Scarpello and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Scarpello and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2017] AATA 1410 (6 September 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2015/0658

Re:Silvana Scarpello

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date:6 September 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal varies the decision under review with respect to the diagnosis of the claimed employment related conditions to reflect the medical evidence and opinion but otherwise affirms the decision under review.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – postal delivery officer – right arm pain and paraesthesia – C6/7 cervical disc prolapse – questionable radiculopathy – questionable right elbow extensor tendonitis – right shoulder pathology – divergent expert opinion – symptomatic improvement with the passage of time – return to work at greater hours than pre-injury – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey [2001] FCA 266
Carney v Newton (2006) TASSC 4
Casarotto v Australian Postal Commission (1989) 17 ALD 321
Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd and Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626
Kelman and Prosegur Australia Pty Ltd (2014) 145 ALD 692
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

6 September 2017

  1. Ms Scarpello has been employed as a postal delivery officer with Australia Post since March 2008. On 25 March 2013 she developed pain and paraesthesia in the right forearm and wrist while sorting and throwing off sequence mail. Liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) while originally denied was accepted for right shoulder sub-acromial bursitis, right trapezius muscle tenderness and mild right lateral epicondylitis on 31 July 2013. Following further investigation and medical opinion, liability as above was ceased and by a reviewable decision dated 17 July 2014, s 14 liability and s 16 and s 19 compensation were accepted in respect of neck and right arm symptoms arising from an aggravation pre‑existing disc prolapse at C6/7 level. 

  2. On 12 November 2014 the Australian Postal Corporation (the respondent) ceased liability pursuant to s 16 and s 19 of the SRC Act. This determination was affirmed on 16 December 2014. On 12 February 2015 Ms Scarpello lodged her application for review of the decision by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

  3. At the hearing conducted over three days, the first being 24 May 2016 and second and third being in late November 2016 Ms Scarpello was represented by Mr Mark Carey of counsel, instructed by Maurice Blackburn, solicitors. The respondent was represented by Mr Peter Woulfe instructed by Ms Leanne Kellett, litigation officer of Australia Post. The Tribunal was provided with the documentation filed in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) and both parties tendered further reports and documents, a list of which is appended to this decision.  Ms Scarpello, Mr Michael Khan and Mr Vasudeva Pai gave evidence in person. 

    BACKGROUND TO THE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scarpello and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1410
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Ms Scarpello and the Australian Postal Corporation concerning a claim for workers' compensation. Ms Scarpello, a postal delivery officer, alleged she suffered injuries to her right shin, neck, and right upper limb during her employment. The Australian Postal Corporation had sought to cease compensation payments, leading to the matter being brought before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine the appropriate diagnosis of Ms Scarpello's claimed conditions, whether these conditions should be characterised as an "injury" (other than a disease) as defined by the relevant legislation, and if so, whether they arose out of or in the course of her employment. Furthermore, if the conditions were deemed an aggravation of a pre-existing condition, the Tribunal needed to ascertain if employment was a significant contributing factor.

