Scott v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Scott v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission [2018] QCAT 284

PARTIES:

RACHEL LEIGH SCOTT
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND RACING INTEGRITY COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR252-16

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

28 May 2018

HEARING DATE:

23 May 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Olding

DIRECTIONS:

1.   The respondent must deliver to Mr Ross Wenzel, Senior Scientist, Trace Elements Laboratory, Level 5, Acute Services Building, Royal North Shore Hospital, Pacific Highway, St Leonards NSW 2015 part or all of the reserve sample of urine sample 394099 collected from the horse “Nolonga Your Choice NZ” at Redcliffe on 2 April 2016 for the purpose of identifying:

(a)   the urine specific gravity of the sample;

(b)   the respective proportions of the element cobalt held in the sample in inorganic and organic form.

2.   The applicant must pay the respondent’s reasonable costs of delivering the sample to Mr Wenzel.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where applicant sought review of Queensland Racing Integrity Commission decision to confirm conviction and penalty for presenting a horse for racing not free of the permitted concentration of the prohibited substance cobalt – where conviction based on conclusive evidence certificates as to cobalt concentration in urine samples – where applicant sought directions that remnant urine sample be delivered for testing for urine specific gravity and proportions of organic and inorganic cobalt – whether Tribunal has power to make the directions – whether appropriate for the directions to be made

Australian Harness Racing Rules, rr 190(2), 190(4), 190(7), 191
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), ss 3(b), 19, 20, 21, 24, 28, 95(1)(a), 97(1)(b) and 98(1)(c)
Racing Integrity Act 2016 (Qld), s 246

Day v Harness Racing New South Wales [2014] NSWSC 1402
Hope v Racing Victoria (No 1) (Review and Regulation) [2018] VCAT 642

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

S Murdoch QC, instructed by O’Connor Ruddy & Garrett Solicitors

Respondent:

P Williams, instructed by Landers & Rogers Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicant, Ms Scott, is a licensed horse trainer. On the basis that standard tests of urine samples from the horse ‘Nolonga Your Choice NZ’ which she presented for racing revealed cobalt in excess of permitted concentration levels, Ms Scott was convicted by the Stewards of presenting a horse to race not free of prohibited substances, contrary to Rule 190(2) of the Australian Harness Racing Rules (the Rules)[1], and disqualified for a period of 15 months. The respondent Commission confirmed that decision, both as to conviction and penalty, on internal review.

    [1]All legislative references are to the Rules unless otherwise indicated.

  2. Ms Scott has applied to the Tribunal for review of the internal review decision, which has been stayed pending the outcome of the review.

  3. To support her application for review, and acting on scientific advice, Ms Scott wishes to have the remnant urine sample further tested.  Having made multiple requests to the Stewards and the Commission over an extended…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Scott v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission involved the applicant seeking a review of a decision by the Queensland Racing Integrity Commission to confirm a conviction and penalty for presenting a horse for racing that was not free of a permitted concentration of the prohibited substance cobalt. The conviction was based on certificates of evidence of cobalt concentration in urine samples. The applicant sought directions for a remnant urine sample to be delivered for further testing to determine the urine specific gravity and the proportions of organic and inorganic cobalt. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was required to determine whether it had the power to make such directions and if it was appropriate to do so.

The court considered whether the further testing could impact the determination of the appropriate penalty and whether the results could inform the Tribunal on the hearing of the review. The court found that the results of testing for the proportions of organic and inorganic cobalt might be relevant to determining the appropriate level of penalty, as they could assist in determining the extent to which supplementation caused cobalt concentration to reach the levels revealed by the tests. The results of testing for urine specific gravity might also be relevant to the penalty if they provided some context for the concentration levels. However, it was less clear that the urine specific gravity testing could be relevant to whether the applicant’s conviction should be confirmed or set aside. The court concluded that the potential relevance of the results of further testing to the appropriate level of penalty if the conviction was confirmed was sufficient reason to make the directions.

The court ordered that the directions be made for the further testing to be conducted. This decision was made despite the potential delay and costs associated with the further testing, as the court considered the potential relevance of the test results to the penalty to be a sufficient justification. The court also noted that the ultimate value of the test results would depend on the nature and expert explanation of the implications of the test results.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given that the extent of any impact is not known, I do not consider that the possibility of degradation of the sample is a reason to refuse to make the directions, but rather would be a matter going to the weight to be given to evidence of the further test results to be determined by the Tribunal on the hearing of the review, with the benefit of the test report and any other relevant evidence. Further, the Commission itself has produced a certificate of further testing of the sample by another laboratory in early 2018, without any apparent concerns about degradation.Conclusion For the reasons outlined, it seems to me to be relatively clear that the results of testing for the proportions of organic and inorganic cobalt may be relevant to determining the appropriate level of penalty, in that they may assist in determining the extent to which supplementation caused cobalt concentration to reach the levels revealed by the tests carried out for the Commission. The results of testing for USG may also be relevant to penalty if, with accompanying explanation, they also cast some light on the reasons for, or provide some context for, the concentration levels. To what extent, if any, such results may actually be relevant in these respects is a matter to be determined at the hearing of the review, but they do seem likely to be capable of relevantly informing the Tribunal. It is less clear that the USG testing could be relevant to whether Ms Scott’s conviction should be confirmed or set aside. If, as Mr Murdoch maintains, Professor Chapman’s evidence is that failure to take into account USG may lead to an inaccurate reading of the absolute amount of cobalt, then I would conclude that the results of the further testing may be relevant to whether the testing procedure is materially flawed. However, if, as appears on one reading, Professor Chapman merely asserts that the actual concentration should, as a matter of fairness, be notionally adjusted for USG, I cannot see how evidence of USG levels would be relevant to whether the testing is flawed. Testing that produces an accurate measure of cobalt concentration would not be flawed, even if it is accepted that the concentration so measured is affected by USG levels. Ultimately, what the relevant parts of his report mean may need to be clarified by Professor Chapman if it is to be relied upon. It is not necessary for me to finally determine this because, for the reasons that follow, I would in any case make the directions on the basis of the potential relevance of the results of further testing to the appropriate level of penalty if the conviction is confirmed. In that regard, I have carefully considered Mr Williams’ point that allowing for the further testing will delay and potentially extend the hearing and associated costs. It is a valid point in view of the statutory command for the Tribunal to conduct proceedings speedily[5], particularly having regard the uncertainty regarding the ultimate value of any further test results, which will depend on the nature and expert explanation of the implications of the test results.[5]QCAT Act, s 28(3)(d). See also s 3(b).