Schanka v Employment National (Administration) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Schanka v Employment National (Administration) Pty Limited [2001] FCA 579

INDUSTRIAL LAW – representative proceeding – Australian Workplace Agreements (“AWAs”) – duress – illegitimate pressure – abolition of Commonwealth Employment Service (“CES”) – creation of competitive market for provision of employment placement services – offer of employment to employees of CES by company formed by Commonwealth to participate in employment placement services market – offer conditional on entry into AWA

WORDS AND PHRASES – “duress”

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) s 170WG(1)
Public Service Act 1922 (Cth) s 81C

Schanka v Employment National (Administration) Pty Ltd (1999) 166 ALR 663 followed
Schanka v Employment National (Administration) Pty Ltd (2000) 97 FCR 186 followed
Maritime Union of Australia v Burnie Port Corporation Pty Ltd (2000) 101 IR 435 distinguished

PETER SCHANKA, ERICA ALDRIDGE, RICHARD WALDEN AND JAMES BURNS v EMPLOYMENT NATIONAL (ADMINISTRATION) PTY LIMITED (ACN 080 046 411)

NG 461 OF 1998

MOORE J
18 MAY 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 461 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

PETER SCHANKA
FIRST APPLICANT

ERICA ALDRIDGE
SECOND APPLICANT

RICHARD WALDEN
THIRD APPLICANT

JAMES BURNS
FOURTH APPLICANT

AND:

EMPLOYMENT NATIONAL (ADMINISTRATION) PTY LIMITED (ACN 080 046 411)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 MAY 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   The parties prepare and serve short minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons within seven days.

2.   The application be stood over until 9.00am Friday 1 June 2001 or such other time as the Court may direct.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 461 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

PETER SCHANKA
FIRST APPLICANT

ERICA ALDRIDGE
SECOND APPLICANT

RICHARD WALDEN
THIRD APPLICANT

JAMES BURNS
FOURTH APPLICANT

AND:

EMPLOYMENT NATIONAL (ADMINISTRATION) PTY LIMITED (ACN 080 046 411)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

18 MAY 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. These proceedings now have a lengthy history. On 15 May 1998 an application was filed under s 170VV of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“WR Act”) alleging contravention of s 170WG by Employment National (Administration) Pty Ltd (“ENA”). Section 170WG provides that it is an offence to apply duress to an employee in connection with an Australian Workplace Agreement (“AWA”) which is an agreement regulated by the WR Act concerning terms and conditions of employment and made by an employer and an individual employee. The applicants were named individuals and the Community and Public Sector Union (“CPSU”). The proceedings were instituted as representative proceedings under Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“FC Act”).

  2. On 31 July 1998 ENA filed a notice of motion raising several issues. The principal issue was whether an order should be made under s 33N of Part IVA of the FC Act that the proceedings no longer continue as a representative proceeding.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schanka v Employment National (Administration) Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an appeal by Employment National (Administration) Pty Limited (ENA) against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia regarding the employment terms offered to former Commonwealth Employment Service (CES) employees. The appeal was initially dismissed by the Full Court but subsequently rejected by the High Court, leading to the final hearing of the matter. The key issue before the court was whether ENA had applied duress to certain former CES employees by imposing unfavorable employment terms, specifically through the requirement of signing Australian Workplace Agreements (AWAs) to secure employment.

The court examined the sequence of events leading up to the transfer of CES employees to ENA. Initially, ENA offered employees a choice between working under an AWA or under terms set by a board determination under section 81C(3) of the Public Service Act 1992 (Cth). However, after the Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU) threatened legal action against the board's determination, ENA withdrew the option of employment under the board's determination and required all employees to sign AWAs. This left employees with no choice but to accept the terms of the AWAs if they wished to continue their employment with ENA.

The court concluded that while the board's determination did provide a legal means for ENA to impose employment terms, the employees had the option to reject the AWAs until 20 April 1998. However, the court found that the manner in which ENA handled the situation created an environment of duress for some employees, leading to the conclusion that ENA applied duress to certain employees. The court ordered that the matter be adjourned to determine the appropriate penalties and other orders concerning the affected employees.

In summary, the court found that while the employees had the legal right to reject the AWAs, the circumstances under which they were required to make this decision amounted to duress, thus invalidating their acceptance of the terms. The court ordered the matter to be adjourned to allow for further submissions on the appropriate penalties and orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties prepare and serve short minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons within seven days.

