Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd v 3RD Solution Investment Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd v 3RD Solution Investment Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1153

File number: NSD 2412 of 2018
Judgment of: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 11 August 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where eight of the applicant’s witnesses are resident in China – where travel from China is prevented due to SARS-CoV-2 pandemic – whether in the interests of the administration of justice to allow evidence to be given by overseas witnesses through video link – whether Chinese Civil Procedure Law prevents witnesses giving evidence by video link from China to Australia – whether relevant Chinese authority has given approval for evidence to be given from China – where circumstances of pandemic will otherwise result in a substantial and indeterminate delay to trial – whether cross-examination with interpretation and allegations of fraud suitable over video link – whether appropriate safeguards for the integrity of evidence provided over video link – leave granted subject to conditions
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for notice order as precursor to possible freezing order – where allegations of fraudulent conduct – where inter partes undertakings have been proffered – whether sufficient danger that prospective judgment will be wholly or partly unsatisfied – application refused   
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 47A, 47C

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.32, 7.35

Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China (1991) and (revised 2017)

Hague Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters. Opened for signature 18 March 1970. 847 UNTS 231 (entered into force 7 October 1972)

Cases cited:

Alka Developments Pty Ltd v Lemery Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 1335

 Ascot Vale Self Storage Centre Pty Ltd v Nom De Plume Nominees Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 242

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pirovic Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 544

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v GetSwift Limited [2020] FCA 504

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Wilson [2020] FCA 873

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25; 186 CLR 541

Campaign Master (UK) Ltd v Forty Two International Pty Ltd (No 3) [2009] FCA 1306; 181 FCR 152

Capic v Ford Motor Company of Australia Limited (Adjournment) [2020] FCA 486

Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 18; 198 CLR 380

Haiye Developments Pty Ltd v The Commercial Business Centre Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 732

In the matter of Black Eagle Media Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1778

Joyce v Sunland Waterfront (BVI) Ltd [2011] FCAFC 95; 195 FCR 213

Ninemia Maritime Corporation v Trave Schiffahrtsgesellschaft and Co KG (The Niedersachsen) [1983] 1 WLR 1412

Patterson v BTR Engineering Australia Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 319

Porter v Mulcahy & Co Accounting Services Pty Ltd (Ruling) [2020] VSC 430

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 4) [2020] FCA 614

Rooney v AGL Energy Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 942

RRG Nominees Pty Ltd v Visible Temporary Fencing Australia Pty Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd v 3RD Solution Investment Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd sought leave to have eight witnesses, all resident in China, give evidence by audio-visual link due to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic preventing travel from China. The respondents argued that Chinese law may prohibit evidence being given in this way, and that cross-examination with interpretation and allegations of fraud were unsuitable over video link. The court had to decide whether it was in the interests of the administration of justice to allow the evidence by audio-visual link, whether Chinese law prevented this, and whether there were appropriate safeguards for the integrity of the evidence. The court found that the administration of justice required the evidence by audio-visual link, that Chinese law permitted this with relevant approval, and that appropriate safeguards were in place. Therefore, the applicant was granted leave for its Chinese witnesses to give evidence by audio-visual link subject to certain conditions. The application for a "notice order" in relation to the proceeds of sale of the farm was refused. The court found that there was no sufficient danger that a prospective judgment would be wholly or partly unsatisfied.

The underlying claim concerns the lease of rural land near Tamworth, known as Kia Ora Farm. The applicant, Auken Animal Husbandry Pty Ltd, is an indirectly wholly-owned subsidiary of a PRC corporation, Ningxia Agricultural Reclamation Group Co Ltd. The applicant seeks orders declaring the lease to be void ab initio or alternatively to vary the lease to remove certain obligations, an order that the first respondent refund the sum of nearly $6 million, and orders for damages or compensation under the Australian Consumer Law, contract or tort. The trial of the matter will require resolution of, amongst other issues, competing versions of a series of oral conversations. The oral evidence of witnesses and, in particular, their cross-examination will be critical to that task. The applicant’s evidence in support of the giving of evidence by audio-visual link was that the eight witnesses are PRC citizens resident in the Ningxia region and would require an interpreter. It was common ground that there is no reasonable prospect that in the foreseeable future any of the applicant’s Chinese witnesses will be able to travel to Australia to give evidence due to restrictions on international travel imposed by the Australian federal government as a means of containing the spread of the novel SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes the disease known as COVID-19. The applicant proposed that its Chinese witnesses travel to Shanghai and give their evidence from a conference room within Baker McKenzie’s offices there. The applicant also proposed to use the litigation support service, Law In Order, to provide a "virtual hearing solution" including secure video conferencing software, evidence presentation, and technical support. The applicant's Australian solicitor, Mr Andrew Salgo, deposed an affidavit in support of the application. He is a partner of Baker McKenzie in Sydney. That firm has an office in Shanghai, PRC. The relevance of that will shortly become apparent. Mr Salgo takes his instructions from JunZeJun law firm in Shanghai. The applicant has served outlines of evidence of 10 lay witnesses. Eight of those witnesses are PRC citizens resident in the Ningxia region. None of those witnesses is able to communicate adequately in English; all will require an interpreter. The applicant proposes that its Chinese witnesses travel to Shanghai and give their evidence from a conference room within Baker McKenzie’s offices there. The applicant has indicated that it intends to contract with the well-known litigation support service, Law In Order, to provide a "virtual hearing solution" including secure video conferencing software that meets the technological requirements of the court, monitoring of the status of the virtual hearing at all times, controlling the audio where necessary and ensuring the speakers and witnesses are the focus at relevant times, an evidence presentation operator to rapidly display evidence on a second screen, and a technical support operator available to assist with any software or connection-related queries. Mr Salgo says in his affidavit that two identified lawyers at JunZeJun law firm have advised him with regard to any restrictions under PRC law on the applicant’s witnesses giving evidence from China by audio-visual link to Australia. That advice is that there is a restriction on the ability of a witness in Australian proceedings to give evidence by audio-visual link from China to be found in Article 263 of the Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China (1991) which provides that: Request for and provision of judicial assistance shall be carried out via the channels stipulated in the international treaty concluded or participated by the People’s Republic of China; where there is no treaty relations, request for and provision of judicial assistance shall be carried out via diplomatic channels. An embassy or consulate of a foreign country based in the People’s Republic of China may serve documents on a citizen of the foreign country and carry out investigations and collection of evidence, but shall not violate the laws of the People’s Republic of China and shall not adopt mandatory measures. Except for the circumstances stipulated in in the preceding paragraph, no foreign agency or individual shall carry out service of documents, investigation and collection of evidence in the People’s Republic of China without the consent by the relevant administrative authorities of the People’s Republic of China. With the consent of the relevant administrative authority of the PRC as provided within Article 263, there would be no constraint on the giving of audio-visual link evidence. Application was made by JunZeJun law firm for approval from the relevant administrative authority of the PRC, being the Foreign Affairs Office of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of China, on 8 July 2020. The Foreign Affairs Office of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of China has given its approval for an audio-visual link hearing to be conducted. The respondents also raise some issues with regard to the practicalities and integrity of the evidence by audio-visual link. I will deal with those separately. The interests of the administration of justice Section 47A(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) provides that the court may, for the purposes of any proceeding, direct or allow testimony to be given by video link, audio link or other appropriate means. Section 47C(1) of the Act provides that the court must not exercise that power unless the court is satisfied, essentially, that the courtroom or other place where the court is sitting is equipped with facilities that enable all eligible persons present in that courtroom or place to see and hear the remote witness and that the place at which the remote witness is located is equipped with facilities that enable all eligible persons present in that place to see and hear each eligible person who is present in the courtroom or other place where the court is sitting. Eligible persons are such persons as the court considers should be treated as eligible persons for the purpose of the proceeding: s 47C(6). I am satisfied with regard to the above matters. The evidence is that the relevant connection between the Court’s technology and that of Baker McKenzie in Shanghai is expected to work well with the contracted support of Law In Order. I also accept the submission that there is ample time between now and the hearing to ensure that any technical difficulties that there may be can be solved and that the system can be made to be stable and reliable. I respectfully agree with and adopt what was said by Flick J in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pirovic Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 5

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 47A(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the applicant has leave for the testimony of the eight witnesses identified in its interlocutory application filed on 24 July 2020 to be given by way of audio visual link from Shanghai, People’s Republic of China.

2. The leave referred to in Order 1 is subject to the following conditions attaching to the giving of the testimony:

(a) The witnesses will give their testimony from a hearing room in the offices of Baker McKenzie in Shanghai;

(b) At the time that a witness is giving evidence, no one else will be present in the hearing room save for a person independent of the applicant and its Chinese lawyers, JunZeJun, to assist with technical or administrative issues and a lawyer from Baker McKenzie, whose name will be provide to the Court, who will be responsible for ensuring that the witness’s evidence is their own and that they are not prompted or otherwise assisted in answering questions;

(c) The evidence of each witness will not be available to any other witness yet to give evidence on any medium including video, audio or transcript;

(d) Documents to be shown to a witness will be made available as needed on a separate screen for viewing by the witness;

(e) The evidence of the witnesses will be interpreted by an interpreter who is appropriately qualified and experienced, agreed to by the parties and present in the courtroom in Sydney;

(f) The applicant’s Sydney based solicitors are responsible for taking all necessary steps to ensure that the above conditions are met.

