FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| SEDGLEY & IRVINE | [2016] FCCA 2902 |
| Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – Parenting proceedings adjourned by consent as parties and children are undergoing family therapy – small property pool – parties in poor financial circumstances. |
| Legislation: Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), s.27G(b)(i)(B) Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.4(1), 75(2), 79(1), 79(2), 79(4), 90SB(a), 90SD, 90SM(1), 90SM(3), 90SM(4), 90SF(3) Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981 (Cth), s.10 |
| Cases cited: Amador & Amador (2009) 43 Fam LR 268 Bevan & Bevan [2013] FamCAFC 116 NHC & RCH [2004] FamCA 633 Hickey & Hickey & Attorney-General (Intervener) (2003) FLC 93-143 Kennon & Kennon (1997) FLC 92 – 757 S & S [2003] FamCA 905 Scott & Scott [2015] FCCA 2394 Masoud & Masoud [2016] FamCAFC 24 Stanford & Stanford [2012] HCA 52 Watson & Ling (2013) 49 Fam LR 303 Vass & Vass [2015] FamCAFC 51 Townsend & Townsend (1995) FLC 92-569 Kowaliw & Kowaliw (1981) FLC 91-092 C & C [1998] FamCA 143 M & M [1998] FamCA 42 Russell & Russell (1999) FLC 92-877 |
| Applicant: | MS SEDGLEY |
| Respondent: | MR IRVINE |
| File Number: | MLC 1547 of 2014 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Harland |
| Hearing dates: | 29 & 30 September 2015, 16 & 17 November 2015, 10 August 2016 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 27 September 2016 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 11 November 2016 |
REPRESENTATION
| HEARING: 29 & 30 September 2015, 16 & 17 November 2015 Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr Penno |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Bevan-Rhys James |
| Counsel for the Respondent: | Ms Harris |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | Lawcorp Lawyers |
| Counsel for the Independent Children's Lawyer: | Mr O'Connell |
| Solicitors for the Independent Children's Lawyer: HEARINGS: 10 August 2016 Counsel for the Applicant: Solicitors for the Applicant: Solicitor advocate for the Respondent: Solicitors for the Respondent: Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Solicitors for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: | Barbayannis Lawyers Mr Penno Bevan-Phys James Mr Bajic Lawcorp Lawyers Ms Glaister Barbayannis Lawyers |
ORDERS
Pursuant to the provisions of section 10 of the Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act1981, the Court CERTIFIES THAT, in the opinion of the Court, it would be appropriate for the Attorney General to authorise a payment under that Act to the wife and husband in respect of such part as the Attorney General considers appropriate of the costs incurred by the wife and husband in relation to their attendance on the third day of the final hearing on 1 October 2015.
The mother have sole parental responsibility for the children X born (omitted) 2004, Y born (omitted) 2008 and Z born (omitted) 2009 (“the children”).
That within 60 days of the date of these orders each party shall do all such things and execute all documents necessary to transfer the property situated at and known as Property B being the whole of the land contained in folio identifier lot (omitted) volume (omitted) (“the property”)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SEDGLEY & IRVINE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FCCA 2902
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate division of the parties' property, particularly a property designated as "Property B," and to make orders regarding parental responsibility for the three children. Additionally, the court considered the appropriateness of certifying costs for the parties under the *Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981*, given their poor financial circumstances.
Judge Harland made orders for the sole parental responsibility of the mother for the children. In relation to property, the court ordered the transfer of Property B to the wife's sole name, with the wife to discharge all associated liabilities and indemnify the husband. Provisions were made for the sale of Property B by private treaty if the wife was unable to comply with the transfer orders within 90 days, with proceeds to be applied in a specified priority, ultimately leaving any net balance to the wife. The wife also received sole ownership of a motor vehicle, with a similar indemnity to the husband. Further orders declared each party the sole and absolute owner of all other property in their possession or control not otherwise dealt with. The court also certified that it would be appropriate for the Attorney General to authorise a payment under the *Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981* to both parties in respect of costs incurred on the third day of the final hearing.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
Pursuant to the provisions of section 10 of the Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981, the Court CERTIFIES THAT, in the opinion of the Court, it would be appropriate for the Attorney General to authorise a payment under that Act to the wife and husband in respect of such part as the Attorney General considers appropriate of the costs incurred by the wife and husband in relation to their attendance on the third day of the final hearing on 1 October 2015.
2.
The mother have sole parental responsibility for the children X born (omitted) 2004, Y born (omitted) 2008 and Z born (omitted) 2009 (“the children”).
3.
That within 60 days of the date of these orders each party shall do all such things and execute all documents necessary to transfer the property situated at and known as Property B being the whole of the land contained in folio identifier lot (omitted) volume (omitted) (“the property”) to the sole name of the the wife at the cost of the wife; and
4.
Simultaneously with the transfer pursuant to order 3 above the wife shall pay all monies necessary to discharge and remove all mortgages, charges, encumbrances and all other liabilities, whether in law or equity for which the husband bears any actual or contingent liability at the date of these orders.
5.
Simultaneously with the transfer pursuant to order 3 above shall execute all documents and do all acts and things to give effect to the order.
6.
The wife shall indemnify and keep indemnified the husband in respect of all liabilities in relation to the property whenever and however arising.
7.
Pending transfer of the property provided for in order 3 the wife shall be responsible for all mortgage payments, statutory rates and charges, other utilities, insurances, outgoings and expenses in relation to the property incurred prior to the date of transfer and shall make all such payments as and when they fall due and hereby indemnifies the other party in respect of all other liabilities incurred prior to the date of transfer.
8.
In the event the wife is unable to comply with the orders within 90 days of the date of these orders each party shall do all things and execute all documents necessary to cause the property to be sold by private treaty at the earliest possible date and that the proceeds of sale be disbursed as follows and in that priority:
(a) In payment of agents commission, advertising expenses, conveyancing adjustments and legal expenses of the sale;
(b) In payment of costs incurred in relation to the nomination of a real estate agent (if any), in payment of costs incurred in relation to the nomination of a solicitor (if any) and in payment of costs in relation to determination of value or selling price by the President of the Victorian Division of the Australian Property Institute or his/her nominee (if any);
(c) Discharge of all mortgages secured on title;
(d) The net balance to the wife.
9.
That within 60 days from the date of these orders each party shall do all things necessary to:
(a) Transfer to the sole name of the wife of the motor vehicle (omitted) registration number (omitted) at the cost of the wife; and
(b) Simultaneously with the transfer, discharge of all liability of the in relation to this motor vehicle at the cost of the wife;
AND the wife hereby indemnifies and shall keep indemnified the husband in relation to all liabilities in respect of the motor vehicle whenever and however arising.
10.
That pursuant to Section 78 Family Law Act that each of the husband and the wife shall be and hereby are declared to be the sole and absolute owners at law and in equity of:
(a) all items of furniture, furnishings, personalty, chattels and jewellery;
(b) all monies (whether held in cash or in deposit with any financial institution);
(c) any motor vehicle;
(d) all contributions to or benefits or entitlements arising from membership of any fund of insurance or superannuation whether such interest be present, contingent or expectant;
in the possession, custody or control or each or in which either has an interest which are not otherwise dealt with in these orders.
11.
That in the event that either party should fail, neglect or refuse to sign or execute any deed, document or instrument required by or to give effect to these Orders then pursuant to Section 106A Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) that the Registrar of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, Melbourne Registry shall be and is hereby authorised, empowered and directed to sign and execute such deed, document or instrument in the place and instead of such party and to thereafter do all things and acts as are necessary to give validity and operation to same.
Background
Background to the litigation
The property proceedings in this case revolve around a small pool of assets, with both parties in poor financial circumstances. The primary asset in dispute is a property known as Property B. The wife claimed the husband had made contributions to the purchase of the property, which the husband denied. The wife also alleged that the husband had failed to make full disclosure of his financial circumstances and assets, a claim the husband contested. The case includes a Kennon claim, which pertains to the non-disclosure of assets and the impact of such non-disclosure on the distribution of the property pool.
The wife sought sole parental responsibility for the children, which was granted, along with orders for the transfer of Property B to her sole name and the discharge of associated liabilities. The wife was also ordered to indemnify the husband against any liabilities arising from the property. In the event of non-compliance with the orders within a specified timeframe, the property was to be sold, with the proceeds disbursed according to a priority list. Additionally, the wife was to transfer a motor vehicle to her sole name and indemnify the husband against any related liabilities. Each party was declared the sole owner of various items of personal property, monies, and contributions to insurance or superannuation funds not otherwise addressed in the orders. The case further includes provisions for the execution of necessary documents in the event either party fails to comply.
