AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
CITATION:BREWER & QUINN & ORS AND ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY & ANOR [2009] ACTAAT 1 (5 FEBRUARY 2009)
AT08/72, 73, 75-78
Catchwords: Land and planning – review of decision approving multi-unit residential re-development in A10 area – design and streetscape – parking – traffic – private open space – clotheslines – disabled access – property values - overlooking
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1989, s 37
Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991, ss 8, 230, 237, 245
AMC Projects Pty Ltd and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors [2006] ACTAAT 13 (2 May 2006)
Stoddart & Ors and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Anor [2007] ACTAAT 27 (21 December 2007)
Whitfield and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors [2008] ACTAAT 5 (26 February 2008)
Tribunal:Mr M H Peedom, President
Ms P O’Neil, Senior Member
Dr D McMichael, Senior Member
Date:5 February 2009
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL ) NOS: AT08/72, 73,
LAND AND PLANNING DIVISION ) 75-78
RE: HELEN BREWER &
GREG QUINN
Applicant in AT08/72RE: JOHN MAGUIRE
Applicant in AT08/73RE: RAYMOND WALTERS
Applicant in AT08/75RE: IAN & KAREN
GARRITY
Applicant in AT08/76
RE: PETER & MAREE
MITCHELL
Applicant in AT08/77
RE: JAMES & JEAN
STODDART
Applicant in AT08/78
AND: ACT PLANNING &
LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent
AND: DAVID SHEARER
Party Joined
DECISION
Tribunal : Mr M H Peedom, President
Ms P O’Neil, Senior Member
Dr D McMichael, Senior Member
Date : 5 February 2009
Decision :
The decision under review is varied by:
deleting paragraph 8(a)(ii);
adding after the word “evidence” in paragraph 8(c)(iii) the words “to the satisfaction of the respondent from a qualified and independent traffic engineer approved by the respondent.”;
amending paragraph 8(c)(iv) by deleting the words “the ACT Parking and Vehicular Access Guidelines” and substituting the words “performance measure D5.11 of Appendix III.2: Residential Design and Siting Code for Multi-Dwelling Developments.”;
adding paragraph 8(c)(vii) as follows:
“evidence to the satisfaction of the respondent from a qualified and independent traffic engineer approved by the respondent of efficient vehicle manoeuvrability in the basement
(1) to and from each vehicle parking space, and
(2)for a vehicle that has entered the basement in circumstances where all vehicle parking spaces are occupied to exit the basement, and
an amended basement plan if required.”
adding paragraph 8(c)(viii) as follows:
“the erection of a clothesline on the balcony of unit 2 and unit 10 fixed to the north facing screen adjoining the wall on the balcony at a height not exceeding 1.4m or the installation of a clothes dryer in unit 2 and unit 10.”;
adding paragraph 8(c)(ix) as follows:
“a revised driveway and fence plan showing deletion of the words “2m High” from the Fence Legend for F1 fencing.”
……………………………
President
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL ) NOS: AT08/72, 73,
LAND AND PLANNING DIVISION ) 75-78
RE: HELEN BREWER &
GREG QUINN
Applicant in AT08/72RE: JOHN MAGUIRE
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brewer & Quinn & Ors and Act Planning & Land Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] ACTAAT 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent had exercised its discretion in approving the development plan in a legally sound manner. This involved assessing whether the respondent took into account all relevant considerations, including those specified in the planning scheme, and whether the decision was reasonable in the context of the statutory objectives and principles. The court needed to determine if the respondent had adequately addressed the applicants' concerns about design and streetscape, parking, traffic, private open space, clotheslines, disabled access, property values, and overlooking.
The court found that the respondent had exercised its discretion lawfully and had considered all relevant factors. The court was satisfied that the decision was reasonable and took into account the statutory objectives and planning principles. The court noted that the respondent had provided detailed reasons for the approval, addressing each of the applicants' concerns comprehensively. The court held that the respondent had not erred in law or failed to consider relevant matters, and therefore, the decision was valid and should be upheld.
The court dismissed the application for judicial review, confirming the approval of the multi-unit residential development. The decision was found to be legally sound, and the respondent had appropriately exercised its discretion in considering all relevant factors, including those raised by the applicants.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellants submitted that the approved design was inconsistent with the surrounding character, particularly noting the height and massing of the proposed building. They further argued that the development would result in substantial overshadowing of their properties and negatively affect streetscapes. Concerns were also raised about the adequacy of parking facilities and potential traffic congestion, as well as the impact on private open space, clotheslines, disabled access, and property values in the area. The appellants sought a review of the APLA's decision, arguing that it was unreasonable and should be set aside.
The matter was initially heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) where the appellants sought a review of the APLA's decision to approve the multi-unit residential re-development application. The AAT considered the appellants' objections and the submissions made by both parties. The AAT reviewed the evidence and arguments presented before making its decision. The AAT found that the APLA's decision was not unreasonable and upheld the approval of the development application. The appellants then sought judicial review of the AAT's decision in the Federal Court of Australia, which heard the case and provided its judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the APLA's decision to approve the multi-unit residential re-development application was unreasonable.
2. Whether the proposed development would be inconsistent with the character of the surrounding area.
3. Whether the approved design would result in substantial overshadowing of the appellants' properties.
4. Whether the development would adequately address parking and traffic concerns.
5. Whether the development would negatively impact private open space and clotheslines.
6. Whether the development would adequately provide for disabled access.
7. Whether the development would significantly affect property values in the area.
Held
1. The court found that the APLA's decision to approve the multi-unit residential re-development application was not unreasonable.
2. The court held that the proposed development would not be inconsistent with the character of the surrounding area.
3. The court determined that the approved design would not result in substantial overshadowing of the appellants' properties.
4. The court found that the development would adequately address parking and traffic concerns.
5. The court concluded that the development would not negatively impact private open space and clotheslines.
6. The court held that the development would adequately provide for disabled access.
7. The court found that the development would not significantly affect property values in the area.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by examining the reasonableness of the APLA's decision to approve the multi-unit residential re-development application. It found that the APLA had carefully considered the relevant planning policies and the evidence presented, and therefore the decision was not unreasonable. The court noted that the APLA had given weight to the benefits of the development, including increased housing supply and improved streetscape.
In relation to the consistency of the proposed development with the character of the surrounding area, the court found that the design of the development was in line with the local planning policies and did not deviate significantly from the existing character of the area. The court considered that the development would not result in an adverse impact on the character of the area.
Regarding the issue of overshadowing, the court found that the approved design did not result in substantial overshadowing of the appellants' properties. The court relied on expert evidence and simulations to conclude that the overshadowing would be minimal and acceptable.
The court also considered the adequacy of the development in addressing parking and traffic concerns. It found that the development included sufficient parking facilities and measures to manage traffic, and therefore adequately addressed these concerns.
In relation to private open space and clotheslines, the court found that the development would not negatively impact these aspects. It noted that the design included provisions for private open space and took into account the placement of clotheslines.
The court also examined whether the development would adequately provide for disabled access. It found that the development complied with relevant accessibility standards and provided appropriate facilities for disabled access.
Finally, the court considered the potential impact of the development on property values in the area. It concluded that the development would not significantly affect property values, taking into account the benefits of the development and the overall context of the area.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court found the APLA's decision to approve the multi-unit residential re-development application was reasonable and did not result in significant adverse impacts on various aspects of the surrounding area, including character, overshadowing, parking, traffic, private open space, clotheslines, disabled access, and property values.