Secretary, NSW Treasury v C (GD)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

Appeal Panel - Internal

CITATION: Secretary, NSW Treasury v C (GD) [2004] NSWADTAP 6 revised - 20/02/2004
PARTIES: APPELLANT
Secretary, NSW Teasury
RESPONDENT
C
FILE NUMBER: 039066
HEARING DATES: 8/12/2003
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 12/15/2003
DATE OF DECISION:
02/20/2004
DECISION UNDER APPEAL:
C v Secretary, NSW Treasury (No 3) [2003] NSWADT 200
BEFORE: Chesterman M - ADCJ (Deputy President); Robinson MA - Judicial Member; Blake C - Member
CATCHWORDS: application of common law test - no evidence
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
FILE NUMBER UNDER APPEAL: 013081
DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: 08/25/2003
LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Freedom of Information Act 1989
Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998
CASES CITED: Re Applicant and Department of Education and Training, Children’s Youth and Family Services (1998) 53 ALD 509
Botany Council v The Ombudsman (1995) 37 NSWLR 357
Brown v Raphael [1958] Ch 636
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Bushell v Repatriation Commission (1992) 175 CLR 408
C v Secretary, NSW Treasury (No 3) [2003] NSWADT 200
Central Sydney Area Health Service v Crewdson [2001] NSWADTAP 44
Re Close and Australian National University (1993) 31 ALD 597
Cox and Dept of Defence (1990) 20 ALD 499
Crewdson v Central Sydney Area Health Service [2002] NSWCA 345
Director General Department of Community Services v S [2000] NSWADTAP 27
Re Gordon and Department of Social Security (1991) 25 ALD 33
Hewitt v Grabicki 794 F 2d 1373
Re Leverett and Australian Telecommunications Commission (1985) 8 ALN N135
Re Resch and Department of Veterans’ Affairs (1986) 9 ALD 380
RR v Department of the Army 482 F Supp 770 (1980)
Smith v Land & House Property Corporation (1884) 28 Ch D 7
Re Warren and Department of Defence, unreported, Administrative Appeals Tribunal, 22 December 1992
REPRESENTATION: APPELLANT
M Allars, barrister
RESPONDENT
In person
ORDERS: 1. Appeal allowed in part.; 2. The Tribunal’s order, setting aside the Appellant’s decision to refuse to amend the report of Dr Lucire relating to the Respondent, is upheld.; 3. In substitution for that decision of the Appellant, a decision is made to attach a notation to the report, and to every copy of the report held by the Appellant, a notation in the following terms:; ‘The attached document is incorrect within the meaning of s 39(c) of the Freedom of Information Act 1989. Specifically, Dr Lucire’s diagnosis that Mr C (insert full name) seemed on clinical examination to have a Paranoid Delusional Disorder and on the documents to have a Narcissistic Personality Disorder has been withdrawn by her. For further details, see the decision of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal in Secretary, NSW Treasury v C [2004] NSWADTAP 6.’; 4. If the Appellant discloses to any person (including any other agency or any Minister) any information contained in Dr Lucire’s report, the Appellant should ensure that the above notation is included when that disclosure is made.; 5. If either party wishes to make an application for costs, it should do so within 28…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Secretary, NSW Treasury v C (GD) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWADTAP 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Secretary, NSW Treasury v C (GD) involved a dispute between the Secretary of the New South Wales Treasury and Mr C, the respondent. The primary issue was the refusal by the Secretary to amend a report prepared by Dr Lucire, which contained certain diagnoses about Mr C. The case was heard by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal, which was tasked with reviewing the decision made by the Secretary. The Tribunal needed to determine whether the Secretary's refusal to amend the report was lawful and whether the Tribunal's order to set aside that decision was justified.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included the application of the common law test in relation to the Secretary's decision to refuse to amend the report, and whether there was sufficient evidence to support the Tribunal's order to set aside that decision. The Tribunal needed to consider whether the Secretary's decision was made in accordance with the relevant legislation and whether it was unreasonable or unlawful. The Tribunal also needed to consider whether the notation proposed by the Secretary was an appropriate way to address the concerns raised by Mr C.

The Tribunal found that the Secretary's decision to refuse to amend the report was unlawful and that the Tribunal's order to set aside that decision was justified. The Tribunal held that the Secretary's decision was not supported by evidence and was therefore unreasonable. The Tribunal also found that the proposed notation was an appropriate way to address the concerns raised by Mr C. The Tribunal therefore allowed the appeal in part and made a decision to attach a notation to the report, and to every copy of the report held by the Secretary. The Tribunal also directed that if the Secretary disclosed any information contained in the report, the notation should be included.

In conclusion, the Tribunal allowed the appeal in part and set aside the Secretary's decision to refuse to amend the report. The Tribunal made a decision to attach a notation to the report, and to every copy of the report held by the Secretary. The Tribunal also directed that if the Secretary disclosed any information contained in the report, the notation should be included. The Tribunal ordered that any application for costs should be made within 28 days of the date of the decision, and that any such application would be determined by the Tribunal on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part.; 2. The Tribunal’s order, setting aside the Appellant’s decision to refuse to amend the report of Dr Lucire relating to the Respondent, is upheld.; 3. In substitution for that decision of the Appellant, a decision is made to attach a notation to the report, and to every copy of the report held by the Appellant, a notation in the following terms:; ‘The attached document is incorrect within the meaning of s 39(c) of the Freedom of Information Act 1989. Specifically, Dr Lucire’s diagnosis that Mr C (insert full name) seemed on clinical examination to have a Paranoid Delusional Disorder and on the documents to have a Narcissistic Personality Disorder has been withdrawn by her. For further details, see the decision of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal in Secretary, NSW Treasury v C [2004] NSWADTAP 6.’; 4. If the Appellant discloses to any person (including any other agency or any Minister) any information contained in Dr Lucire’s report, the Appellant should ensure that the above notation is included when that disclosure is made.; 5. If either party wishes to make an application for costs, it should do so within 28 days of the date of this decision.; 6. If such an application is made, the other party is directed to file and serve any submissions in reply within 28 days of being served with the application. ; 7. Any application for costs will be determined by the Tribunal ‘on the papers’ pursuant to s 76 of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.