3. The applicant’s interlocutory process filed on 24 July 2020 is otherwise dismissed.

4. The costs of the application are costs in the cause in the principal proceeding, save that the parties have leave to apply for a reconsideration of that costs order by the filing of written submissions (of no more than three pages) within seven days of these orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I have resolved that the applicant should have leave for its Chinese witnesses to give evidence by AVL but that its “notice order” in relation to the proceeds of sale of the farm should be refused.Background The underlying claim concerns the lease of rural land near Tamworth, known as Kia Ora Farm. The first respondent as lessor and the applicant as lessee entered into a lease of the farm on 16 September 2016. On or about that date, the applicant paid rent and security deposits totalling nearly $6 million. No further rent was paid under the lease, and the first respondent terminated the lease on or about 15 May 2018. In December 2018, the applicant commenced the proceeding. The applicant is an indirectly wholly-owned subsidiary of a PRC corporation, Ningxia Agricultural Reclamation Group Co Ltd. Ningxia Agricultural is indirectly wholly-owned and controlled by the Government of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, an area in north-western PRC. The applicant seeks orders declaring the lease to be void ab initio or alternatively to vary the lease to remove from it certain obligations on the applicant, an order that the first respondent refund the sum of nearly $6 million, and orders for damages or compensation under the Australian Consumer Law, contract or tort. The second respondent, Mr Carey Lee, is a director of the first respondent and is said to have made various representations that led to the conclusion of the lease. It is alleged that the representations were not only false, but, in the alternative, that the second respondent knew them to be false and intended that the applicant would rely on them. Thus, the case turns at least in part on allegations of fraud. The first respondent has brought a cross-claim against the applicant. The cross-claim seeks payment of approximately $1.8 million of unpaid rent plus outgoings and rates and taxes, as well as damages for breach of the lease. The trial of the matter will require resolution of, amongst other issues, competing versions of a series of oral conversations. The oral evidence of witnesses and, in particular, their cross-examination will be critical to that task. Save for formal and uncontroversial aspects, the evidence in chief will be adduced orally, and not by way of affidavit.The applicant’s evidence in support of the giving of evidence by AVL The applicant’s Australian solicitor, Mr Andrew Salgo, deposed an affidavit in support of the application. He is a partner of Baker McKenzie in Sydney. That firm has an office in Shanghai, PRC. The relevance of that will shortly become apparent. Mr Salgo takes his instructions from JunZeJun law firm in Shanghai. The applicant has served outlines of evidence of 10 lay witnesses. Eight of those witnesses are PRC citizens resident in the Ningxia region. None of those witnesses is able to communicate adequately in English; all will require an interpreter. As indicated, it is common ground that there is no reasonable prospect that in the foreseeable future any of the applicant’s Chinese witnesses will be able to travel to Australia to give evidence. That is because of restrictions on international travel, including restrictions imposed by the Australian federal government, as a means of containing the spread of the novel SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes the disease known as COVID-19.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The trial of the matter will require resolution of, amongst other issues, competing versions of a series of oral conversations. The oral evidence of witnesses and, in particular, their cross-examination will be critical to that task. Save for formal and uncontroversial aspects, the evidence in chief will be adduced orally, and not by way of affidavit.The applicant’s evidence in support of the giving of evidence by AVL The applicant’s Australian solicitor, Mr Andrew Salgo, deposed an affidavit in support of the application. He is a partner of Baker McKenzie in Sydney. That firm has an office in Shanghai, PRC. The relevance of that will shortly become apparent. Mr Salgo takes his instructions from JunZeJun law firm in Shanghai. The applicant has served outlines of evidence of 10 lay witnesses. Eight of those witnesses are PRC citizens resident in the Ningxia region. None of those witnesses is able to communicate adequately in English; all will require an interpreter. As indicated, it is common ground that there is no reasonable prospect that in the foreseeable future any of the applicant’s Chinese witnesses will be able to travel to Australia to give evidence. That is because of restrictions on international travel, including restrictions imposed by the Australian federal government, as a means of containing the spread of the novel SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes the disease known as COVID-19. The applicant proposes that its Chinese witnesses travel to Shanghai and give their evidence from a conference room within Baker McKenzie’s offices there. There would be costs associated with the use of the facility, not for the facility itself but to pay for technical and other support including such support being given outside of ordinary office hours which may be necessitated because of the two-hour time difference between Shanghai and Sydney. It has not, however, been suggested that the costs of giving evidence by AVL would come anywhere near the cost of bringing the witnesses to Australia for the purpose of them giving evidence