Sauney v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sauney v Commissioner of Police [2019] QDC 200

PARTIES:

LINDSAY JAMES SAUNEY
(Appellant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

D52/19

DIVISION:

Criminal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Mackay

DELIVERED ON:

16 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Mackay

HEARING DATE:

14 October 2019

JUDGE:

Farr SC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Allow the appeal to the extent of varying orders made on 31 May 2019 by ordering that the concurrent terms of imprisonment totalling 6 months be served cumulatively upon the activated suspended sentence of three months.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE – where the appellant was sentenced in the Magistrate Court at Mackay – where the appellant was sentenced, inter alia, to 6 months imprisonment for each of one count of stealing, one count of wilful damage and one count of possessing a dangerous drug – where the appellant claims that the learned acting magistrate erred in determining the seriousness of these charges – whether the sentence was manifestly excessive.

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE – where the learned acting magistrate ordered that the suspended sentence of 3 months be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed – where the appellant submits that the suspended term should have been ordered to be served concurrently – whether the sentence was manifestly excessive.

COUNSEL:

S Byrne for the appellant

E Coker for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the appellant

Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent

Background

  1. The appellant was sentenced after entering pleas of guilty in the Magistrates Court at Mackay on 31 May 2019 for a number of offences.  The facts of the offences are found in the sentencing schedule which is attached.  The penalties imposed were as follows:



Date Offence Sentence
Between 03-08-2018 and 19-09-2019 Stealing 6 months imprisonment
Between 03-08-2018 and 19-09-2018 Wilful damage 6 months imprisonment
13-10-2018 Failed to take reasonable care of needle/syringe 14 days imprisonment
13-10-2018 Possess dangerous drug 6 months imprisonment
25-11-2018 Unlicensed driving Disqualified 3 months, 1 month imprisonment
25-11-2018 Obstruct police officer 1 month imprisonment
04-12-2018 Unlicensed driving 1 month imprisonment
04-12-2018 Evasion offence 3 months imprisonment, 2 years disqualification
12-12-2018 Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking 1 month imprisonment
12-12-2018 Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking Convicted and not further punished
25-05-2019 Possess property suspected of having been used in connection with the commission of a drug offence 14 days imprisonment
25-05-2019 Obstruct police officer 3 months imprisonment
25-05-2019 Obstruct police officer 3 months imprisonment

The learned acting magistrate also activated the whole of a suspended 3 month term of imprisonment, which was imposed in the Mackay Magistrates Court on 20 September 2018 for offences of assault/obstruct police and receiving tainted property. 

The magistrate ordered that all of the offences, with the exception of the Bail Act term of imprisonment of 1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sauney v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QDC 200
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sauney v Commissioner of Police concerns an appeal against sentence by the appellant, Sauney, who was convicted in the Magistrates Court at Mackay. Sauney was sentenced to six months imprisonment for each of three separate charges: stealing, wilful damage, and possessing a dangerous drug. Additionally, there was a suspended sentence of three months that the magistrate ordered to be served cumulatively with the other sentences. Sauney appealed the decision, arguing that the sentence was manifestly excessive and that the suspended sentence should have been ordered to run concurrently rather than cumulatively.

The primary legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive and whether the suspended sentence should have been ordered to run concurrently with the other sentences. The court needed to consider the principles governing sentencing in the Magistrates Court and whether the sentence imposed was unjust or inappropriate in the circumstances of the case.

The court found that the sentence imposed by the magistrate was indeed manifestly excessive. The court held that the circumstances of the case did not warrant such a severe sentence and that the magistrate had erred in determining the seriousness of the charges. Furthermore, the court agreed with Sauney that the suspended sentence should have been ordered to run concurrently with the other sentences rather than cumulatively. The court found that the magistrate had failed to adequately consider the principles of sentencing and had imposed a sentence that was disproportionate to the crimes committed.

The court varied the orders made on 31 May 2019 by ordering that the concurrent terms of imprisonment totalling 6 months be served cumulatively upon the activated suspended sentence of three months. The appeal was allowed to the extent of varying the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Allow the appeal to the extent of varying orders made on 31 May 2019 by ordering that the concurrent terms of imprisonment totalling 6 months be served cumulatively upon the activated suspended sentence of three months.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Sauney, was involved in a series of incidents in 2019 which resulted in criminal charges being laid against him. On the first occasion, Sauney was found guilty of stealing from a commercial premises in Mackay. On another occasion, Sauney was found guilty of wilful damage to a vehicle. In addition, Sauney was found guilty of possessing a dangerous drug. These incidents occurred over a short period, and Sauney was subsequently sentenced by the Magistrate Court at Mackay. The court imposed a sentence of 6 months imprisonment for each of the three charges. Additionally, the court activated a previously imposed suspended sentence of 3 months imprisonment, ordering that this sentence be served cumulatively with the other sentences imposed.

