Shah and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Shah and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration) [2025] ARTA 2008 (2 October 2025)

Applicant:Mr Prayas Thakorbhai Shah

Respondent: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Tribunal Number:                2025/4339

Tribunal:General Member A E Burke

Place:Melbourne

Date:2 October 2025  

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........................[SGD]...............................................

General Member A E Burke

Catchwords

MIGRATION – Class VB Subclass 887 Skilled Regional visa – substantial criminal record – Indian national – failure to pass character test – recidivist offending - whether another reason mandatory cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 110 applied – ties to Australia – best interest of minor child – impediments to removal – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 202

LZGG and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2020] AATA

Meissner v R (1995) 130 ALR 547
Rano v Minister for Home Affairs, Minister for Cyber Security [2024] FCA 1003

461

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 110 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501
The Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (ACIC) submission to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Law Enforcement (PJCLE) Inquiry into Australia’s illicit drug problem: Challenges and opportunities for law enforcement, intelligence and national security.

Australian Government Department of Home Affairs - Illicit Drugs Action Plan

Statement of Reasons

  1. On 2 October 2024, a delegate of the Minister administering the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Minister), cancelled Mr Shah’s Class VB Subclass 887 Skilled – Regional Visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. On 11 October 2024, Mr Shah provided a response to the decision, requesting revocation of the decision to cancel his visa for other reasons. Most particularly:

    He requests that the cancellation decision be revoked for reasons including (but not limited to):

    a. He has a wife and daughter who are both Australian citizens (strength, nature, and duration of ties to Australia).

    b. His 8-year-old daughter will be affected by the decision (best interest of minor children in Australia affected by the decision).

  3. On 10 July 2025, a delegate of the Minister made a decision not to revoke the cancellation of Mr Shah’s visa. The delegate found that:

    46.   I accept that a number of factors, as outlined above, may have contributed in part to Mr SHAH’s offending behaviour. I note Mr SHAH was clinically depressed and drug addicted when he offended. However, his criminal history clearly shows a pattern of reoffending, and indicates that he has neither addressed his ongoing drug addiction nor consistently engaged in rehabilitation. This suggests to me that he may reoffend, particularly when an opportunity arises to gain a financial benefit.

    47.   I acknowledge that the judge accepted Mr SHAH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shah and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 2008
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Shah, an Indian national, appealed the decision to cancel his Class VB Subclass 887 Skilled - Regional visa. The key issue before the Tribunal was whether the cancellation of Mr Shah's visa should be revoked, considering the factors outlined in Ministerial Direction No. 110. The Tribunal needed to determine if there were sufficient grounds to revoke the cancellation, particularly focusing on the impact on Mr Shah's family and his ties to Australia.

The Tribunal considered Mr Shah's criminal history, his significant ties to Australia, and the impact on his family, especially his young daughter. Mr Shah had a substantial criminal record, including multiple drug-related offenses, and had failed the character test. However, he argued that he had shown remorse and had undertaken rehabilitation efforts. The Tribunal examined his ties to Australia, including his employment history, business ownership, and the impact on his family if he were to be removed. The Tribunal also considered the legal consequences of the decision, including the potential for indefinite exclusion from Australia and the impediments to his removal.

The Tribunal concluded that while Mr Shah's criminal history was serious, the primary consideration was the protection of the Australian community. However, the Tribunal found that Mr Shah's substantial ties to Australia, particularly his family, warranted a favorable consideration. The Tribunal was satisfied that there were other reasons to revoke the original decision, emphasizing the best interests of Mr Shah's minor child and the impediments to his removal.

The Tribunal decided to revoke the cancellation of Mr Shah's visa, allowing him to remain in Australia with his wife and daughter. The Tribunal noted that removing Mr Shah would cause significant hardship to his family and that his rehabilitation efforts and ties to Australia were compelling factors in their decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of his application on 17 and 19 September 2025, Mr Shah was represented by Mr Surendra Man Shrestha of Australian Immigration & Citizenship Centre, and Mr Matthew Daly instructed by Ms Jami Klisaris and Claire Lewis of Mills Oakley, appeared for the Minister. The Minister lodged a set of paginated tender documents inclusive of the G-Documents, summons documents from Victoria Police, Melbourne County Court Corrective Services Victoria, Victorian Department of Transport and Planning, a supplementary tender bundle inclusive of Mr Shah’s immigration records and several policy documents. Mr Shah submitted a character refence.BACKGROUND Mr Shah is a 41-year-old Indian citizen, who migrated to Australia with his wife on 26 April 2008 originally on a Student (Temporary) (class TU) Higher Education Sector (subclass 573) visa at the age of 23. On 5 April 2017 Mr Shah was granted a Class VB Subclass 887 Skilled - Regional visa. Mr Shah and his wife have one daughter aged nine. His wife and daughter are Australian citizens. Since his arrival in Australia Mr Shah has departed Australia on numerous occasions, returning to India several times and holidaying in Fiji. Mr Shah and his wife grew up in the same neighbourhood in India but came from different castes. They met while they were both still at school and married on 13 September 2007. Mr Shah reported they married against the wishes of their parents and the societal pressures of their community. Mr Shah and his wife reported they came to Australia for a better life and to escape the shunning they had encountered because of their love and marriage against the tradition of their region. Mr Shah completed his education in India obtaining a bachelor’s degree in accounting before he commenced work in the construction industry. When he arrived in Australia, he originally resided in Sydney, where he worked in a carwash. He and his wife then relocated to Melbourne where he worked in a warehouse as a store supervisor and forklift driver from 2008-2016. Mr Shah and his wife purchased and commenced their own courier business in June 2015, which they had intended to operate as a side venture However the business began to collapse in June 2016 after Alpha Logistics, who they provided the majority of their services to, went into receivership leaving them unable to recover $110,000 owed. Whilst Mr Shah successfully litigated, and entered into a payment plan with Alpha Logistics, he never recovered any money. Mr Shah was left with considerable debt, as he had borrowed money to purchase three vans and was paying his driver from his own savings as he waited to receive the outstanding contractual payments. Mr Shah sustained an injury at work around 2015 and eventually underwent spinal surgery in 2016. A series of events resulted in Mr Shah leaving his role at the warehouse, and it was around this time he turned to substance abuse to deal with his back pain and financial stress. Mr Shah’s wife was also pregnant at this time and was suffering significant complications with the pregnancy which required Mr Shah to drive his wife three times a week to medical appointments. Following the birth of their daughter Mr Shah’s parents-in-law arrived from India to help his wife but this only added to Mr Shah’s stress, shame and eventual depression.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the issue for consideration by the Tribunal is whether the cancellation of Mr Shah’s visa should be revoked, taking into account the relevant considerations in the Direction. In essence, the Tribunal must be satisfied there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.EVIDENCEMr Shah’s Offending The following table has been derived from a national criminal history check relating to Mr Shah, produced by the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission on 24 September 2024: Following a guilty plea to the 2024 convictions, his Honour Justice Trapnell, imposed a term of six years’ imprisonment with a four year non-parole period. his Honour in his sentencing remarks of 24 August 2024 outlined an agreed statement of facts: Interception and search of your motor vehicle5. On 26 May 2022 at about 1:45am, First Constable Ronald Medcraft and Sergeant Timothy Ryan observed a white Holden Captiva driving along Banksia Street in Ivanhoe. They followed the vehicle and saw you driving at a speed of approximately 81 km/h in a 60 km/h zone (Summary Charge 27). You were intercepted.6. You produced your Victorian driver licence upon request. When asked if you had previously been involved with police, you admitted you ‘had for drugs’ and said you were undergoing rehabilitation and mandatory drug testing. You also said you had not used drugs for quite some time.7. Medcraft asked if he would find drugs if he searched your car, to which you replied ‘100% no’. You appeared nervous and Medcraft asked you to exit the vehicle. A search of your car was conducted during which a zip lock bag containing 0.3 grams of methylamphetamine was discovered in a console near the steering wheel. You admitted ownership of the bag when it was shown to you. You denied using ice that night.8. In the console Medcraft also found a quantity of cash wrapped in facemasks and a zip lock bag containing 1.4 grams of heroin. You ‘swore’ the money was not the proceeds of selling drugs. A pink case was then located under the driver’s seat which contained two large zip lock bags with numerous smaller zip lock bags filled with powder. The powder was subsequently tested and found to be methylamphetamine, totalling 43.4 grams in weight, of which 35.94 grams was pure.Search of your home9. At approximately 8am the same day, police attended your residential address in Rosanna. Your wife was home at the time and informed police there were two rooms connected to the garage, one used for storage and the other used by you. Your wife told police you spend the majority of your time in that area and rarely venture into the house.10. During a search of the room used by you, police located the following items:(a) On a desk, an orange container containing methylamphetamine in the form of crystal residue (Charge 1).(b) In a drawer of the desk:(i) 7.0 grams of methylamphetamine (Charge 1);(ii) various quantities of heroin totalling 11.1 grams (Charge 2);(iii) $600 in cash (Charge 7); and(iv) scales.(c) In a black pencil case located in a box underneath the desk:(i) 10.9 grams of methylamphetamine (Charge 1);(ii) various quantities of heroin totalling 6.4 grams (Charge 2); and(iii) 1.8 grams of cocaine (Charge 6).(d) In a black box underneath the desk:(i) various quantities of cannabis totalling 24.5 grams, some of which was wrapped in individual foils (Charge 3); and(ii) small zip lock bags.(e) In another desk drawer, a handwritten note evidencing drug transactions.(f) In a backpack, $10,000 in cash (Charge 7).(g) Inside a plastic bag on a shelf, a further quantity of cannabis (Charge 3).(h) In a wooden ‘Yo-Yo’ box underneath the staircase:(i) a quantity of methylamphetamine (Charge 1);(ii) a quantity of heroin (Charge 2);[13](iii) $18,900 in cash (Charge 7); and(iv) empty ‘deal’ bags.(i) In a harmonica box underneath the staircase:(i) 234.8 grams of methylamphetamine (Charge 1);(ii) 10.3 grams of cannabis seeds (Charge 3);(iii) 60 diazepam tablets (Charge 4);(iv) 7 oxycodone tablets (Endone) (Charge 5);(v) 0.04 grams of quetiapine (Syquet) (Summary Charge 50);(vi) 9 zopiclone tablets (Imrest) (Summary Charge 51);(vii) a quantity of sildenafil tablets (Viagra) (Summary Charge 52); and(viii) 3 pregabalin tablets (Lyrica) (Summary Charge 53).(j) $300,050 in cash located in a shoebox in a green bag.11. The total amount of cash found at your address was $329,550 (Charge 7).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In making a decision under ss 501(1), 501(2) or 501CA(4) of the Act, the considerations below must also be taken into account, where relevant, in accordance with the following provisions. These considerations include (but are not limited to):·Legal consequences of the decision;·Extent of impediments if removed; and·Impact on Australian business interests.Legal consequences of the decision The Direction reminds decision-makers to be mindful that unlawful non-citizens are liable for removal from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable pursuant to s 198 of the Act, noting that s 197C(1) provides that, for the purposes of s 198, it is irrelevant that Australia has non-refoulement obligations in respect of an unlawful non-citizen. SubmissionsMr Shah Mr Shah’s representative made no contention in respect of this consideration. Respondent The Respondent’s representative submitted Mr Shah made no submissions in relation to this consideration. The Respondent’s representative submitted as Mr Shah does not have a protection finding as defined in s 197C of the Act, that if his visa remains cancelled, he would face a period of detention and removal from Australia to India. Further Mr Shah may not be able to meet the criteria for a visa that would enable him to return to Australia as a result of the Special Return Criteria in Schedule 5 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The Respondent’s representative submitted these are the intended consequences of a visa cancellation and as Mr Shah has made no claims on this consideration it should therefore be given neutral weight.Summary finding The Tribunal finds that there are no non-refoulement obligations that need to be observed in this situation. Neither Mr Shah nor the Respondent sought to pursue this argument noting that international non-refoulement obligations do not arise in this situation as Mr Shah was not being removed to a country where he faced the prospect of being subjected to cruel or unusual punishment. The Tribunal finds the legal consequence of Mr Shah’s visa cancellation would be his removal and inability to return to Australia, the Tribunal noting his Honour Judge Feutrill’s recent decision in Rano v Minister for Home Affairs, Minister for Cyber Security [2024] FCA 1003:Relevantly, the legal consequence of the Minister’s decision is that the applicant will be removed from Australia and cannot satisfy the special return criteria in cl 5001 of Sch 5 of the Regulations. In substance, that means that the applicant is ineligible for most classes of visa that would otherwise relate to him. That is not a matter of speculation. It is not necessary to wait for an application for a visa to be made to know that he cannot be granted a visa in any of the applicable classes. Therefore, the practical reality in human terms that flows from the legal