2. The application be stood over until 9.00am Friday 1 June 2001 or such other time as the Court may direct.

Background

Background to the litigation

ENA appealed against the determination of these preliminary questions. On 3 March 2000 the Full Court granted leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal: (2000) 97 FCR 186. An application for special leave to appeal from the Full Court's judgment was dismissed by the High Court on 24 November 2000. During 2000, the matter remained in my docket and issues arose about the adequacy of the pleadings and the nature of the proceedings resulting in one interlocutory judgment of 2 June 2000 concerning the statement of claim: [2000] FCA 730. The hearing of the matter commenced on 27 November 2000 but a successful, though late, application to further amend the pleadings resulted in the hearing being adjourned until January-February 2001 when it concluded.The general background Before turning to consider the evidence, it is convenient to summarise the general background by repeating a summary in my judgment of 9 September 1998 ((1998) 86 IR 283 at 284):The Commonwealth Employment Service (“CES”) was an agency of the Commonwealth engaged in placing people in employment whether employed or unemployed. It operated within the administrative structure of the Department of Employment, Education, Training and Youth Affairs (“DEETYA”). Commonwealth employees engaged in CES’s operations were employed under the Public Service Act 1922 (Cth) (“PS Act”) and their terms and conditions of employment were predominantly regulated by the Australian Public Service, Administrative Services Officers (Salaries and Specific Conditions) Award 1995 and the Australian Public Service, General Employment Conditions Award 1995. Executives in the CES had their terms and conditions of employment regulated by the Australian Public Service, Senior Executive Service (Salaries and Specific Conditions) Award 1995. In August 1996 the Australian Government announced that a new competitive market would operate in relation to the provision of employment placement services. It announced that there would be a publicly owned provider competing in the new market and CES would cease operations. To that end a company, Employment National Limited (“EN”), was incorporated under the Corporations Law with all shares owned by the Commonwealth. EN contracted to DEETYA to provide employment services. The contract was secured through a national tendering process and EN is one of a considerable number of providers of employment services. ENA is a wholly owned subsidiary of EN and has contracted to EN to provide all services, including staff, required by EN to perform its contract with DEETYA. In some of the material in evidence a rigid distinction is not drawn between EN and ENA concerning which company is the employer. I will repeat what the material says and thus it may appear, at times, that EN, and not ENA, is the employer.In October/November 1997 certain of CES’s functions were transferred to an agency called Centrelink and 2,900 staff who had worked in the CES transferred to that agency. Towards the end of 1997 expressions of interest were sought from staff of the CES to work for ENA. Schanka, Aldridge, Walden and Burns expressed interest in working for ENA. In February 1998 Aldridge received an email advising her that she had obtained a position with ENA. She was invited to respond and did so, indicating she accepted the position. On about 25 February 1998 the staff of CES were sent a survey that had to be completed by 13 March 1998. It asked each employee to indicate their preference for a number of options concerning future employment. The survey form said that by indicating a preference the employee was not committing themselves to an option nor was a guarantee being provided that their preference would be met. The options were employment in EN, voluntary retrenchment, redeployment to Centrelink (while remaining a member of the Australian Public Service) or redeployment elsewhere within the Australian Public Service. On 25 February 1998 Walden received a letter offering employment with ENA. It provided:I am pleased to be able to invite you to join Employment National (Administration) Pty Ltd, as Associate Consultant, from the 1st of May 1998. This position will be initially located at Sydney CBD.As you are aware, we are currently developing the employment framework with existing employees and these will be finalised and reflected in a Certified Agreement before you transfer across to us on the 1st of May. The terms and conditions in this agreement will incorporate the Government guarantees announced in December 1996 and will reflect the employment arrangements outlined in the Employment Relationship Agreement and the Personnel Policies and Procedures Manual, under which current staff are employed. Any movement in remuneration that arises from the current DEETYA negotiations on a certified agreement for Network staff will also be incorporated.Should you have any questions in relation to these arrangements, or should you wish to review any of the documents I have referred to, please see your Business Manager.As you would appreciate, it is necessary or [sic] Employment National to continue to manage the Network until 30 April 1998 and you will contribute to the successful finalisation of that contract.In the meantime, I need to know for planning purposes, if you intend to take up the offer of employment and I would be grateful for advice of your intentions by 4 March 1998.I look forward to working with you to achieve our goal of making Employment National the market leader in employment services.Yours sincerely, I accept, subject to the finalisation of a Satisfactory employment framework.Bob HallRegional Manager Richard WaldenSydney Metropolitan RegionBurns received a letter in the substantially same terms dated 26 February 1998. On 27 February 1998 Burns signed the letter of invitation and returned it to the manager of ENA who had sent him the letter of 26 February 1998. Walden took a similar step on 3 March 1998 by emailing an acceptance “subject to finalization of a satisfactory employment framework”. On 20 March 1998 the board of ENA passed a resolution in exercise of powers thought to be conferred by s 81C(3) of the PS Act which provides:For the purpose of facilitating a transfer of persons into the employment of a Commonwealth authority, the Commonwealth authority may, notwithstanding anything in any other law (other than an industrial award), determine any special terms or conditions of employment that are to apply to the persons.This section applies when the Prime Minister has certified that a function performed by persons appointed or employed under the PS Act is to be performed by a Commonwealth authority. It provides a mechanism for the transfer, by operation of law, of the employment of employees by the Commonwealth in the Australian Public Service to employment by the relevant authority. A Commonwealth authority is defined to include a company in which the Commonwealth has a controlling interest: see s 7 of the PS Act. The exercise of this power by the board appears to have proceeded on the assumption that EN or ENA (which is the relevant Commonwealth authority performing the function is not clear and may have been relevant to the valid operation of s 81C) would be performing functions formerly performed by members of the Australian Public Service employed under the PS Act. On 22 March 1998 the managing director of ENA sent a memorandum to staff of the CES. It read:Today the board has authorized me to make the following announcement regarding recruitment to Employment National.1. Basis of Employment – Your ChoiceStaff joining Employment National on or before 30 April 98 may elect, at their discretion, to work under the terms of an Australian Workplace Agreement (already signed by some 250 colleagues) or to work under terms identical to those of the AWA but without the formal agreement (as determined by the Board today under s 81c [sic] of the Public Service Act).In due course, pending proceedings in the AIRC, a Certified Agreement will be offered to staff.2. Salaries and Bonuses – Further BenefitsAll staff joining Employment National from the CES will receive the financial benefits agreed by the Network with DEETYA, specifically: 2% salary increase plus a $500 bonus.In addition to this, staff joining employment National from the CES on or before 30 April 98 will receive a further 2% salary increase and a further $500 bonus on 1 December 98.3. TimingTo enable staff to fully consider this offer the closing date for acceptance has been extended until 3 April 98.A further and more detailed memorandum was sent shortly after to staff of the CES. The memorandum indicated that EN was seeking to put in place the certified agreement as soon as possible and it would replace the determination that the board had earlier made. The memorandum included:All operational staff (excluding Business Managers) who have signed up to date on AWAs can transfer to the determination made by the Board if they wish. Similarly, you can elect to sign an AWA, and not fall under the determination. The option is yours.At this point EN was managing the operation of CES and had been doing so since December 1997. On 2 April 1998 CPSU wrote to ENA threatening legal action if the determination made under s 81C(3) of the PS Act was not revoked. As a result of this action by the CPSU, the option that employees might have their employment with ENA regulated by the s 81C(3) determination was withdrawn. This occurred on or about 18 April 1998 though the precise time does not clearly emerge from the material to which I have been referred. From that point any employee accepting employment with ENA had to sign an AWA. In early April 1998 Schanka and Walden received an offer of appointment to the staff of ENA though the letter contained the following:It is a condition of this offer of employment that you and the Company enter into two Agreements: firstly, an Employment Relationship Agreement which is an Australian Workplace Agreement (AWA) made under the provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 and secondly, an Agreement to terminate that AWA when a Certified Agreement is made and certified by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission. Copies of both Agreements are included in the Information Kit that accompanies this letter.The letter went on to detail the process that would lead to the signing of the AWA and how information would be provided concerning it. It nominated a person who could answer any queries. It also contained an explanation about the termination agreement. As stated in the letter, it was accompanied by an information kit. Burns received a similar letter on 1 April 1998. On 6 April 1998 the CPSU issued a bulletin informing members that it was not necessary to sign an AWA if they had been offered a job in EN and wanted to take it up. The bulletin said:If you sign an AWA then you accept those employment conditions until and unless we can improve them through a certified agreement. If you agree to transfer without an AWA, then at the very least your conditions will be those outlined in the AWAs, and if our legal challenge is successful they will be better.By email dated 15 April 1998 Burns indicated he did not wish to sign an AWA but wished to be transferred under s 81C(3) of the PS Act. On 20 April 1998 he was advised that the option under s 81C(3) was no longer available and, accordingly, Burns declined the offer of employment. Also on 20 April 1998 Aldridge was told that if she did not sign an AWA she would not have a job with ENA. On 22 April 1998 Aldridge accepted an offer of employment and signed an AWA. On 23 April 1998 Schanka was told that if he did not sign an AWA his offer of employment would be withdrawn. That day he signed one. On 29 April 1998 Walden accepted his offer of employment and signed an AWA.On 30 April 1998 the CES ceased to function. At that time there were 4,400 employees employed in its various operations. Two thousand had accepted an offer of voluntary retrenchment, 450 had transferred to Centrelink, 150 were to be retrenched voluntarily later in 1998, 600 were declared excess to requirements and 150 would be declared excess to requirements when winding up duties had been completed. The two lastmentioned groups constituted 750 former CES staff who were seeking redeployment.On 1 May 1998 Schanka, Aldridge and Walden commenced employment with ENA. The declaration made under s 81C of the PS Act transferring certain former employees of the CES to ENA was gazetted on 4 May 1998 effective 1 May 1998. By 12 May 1998 1,100 people who had been employed in the CES had taken up employment with ENA. 400 of them were temporary staff and 930 were employed on AWAs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Except for some of the figures in the last two paragraphs and certain specific matters which I will later refer to, the evidence at the final hearing established, as a matter of fact, the various matters referred to in the preceding passage. From this point it will be convenient to refer to the form of letter sent to Walden on 25 February 1998 referred to in the above passage as "the February 1998 invitation letter" and the condition in the letter sent to Schanka and Walden in April 1998 as "the April 1998 condition". It is appropriate to turn now to some of the evidence in greater detail and make findings about some contentious factual issues.The evidence I should, at the outset, note that both the applicants and ENA tendered various types of documents such as newsletters or notices from the CPSU to its membership in the Department of Employment, Education, Training and Youth Affairs (“DEETYA”) and notices or bulletins from the management at DEETYA or ENA to employees or prospective employees. At one point during the hearing, a question arose about the evidentiary status of these documents. It was ultimately accepted, however, that they could be treated as not only what, on their face, they purported to be (a newsletter, a notice or a bulletin) but also as evidence tending to establish the truth of facts recounted in them. Their tender had the potential of creating problems of the type adverted to by Kirby and Callinan JJ in Tepko Pty Ltd v Ministerial Holding Corporation [2001] HCA 19 at par 171. In addition, the oral evidence called by the parties tended to cover a more limited range of events than the documents themselves. But often the documents presented an incomplete picture of events to which they related. Accordingly the evidence is, in some respects, incomplete and this may be reflected in the following discussion.(i)The industrial manoeuvring It is to be recalled that generally the terms and conditions of employment of employees in the CES (and more generally DEETYA) were regulated by the Australian Public Service, Administrative Services Officers (Salaries and Specific Conditions) Award 1995 ("the Salaries Award") and the Australian Public Service (General Employment Conditions) Award 1995 ("the Conditions Award") (collectively "the applicable Awards"). Executives in the CES had their terms and conditions of employment regulated by the Australian Public Service, Senior Executive Service (Salaries and Specific Conditions) Award 1995. With the prospect that significant numbers of employees in DEETYA might take up employment with ENA, the CPSU tried, mainly during 1997 and 1998, to create a situation where any such employees would, when employed with ENA, have the same or substantially the same terms and conditions of employment as in the applicable Awards. This was an outcome which was resisted by ENA. In the result, the CPSU and ENA engaged, in that period, in what might be described as industrial manoeuvring to bring about the desired result as each saw it. The following reflects findings I make about these and related events.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MOORE J
It is true that the board's determination reflected the terms and conditions of employment in the AWA and accordingly a person could not avoid those terms and conditions by taking up employment under the determination. However the lack of choice about the terms and conditions arose because of the unusual circumstances in which ENA was commencing operations including the existence of the prescription of conditions power which was quite unusual. Whether, more generally, the position the individuals being offered employment were in before 20 April 1998 was unfair and inequitable, or the behaviour of ENA was unconscionable, is presently irrelevant. Any employee who did not want to accept the terms and conditions offered by ENA which were contained in the proposed AWA could reject them by rejecting employment under an AWA. The fact that a person who was free to reject the terms and conditions (as they were proposed in the AWA) by rejecting the AWA, would (if the AWA was rejected) nonetheless be bound by the same terms and conditions because of the board's determination if he or she took up employment with ENA, does not gainsay the freedom the person had to reject the terms and conditions in the AWA as enlivened by the making of an AWA. What is unusual about this case is that the board of ENA had available, at least arguably, a legal means of insisting on the terms and conditions it desired by imposing them by exercising the prescription of conditions power even in the face of rejection of an AWA. It purported to do so by making the determination and it thereby effectively frustrated or rendered ineffective any rejection of the terms and conditions by the rejection of the AWA. Nonetheless each person offered employment with ENA was in a position where they could reject the AWA, (and, by operation of the AWA, the terms it contained) until about 20 April 1998.Conclusion Having regard to the various conclusions expressed in the preceding reasons, my present view is that the appropriate orders are orders declaring that ENA applied duress to Brushe, Walden, Schanka and Burns only, adjourning the proceedings for the purposes of determining what penalty, if any, should be imposed and what other orders should be made concerning Brushe, Walden, Schanka and Burns. However it will also be necessary to consider whether an order should be made otherwise dismissing the application (which is a vexed question given that any such order will or may bind all members of the group: see s 33ZB of the FC Act), or whether an order should be made under s 33N. Accordingly, I propose only to make an order standing the matter over to a specified day to enable the parties to make submissions about the form of orders that should be made to give effect to these reasons and requiring the parties to prepare short minutes. I intend that any submissions on penalty would be made at some later date.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MOORE J