ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
SCHERL & ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY & ORS (Administrative Review) [2011] ACAT 37
AT 9 of 2011
Catchwords: LAND AND PLANNING––review of reconsidered decision by ACTPLA– multi-unit development––RZ2-Suburban Core Zone––zone objectives––neighbourhood characteristics––form, scale and site development––private open space––solar access––overshadowing––overlooking––interfacing––privacy––screened from public view––parking and site access––amenity––3-point turns––waste disposal––garbage bins
List of Legislation: Planning and Development Act 2007
(ACT)
ss 53, 55, 119, 120, 121(2), Unit Titles Act 2001 (ACT)
Subordinate Law: Territory Plan 2008: RZ2 Suburban Core Zone; Residential Zones Multi Unit Housing Development Code; Parking and Vehicular Access General Code
List of Cases: Brewer & Quinn and Ors and act Planning and Land & Anor
[2009] ACTAAT 1 (5 February 2009)
Arnold Frank
Tribunal: Mr J. Ashe, Senior Member
Ms J. Greagg, Member
Date of Orders: 30 May 2011
Date of Reasons for Decision: 30 May 2011
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ) AT 9 of 2011
BETWEEN:
ANTHONY SCHERL
Applicant
AND:
ACT PLANNING AND
LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent
AND:
HERTA SCHERL
Party Joined (1)
AND:
DIANE KOSEV
Party Joined (2)
AND:
PATRICIA ABDILLA
Party Joined (3)
AND:
OLIVIA REID
Party Joined (4)
Tribunal: Mr J. Ashe, Senior Member
Ms J. Greagg, Member
DATE: 30 May 2011
ORDER
- The respondent’s decision of 21 December 2010 in respect of DA 201017758 is varied by amending condition A1(a) to read as follows:
(a)
Revised architectural drawings, showing:
(i)the northern upper floor window in unit 3 to be a high-silled window with a sill height of 1.7 metres measured from the finished floor level, or to be fixed obscure glazing to a sill height of 1.7 metres.
(ii)the northern upper floor window to bedroom 2 to be provided with a screen, as indicated in the attachments to exhibit PJ2, to prevent overlooking and enhance the privacy of the private open space of unit 2 as described.
(iii)the relocation of the water tank and the clothesline in the POS of unit 2 to positions abutting the wall of unit 1 and the western courtyard wall respectively.
(iv)a 1.8 metre high courtyard wall with an entrance gate of the same height enclosing the northern private open space of unit 5.
(v)site levels and elevations to provide the natural and finished ground levels indicated in Attachment D of exhibit PJ2, being a site plan showing site cuts, finished floor levels and cross fall.
2. The following plans and documents submitted with the reconsideration application or during the hearing are approved:
(a)T200–Water Reduction Spreadsheet
(b)T201–Proposed New Exterior Colour Scheme
(c)T202–Landscape Plan (subject to the amendment in 1(a) (iii) above)
(d)T203–Site Plan
(e)T204–Demolition and Tree Management Plan
(f)T206–Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
(g)T207–CPTED and Verge Management Plan’
(h)T209–Letter Boxes, Site Signage and Garbage Bin Location Plan
(i)T213–Elevations Units 4–6 Left and Right
(j)T215–Elevations Units 4–6 Front and Back
(k)T217–Typical Section
(l)T219–GFA Schedule
(m)T224–Elevations 1–3 Left and Right
(n)T226–Section Unit 6
(o)T227–Section Unit 7
(p)T229–Section Unit 4
(q)T230–Elevations Units 1–3 Front and Back
(r)Floor Plans Units 1–6…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Scherl & Act Planning and Land Authority & Ors (Administrati... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] ACAT 37
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the respondent's decision to reject certain aspects of the development application was lawful, rational, and justified. The applicant argued that the decision was flawed and that the proposed modifications, including changes to window placements and courtyard wall heights, were necessary to comply with planning regulations and improve privacy.
The court examined the merits of the applicant's arguments and the respondent's rationale for the decision. It found that the respondent's concerns about overlooking and privacy were valid but could be addressed through the proposed modifications. The court concluded that the modifications, as outlined in the varied decision, were reasonable and in compliance with the planning scheme. Therefore, the court varied the respondent's decision and approved the amended plans and documents submitted by the applicant.
The court's final orders included the amendment of specific architectural conditions and the approval of numerous plans and documents, subject to certain conditions, thereby allowing the development to proceed with the modifications deemed necessary for compliance and privacy.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondent’s decision of 21 December 2010 in respect of DA 201017758 is varied by amending condition A1(a) to read as follows:
(a)
Revised architectural drawings, showing:
(i) the northern upper floor window in unit 3 to be a high-silled window with a sill height of 1.7 metres measured from the finished floor level, or to be fixed obscure glazing to a sill height of 1.7 metres.
(ii) the northern upper floor window to bedroom 2 to be provided with a screen, as indicated in the attachments to exhibit PJ2, to prevent overlooking and enhance the privacy of the private open space of unit 2 as described.
(iii) the relocation of the water tank and the clothesline in the POS of unit 2 to positions abutting the wall of unit 1 and the western courtyard wall respectively.
(iv) a 1.8 metre high courtyard wall with an entrance gate of the same height enclosing the northern private open space of unit 5.
(v) site levels and elevations to provide the natural and finished ground levels indicated in Attachment D of exhibit PJ2, being a site plan showing site cuts, finished floor levels and cross fall.
2. The following plans and documents submitted with the reconsideration application or during the hearing are approved:
(a) T200–Water Reduction Spreadsheet
(b) T201–Proposed New Exterior Colour Scheme
(c) T202–Landscape Plan (subject to the amendment in 1(a) (iii) above)
(d) T203–Site Plan
(e) T204–Demolition and Tree Management Plan
(f) T206–Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
(g) T207–CPTED and Verge Management Plan’
(h) T209–Letter Boxes, Site Signage and Garbage Bin Location Plan
(i) T213–Elevations Units 4–6 Left and Right
(j) T215–Elevations Units 4–6 Front and Back
(k) T217–Typical Section
(l) T219–GFA Schedule
(m) T224–Elevations 1–3 Left and Right
(n) T226–Section Unit 6
(o) T227–Section Unit 7
(p) T229–Section Unit 4
(q) T230–Elevations Units 1–3 Front and Back
(r) Floor Plans Units 1–6 at exhibit PJ1
(s) Site Cuts and Finished Floor Levels at Attachment D to exhibit PJ2
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi