Shahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON AND BELL JJ

SAYED ABDUL RAHMAN SHAHI  PLAINTIFF

AND

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP  DEFENDANT

Shahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] HCA 52
14 December 2011
M10/2011

ORDER

Order that the question stated in the special case be answered as follows:

Question 1: Did the delegate make a jurisdictional error in finding that the plaintiff's mother did not meet the requirements of cl 202.221 of Sched 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)?

Answer:         Yes.

Representation

L G De Ferrari for the plaintiff (instructed by Victoria Legal Aid (Civil Law Section))

S B Lloyd SC for the defendant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND BELL JJ.   The plaintiff, a refugee from Afghanistan, holds a protection visa.  He proposed that his mother (and some other relatives) be granted visas to enter and remain in Australia.  A criterion for the grant of the visa for which the plaintiff's mother applied was that at the time of her application she continue to be a member of the proposer's immediate family.  After the mother made her application, but before the Minister's delegate decided whether to grant or refuse the application, the plaintiff attained 18 years of age and, as a result, the mother ceased to be a member of the plaintiff's "immediate family".  The Minister's delegate decided that the mother's ceasing to be a member of the plaintiff's immediate family required that the mother's application be refused.

  2. Was this jurisdictional error, attracting relief in the original jurisdiction of this Court under s 75(v) of the Constitution?  The litigation has proceeded on the footing that in this matter the Parliament has not conferred the necessary federal jurisdiction upon any other court.

    The Act and Regulations

  3. The Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Act") provides, by s 31(3), that regulations made under the Act "may prescribe criteria for a visa or visas of a specified class". The Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) ("the Regulations") provide (reg 2.01) for prescribed classes of visas. One such class, identified in item 1402 of Sched 1 to the Regulations, is Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB). That class of visa is divided[1] into several subclasses.  The presently relevant subclass is Subclass 202 Global Special Humanitarian.

    [1]Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), reg 2.02(1), Sched 1, item 1402(4).

  4. Regulation 2.03(1) provides that "the prescribed criteria for the grant to a person of a visa of a particular class" are those set out in Sched 2 to the Regulations. The criteria may be (and in the case of Subclass 202 visas are) divided into primary and secondary criteria.

  5. This case concerns the construction of those provisions of the Regulations that prescribe the primary criteria for the grant of a Subclass 202 visa. More particularly, how does the requirement made by cl 202.221 that "[t]he applicant continues to satisfy the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] HCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter before the High Court of Australia, the plaintiff, an Australian permanent resident and eligible proposer, sought judicial review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship to refuse a Subclass 202 Global Special Humanitarian visa for his mother. The core of the dispute concerned the interpretation of the visa application criteria, specifically whether the applicant's mother continued to meet the definition of "member of the immediate family of the proposer" at the time of the decision, given that the proposer had turned 18 between the application date and the decision date.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the delegate made a jurisdictional error in finding that the plaintiff's mother did not meet the requirements of clause 202.221 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). This required the Court to determine the temporal scope of the criterion that the applicant "continues to be a member of the immediate family of the proposer," and whether this criterion needed to be satisfied at the time of the visa application or at the time of the decision.

The Court reasoned that the definition of "member of the immediate family" in regulation 1.12AA(1) stipulated that a person is a parent of another if the latter is not 18 years or more. The plaintiff had applied for the visa before turning 18, at which point his mother was considered an immediate family member. However, the delegate's decision was made after the plaintiff turned 18, meaning his mother no longer fell within the definition of an immediate family member. The Court found that clause 202.211(2)(c) of the Migration Regulations, which requires the applicant to "continue to be a member of the immediate family of the proposer," was the critical provision. The Court concluded that this criterion, unlike others within subclause (2) of clause 202.211, had a specific temporal requirement that differed from other elements.

The High Court answered the question stated in the special case in the affirmative, finding that the delegate did make a jurisdictional error in determining that the plaintiff's mother did not meet the requirements of clause 202.221.

Orders

Orders of the court

Order that the question stated in the special case be answered as follows:

Question 1: Did the delegate make a jurisdictional error in finding that the plaintiff's mother did not meet the requirements of cl 202.221 of Sched 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)?

Answer: Yes.

