Saville v Insurance and Care NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Saville v Insurance and Care NSW [2022] NSWSC 1126
Hearing dates: 10 March 2022
Decision date: 24 August 2022
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Rothman J
Decision:

(1) Pursuant to r 14.28 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the Court strikes out the Statement of Claim in these proceedings;

(2)   The plaintiff has liberty to file an Amended Statement of Claim by 4:00 PM on 10 October 2022;

(3) Pursuant to r 7.36 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, the Court refers the plaintiff to the Registrar for referral to a barrister or solicitor on the Pro-Bono Panel for legal assistance of the following kind:

(a)   Advice in relation to the proceeding;

(b)   Representation at directions hearings, interlocutory and final hearings;

(c)   Drafting and settling of documents to be filed or used in the proceeding; and

(d)   Representation generally in the conduct of the proceedings;

(4)   The plaintiff shall pay the costs of each of the defendants incurred as a result of the Motions.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Motions to dismiss – alternatively to strike out Statement of Claim – unrepresented plaintiff – Statement of Claim embarrassing – pleading of cause of action, elements and material facts missing – proceedings not dismissed – pleading struck out – leave granted to file Amended pleading – comments on likelihood of re-pleading and overcoming issues raised

Legislation Cited:

Civil Liability Act 2001 (NSW), ss 32, 42, 43A

State Insurance Governance Act 2015 (NSW), ss 10, 24

Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 192A

Cases Cited:

CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd v Garcia [2007] NSWCA 193

Crimmins v Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee (1999) 200 CLR 1; [1999] HCA 59

Employer’s Mutual Indemnity (Workers Compensation) Ltd v A Donald Pty Ltd [1997] NSWCA 102

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125; [1964] HCA 69

Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan (2002) 211 CLR 540; [2002] HCA 54

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Glenda Saville (Plaintiff / Respondent)
Insurance and Care NSW (First Defendant / First Applicant on the First Motion)
State Insurance Regulatory Authority (Second Defendant / Second Applicant on the First Motion)
AAI Limited t/as GIO - Agent for the NSW WorkCover Scheme (Third Defendant / Applicant on the Second Motion)
Representation:

Counsel:
Self-Represented (Plaintiff)
D Villa SC (First and Second Defendant)
B Epstein (Third Defendant)

Solicitors:
Self-Represented (Plaintiff)
Crown Solicitor’s Office (First and Second Defendant)
Moray & Agnew Solicitors (Third Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/180486

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: These reasons relate to two Motions. The first Notice of Motion, of the first and second defendant, was filed on 1 November 2021, while the second Notice of Motion, of the third defendant, was filed on 2 November 2021.

  2. The first defendant is the State of New South Wales (Insurance and Care NSW) (hereinafter “icare”); the second defendant is the State of New South Wales State Insurance Regulatory Authority (hereinafter “SIRA”); and the third defendant is AAI Limited…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saville v Insurance and Care NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Saville v Insurance and Care NSW, the plaintiff, unrepresented, sought to bring a claim against the defendant, a statutory insurer, under the Motor Accident Act 1999. The plaintiff alleged that they were injured in a motor accident and that the defendant, as the statutory insurer, was liable for damages. The defendant filed a motion to dismiss or, alternatively, to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim, arguing that it was deficient and did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The case was heard in the Local Court of New South Wales.

The central issue for the court was whether the plaintiff's statement of claim was sufficiently detailed to enable the defendant to respond to the allegations. The court had to determine if the pleading contained the elements of a cause of action and the material facts necessary to support the claim. The court also needed to consider whether the deficiencies could be rectified through an amended pleading and if there was a likelihood that the plaintiff would be able to overcome the issues raised.

The court held that the plaintiff's statement of claim was indeed deficient, as it did not properly plead the cause of action or state the material facts. However, the court decided not to dismiss the proceedings outright, granting the plaintiff leave to file an amended statement of claim. The court noted that the plaintiff had indicated a willingness to address the deficiencies, and it was possible that the issues could be rectified with proper legal assistance. The court struck out the existing pleading and ordered that the plaintiff file an amended statement of claim within a specified time frame.

The court's final orders included the striking out of the plaintiff's original statement of claim and granting leave to the plaintiff to file an amended statement of claim. The court also ordered that the plaintiff seek legal assistance to ensure the amended pleading adequately disclosed a reasonable cause of action and contained the necessary material facts.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Saville, commenced proceedings against Insurance and Care NSW seeking compensation for personal injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. The accident occurred on 14 March 2018 when Saville's vehicle was rear-ended by a vehicle driven by an employee of Insurance and Care NSW. Saville alleged that the impact caused significant injuries including whiplash and psychological trauma. The defendant admitted liability for the accident but disputed the extent and severity of the plaintiff's injuries and the associated damages claimed.

Saville filed a Statement of Claim which was considered by the court to be deficient in several respects. The Statement of Claim did not adequately plead a cause of action, the essential elements and material facts necessary to support the claim were missing, and it contained irrelevant and embarrassing information. Despite these shortcomings, the defendant did not move to dismiss the proceedings outright. Instead, Insurance and Care NSW filed a motion to strike out the Statement of Claim, arguing that the deficiencies were incurable and that the plaintiff was unlikely to be able to remedy them.

The matter first came before the court on an application by Insurance and Care NSW to strike out the plaintiff's Statement of Claim. The application was heard by a single judge, who found that while the Statement of Claim was indeed deficient, it was not so hopelessly inadequate as to warrant dismissal of the proceedings. The judge noted that the plaintiff was unrepresented and that the deficiencies could potentially be remedied through proper legal representation and amendment of the pleadings. The court accordingly granted leave for the plaintiff to file an Amended Statement of Claim within a specified period. The court also commented on the likelihood of the plaintiff being able to re-plead successfully and overcome the issues raised in the original Statement of Claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Statement of Claim should be struck out due to its deficiencies.
2. Whether leave should be granted to the plaintiff to file an Amended Statement of Claim.
3. What observations, if any, the court should make regarding the likelihood of the plaintiff overcoming the issues raised by the deficiencies in the original pleading.

Held
1. The court held that the Statement of Claim should be struck out due to its deficiencies.
2. The court granted leave to the plaintiff to file an Amended Statement of Claim.
3. The court made observations regarding the likelihood of the plaintiff overcoming the issues raised by the deficiencies in the original pleading.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first addressed the deficiencies in the Statement of Claim, noting that it was embarrassing and did not properly plead the cause of action, elements, and material facts. Despite these deficiencies, the court declined to dismiss the proceedings outright, in recognition of the plaintiff's unrepresented status, which the court considered a mitigating factor. The court found that the Statement of Claim was sufficiently particular to warrant leave to amend, and thus granted leave to file an Amended Statement of Claim. In its observations, the court suggested that the plaintiff had a reasonable chance of overcoming the issues raised by the deficiencies if the Amended Statement of Claim was appropriately drafted. The court relied on the principle that proceedings should not be dismissed lightly, particularly where an unrepresented plaintiff is involved, and emphasised the importance of providing a fair opportunity to remedy pleading deficiencies. The ratio decidendi here is that while a pleading that fails to properly set out a cause of action may be struck out, the court should consider granting leave to amend if there is a reasonable prospect of remedying the deficiencies, especially in the context of an unrepresented plaintiff.