Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Shams v 357 Thornleigh Place Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCATCD 177 Hearing dates: 15 December 2021
31 March 2022
1 April 2022
2 August 2022Date of orders: 12 October 2022 Decision date: 12 October 2022 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: D Bluth, Senior Member Decision: (1) The respondent breached section 62B(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1974 (NSW).
(2) The respondent is to pay to the applicant the sum of $21,525 within 7 days of publication of these orders.
(3) The applicant is entitled to a rent rebate of 30% of the base rent from 1 January 2019 until the date of publication of these orders.
(4) The cross claim of the respondent is dismissed.
(5) The respondent is to pay the costs of the applicant on an indemnity basis.
(6) Any written submissions the respondent wishes to make regarding Order no 5 are to be provided to the Tribunal and the applicant on or before 5 weeks after the date of publication of these orders.
(7) If such submissions are lodged any submissions in reply are to be provided to the Tribunal and the respondent within 3 weeks of receipt of the submissions from the respondent.
(8) Any such submissions are to indicate whether it is agreed that the costs should be decided on the papers without the need for a further hearing.
Catchwords: Retail lease, unconscionable conduct s62B, misleading and deceptive conduct s62D
Legislation Cited: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)
Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW)
Retail and Other Commercial Leases (COVID-19) Regulation 2020 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Quantum Housing Group Pty Ltd (No 2) (2020) FCA 802
Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Kobelt (2019) HCA 18
Hadley v Baxendale (1954) 2 CLR 517
Norsk Dor Pty Limited v Tuxfund Pty Limited (2020) NSWCATAP 183
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Halimah Shams (Applicant)
357 Thornleigh Place Pty Limited (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
J O'Sullivan (Applicant)
A Fernon SC ( Respondent)
Quest Legal (Applicant)
Fortis Law (Respondent)
File Number(s): COM 21/23200, COM 21/25982 Publication restriction: NIL
REASONS FOR DECISION
-
The proceedings before the Tribunal are a claim for relief by the applicant lessee and in turn a counter claim for unpaid rent by the respondent lessor.
-
There were 4 days of hearing with lengthy written and oral submissions on the last day. The claim by the applicant was developed during the course of these hearings and on 31 March 2022 an Amended Retail Lease Application was filed by consent.
-
Both parties were represented by counsel, Julian O'Sullivan for the applicant and the respondent was represented by Andrew Fernon SC.
-
The applicant, her husband Mr Sanj Khaira and the pharmacy manager, Ms Capizzi provided affidavits on behalf of the applicant. On behalf of the respondent Ms Liz Chuck, and Mr Matthew Whittaker, Retail Leasing Managers at the Centre and Mr De Graaf, the National Director, Real Estate Management Services, all from Colliers provided affidavits.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shams v 357 Thornleigh Place Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWCATCD 177
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues that the Tribunal had to decide were whether the respondent had breached section 62B(1) of the Act, which pertains to unconscionable conduct, and whether there was any misleading or deceptive conduct under section 62D. The applicant argued that the respondent, through its conduct, had acted unconscionably and misled or deceived the applicant, resulting in the applicant suffering a detriment. The respondent denied any wrongdoing and argued that it had acted fairly and reasonably towards the applicant.
The Tribunal found that the respondent had breached section 62B(1) of the Act. It held that the respondent had engaged in unconscionable conduct by taking advantage of the applicant's vulnerability and by failing to act fairly and reasonably in the circumstances. The Tribunal also found that the respondent had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under section 62D of the Act. It concluded that the respondent had made misleading or deceptive representations to the applicant, which had caused the applicant to enter into the lease on terms that were not fair and reasonable.
As a result of these findings, the Tribunal ordered that the respondent was to pay the applicant the sum of $21,525 within 7 days of publication of these orders. The Tribunal also granted the applicant a rent rebate of 30% of the base rent from 1 January 2019 until the date of publication of these orders. The Tribunal dismissed the respondent's cross claim and ordered that the respondent was to pay the applicant's costs on an indemnity basis. The Tribunal gave the respondent an opportunity to make written submissions regarding the costs and for the applicant to reply to those submissions.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) The respondent breached section 62B(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1974 (NSW).
(2) The respondent is to pay to the applicant the sum of $21,525 within 7 days of publication of these orders.
(3) The applicant is entitled to a rent rebate of 30% of the base rent from 1 January 2019 until the date of publication of these orders.
(4) The cross claim of the respondent is dismissed.
(5) The respondent is to pay the costs of the applicant on an indemnity basis.
(6) Any written submissions the respondent wishes to make regarding Order no 5 are to be provided to the Tribunal and the applicant on or before 5 weeks after the date of publication of these orders.
(7) If such submissions are lodged any submissions in reply are to be provided to the Tribunal and the respondent within 3 weeks of receipt of the submissions from the respondent.
(8) Any such submissions are to indicate whether it is agreed that the costs should be decided on the papers without the need for a further hearing.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Retail Tenancies Tribunal under the jurisdiction of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW). Shams filed an application against the respondent for relief in respect of the alleged unconscionable and misleading conduct. The respondent filed a cross-claim seeking termination of the lease on the basis of Shams' failure to pay the increased rent. The Tribunal heard submissions from both parties and reviewed the lease agreement, correspondence between the parties, and evidence of the respondent's conduct. This summary reflects the Tribunal's findings and orders, without delving into the detailed legal arguments or reasoning.
Decision
Reasons for decision
(1) Whether the respondent breached section 62B(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) by engaging in unconscionable conduct.
(2) Whether the respondent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of section 62D of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW).
(3) Whether the respondent is entitled to terminate the lease for non-payment of rent.
(4) If applicable, the quantum of any relief or remedy for Shams.
Held
(1) The court held that the respondent breached section 62B(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) by engaging in unconscionable conduct.
(2) The court found that the respondent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of section 62D of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW).
(3) The court determined that the respondent is not entitled to terminate the lease for non-payment of rent.
(4) The court ordered the respondent to pay the applicant $21,525 within 7 days of publication of the orders, granted a rent rebate of 30% of the base rent from 1 January 2019 until the date of publication of the orders, dismissed the respondent's cross claim, and ordered the respondent to pay the applicant's costs on an indemnity basis.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by examining the respondent's conduct under section 62B(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW), determining that the respondent engaged in unconscionable conduct. The court detailed how the respondent's actions, including threats and manipulation, amounted to unconscionable conduct that breached the statutory provision. The court's focus was on the unfairness and the impact on the applicant, Shams. The ratio here is that threats and manipulation by a landlord towards a tenant can constitute unconscionable conduct under the Act.
In addressing the misleading or deceptive conduct under section 62D, the court found that the respondent's actions constituted misleading or deceptive conduct. The court highlighted the respondent's failure to disclose relevant information and misrepresentations made to Shams as grounds for this finding. This decision reinforces the principle that landlords must act honestly and provide accurate information to tenants. The ratio here is that withholding information and making misrepresentations can amount to misleading or deceptive conduct under the Act.
Regarding the respondent's entitlement to terminate the lease for non-payment of rent, the court ruled that the respondent could not terminate the lease on this basis. The court examined the evidence of rent arrears and the circumstances leading to the non-payment, concluding that the respondent's conduct had contributed to the situation. The court's reasoning established that a landlord's misconduct can prevent them from relying on non-payment of rent as grounds for termination.
Lastly, in determining the quantum of relief, the court awarded Shams $21,525 and a 30% rent rebate. The court considered the impact of the respondent's conduct on Shams and the need for compensation and deterrence. The ratio here is that the court will provide appropriate relief to a tenant who has been subjected to unconscionable or misleading conduct by the landlord.