Background

Background to the litigation

The expression "member of the immediate family" is defined in reg 1.12AA(1):"For these Regulations, a person A is a member of the immediate family of another person B if:(a) A is a spouse or de facto partner of B; or(b) A is a dependant child of B; or(c) A is a parent of B, and B is not 18 years or more."The facts In May 2009, the plaintiff arrived in Australia as an unaccompanied minor. In September 2009, he applied for and was granted a Protection (Class XA) visa. In December 2009, the plaintiff was the proposer in an application by his mother (and some other relatives) for the grant of a Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) visa. The relevant subclass of visa was Subclass 202 Global Special Humanitarian. At the time of the visa application the plaintiff was under 18 years of age and thus the mother was "a member of the immediate family" of the plaintiff. The visa application was refused by a delegate of the Minister in September 2010. The plaintiff does not know his exact date of birth. The parties have agreed that at some time between the date of the visa application (in December 2009) and the date of the decision to refuse the application (in September 2010) the plaintiff attained 18 years of age. Once the plaintiff turned 18, his mother was no longer a member of his "immediate family" as reg 1.12AA(1) defines that term.The delegate's decision The Minister's delegate decided that the visa application should be refused on grounds including that, at the time of the decision, the plaintiff's mother was no longer a member of the immediate family of the proposer (the plaintiff) because the proposer was no longer under 18 years of age. The delegate also decided that another provision of subdiv 202.22 had not been met. That other provision (cl 202.222) requires the Minister to be "satisfied that there are compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting to the applicant a permanent visa, having regard to" certain matters. The parties agreed that the delegate's conclusion about the application of this other provision "does not provide a separate basis for the decision". It was said, in argument, that it was the policy of the Minister to treat the presence or absence of "compelling reasons" as affected by (even dependent upon) satisfaction of the matters identified in cl 202.211. The accuracy of this view was not in issue and need not be examined.Applying cl 202.221 The provision made by cl 202.221 that "[t]he applicant continues to satisfy the criterion in clause 202.211" is readily applied to the first of the alternative criteria stated in cl 202.211 (that "[t]he applicant … is subject to substantial discrimination, amounting to gross violation of human rights, in the applicant's home country and is living in a country other than the applicant's home country"). The criterion in cl 202.211(1)(a) is stated in such a way as readily to permit its application "at time of application" and its separate application "at time of decision". Seeking to have cl 202.221 engage with the second criterion stated in cl 202.211 (that "[t]he applicant … meets the requirements of subclause (2)") is more difficult. The difficulty arises from the circumstance that the requirements of sub‑cl (2) of cl 202.211 have several different temporal elements. Those different temporal elements can be identified as follows.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND BELL JJ HEYDON J
The plaintiff does not know his exact date of birth. The parties have agreed that at some time between the date of the visa application (in December 2009) and the date of the decision to refuse the application (in September 2010) the plaintiff attained 18 years of age. Once the plaintiff turned 18, his mother was no longer a member of his "immediate family" as reg 1.12AA(1) defines that term.The delegate's decision The Minister's delegate decided that the visa application should be refused on grounds including that, at the time of the decision, the plaintiff's mother was no longer a member of the immediate family of the proposer (the plaintiff) because the proposer was no longer under 18 years of age. The delegate also decided that another provision of subdiv 202.22 had not been met. That other provision (cl 202.222) requires the Minister to be "satisfied that there are compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting to the applicant a permanent visa, having regard to" certain matters. The parties agreed that the delegate's conclusion about the application of this other provision "does not provide a separate basis for the decision". It was said, in argument, that it was the policy of the Minister to treat the presence or absence of "compelling reasons" as affected by (even dependent upon) satisfaction of the matters identified in cl 202.211. The accuracy of this view was not in issue and need not be examined.Applying cl 202.221 The provision made by cl 202.221 that "[t]he applicant continues to satisfy the criterion in clause 202.211" is readily applied to the first of the alternative criteria stated in cl 202.211 (that "[t]he applicant … is subject to substantial discrimination, amounting to gross violation of human rights, in the applicant's home country and is living in a country other than the applicant's home country"). The criterion in cl 202.211(1)(a) is stated in such a way as readily to permit its application "at time of application" and its separate application "at time of decision". Seeking to have cl 202.221 engage with the second criterion stated in cl 202.211 (that "[t]he applicant … meets the requirements of subclause (2)") is more difficult. The difficulty arises from the circumstance that the requirements of sub‑cl (2) of cl 202.211 have several different temporal elements. Those different temporal elements can be identified as follows. One of the requirements of cl 202.211(2) (provided by cl 202.211(2)(a)) looks to the past, that is, to a time before the time of application: "the applicant's entry to Australia has been proposed …". The requirements made by cl 202.211(2)(b)(i) to (iii) look to the present or the past: "the proposer is, or has been, the holder" of a particular class of visa. The requirement made by cl 202.211(2)(ba) looks to a period of time fixed by reference to the date of application for the visa and the date of grant of the proposer's relevant visa: "the application is made within 5 years of the grant" of the relevant visa that is or was held by the proposer. The requirement made by cl 202.211(2)(d) takes the time of the grant of the relevant visa that is or was held by the proposer as the relevant time and looks backwards: "before the grant of that visa, that relationship was declared to Immigration". And of critical importance to the present matter, the requirement of cl 202.211(2)(c) has a temporal requirement that differs from all other elements of cl 202.211(2). It requires that "the applicant continues to be a member of the immediate family of the proposer".

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND BELL JJ, HEYDON J