the applicant’s lumbar spondylosis was recorded as 14 September 2009, which was significantly after his defence service concluded. Crucially, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the material before it raised a connection between the applicant's diabetes and his defence service, nor that the relevant SOP upheld the contention that the diabetes was defence-caused on the balance of probabilities.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that Mr Sheridan’s diabetes mellitus (type 2) was defence-caused within the meaning of the Act. The reviewable decision of the Repatriation Commission was therefore affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this matter, the Applicant relies on Statement of Principles concerning diabetes mellitus No. 90 of 2011 as amended by Instrument No. 89 of 2014 (the SOP).Relevant background The Applicant served in the Australian Army (Field Engineers) for a period of just over three years, from 5 January 1972 to 14 February 1975. Mr Sheridan’s defence service, as per s 68(1) of the Act spans from 7 December 1972 to 14 February 1975. At the hearing, Mr Sheridan gave evidence that he was initially influenced by his butcher to join the Army. He further stated that he was also attracted to the lifestyle it offered: he told the Tribunal that in his youth, he used to participate in amateur Under19s football and enjoyed swimming, bike riding, camping, fishing and shooting. He also stated that he had pretty close mates and this is what appealed to him about the Army lifestyle. He was a young country lad. He had wanted to serve overseas in Vietnam. In the end, however, the plan to serve in Vietnam did not eventuate and Mr Sheridan remained in Australia throughout his service. Mr Sheridan stated that his long term ambition was to make a career out of the Army. He left school at age 15 and enlisted with the Army for six years. However, he left the Army long before the end of that period. Documents record a number of infractions during that period leading up to discharge. He stated in evidence he was unhappy in the Army. After discharge from the Army, the Applicant worked in various jobs but mainly driving trucks and machinery. It is not correct to say (as the Respondent’s Statement of Facts and Contentions asserts) that he did little work after 15 December 1974. In fact, the Applicant is still working full time, at age 62, in Myrtleford in Victoria on clerical duties. The focus of the Applicant’s case at the hearing was clearly on his accepted condition of lumbar spondylosis but there was also discussion of his right ankle injury.Lumbar spondylosis With regards to his lumbar spondylosis, prior to discharge from the Army, Mr Sheridan began experiencing low back symptoms including pain, but only intermittently. His duties in the Army had involved the construction of landing zones for helicopters and carrying heavy packs and equipment and tools, such as chainsaws. This included when Mr Sheridan was required to be in the bush. Although he was cross-examined by Mr Rudge on the point, I am not concerned to establish whether Mr Sheridan spent nine months out of 12 or some shorter period in the bush. In the hearing, Mr Sheridan gave further evidence that on 25 February 1972, he injured himself doing back squatting. Prior to this, he was able to perform all physical tasks required of him in service. Mr Sheridan told the Tribunal that following the injury, he was required to undertake constant physiotherapy, as well as an exercise regimen and was placed on light duties. He was also sent for a sight test. Further, Mr Sheridan described himself as having a medical discharge threat hanging over [his] head if he didn’t perform and meet [the] standard. He told the Tribunal that this pushed him along and caused him to do more than usual, pushing himself to give 120% instead of 100%.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the above reasons, I am not satisfied that the relevant SOP upholds the contention that Mr Sheridan’s diabetes mellitus (type 2) is, on the balance of probabilities, connected with his defence service. I therefore cannot find that it is defence caused within the meaning of s 120(4) of the Act.CONCLUSION I am satisfied, for the reasons I have given, that the reviewable decision must be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The date of clinical onset of the Applicant’s lumber spondylosis is 14 September 2009. This is the date recorded by Dr Verhoef, the Applicant’s local medical officer, as the date when the symptoms were first reported.CONSIDERATION Application of criteria in Statement of Principles The question for me to decide is whether the Applicant satisfies the criteria set out in the SOP. As the Applicant’s service is defence service, I must apply the SOP as set out in s 120B(3) of the Act. I can therefore only be reasonably satisfied that an injury suffered by the Applicant is defence-caused if the material before me raises a connection between the injury and some particular service rendered by the Applicant, and that there is a Statement of Principles determined that upholds the contention that the injury, disease or death of the person is, on the balance of probabilities, connected with that service. As noted above and identified by the Applicant, the relevant SOP in this case is Statement of Principles concerning diabetes mellitus No. 90 of 2011 as amended by Instrument No. 89 of 2014. The SOP in paragraph 3(b) defines diabetes mellitus exhaustively as a metabolic disorder characterised by hyperglycaemia. Paragraph 6 the SOP sets out the factor or factors that must exist before it can be said that, on the balance of probabilities, a case of diabetes mellitus is connected with the circumstances of a person’s service. It states:(a)………..(b) for type 2 diabetes mellitus only,(i) being overweight for a period of at least five years before the clinical onset of diabetes mellitus; or (ii) an inability to undertake any physical activity greater than three METs for at least the ten years before the clinical onset of diabetes mellitus;……..(c)….. Paragraph 3(b) of the SOP defines the expression being overweight used in paragraph 6(b) as meaning:an increase in body weight by way of fat accumulation which results in at least one of the following:(i) a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 25 or greater ;or (ii) a waist circumference of greater than 80 centimetres in women or greater than 94 centimetres in men;The BMI = W/H² and where:W is the person’s weight in kilograms and H is the person’s height in metres; The Applicant relies upon the factors in paragraphs 6(b)(i) (and also 6(b)(ii)) of the SOP. Mr Sheridan argues (as it was expressed by the Respondent) that he falls within paragraph 6(b) of the SOP. He argues he became overweight because he could not exercise as a result of his lumbar spondylosis and/or right ankle fracture (occurring on 28 February 1972), osteoarthritis of the right ankle and bony spur at the site of the ankle fracture. Mr Horan contended that Mr Sheridan’s condition of Diabetes Mellitus is attributable to his defence service as a result of his limited exercise capability because of his accepted condition of lumbar spondylosis. Mr Horan submitted that this limited exercise ability caused an increase in weight to the extent that he eventually became morbidly obese.