Schafer v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Schafer v Brisbane City Council [2024] QIRC 229

PARTIES:

Schafer, Justin

(Applicant)

v

Brisbane City Council
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

TD/2023/102

PROCEEDING:

Application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

17 September 2024

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

HEARD ON:

Hartigan, DP

Brisbane

13 September 2024

ORDER:

1.     The application for leave for the witnesses, Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy, to give evidence by video link is granted.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – APPLICATION FOR REINSTATEMENT – application in existing proceedings for witnesses to give evidence by video link – where the witnesses have prior work commitments – where witnesses are not witnesses of credit – where Applicant not disadvantaged if witnesses do not appear in-person – where Commission has discretion to grant leave –

where leave is granted for the witnesses to appear by video link.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 47A

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 447(2)(b), 451

Practice Direction Number 8 of 2021 – Taking Evidence by Telephone or Video link


Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd v 3RD Solution Investment Pty Ltd (2020) 147 ACSR 521

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Wilson (No 2) [2020] FCA 873

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. The substantive application in this matter is an application for reinstatement filed on behalf of Mr Justin Schafer.  The substantial application is listed for a hearing on 18 and 19 September 2024.

  2. The Respondent has applied for leave for two of its proposed witnesses, Mr Travis McDonogh and Mr Patrick Grahvendy, to give evidence by video link at the substantive hearing.

  3. The Applicant objects to the application.

  4. At the hearing of the application on Friday, 13 September 2024, I granted leave for Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy to give evidence by video link at the hearing commencing on Wednesday, 18 September 2024. These are the reasons for that decision.

Relevant legislative provisions and Direction

  1. The Respondent relies on ss 447(2)(b) and 451 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) (‘the IR Act’) in support of its application.

  2. Section 447(2)(b) of the IR Act provides for the Commission’s functions as follows:

    447 Commission's functions

    …

    (2) The commission must perform its function in a way that –

    …

    (b) avoids unnecessary technicalities and facilitates the fair and practical conduct of proceedings under this Act.

  3. Section 451 of the IR Act provides for the general powers of the Commission as follows:

    451 General powers

    (1)The commission has the power to do all things necessary or convenient to be done for the performance of its functions.

    (2)Without limiting subsection (1) – the commission in the proceeding may:

    (a)give directions about the hearing of a matter; or

    (b)make a decision it considers appropriate, irrespective of the relief sought by a party; or

    (c)make an order it considers appropriate.

  4. Additionally, Practice Direction 8[1] confirms, that a decision by a Member of the Commission to approve the taking of evidence, by telephone or by video link, is an exercise of discretion.

    [1] Practice Direction Number 8…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schafer v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Schafer v Brisbane City Council, the applicant sought leave for two witnesses, Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy, to give evidence by video link rather than in person. Mr McDonogh operates a small cleaning business in Hervey Bay, Queensland, and has clients who rely on consistent and reliable service, particularly those funded by the National Disability Insurance Scheme. Mr Grahvendy works as an electronic technician in an underground mine near Cobar, New South Wales, and is scheduled to work a night shift during the hearing. Both witnesses argued that attending the hearing in person would disrupt their work commitments and personal circumstances.

The legal issue before the court was whether the Commission should exercise its discretion to permit the witnesses to give evidence by video link. The applicant argued that they should have every opportunity to test the evidence of both witnesses, and that their evidence was crucial to the case. The applicant also noted that there were issues of fact and credit at stake and that the forensic advantage of having evidence taken in the same environment would be lost if the witnesses were required to attend in person. The respondent, however, contended that the witnesses were not employees of the council and that their participation in the proceedings required the allocation of their own personal time and was at the expense of their own personal circumstances.

The court considered the principles referred to in Auken and found that the Commission had discretion to grant leave for the witnesses to give evidence by video link. The court found that the applicant would not be disadvantaged if the witnesses did not appear in person, and that the witnesses’ work commitments and personal circumstances were compelling reasons to permit them to give evidence by video link. The application for leave for the witnesses to give evidence by video link was therefore granted.

The court ordered that the application for leave for the witnesses, Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy, to give evidence by video link was granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave for the witnesses, Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy, to give evidence by video link is granted.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I consider that the principles referred to in Auken are of assistance as guiding principles for the exercise of the discretion by the Commission in this matter. Should the Commission exercise its discretion to permit Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy to give evidence by video link? This application is made on the basis that both Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy work and reside outside of Brisbane. The Respondent contends that neither witness is an employee of the Respondent and that their participation in the proceedings “requires the allocation of their own personal time and is at the expense of their own personal circumstances.”[3] [3] Application in Proceedings filed by the Respondent on 12 September 2024. With respect to Mr McDonogh, he resides and works in Hervey Bay, Queensland, where he and his spouse operate a small cleaning business. A number of the clients of Mr McDonogh are members of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘NDIS’) who require regular scheduled cleaning as part of their NDIS funding. It is said that it is critical that Mr McDonogh’s NDIS clients have consistent and reliable service. In this regard, the evidence is that Mr McDonogh has regular work scheduled on both 18 and 19 September 2024 and is unable to attend the hearing in Brisbane by reason of the existing bookings. With respect to Mr Grahvendy, he resides and works near Cobar, New South Wales. He is engaged as an electronic technician at an underground mine. The work he performs includes monitoring and maintaining the automation and remote-control system for heavy earthmoving equipment. He is rostered to work a night shift during the hearing of the matter. In addition to applying for leave to attend the hearing, it is said that any attendance in person would require Mr Grahvendy to fly from Cobar (or the nearest hub) to Brisbane, obtain accommodation, and then fly back to Cobar after giving his evidence. However, if Mr Grahvendy were to give his evidence by video link he would be in a position where he could perform his night shifts (and hence work) without any disruption. In response, the Applicant makes general submissions, in relation to both Mr McDonogh and Mr Grahvendy, that: (a) the Applicant should have every opportunity to test that evidence of both critical witnesses; (b) the Applicant intends to test the evidence of both critical witnesses as there is a contest about the evidence (notwithstanding that the evidence of both witnesses were not addressed in the Applicant’s reply evidence); (c) there are issues of fact and of credit and that all of the proposed evidence to be taken by electronic means is centrally important to the case; (d) the Respondent is not the cross-examining party and is in no position to make reliable submissions to the Commission about the likely length of cross-examination of the crucial witnesses and, in any event, the length of time required for cross-examination may vary depending on a range of factors such as the witnesses’ approach to giving evidence and the way other evidence has fallen in the proceeding; (e) the Applicant would lose the forensic advantage of having the evidence of a critical witness conducted in the same or similar environment to other critical witnesses including the Applicant himself; and (f) documents may be put to both critical witnesses and the Applicant would lose any forensic advantage if he was required to provide them ahead of time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established