Seven Network Limited v News Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Seven Network Limited v News Limited [2003] FCA 388

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – motion to strike out pleadings – causes of action pleaded under s 45(2) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 – statement of claim fails to plead a sufficient link between the provisions of an alleged contract, agreement or understanding and the alleged lessening of competition.

Federal Court Rules, O11 r 16
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), Part IV, s 45(2)

BT Australia Pty Ltd v New South Wales [1999] ATPR (Digest) 46-187 cited.
Banque Commerciale SA (in Liq) v Akhil Holdings Limited (1990) 169 CLR 279 cited.
Multigroup Distribution Services Pty Ltd v TNT Australia Pty Ltd (1996) ATPR 41-522 cited.
The Bega Co-operative Society Limited v The Milk Authority of the Australian Capital Territory (FCA, 12 May 1992, unreported) cited.
Trade Practices Commission v David Jones (Australia) Pty Ltd (1985) 7 FCR 109 cited.
Sammy Russo Supplies Pty Ltd v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd [1998] ATPR 41-641 cited.
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Paper Pty Ltd (2000) 186 ALR 731 cited.
ASX Operations Pty Ltd v Pont Data Australia Pty Ltd (No 1) (1990) 27 FCR 460 cited.
Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2002) 118 FCR 236 cited.
Tillmanns Butcheries Pty Ltd v Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (1979) 27 ALR 367 cited.
News Ltd v Australian Rugby Football League Ltd (1996) 64 FCR 410 cited.
Dowling v Dalgety Australia Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 109 cited.
Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 195 ALR 609 cited.
Queensland Wire Industries Pty Ltd v Broken Hill Proprietary Co Ltd (1989) 167 CLR 177 cited.

SEVEN NETWORK LIMITED & ANOR v NEWS LIMITED & ORS
N 1223 of 2002

SACKVILLE J
SYDNEY
6 MAY 2003


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1223 of 2002

BETWEEN:

SEVEN NETWORK LTD
FIRST APPLICANT

C7 PTY LIMITED
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

NEWS LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

SKY CABLE PTY LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

TELSTRA MEDIA PTY LIMITED
THIRD RESPONDENT

FOXTEL MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED
FOURTH RESPONDENT

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
FIFTH RESPONDENT

TELSTRA MULTIMEDIA PTY LIMITED
SIXTH RESPONDENT

PUBLISHING AND BROADCASTING LIMITED
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

NINE NETWORK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

SPORTS INVESTMENTS AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
NINTH RESPONDENT

NETWORK TEN PTY LIMITED
TENTH RESPONDENT

AUSTRALIAN FOOTBALL LEAGUE
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

AUSTRALIAN RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED
TWELFTH RESPONDENT

NATIONAL RUGBY LEAGUE INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED
THIRTEENTH RESPONDENT

NATIONAL RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED
FOURTEENTH RESPONDENT

FOXTEL CABLE TELEVISION PTY LIMITED
FIFTEENTH RESPONDENT

OPTUS VISION PTY LIMITED
SIXTEENTH RESPONDENT

AUSTAR UNITED COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED
SEVENTEENTH RESPONDENT

AUSTAR ENTERTAINMENT PTY LIMITED
EIGHTEENTH RESPONDENT

IAN HUNTLY PHILIP
NINETEENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SACKVILLE J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 MAY 2003

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The following portions of the Statement of Claim be struck out:

(a)         pars 225, 227 and 228;

(ii)the words “159 to 175, 194 to 196 and” in par 201, the words “159 to 185, 194 to 196, and” in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seven Network Limited v News Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Seven Network Limited v News Limited, the primary legal issue involved the admissibility and sufficiency of certain paragraphs in the Statement of Claim filed by the plaintiffs. The case was heard and decided in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The core legal issues centered on whether specific paragraphs in the Statement of Claim were properly pleaded, particularly in relation to allegations concerning a 1997 Agreement and a "rationalisation provision" which purportedly required the parties to rationalise the pay television industry for the benefit of Foxtel. The defendants, Telstra, argued that certain paragraphs were either redundant, vague, or did not sufficiently allege facts to support the claims made.

The court found that several paragraphs in the Statement of Claim were insufficiently pleaded and should be struck out. This included paragraphs that did not adequately explain the nature of the "rationalisation provision" or how it led to the alleged contravention of the Trade Practices Act. Additionally, the court determined that certain references and allegations were inconsistent with other parts of the pleadings, thereby warranting their removal. The court also found that the references to the alleged prevention of C7 from acquiring the NRL pay rights were consistent with the rest of the pleading and thus should remain.

In its ruling, the court ordered the striking out of specific paragraphs in the Statement of Claim, as detailed in the judgment. It directed the parties to reach an agreement on which other paragraphs should be struck out within fourteen days. If they failed to agree, Telstra was to propose which paragraphs should be removed, followed by the plaintiffs' proposal within seven days. The plaintiffs were granted leave to file a further amended statement of claim, while the issue of costs was reserved for a later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The following portions of the Statement of Claim be struck out:

(a) pars 225, 227 and 228;

(ii) the words “159 to 175, 194 to 196 and” in par 201, the words “159 to 185, 194 to 196, and” in par 203 and the words “159 to 193”, in par 206;

(iii) pars 239 to 254;

(iv) pars 207 to 223; and

(v) pars 383, 386 and 390.

