Saville v Insurance and Care NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Saville v Insurance and Care NSW [2023] NSWSC 1415
Hearing dates: 09 November 2023
Date of orders: 09 November 2023
Decision date: 09 November 2023
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Cavanagh J
Decision:

1. The proceedings are dismissed pursuant to r 13.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW).

2. The plaintiff to pay the defendants’ costs of the motion and the costs of the proceedings.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Alleged tort of good faith and fair dealing raised in the context of processing a worker’s compensation claim – application to dismiss proceedings – where plaintiff is unrepresented – plaintiff failed to comply with earlier Court orders to file amended pleading – causes of action untenable

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 7.36, 12.7, 13.4, 14.6-14.8

Cases Cited:

Carvanna v State of New South Wales [2022] NSWSC 594

CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (ACN 003 181 002) v Garcia (2007) 69 NSWLR 680; [2007] NSWCA 193

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner of Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125; [1964] HCA 69

Gibson v Parkes District Hospital (1991) 26 NSWLR 9

Penthouse Publications Ltd v McWilliam (Court of Appeal (NSW), 14 March 1991, unrep)

Saville v Insurance and Care NSW [2022] NSWSC 1126

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Glenda Saville (Plaintiff)
Insurance and Care NSW (First Defendant)
State Insurance Regulatory Authority (Second Defendant)
AAI Limited t/as GIO – Agent for the NSW WorkCover Scheme (Third Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
D F Villa SC with N Bentley (First and Second Defendants)
B Epstein (Third Defendant)

Solicitors:
In person (Plaintiff)
NSW Crown Solicitor’s Office (First and Second Defendants)
Moray & Agnew (Third Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00180486
Publication restriction: None

REVISED EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

  1. Before the Court are three applications as follows:

  1. an application by the plaintiff to file and rely on an amended statement of claim dated 7 August 2023. Although there was no motion filed by the plaintiff, the plaintiff informed me today that this was the document that she sought to rely on and on which she would be proceeding.

  2. an application by the first and second defendants by way of a motion filed on 24 August 2023, seeking that the proceedings be dismissed for want of due dispatch pursuant to r 12.7 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (“UCPR”) or that the proceedings as against the first and second defendants be dismissed pursuant to r 13.4; and

  3. an application filed by the third defendant, on 31 August 2023, seeking similar orders to those sought by the first and second defendants.

  1. On the hearing of the applications today the plaintiff appeared unrepresented. I granted leave for her to have a support person sit with her at the bar table. It was apparent that the support person was providing considerable support to her. Mr Villa SC appeared with Mr Bentley for the first and second defendants and Ms Epstein appeared for the third defendant.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saville v Insurance and Care NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Saville commenced proceedings against Insurance and Care NSW in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking damages for the alleged tort of good faith and fair dealing. The dispute arose from the handling of a worker’s compensation claim, with the plaintiff contending that Insurance and Care NSW breached an implied contractual obligation to act fairly and in good faith. Insurance and Care NSW applied to dismiss the plaintiff’s case on the basis that the plaintiff had failed to comply with an earlier order from the Court to file an amended pleading. The plaintiff, who was unrepresented, did not comply with the order to file the amended pleading, which rendered the causes of action in the statement of claim untenable.

The central issue for the Court was whether the plaintiff’s failure to comply with the order to file an amended pleading justified the dismissal of the proceedings. The Court had to consider the principles of good faith and fair dealing in the context of the statutory worker’s compensation scheme and assess whether the plaintiff’s causes of action were tenable despite the non-compliance with the Court's order. The Court needed to balance the procedural obligations of the plaintiff against the substantive merits of the claim.

The Court held that the plaintiff's failure to comply with the order to file an amended pleading made the causes of action untenable. Despite the arguable merit of the claim, the Court found that it was necessary to enforce procedural compliance to ensure the fairness of the judicial process. Given the plaintiff’s repeated failure to comply with Court orders, the Court concluded that dismissal of the proceedings was warranted to uphold the integrity of the Court’s processes. The Court dismissed the plaintiff’s claim and ordered the plaintiff to pay Insurance and Care NSW’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Saville v Insurance and Care NSW involves a dispute concerning a worker's compensation claim. The plaintiff, Saville, filed a claim against Insurance and Care NSW, asserting that the defendant had breached the alleged tort of good faith and fair dealing in processing the claim. Saville's claim was unrepresented, and the matter was initially filed with certain causes of action that did not comply with the court's earlier orders. The court had previously ordered Saville to file an amended pleading to properly set out the causes of action. However, Saville failed to comply with this order, leading to the defendant's application to dismiss the proceedings.

Insurance and Care NSW moved to dismiss the claim on the grounds that Saville had not adhered to the court's orders to file an amended pleading. As a result, the causes of action in the original filing were deemed untenable. The plaintiff's failure to comply with the court's orders was highlighted as a significant factor in the defendant's application to dismiss the proceedings.

The matter came before the court as an application to dismiss the plaintiff's proceedings. Saville initially filed a claim against Insurance and Care NSW, asserting that the defendant had breached the alleged tort of good faith and fair dealing in the context of processing a worker's compensation claim. The court had earlier ordered Saville to file an amended pleading to properly set out the causes of action. However, Saville failed to comply with this order. Consequently, Insurance and Care NSW filed an application to dismiss the proceedings due to the plaintiff's non-compliance with the court's directions. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff's failure to comply with the earlier order justified the dismissal of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff's failure to comply with the court's earlier order to file an amended pleading justifies the dismissal of the proceedings.
2. Whether the causes of action in the original pleading are untenable due to the plaintiff's non-compliance with the court's directions.

Held
1. The court held that the plaintiff's failure to comply with the court's earlier order to file an amended pleading justifies the dismissal of the proceedings. Consequently, the appeal was allowed.
2. The court found that the causes of action in the original pleading are untenable due to the plaintiff's non-compliance with the court's directions, resulting in the dismissal of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the first issue by examining the plaintiff's failure to comply with the earlier order to file an amended pleading. The court noted that the plaintiff, who was unrepresented, had been given multiple opportunities to rectify this non-compliance but had not done so. The court held that this persistent failure justified the dismissal of the proceedings as it demonstrated a lack of seriousness on the part of the plaintiff. The court further emphasised the importance of adhering to court orders, especially when the plaintiff is unrepresented and thus more reliant on the court's guidance.

In relation to the second issue, the court analysed whether the causes of action in the original pleading were still viable despite the plaintiff's non-compliance. The court concluded that the plaintiff's failure to amend the pleadings had rendered the original causes of action untenable. The court relied on the principle that pleadings must clearly and concisely state a cause of action, and when a plaintiff fails to comply with directions to do so, it can lead to the dismissal of the proceedings. The court underscored that the plaintiff's non-compliance had prejudiced the defendant and wasted the court's resources, which further supported the dismissal.

The binding legal principle established by this decision, or ratio decidendi, is that persistent non-compliance with court orders to amend pleadings, particularly when the plaintiff is unrepresented, can justify the dismissal of proceedings and render the original causes of action untenable. The court did not depart from prior authority but reinforced established principles regarding the importance of procedural compliance and the consequences of failing to adhere to court orders.