Schembri v Blacktown City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Schembri v Blacktown City Council [2020] NSWWCCPD 35
APPELLANT: Victoria Schembri
RESPONDENT: Blacktown City Council
INSURER: Self-insured
FILE NUMBER: A1-3043/19
ARBITRATOR: Ms C McDonald
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 6 November 2019
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 9 June 2020
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Consequential condition; whether the worker suffered a consequential condition of her right shoulder from favouring her injured left shoulder; consideration of competing medical evidence; adequacy of reasons
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Geoffrey Parker SC
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant:
Mr C Tanner, counsel
Turner Freeman Lawyers
Respondent:
Mr W Murphy, solicitor
Bartier Perry
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.    The Certificate of Determination dated 6 November 2019 is confirmed.

INTRODUCTION

  1. The appellant, Ms Schembri, was employed as a cleaner by Blacktown City Council, the respondent. Her duties extended to cleaning office spaces, vacuuming large areas, cleaning windows, scrubbing toilets and emptying rubbish bins.[1]

    [1] Schembri v Blacktown City Council [2019] NSWWCC 358 (Reasons), [1].

  2. On 5 July 2005, she sustained injury to the left shoulder, neck and lumbar spine while scrubbing the disabled access ramp in the Council’s Rates Department.

  3. In 2010, she received lump sum compensation in respect of 5% whole person impairment. This arose from the injury to the cervical spine.

  4. The parties agreed that Ms Schembri had not suffered any additional impairment with respect to her cervical spine.[2]

    [2] Reasons, [8].

  5. At issue in the present matter was whether Ms Schembri has suffered a consequential condition to her right shoulder. If the issue were resolved in favour of the appellant, the right shoulder should would be remitted to the Registrar for referral to an Approved Medical Specialist for a further assessment of the permanent whole person impairment.

  6. The appellant appeals from the Arbitrator’s determination that the right shoulder condition should not be remitted. The Arbitrator said she was not satisfied that the cause of the condition in Ms Schembri’s right shoulder was a consequence of the accepted left shoulder injury.[3]

    [3] Reasons, [66].

BACKGROUND FACTS

  1. The following background facts taken from the Arbitrator’s decision are undisputed.

  2. The appellant claimed that she suffered a right carpal tunnel syndrome in 2002 and this claim was accepted but later disputed. Ms Schembri complained of symptoms on a continuing basis in both arms.[4] A carpal tunnel release procedure was performed in 2016.

    [4] Reasons, [11].

  3. Ms Schembri sustained an injury to the left shoulder, neck and back on 5 July 2005. The respondent accepted liability for this claim and paid compensation.

  4. After leaving the employ of the Blacktown City Council, the appellant pursued a number of employments set out by the Arbitrator at [14] of her reasons. No reliance is placed on the work performed by the appellant in those employments. These employments were, with one immaterial exception (Code Blue Recruitment Pty Limited), casual light cleaning duties.

  5. In 2007, the appellant’s General Practitioner, Dr S Martin, referred her to Dr Watson, neurologist. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schembri v Blacktown City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWWCCPD 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff in Schembri v Blacktown City Council alleged that she suffered a consequential condition in her right shoulder due to her left shoulder injury, which she claimed arose from her employment. The defendant, Blacktown City Council, disputed the claim and the case was heard by the Workers Compensation Magistrate, who concluded that the plaintiff had not established her case on the balance of probabilities. The plaintiff appealed against this decision, arguing that the magistrate had failed to adequately consider her evidence and that of her expert witnesses. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff had proved on the balance of probabilities that her right shoulder condition was a consequential condition of her left shoulder injury. This involved weighing the competing medical evidence from both parties and assessing the adequacy of the reasons provided by the magistrate in reaching their decision. The court found that the magistrate had properly considered the evidence and provided sufficient reasons for their conclusion. The appeal was dismissed and the original decision was confirmed. The plaintiff was not entitled to compensation for the claimed consequential condition in her right shoulder.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Certificate of Determination dated 6 November 2019 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established