2. The parties bring in agreed short minutes of order within fourteen days identifying which, if any, of pars 259 to 320 and 468 to 473 of the Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim should be struck out consistently with the reasons for judgment.

3. In default of agreement

(a) the Telstra respondents bring in short minutes of order within twenty-one days identifying which of pars 259 to 320 and 468 to 473 of the Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim should be struck out consistently with the reasons for judgment, accompanied by brief submissions in support of the proposed short minutes of order.

(b) the applicants, within a further seven days, bring in short minutes of order identifying which, if any, of pars 259 to 320 and 468 to 473 of the Consolidated Amended Statement of Claim should be struck out consistently with the reasons for judgment, accompanied by brief submissions in support of the proposed short minutes of order.

4. The applicants have leave to file a Further Amended Statement of Claim.

5. The question of costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SACKVILLE J
Telstra also submitted that pars 468 to 473 of the Statement of Claim should be struck out. The written submissions assert, without elaboration, that these paragraphs give rise to the same issues. The issue was not addressed in oral submissions. I shall take the same approach to these paragraphs as I have to pars 259-320.CONCLUSION Telstra’s challenge to the Statement of Claim has succeeded to some extent. The following paragraphs in the Statement of Claim should be struck out:(i) pars 225, 227 and 228;(ii)the words “159 to 175, 194 to 196 and” in par 201, the words “159 to 185, 194 to 196, and” in par 203 and the words “159 to 193”, in par 206;(iii) pars 239 to 254;(iv) pars 207 to 223; and(v) pars 383, 386 and 390. I shall direct the parties within fourteen days to bring in agreed short minutes of order identifying which, if any, of pars 259 to 320 and 468 to 473 should be struck out. Failing agreement within that time, Telstra should bring in short minutes of order identifying which, if any, of those paragraphs should be struck out, together with a brief outline of submissions supporting the short minutes of order. The applicants should, within a further seven days, file their own proposed short minutes of order supported by a brief outline of submissions. The applicants will have leave to file a further amended statement of claim addressing the issues dealt with in this judgment. My tentative view, subject to any contrary argument, is that the applicants should pay Telstra’s costs of the motion. However, I shall reserve the question of costs until the final form of orders is determined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SACKVILLE J

Mr Archibald suggested that the references in pars 198 and 199 to C7 having been prevented from acquiring the NRL pay rights should be struck out as inconsistent with the rest of the pleading. I do not see any substance in this complaint. The allegations in pars 198 and 199 do not contradict any other part of the pleading.THE RATIONALISATION PROVISION Telstra challenged pars 239 to 254 of the Statement of Claim, which concern an agreement allegedly entered into by Telstra Corporation, News and PBL (“the 1997 Agreement”). Those paragraphs plead that the parties to the 1997 Agreement contravened s 45(2)(a)(ii) and s 45(2)(b)(ii) by making an agreement containing the “rationalisation provision” and by giving effect to that provision. The “rationalisation provision” required the parties to the 1997 Agreement to “[rationalise] the pay television industry for the benefit of Foxtel”. No further content is given in the pleading to the word “rationalise”. The pleading continues as follows: During the period August 1999 to May 2002, C7 was threatening to compete with Foxtel in the retail pay television market and was seeking to obtain the AFL pay rights for a further five years (par 240). At the time of entry into the Master Agreement, the removal of C7 from the pay television industry and the acquisition of the AFL rights by Foxtel would benefit Foxtel (par 241). At that time, the likely effect of the Master Agreement was the removal of C7 from the pay television industry and the acquisition of the AFL rights by Foxtel, “thus rationalising the pay television industry for the benefit of Foxtel” (par 242). In entering the Master Agreement containing the Master Agreement provision and performing the Master Agreement provision, the parties to the 1997 Agreement have given effect to the rationalisation provision (par 243). Accordingly, the effects of the rationalisation provision include the effects of the Master Agreement provision as pleaded in pars 159 to 196 (par 244). By reason of the matters in pars 239 to 244: “in giving effect to the rationalisation provision by the entry into the Master Agreement incorporating the Master Agreement provision and the performance of the Master Agreement, each of News, PBL and Telstra [Corporation] has engaged in conduct in contravention of section 45(2) of the TPA (par 247).” One difficulty with this pleading is that, for the reasons I have already given, the Statement of Claim does not adequately plead that the Master Agreement provision had or was likely to have the effects referred to in pars 139 to 196. More fundamentally, the Statement of Claim does not allege that the rationalisation provision required or even contemplated that the parties to the 1997 Agreement would enter into the Master Agreement or the Master Agreement provision. The pleading does not attempt to specify the obligations of the parties to the rationalisation provision or how those obligations might have required or encouraged them to agree to the Master Agreement provision. At its highest, the allegation appears to be that the Master Agreement was consistent with the object of rationalisation of the pay television industry. It is simply unclear on the pleading in its current form how the rationalisation provision had or was likely to have had the effect of causing the parties to enter into the Master Agreement provision. The paragraphs to which I have referred should be struck out.