here. Cost is therefore not a factor raised against the application. The applicant has indicated that it intends to contract with the well-known litigation support service, Law In Order, to provide a “virtual hearing solution” including secure video conferencing software that meets the technological requirements of the court, monitoring of the status of the virtual hearing at all times, controlling the audio where necessary and ensuring the speakers and witnesses are the focus at relevant times, an evidence presentation operator to rapidly display evidence on a second screen, and a technical support operator available to assist with any software or connection-related queries. Mr Salgo says in his affidavit that two identified lawyers at JunZeJun law firm have advised him with regard to any restrictions under PRC law on the applicant’s witnesses giving evidence from China by AVL to Australia. That advice is the following:(1)The restriction on the ability of a witness in Australian proceedings to give evidence by AVL from China is to be found in Article 263 of the Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China (1991) which provides as follows:Request for and provision of judicial assistance shall be carried out via the channels stipulated in the international treaty concluded or participated by the People’s Republic of China; where there is no treaty relations, request for and provision of judicial assistance shall be carried out via diplomatic channels.An embassy or consulate of a foreign country based in the People’s Republic of China may serve documents on a citizen of the foreign country and carry out investigations and collection of evidence, but shall not violate the laws of the People’s Republic of China and shall not adopt mandatory measures.Except for the circumstances stipulated in in the preceding paragraph, no foreign agency or individual shall carry out service of documents, investigation and collection of evidence in the People’s Republic of China without the consent by the relevant administrative authorities of the People’s Republic of China.(2)With the consent of the relevant administrative authority of the PRC as provided within Article 263, there would be no constraint on the giving of AVL evidence.(3)Application was made by JunZeJun law firm for approval from the relevant administrative authority of the PRC, being the Foreign Affairs Office of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of China, on 8 July 2020.(4)The Foreign Affairs Office of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of China has given its approval for an AVL hearing to be conducted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents also raise some issues with regard to the practicalities and integrity of the evidence by AVL. I will deal with those separately.The interests of the administration of justice Section 47A(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) provides that the court may, for the purposes of any proceeding, direct or allow testimony to be given by video link, audio link or other appropriate means. Section 47C(1) of the Act provides that the court must not exercise that power unless the court is satisfied, essentially, that the courtroom or other place where the court is sitting is equipped with facilities that enable all eligible persons present in that courtroom or place to see and hear the remote witness and that the place at which the remote witness is located is equipped with facilities that enable all eligible persons present in that place to see and hear each eligible person who is present in the courtroom or other place where the court is sitting. Eligible persons are such persons as the court considers should be treated as eligible persons for the purpose of the proceeding: s 47C(6). I am satisfied with regard to the above matters. The evidence is that the relevant connection between the Court’s technology and that of Baker McKenzie in Shanghai is expected to work well with the contracted support of Law In Order. I also accept the submission that there is ample time between now and the hearing to ensure that any technical difficulties that there may be can be solved and that the system can be made to be stable and reliable. I respectfully agree with and adopt what was said by Flick J in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pirovic Enterprises Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 544 at [11], namely that in deciding whether or not to allow AVL evidence:The overriding consideration must, however, forever remain what is considered by the Court to be in the best interests in the administration of justice, including the need to ensure that justice is done as between the parties. His Honour also said (at [11]) that the exercise of the discretion conferred by s 47A(1) of the Act must unquestionably be guided by the facts and circumstances of the individual case in which permission is sought to adduce evidence by way of AVL. I also respectfully agree with and adopt what was said by Jackson J in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Wilson[2020] FCA 873 at [36] that the process of deliberation required in order to exercise the s 47A(1) discretion properly is accurately described as a balancing exercise. In this particular case there are a number of key factors to consider.The PRC approval issue First, there is the question of whether it is lawful under PRC law for the witnesses to give evidence by AVL from the PRC and, if not, what effect that has on the proceeding in this Court. This is the respondents’ principal objection to leave being granted. They submit that the AVL evidence is unlawful, or at least has not been shown to be lawful, with the result that the oath or affirmation will not bind the witnesses to telling the truth in the sense of a criminal sanction being available in the event that they do not tell the truth.