Sentinel Property Group Pty Ltd v ABH Hotel Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sentinel Property Group Pty Ltd v ABH Hotel Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QSC 165

PARTIES:

SENTINEL PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD ACN 149 805 489

(Plaintiff)

v
ABH HOTEL PTY LTD ACN 622 296 011 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ABH HOTEL TRUST
(Defendant)
and
SENTINEL MULTI-SECTOR INCOME PTY LTD ACN 645 514 521 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SENTINEL MULTI-SECTOR INCOME TRUST

(Defendant added by Counterclaim)

FILE NO/S:

BS 12953 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

26 August 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 – 8 and 14 October 2021. Written submissions filed 21 and 28 October 2021

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.    The defendant terminated the call option to purchase Lot 18 on RP900236 (the Land) in the Heads of Agreement made between the defendant and the plaintiff dated 7 October 2020 by notice in writing on 13 November 2020;

2.   The plaintiff has no interest in the Land; and

3.  The defendant added by counterclaim has no interest in the Land.

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

4.  The plaintiff has leave to file the fourth amended statement of claim;

5.     There be judgment for the defendant on the plaintiff’s claim and judgment for the defendant (against the plaintiff and the defendant added by counterclaim) on the defendant’s counterclaim; and

6. Pursuant to s 127(2) of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) caveat no. 720390477 lodged by the plaintiff over the title to the Land be removed forthwith.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS - where the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a Heads of Agreement (HOA) on 7 October 2020 – where under the HOA the defendant granted to the plaintiff a call option in respect of the land – where the defendant terminated the call option in the HOA on 13 November 2020 – where the plaintiff subsequently attempted to exercise the call option on 11 December 2020 – whether the parties are bound by the HOA – whether the defendant on 13 November 2020 terminated the HOA – whether the defendant is in breach of the HOA – whether the plaintiff’s subsequent attempt to exercise the call option has any legal effect 

Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), s 127(2)

Al Achrafi v Topic [2016] NSWSC 1807, considered.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v XIVth, cited.

Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540, cited.

Banque Brussels Lambert SA v Australian National Industries Ltd (1989) 21 NSWLR 502, cited.

Egan v Geraghty [1994] QCA 8, cited.

Hardy v Wardy (2001) NSWSC 1141, considered.

Hospital Products Ltd v United Stated Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41, cited.

Nightowl Properties Pty Ltd v BDR No 3 Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 143, cited.

Scammell and Nephew Ltd v Ouston (1941) AC 251, followed.

COUNSEL:

B O’Donnell QC with C Johnstone for the plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sentinel Property Group Pty Ltd v ABH Hotel Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sentinel Property Group Pty Ltd (SPG) brought an action against ABH Hotel Pty Ltd (ABH) regarding an option to purchase the site of the Airlie Beach Hotel. The dispute arose from a Heads of Agreement (HOA) dated 7 October 2020, where ABH granted SPG a call option over the land. ABH terminated this option on 13 November 2020, and SPG attempted to exercise the option on 11 December 2020. The primary issues before the court were whether the parties were bound by the HOA, whether ABH effectively terminated the HOA, whether ABH breached the HOA, and whether SPG's attempt to exercise the option had any legal effect.

The court found that the conduct of both parties after 7 October 2020 was consistent with their belief that they were bound by the HOA but not by the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) or the Proforma Lease. The court ruled that ABH had indeed terminated the call option under the HOA by its letter dated 13 November 2020. Consequently, SPG had no interest in the land, and neither SPG nor the defendant added by counterclaim had any interest in the land. The court granted SPG leave to file a fourth amended statement of claim, entered judgment in favour of ABH on both the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's counterclaim, and ordered the removal of the caveat lodged by SPG over the title to the land.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1. The defendant terminated the call option to purchase Lot 18 on RP900236 (the Land) in the Heads of Agreement made between the defendant and the plaintiff dated 7 October 2020 by notice in writing on 13 November 2020;

2. The plaintiff has no interest in the Land; and

3. The defendant added by counterclaim has no interest in the Land.

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

4. The plaintiff has leave to file the fourth amended statement of claim;

5. There be judgment for the defendant on the plaintiff’s claim and judgment for the defendant (against the plaintiff and the defendant added by counterclaim) on the defendant’s counterclaim; and

6. Pursuant to s 127(2) of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) caveat no. 720390477 lodged by the plaintiff over the title to the Land be removed forthwith.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a dispute about an option to purchase the site of the Airlie Beach Hotel, The Esplanade, Airlie Beach. Background to the dispute between the parties For some years, Oncore (1982) Pty Ltd (Oncore) had been the owner of the land and operator of the business of the Airlie Beach Hotel. In September 2018, Oncore sold the hotel business to ABH Operations Qld Pty Ltd (ABHO). Oncore granted a lease of most of the land, and the building erected on it, to ABHO. This lease (the operating lease) was for a term of 40 months from 24 September 2018. Under the operating lease, ABHO carried on the hotel business, including providing hotel and motel accommodation, food and beverage services, retail takeaway liquor and tobacco operations, function and conference room facilities, and gaming operations including gaming machines, TAB and Keno facilities. ABHO held commercial hotel licences and gaming machine licences issued by the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming under the Queensland Liquor Act 1992 and the Gaming Machine Act 1991. The defendant (ABH) is a company related to ABHO. In about August 2019, ABH purchased the freehold in the land from Oncore. ABH held that estate as trustee of the ABH Hotel Trust. It continued to hold the land in that capacity at the time of the trial. On 9 August 2019, ABH granted two mortgages of the freehold. One to Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA). The other to Oncore. Both mortgages were registered over the title on 21 August 2019, with the CBA mortgage being first in time. The CBA mortgage was part of the security for several loan facilities provided by CBA pursuant to facility agreements. The original CBA facility agreement was dated 12 August 2019. The agreement relevant for this dispute is dealt with at [9] below. The Oncore mortgage was part of the security for a loan pursuant to a loan agreement dated 12 August 2019 between ABH and Oncore. The summary of its terms provided by ABH seems sufficient. The principal sum was $4.5 million. This was vendor finance for the purchase of the freehold. It was for a term of two years with interest at 5.5% pa in the first year and 8.5% pa in the second year. Interest was to be capitalised and no repayment was required until the end of the two year term. Bonita McFie, ABHO, Raging Bull Holdings Pty Ltd (RBH) and RGH Hotel Pty Ltd (RGH) were guarantors of ABH’s debt to Oncore. Ms McFie was a director of ABH. RBH and RGH were entities associated with the Reef Gateway Hotel at Cannonvale, about five kilometres from the Airlie Beach Hotel. RGH was the owner of the land occupied by the Reef Gateway Hotel and its warehouse and RGH had leased that land to RGH Operations Pty Ltd. The Airlie Beach Hotel freehold was the only real property over which Oncore held a mortgage to secure the debt it was owed. It held no security over the Reef Gateway Hotel. On 14 May 2020, ABH and RGH agreed with CBA to amend the 12 August 2019 facility agreement. It is convenient to refer to this second amended agreement as the CBA Facility Agreement. The lender was CBA. The borrowers were ABH, ABHO and RGH. The corporate guarantors were ABH, ABHO, RGH, RBH, RGH CTC Pty Ltd, Invado Investments Pty Ltd, Invado Hospitality Pty Ltd and O.L.F. No 2 Pty Ltd.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The text of the letter explained: “Sentinel asks ABH to execute the form of contract and return same to us.We note that the terms of the contract have been subject of negotiations between Sentinel and ABH.Sentinel believes that the form of contract tendered herewith conforms with the requirements of the HOA and also meets the preferences most recently expressed by ABH that also conform with (or at least do not conflict with) the requirements of the HOA. However, we are instructed to make it clear that Sentinel is not wedded to this form of contract and that if ABH believes that some amendments are required, it will be happy to discuss any reasonable suggestions that ABH may wish to make in that regard. We do note that time is of the essence in that respect.Similarly, the Lease has been prepared in accordance with the clause “subject to lease back” contained in the HOA. The Lease is, as you will understand, based on the form in the data room on which ABH invited offers and also meets the preferences most recently expressed by ABH that also conform with (or at least do not conflict with) the requirements of the HOA. We have inserted ABH Operations Queensland Pty Ltd as lessee, in conformity with Sentinel’s understanding of ABH’s intentions in that respect – derived, we note, also from the parties’ negotiations under the HOA.Again, Sentinel is not wedded to the terms of the Lease herewith and will likewise entertain any reasonable suggestions that ABH may wish to make in this respect. It is intended that the commencement date of the Lease will be the day prior to settlement of the contract.We calculate that the date for settlement of the contract will be Monday, 25 January 2021.”Conclusion on conduct after 7 October 2020 The conduct of SPG and ABH after 7 October 2020 until 13 November 2020 is consistent with each of them considering they were both bound by the HOA. It is also consistent with them not considering they were both bound by the IM or the Proforma lease. The relief sought by the parties In the form of its claim at the end of the trial, SPG seeks two declarations, an order for specific performance, damages for breach of contract, interest, and costs. The declarations are: (a)that the 13 November 2020 letter, sent by ABH’s solicitor to SPG’s solicitor, see [116] above, was ineffective to terminate “the agreement for the sale and purchase” of the freehold in the land; and(b)that SPG has an equitable interest as purchaser of the estate in fee simple in the land. The specific performance orders include orders: (a)that ABH execute a contract of sale for sale of the land;(b)that ABH procure ABHO to execute the lease of the land; and(c)that ABH complete the transaction on a date determined by the court. SPG’s damages claim was for alleged breaches of an implied term. In the final form of its counterclaim, ABH seeks declarations: (a)that the HOA has been terminated or discharged; and (b)that each of SPG and SMSI has no interest in the land.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature and terms of the Heads of Agreement (HOA) between the plaintiff and the defendant, determining that the HOA was not a binding contract but rather a preliminary agreement. The court noted that the HOA did not include a clause that would have made it binding upon signature, and the conduct of the parties after the HOA was executed did not indicate an intention to be bound immediately. The court found that the defendant effectively terminated the call option by a written notice on 13 November 2020, and this action was valid given the non-binding nature of the HOA. The court further ruled that the plaintiff had no interest in the land as a result of the effective termination of the call option and the absence of a binding contract. Finally, the court dismissed the plaintiff's subsequent attempt to exercise the call option, holding that it had no legal effect due to the prior termination by the defendant. The binding legal principle established by this case is that a Heads of Agreement without a binding clause does not automatically create a binding contract, and its terms can be effectively varied or terminated by notice where no binding contract exists.