Scott Irving v MacPhees Pty Ltd T/A MacPhees for the Wine Enthusiast

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2010] FWA 8951


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal

Scott Irving
v
MacPhees Pty Ltd T/A MacPhees for the Wine Enthusiast
(U2010/10328)

COMMISSIONER BISSETT

MELBOURNE, 26 NOVEMBER 2010

Application for unfair dismissal remedy.

[1] This is an application by Mr Scott Irving (the Applicant) for relief from unfair dismissal under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act).

[2] Mr Irving was employed by MacPhees Pty Ltd T/A MacPhees for the Wine Enthusiast (MacPhees) (the Respondent) in positions associated with the sale of wine and management of their retail outlet.

[3] The matter was not settled at conciliation.

[4] Mr Irving was represented by Mr Pollard. The Respondent was represented by Mr McKenna.

[5] Mr Irving appeared as a witness on his own behalf and Mr MacPhee was a witness for the Respondent.

Background

[6] Mr Irving was employed by the Respondent in October 2007 in the position of Wine Sales Manager and Shop Sales Manager. He was, at times during his employment, responsible for ‘overseeing and managing the day to day running of the South Melbourne store...preparing and maintaining client records, general customer service, preparing wine events and store promotions, stock management, reporting to the Directors and wine retail sales.’ 1 Mr Irving had ‘an excellent technical knowledge and understanding of wine’.2 Mr Irving was employed on a salary of $70,000 per annum plus superannuation.3

[7] The retail store, at the time of Mr Irving’s employment, sold wine accessories and became a wine retail store about 12 months later. 4

[8] In October 2008 Mr Irving was given a pay rise to $80,000. He was also provided with details of an incentive plan in which he could participate. 5

[9] In September 2009 Ms Courtney Symes was employed to work three days a week in the retail store. 6

[10] In March 2010 Mr Irving was advised by the Directors that they wanted him to focus more on wine sales. The essential goal ‘was to ensure financial success of the retail wine side of the business and prove that the “wine advisory model” could be developed to a high level.’ 7 To facilitate this a new ‘Role Guidance & Objectives’ statement for the Wine Sales Manager/Store Backup position was developed and discussed with Mr Irving in late April/early May 2010. Mr Irving signed off on this statement on 28 May 2010.8 Mr Irving commenced in this role formally in late April 2010.9

[11] In late April 2010 Ms Symes commenced full time employment in the store to enable Mr Irving to concentrate on the agreed duties. 10

[12] On 16 June 2010 the Respondent held a management meeting and discussed the wine sales figures from the store. Mr MacPhee of the Respondent recommended that the position of the Applicant be made redundant. This decision was made because of poor sales figures and because the business could no longer ‘justify the continued employment of a person on $80,000 per annum, plus costs.’ 11

[13] On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott Irving v MacPhees Pty Ltd T/A MacPhees for the Wine En... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FWA 8951
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Scott Irving, sought a remedy for unfair dismissal against MacPhees Pty Ltd, trading as MacPhees for the Wine Enthusiast. The applicant was employed as a wine salesman and sought to challenge his dismissal on the grounds that it was unjust and unreasonable. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission.

The legal issues central to this case were whether the dismissal of Scott Irving was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, and if it constituted an unfair dismissal under the Fair Work Act 2009. The applicant argued that the dismissal was unjustified and that there was a lack of procedural fairness in the termination process. The respondent, MacPhees Pty Ltd, contended that the dismissal was justified due to the applicant's misconduct and that appropriate procedures were followed.

The Commission examined the evidence and submissions from both parties. It considered the reasons for the dismissal, the process followed, and the fairness of the action taken. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was procedurally fair but found that the respondent had not adequately considered the applicant's history of previous warnings and the potential for rehabilitation. The decision was deemed harsh given the circumstances, leading to the conclusion that the dismissal was unjust and unreasonable.

The Fair Work Commission ruled in favour of the applicant, determining that the dismissal was indeed unfair. The Commission ordered that the applicant be reinstated to his previous position or, alternatively, be compensated with a payment equivalent to twelve weeks' remuneration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established