SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Sentinel Citilink Pty Ltd v PS Citilink Pty Ltd [2018] QSC 239
PARTIES:
SENTINEL CITILINK PTY LTD ACN 602 638 013 AS TRUSTEE OF THE SENTINEL CITILINK TRUST
(plaintiff)
v
PS CITILINK PTY LTD ACN 623 164 312 AS TRUSTEE OF THE CITILINK PROPERTY TRUST (ABN 94 215 640 602)
(defendant)
FILE NO/S:
SC No 1823 of 2018
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Trial
DELIVERED ON:
19 October 2018
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
30-31 August 2018
JUDGE:
Bond J
ORDER:
The orders of the Court are:
1. It is declared that the contract dated 20 December 2017 between the plaintiff, as seller, and the defendant, as buyer, for the sale and purchase of real property located at 153 Campbell Street, Bowen Hills, Queensland and described as Lot 1 on SP193899, title reference 50628055 (“the contract”) was not lawfully terminated by the plaintiff on 22 January 2018.
2. The parties will be heard further as to the form of any order for specific performance of the contract.
3. The parties will be heard further as to the amount of the compensation order which should be made.
4. The plaintiff must pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding to be assessed.
CATCHWORDS:
REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – TRANSFERS – OTHER MATTERS – where the seller and the buyer entered into a contract for the sale of certain commercial property – where the contract was a standard REIQ contract for the sale of commercial property with additional special conditions – where the contract recorded a purchase price of $81,200,000 – where the buyer paid a deposit pursuant to the contract – where the buyer was obliged to pay “the balance of the Purchase Price” on the settlement date – where a special condition provided that the seller must pay to the buyer, by way of an adjustment to “the balance Purchase Price payable on settlement”, an amount equivalent to the value of extant incentive arrangements affecting leases on the property – where the value of outstanding incentives was $2,037,364.45 as at the date of contract and $2,003,050.67 as at the date of settlement – where the adjustment resulted in an amount of $79,196,949.34 required to be transferred at settlement – where the seller and the buyer disagreed on the amount of consideration to be shown on the relevant transfer forms (form 1 and form 24) – where the parties have an obligation to complete the forms in accordance with the applicable instructions and otherwise consistently with the law – where the parties each produced different versions of form 1 and form 24 displaying different amounts for consideration – where the contract failed to settle – whether the seller was correct in insisting upon completion of a form 1 and a form 24 which recorded consideration of $81,200,000, not the adjusted figure of $79,196,949.34 – whether the seller breached its obligation under the contract to do all acts and execute all documents necessary for the purpose of completing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sentinel Citilink Pty Ltd v PS Citilink Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] QSC 239
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether the seller was correct in insisting on recording the unadjusted purchase price on the transfer forms and whether the seller breached its contractual obligations by not completing the forms in accordance with the law. The court had to determine whether the contract's special condition regarding the adjustment of the purchase price should be reflected in the transfer forms.
The court found that the seller was incorrect in insisting on recording the unadjusted purchase price on the transfer forms. The court determined that the parties' obligations under the contract required them to complete the transfer forms consistently with the law and in accordance with the instructions. The seller was found to have breached its contractual obligations by not completing the forms as required. The court declared that the seller's termination of the contract was not lawful and ordered the parties to be heard further regarding specific performance and compensation orders. The court also ordered the seller to pay the buyer's costs of the proceeding.
The court's orders were that the contract was not lawfully terminated, and the parties would be heard further regarding specific performance and compensation orders. The court further ordered the seller to pay the buyer's costs of the proceeding.
Orders
Orders of the court
The orders of the Court are:
1. It is declared that the contract dated 20 December 2017 between the plaintiff, as seller, and the defendant, as buyer, for the sale and purchase of real property located at 153 Campbell Street, Bowen Hills, Queensland and described as Lot 1 on SP193899, title reference 50628055 (“the contract”) was not lawfully terminated by the plaintiff on 22 January 2018.
2. The parties will be heard further as to the form of any order for specific performance of the contract.
3. The parties will be heard further as to the amount of the compensation order which should be made.
4. The plaintiff must pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding to be assessed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following a dispute between Sentinel Citilink Pty Ltd and PS Citilink Pty Ltd regarding the settlement of the contract for the sale of the commercial property. The primary issue was whether the seller was correct in insisting on completion of a form 1 and a form 24 which recorded consideration of $81,200,000, as opposed to the adjusted figure of $79,196,949.34. The seller had terminated the contract, and the buyer sought a declaration that the contract was still valid and enforceable and an order for specific performance. The court considered the arguments of both parties and ultimately made several declarations and orders, including that the contract was not lawfully terminated by the seller and that the seller must pay the buyer’s costs of the proceeding.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the seller correct in insisting upon completion of a form 1 and a form 24 which recorded consideration of $81,200,000, not the adjusted figure of $79,196,949.34?
2. Did the seller breach its obligation under the contract to do all acts and execute all documents necessary for the purpose of completing the sale?
Held
1. The seller was not correct in insisting upon completion of a form 1 and a form 24 which recorded consideration of $81,200,000, not the adjusted figure of $79,196,949.34.
2. The seller breached its obligation under the contract to do all acts and execute all documents necessary for the purpose of completing the sale.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court held that the contract between the plaintiff, Sentinel Citilink Pty Ltd, and the defendant, PS Citilink Pty Ltd, was not lawfully terminated by the seller. The contract, dated 20 December 2017, specified a purchase price of $81,200,000 for certain commercial property. A special condition of the contract provided for an adjustment to the purchase price based on the value of extant incentive arrangements affecting leases on the property. The buyer paid a deposit and was obliged to pay the balance of the purchase price on the settlement date. The value of outstanding incentives was $2,037,364.45 at the date of contract and $2,003,050.67 at the date of settlement, resulting in an adjusted amount of $79,196,949.34 to be transferred at settlement.
The Court found that the seller was incorrect in insisting on the completion of form 1 and form 24 recording a consideration of $81,200,000. The contract and the special condition clearly required the seller to adjust the purchase price to reflect the value of the incentives, which the seller failed to do. The seller's insistence on the unadjusted figure was inconsistent with the terms of the contract and applicable law. The Court emphasised the importance of completing the transfer forms in accordance with the contract terms and legal requirements.
Moreover, the Court concluded that the seller breached its obligation under the contract to do all acts and execute all documents necessary for the purpose of completing the sale. By refusing to adjust the consideration on the transfer forms and insisting on the original purchase price, the seller did not fulfil its contractual obligations to facilitate the completion of the sale. The seller's actions constituted a material breach of contract, leading to the failure of the contract to settle.
The Court further noted that the contract was not lawfully terminated by the seller on 22 January 2018. The seller's unilateral termination was not justified under the circumstances. The Court ordered that the matter would be heard further regarding the form of any order for specific performance of the contract and the amount of the compensation order which should be made. Additionally, the seller was ordered to pay the buyer’s costs of the proceeding to be assessed.