The matter before the Court is a final hearing in a parenting and property dispute under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). The proceedings originated in the Family Court of Australia and were transferred to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia for the final hearing. The case involves an application by the wife for a property settlement and sole parental responsibility for the three children. The husband has contested both the property settlement and the parenting arrangements. Prior to the final hearing, the parties had participated in family therapy, resulting in the adjournment of the parenting proceedings by consent. The final hearing spanned three days, during which various applications and submissions were made by both parties. The Court considered the evidence and submissions, including the financial circumstances of both parties and the contributions made by each towards the family property. The Court also took into account the family violence and the impact on the children. The orders made by the Court address both the property settlement and the parenting arrangements, including the transfer of property, the allocation of parental responsibility, and the financial obligations of each party.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What are the appropriate costs to be awarded to the parties for their attendance on the final hearing day?
2. Who should have sole parental responsibility for the children?
3. How should the property transfer be executed, and what are the respective responsibilities of the parties in relation to the property?
4. What should be done if the wife is unable to comply with the property transfer orders within 90 days?
5. How should the motor vehicle be transferred, and what are the respective responsibilities of the parties in relation to the vehicle?
6. What personal property and financial assets should be declared as the sole and absolute ownership of each party?
7. What authority does the Registrar have if either party fails to sign required documents for the execution of these orders?
Held
1. The Court certifies that it would be appropriate for the Attorney General to authorise a payment to the wife and husband for the costs incurred in attending the final hearing on 1 October 2015.
2. The mother shall have sole parental responsibility for the children.
3. The property transfer must be executed within 60 days, with the wife bearing the costs and the husband discharging any liabilities.
4. If the wife is unable to comply with the transfer orders within 90 days, the property must be sold and the proceeds disbursed according to a specified priority.
5. The motor vehicle must be transferred to the wife's sole name within 60 days, with the wife discharging any liabilities and indemnifying the husband.
6. Each party is declared the sole and absolute owner of certain specified personal property and financial assets.
7. The Registrar is authorised to sign and execute any required documents if either party fails to do so, to give effect to the Court's orders.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Sedgley & Irvine, the Family Court addressed several complex issues pertaining to costs, parental responsibility, property and asset division, and enforcement mechanisms. The court’s reasoning and ratio decidendi are grounded in principles of fairness, the best interests of the children, and equitable distribution of assets and liabilities.
The court considered the appropriate costs to be awarded to the parties for their attendance on the final hearing day. It certified that the Attorney General should authorise a payment to both parties under the Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981. This decision reflects a balanced approach to costs, recognising the financial burden of litigation on both parties, particularly in cases involving protracted proceedings and multiple hearings.
In determining who should have sole parental responsibility for the children, the court awarded it to the mother. This decision was influenced by the recommendation of family therapists and the ongoing family therapy that both parties and the children are undergoing. The court’s reasoning aligns with the paramount principle under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) that the best interests of the child are of primary consideration. The court’s focus on the children’s therapeutic needs underscores the importance of stability and continuity in the children’s lives during a period of family transition.
The court ordered that the property transfer be executed within 60 days to the sole name of the wife, with the wife responsible for discharging all existing mortgages and liabilities. This decision was based on the equitable distribution of the property, considering the husband's Kennon claim, which acknowledges non-financial contributions to the relationship. The court’s order ensures that the wife assumes both the benefits and burdens associated with the property, thereby achieving a fair outcome.
In the event that the wife is unable to comply with the property transfer orders within 90 days, the court mandated that the property be sold by private treaty. The proceeds of the sale were to be disbursed in a specified priority, ensuring that costs and liabilities are addressed before any distribution to the wife. This contingency plan reflects the court's commitment to ensuring that the financial obligations and interests of both parties are protected.
Regarding the transfer of the motor vehicle, the court ordered that it be transferred to the sole name of the wife within 60 days, with the wife also responsible for discharging any associated liabilities. This decision mirrors the property transfer order, emphasizing equitable distribution and the assumption of responsibilities along with the benefits of the asset.
The court declared each party to be the sole and absolute owner of specific personal property and financial assets, ensuring that assets not otherwise dealt with in the orders remain with the respective owner. This division was based on the possession, custody, or control of the assets by each party, reflecting the principle of equitable distribution.
Lastly, the court addressed the authority of the Registrar in the event either party fails to sign required documents for the execution of these orders. Pursuant to Section 106A of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), the Registrar is authorised to sign and execute any necessary documents in place of the non-compliant party. This provision ensures the enforceability of the court’s orders and maintains the integrity of the legal process.
The ratio decidendi of this case is the court’s approach to balancing equitable distribution of assets with the protection of financial interests and liabilities, ensuring that the best interests of the children remain paramount in all decisions. The court’s adherence to statutory provisions and its consideration of the parties' financial circumstances and non-financial contributions to the relationship provides a clear legal principle for future cases.