consequences of the Minister’s decision is that the applicant will be removed from Australia and, thereafter, will be precluded from travelling to, entering and (or) remaining in Australia unless he is able to bring himself within the criteria of a visa class to which the special return criteria does not apply. In much the same way that a legal consequence may be characterised as ‘indefinite detention’, the legal consequence here may be characterised as removal and ‘indefinite exclusion’ from Australia. Moreover, in my view, not only is that a legal consequence it is manifestly a purpose of the applicable statutory framework and scheme that includes s 501(3).It is evident that a purpose of specifying that the special return criteria be satisfied for the various visa classes in Sch 2 is that persons who have had their visas cancelled under s 501(3) cannot satisfy the visa criteria and, therefore, cannot be granted visas in those classes and lawfully travel to, enter and (or) remain in Australia. It would plainly defeat a purpose of s 501(3) of the Act if persons who have had their visas cancelled on the grounds of national interest could, upon removal from Australia, immediately be granted a visa and return to Australia because all other criteria for the grant of that visa are satisfied.It follows that the applicant’s indefinite exclusion from travel to, entry and (or) remaining in Australia was a legal consequence of a decision to cancel his visa under s 501(3) of the Act. Accordingly, that was a consideration the Minister was bound to take into account.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Stephen, volunteer with Prison Fellowship Australia, provided an affidavit of character for Mr Shah dated 15 September 2025 in which he attested to Mr Shah’s remorse for his past actions and rehabilitation recommending: l respectfully submit that Mr. Shah be granted the opportunity to remain Australia with his wife and daughter. In my view, separating him from his family would not only cause them great hardship but also undermine his genuine rehabilitation.PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSPrimary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct (paragraph 8.1) The Direction requires the Tribunal to keep in mind that the safety of the Australian community is the highest priority of the Australian Government and to that end, the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens (8.1(1)). The Tribunal must have particular regard to the principle that remaining in Australia is a privilege, given the expectation that non-citizens are law-abiding, respect important institutions and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. This primary consideration also requires the Tribunal to consider two specific elements: the nature and seriousness of a non-citizen’s conduct to date; and the risk to the Australian community, should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct (8.1(2)(a)-(b)).The nature and seriousness of the conduct (paragraph 8.1.1) Mr Shah did not contest he had committed serious crimes and accepted that he failed the character test. Mr Shah in his request for reconsideration of his mandatory visa cancellation dated 29 December 2024 accepted the seriousness of his crimes and advised the following: I fully acknowledge the seriousness of the offenses I committed and the resulting legal actions taken against me. I wish to take this opportunity to provide further clarification regarding the circumstances leading to those offenses and express my sincere request for reconsideration of my case.Submissions Mr Shah submitted in his letter of 29 December 2024: In February 2018, I was arrested for drug use, possession of drugs, and selling drugs, which led to my first sentence of 9 months in prison. Upon completing my sentence, I was given a correction order for 15 months. Unfortunately, I struggled to adhere to the correction order, and on 8 January 2020, I was sentenced to an additional 6 months correction order for breaching its conditions. In February 2020, my home was raided, and I was taken into custody again for drug use and possession, culminating in a further sentence of 9 months in prison and an 18-month correction order on 16 July 2020.I fully recognize the severity of my actions, and I take full responsibility for the choices I made during that time. However, I believe it is important to highlight the mental and emotional challenges that I was experiencing, which significantly influenced my behavior. At the time, I was under immense stress and mental strain. To alleviate my stress, I brought my mother from India to stay with me, hoping her presence would provide me with support. Unfortunately, the relationship between myself and my wife suffered greatly due to the tension and my drug use, which only worsened my already fragile mental state. The arguments and disagreements between us caused further distress, and my mother left without informing me. Shortly after, my wife took our daughter and went to India. This left me completely shattered and pushed me deeper into drug dependence.My worsening dependence on drugs resulted in the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) preventing me from seeing my daughter. This was one of the most painful experiences of my life and added immense pressure, which led to my breaching the correction orders. Without the presence of my wife and daughter, I lacked the strength and motivation to change my ways at that time.