The Tribunal reasoned that the initial presentation of symptoms on 25 March 2013, including right forearm pain and paraesthesia, minor lower back pain, and subsequent right shoulder and neck pain, constituted an injury other than a disease. This conclusion was informed by the diagnosis of trapezius muscle strain by the respondent's occupational health physician, Dr Soliman, and further investigations and opinions from other medical experts. The Tribunal found that these conditions met the criteria of section 5A(1)(b) of the relevant Act, signifying an injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing conducted over three days, the first being 24 May 2016 and second and third being in late November 2016 Ms Scarpello was represented by Mr Mark Carey of counsel, instructed by Maurice Blackburn, solicitors. The respondent was represented by Mr Peter Woulfe instructed by Ms Leanne Kellett, litigation officer of Australia Post. The Tribunal was provided with the documentation filed in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) and both parties tendered further reports and documents, a list of which is appended to this decision. Ms Scarpello, Mr Michael Khan and Mr Vasudeva Pai gave evidence in person. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Ms Scarpello commenced employment as a postal delivery officer with Australia Post on or about 12 March 2008 and after achieving permanent status worked from the Mount Waverley Delivery Centre. On 30 December 2009, Ms Scarpello was involved in a minor collision with a motor vehicle. She had been travelling at a speed she considered to be about 15 kilometres per hour, was knocked off the motorbike and suffered a laceration to her right shin. She was seen by Dr Paul Malloy on the same day. She required the application of steri-strips and was given a tetanus booster shot. Workers’ compensation was claimed. She was off work for two days. In her statement of 28 October 2016, Ms Scarpello said she started having neck pain some weeks after this accident and had first noticed the pain while delivering mail on the motorbike. She has retrospectively provided information that her neck pain became progressively worse in 2011 and 2012. Her incident report of 25 March 2013 did not mention any past neck pain. On 25 March 2013, Ms Scarpello experienced pain in her right upper limb while sorting mail preparatory to her delivery round. In the incident report completed on that date her symptoms were described as soreness in the right forearm, a feeling of weakness, numbness, tightness, tingling from the shoulders down to my wrist. Ms Scarpello had attributed her symptoms to the repetitive high speed task of sorting mail and also to riding the motorbike to deliver mail without breaks in either activity. She was seen by a facility nominated doctor, Dr Nguyen, who made a diagnosis of musculoskeletal pain and restricted her activities to working below shoulder height, no keyboarding, grasping or lifting more than 10 kilograms. Physiotherapy was recommended and the motorbike riding reduced from five to two hours per day. Ms Scarpello lodged an application for rehabilitation and compensation on 10 April 2013. She described her symptoms as pain and soreness in the forearm when throwing off but also included pain in the lower back. An appointment was arranged for her to see Dr Sam Soliman, an occupational health physician, who subsequently made a diagnosis of trapezius muscle strain on the right side. He advised avoidance of repetitive movement of the right upper limb and forceful gripping and imposed a lifting restriction of eight kilograms.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Based on the contents of Mr Haig’s report of 24 October 2014, the respondent determined to give notice of intention to cease compensation payments. This was confirmed by the reconsideration delegate on 16 December 2014 and the parties were advised on 18 December 2014.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL In her evidence before the Tribunal Ms Scarpello confirmed that her normal working hours had been 40 hours and 38 minutes per week prior to her injury with 36 hours and 45 minutes being ordinary time and the extra hours reflecting overtime. Since November 2015, she has been working her normal hours of 40 hours and 38 minutes and had in fact exceeded these hours on several occasions. While she could not recall exactly how much she had received in the form of weekly payments for time off work she did not challenge the figures produced by the respondent. She confirmed that her major symptom was pain in her neck to the right of the mid-line and that the pain in her neck and forearm had been aggravated by her work requiring motorcycle riding. The repetitive duties of sequencing mail if undertaken for more than two hours aggravated the pain. In contrast she had not noticed any aggravation of her symptoms arising from her household duties. Ms Scarpello had a motorbike for her personal use but stopped riding it, other than for very short distances in order to keep the engine in good condition and the battery fully charged. She had found that wearing a helmet increased her neck pain. She sold her motorbike in 2015. Ms Scarpello said that she had been pain free except for a mild right shoulder ache since March of 2015. She was now capable of doing a full range of sorting at all heights and had no restrictions placed on her activities. She continued to have restrictions on her hours of motorbike deliveries. In relation to the surveillance video Ms Scarpello agreed that she had performed the actions seen in the footage. In cross-examination, Mr Woulfe took Ms Scarpello through all of her medical examinations and reports confirming that the various histories given, albeit varying in content, were correct. Ms Scarpello was asked to explain her use of the word inflamed in relation to her thoracic spine and her right elbow. This she said was based on her reading of a book on human anatomy and her study of the muscles of the human body. She denied she had any pain in her upper arm and indicated that all the pain she had experienced had been on the radial aspect of her forearm. Ms Scarpello agreed that she had kept a diary of her symptoms commencing at the time of lodgement of her claim for compensation. Ms Scarpello could not recall all the details of every consultation and in particular those with Dr Li including whether she had asked him to provide only those letters that supported her claim. Ms Scarpello refuted Mr Woulfe’s suggestion that she had doctor shopped, there being evidence from the summonsed documents that she had endeavoured to see several general practitioners. Ms Scarpello explained that she had tried to consult other general practitioners because her general practitioner, Dr Canizzo, only saw patients in the mornings which meant she would have to take time off from work to see him.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Woulfe referred to earlier studies quoted in the Journal of Spinal Disorder, United States Military Report. While the Tribunal notes these results they are not relevant to this matter. The study of Kelsey had shown that there was a relatively strong association with the lifting of heavy objects and a modest association with playing golf. With reference to the article entitled the Incidence, Epidemiology of Cervical Radiculopathy in the United States Military, Mr Woulfe noted the conclusions that age was the greatest risk factor as was female sex, white race and senior military positions. It was reported that army and air force services had a higher incidence of radiculopathy in contrast to the navy and marines who had a low incidence. Mr Woulfe concluded that these scientific articles supported Mr Pai’s opinion but not that of Mr Khan. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS AND DECISION The parties have identified the issues before the Tribunal as being:·what is the appropriate diagnosis of the claimed condition;·should this condition be characterised as an ailment or an injury (other than a disease); and·as a result of those determinations if it is an injury and not a disease, did it arise out of or in the course of employment;·if it is an aggravation of a pre-existing condition was employment a significant contributing factor or was the pre-existing condition aggravated to a significant degree by the applicant’s employment. The Tribunal agrees that these are the essential issues, particularly in relation to characterisation of the condition as an ailment or injury as defined in the SRC Act. All other considerations are dependent upon this determination including the compensability or otherwise of the claimed injuries and the duration of such compensation.What is the appropriate diagnosis of the claimed conditions and are they an Injury or an Ailment as defined in the Act? In determining the character of the claimed condition, the Tribunal is reliant on the medical assessments and reports of both the treating doctors and the independent medical experts. In Ms Scarpello’s case these have been provided over a period of three and a half years during which time her signs and symptoms have changed or fluctuated as has the interpretation of the relevant radiological imaging. The Tribunal decides that the initial presentation of 25 March 2013 with right forearm pain and paraesthesia, minor lower back pain and the subsequent recording of right shoulder and neck pain was an injury (other than a disease). This conclusion is based on the diagnosis by Australia Post’s occupational health physician, Dr Solomon, of trapezius muscle strain and after further investigation with ultrasounds of the right elbow and the right shoulder and opinions from Dr Li, rheumatologist, Dr Oakes, orthopaedic physician, and Dr Muirden, rheumatologist, all of which took place between March and July 2013 the diagnoses of right lateral epicondylitis, right sub-acromial bursitis and right trapezius muscle tenderness problem, while poorly worded in medical terminology, meet the criteria of s 5A(1)(b) being an injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment.