Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.5)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.5) [2022] NSWSC 119
Hearing dates: 15 December 2021
Date of orders: 16 February 2022
Decision date: 16 February 2022
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Garling J
Decision:

1 Advance ruling pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act1995 (NSW) that the evidence contained in:

(1) paragraphs 11-27 and 33-34 of the affidavit of Ms Justine Lee Windsor sworn 25 September 2017; and

(2) paragraphs 30-31, 36-41 and 45-46 of the affidavit of Mr Tyrone Edward Palmer dated February 2018,

is inadmissible.

2 Order that the Commonwealth pay the plaintiff’s and sample Group Members’ costs of and incidental to this Motion.

Catchwords:

EVIDENCE — advance rulings under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) — contested evidence would require additional evidence from 20 witnesses and extend the hearing by between four and six days — issues in the matter are clear — proceedings not at an early stage — advance ruling will save considerable legal expense — advance ruling given

EVIDENCE — relevance — relevance to assessment of damages for breach of contract — contract wholly in writing — no other express or implied term of contract pleaded — ambiguity or vagueness not pleaded — evidence of oral statements at odds with written contract — evidence not relevant

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), Pt 10, s 56

Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss 55, 56, 192A

Cases Cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission, in the matter of Whitebox Trading Pty Ltd v Whitebox Trading Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 324

Davaria Pty Limited v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (No 9) [2021] FCA 473

Searle v Commonwealth of Australia [2018] NSWSC 1017

Searle v Commonwealth of Australia [2019] NSWCA 127

Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2019] NSWSC 14

Texts Cited:

Not Applicable

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Clayton William Searle (P)
Commonwealth of Australia (D)
Representation:

Counsel:
N Kidd SC / D Meyerowitz-Katz (P)
K Andronos SC / S Keizer (D)

Solicitors:
Levitt Robinson (P)
McCullough Robertson (D)
File Number(s): 2016/45027
Publication restriction: Not Applicable

Judgment

  1. In 2016, the plaintiff, Clayton Searle, commenced proceedings against the defendant, the Commonwealth of Australia (“the Commonwealth”), pursuant to Pt 10 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW).

  2. He claimed damages for himself and on behalf of the members of an identified group (“the Group Members”) for breach of contract with respect to the provision of training as a part of their enlistment with the Royal Australian Navy.

  3. On 3 July 2018, for the reasons which he then delivered, Fagan J dismissed the plaintiff’s claim: see Searle v Commonwealth of Australia [2018] NSWSC 1017.

  4. The plaintiff appealed to the Court of Appeal.

  5. On 31 May 2019, the Court of Appeal (Bathurst CJ, Bell P and Basten JA) upheld the plaintiff’s appeal and set aside the orders of Fagan J dismissing the plaintiff’s claim.

  6. The Court of Appeal ordered that judgment for the plaintiff be entered in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Searle v Commonwealth of Australia (No.5), the parties involved were Searle, the plaintiff, and the Commonwealth of Australia, the defendant. The dispute centred on the admissibility of certain evidence in the context of an assessment of damages for breach of contract. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary issue before the court was whether an advance ruling under section 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) could be granted to determine the admissibility of contested evidence, which would require testimony from 20 witnesses and extend the hearing by four to six days. The court also had to consider whether such evidence was relevant to the assessment of damages in the breach of contract case.

The court found that the issues in the case were clear and the proceedings were not at an early stage, which influenced the decision to grant the advance ruling. The court held that the contested evidence was not relevant as it was at odds with the written contract, which was the sole agreement between the parties. There were no other express or implied terms of the contract pleaded, and no ambiguity or vagueness in the contract was alleged. The court reasoned that an advance ruling would save considerable legal expense and facilitate a more efficient resolution of the case.

The Supreme Court granted the advance ruling under section 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), determining that the contested evidence would not be admissible as it was not relevant to the assessment of damages in the breach of contract case. The court also noted that the contested evidence would have required additional evidence from 20 witnesses and would have extended the hearing by four to six days. The court's decision to grant the advance ruling was based on the clear issues in the case, the lack of ambiguity or vagueness in the contract, and the desire to avoid unnecessary legal expense and delay. The final orders of the court were that the contested evidence would not be admitted in the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a dispute over the admissibility of certain evidence in the context of a breach of contract claim. The plaintiff, Searle, sought damages for the alleged breach of a contract by the defendant, the Commonwealth of Australia. The contract in question was wholly documented in writing, with no other express or implied terms pleaded. The plaintiff sought to introduce evidence of oral statements made during the negotiation or execution of the contract, which were claimed to be relevant to the assessment of damages. The defendant opposed the introduction of this evidence, arguing that it was not relevant to the terms of the written contract and would require additional evidence from 20 witnesses, extending the hearing by between four and six days. The court was required to determine whether this contested evidence was relevant and, if not, whether an advance ruling under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) was appropriate given the circumstances.

The matter was before the court on an application for an advance ruling regarding the admissibility of certain evidence. The case had proceeded to a stage where the issues were clear, and the proceedings were not at an early stage. The plaintiff argued that the evidence in question was relevant to the assessment of damages, while the defendant maintained that it was irrelevant and would unduly extend the proceedings. The court considered the potential legal expense savings of an advance ruling and the clarity of the issues involved. It ultimately decided to grant the advance ruling, finding that the contested evidence would not be relevant to the assessment of damages for breach of contract.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the contested evidence relevant to the assessment of damages for breach of contract?
2. Should an advance ruling be given under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) in this matter?

Held
1. The contested evidence is not relevant to the assessment of damages for breach of contract. The court concluded that the contract in question was wholly in writing, and no other express or implied terms of the contract were pleaded. Furthermore, there was no allegation of ambiguity or vagueness. The evidence of oral statements was found to be at odds with the written contract, and thus, it was determined to be irrelevant.
2. An advance ruling should be given under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court found that the issues in the matter were clear, and the contested evidence would require additional evidence from 20 witnesses and extend the hearing by between four and six days. The proceedings were not at an early stage, and an advance ruling would save considerable legal expense.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the relevance of the contested evidence to the assessment of damages for breach of contract by examining the terms of the contract. As the contract was wholly in writing, and no other express or implied terms were pleaded, the court found that the evidence of oral statements was irrelevant as it contradicted the written contract. The court also considered the ambiguity or vagueness of the contract, which was not pleaded. Consequently, the contested evidence was deemed irrelevant.

Regarding the advance ruling under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), the court noted that the issues in the matter were clear, and the contested evidence would require additional evidence from 20 witnesses and extend the hearing by between four and six days. The court determined that the proceedings were not at an early stage, and an advance ruling would save considerable legal expense. Therefore, the court decided to give an advance ruling under s 192A, allowing the parties to avoid unnecessary costs and proceedings. The binding legal principle established in this decision is that an advance ruling under s 192A may be granted even if the proceedings are not at an early stage, provided that the issues are clear and the ruling will save considerable legal expense.