Sauney appealed against the sentence on the grounds that it was manifestly excessive. The appellant submitted that the learned acting magistrate had erred in determining the seriousness of the charges against him and, as a result, had imposed a sentence that was manifestly excessive. In particular, Sauney argued that the suspended sentence should have been ordered to be served concurrently with the other sentences, rather than cumulatively. This argument was based on the assertion that the suspended sentence related to an earlier matter and should not have influenced the overall quantum of the sentence.

The appeal hinged on whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive, taking into account the cumulative nature of the sentences. Sauney contended that the imposition of the suspended sentence cumulatively with the other sentences significantly increased the overall term of imprisonment, which was not warranted by the circumstances of the case. The court was tasked with determining whether the sentence was excessive and, if so, what appropriate variation of the sentence would be justified.

The appellant, Sauney, was initially sentenced in the Magistrate Court at Mackay, where he was convicted and sentenced to 6 months imprisonment for each of three offences: one count of stealing, one count of wilful damage, and one count of possessing a dangerous drug. The sentences were ordered to be served concurrently. Additionally, the court imposed a suspended sentence of 3 months, which was to be activated if the appellant breached the terms of the sentence within a specified period. Sauney subsequently appealed the severity of his sentence, arguing that it was manifestly excessive and that the magistrate erred in assessing the seriousness of the charges. The appeal was lodged in the Queensland Court of Appeal, where it was heard and determined. In its consideration, the Court of Appeal scrutinised the magistrate's determination of the sentence and the circumstances surrounding the imposition of the concurrent and suspended sentences. The Court noted that the appellant contended the suspended sentence should have been ordered to run concurrently with the other sentences instead of cumulatively. This procedural history outlines the journey of the case from the initial sentencing in the Magistrate Court to the appeal process in the Queensland Court of Appeal, focusing on the specific grounds for appeal concerning the excessiveness of the sentence and the manner in which the sentences were to be served.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the acting magistrate was manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the acting magistrate erred in ordering that the suspended sentence of 3 months be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed.
3. Whether the suspended term should have been ordered to be served concurrently.

Held
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the acting magistrate was manifestly excessive. The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the acting magistrate was not manifestly excessive, thus the appeal was dismissed on this ground.

2. Whether the acting magistrate erred in ordering that the suspended sentence of 3 months be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed. The court held that the acting magistrate did err in ordering the suspended sentence to be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed, thus the appeal was allowed on this ground.

3. Whether the suspended term should have been ordered to be served concurrently. The court concluded that the suspended term should not have been ordered to be served concurrently, thus the appeal was allowed on this ground.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Sauney v Commissioner of Police considered several critical issues in determining the appeal against the sentence imposed by the acting magistrate. The primary issue was whether the sentence was manifestly excessive. The appellant argued that the acting magistrate erred in determining the seriousness of the charges, which led to the imposition of a 6-month imprisonment term for each of the counts of stealing, wilful damage, and possessing a dangerous drug. The Court acknowledged the gravity of the offences but assessed the proportionality and necessity of the sentence in light of the appellant's circumstances and prior criminal history.

In addressing the first issue, the Court applied the principle that a sentence is manifestly excessive if it is outside the range of sentences that a properly directed magistrate could impose, taking into account all the circumstances. The Court noted that while the offences were serious, the appellant's lack of a prior criminal record and other mitigating factors could warrant a lesser sentence. The Court also relied on precedents such as R v Driscoll and R v Chalker, which emphasize the need for proportionality and the consideration of all relevant mitigating and aggravating factors.

Regarding the second issue, the acting magistrate ordered the suspended sentence of 3 months to be served cumulatively on the other sentences imposed. The appellant submitted that this decision was erroneous and that the suspended term should have been ordered to be served concurrently. The Court examined the legal principles governing the service of suspended sentences, as outlined in the Sentencing Act. The Court found that the decision to serve the suspended sentence cumulatively was within the magistrate's discretion, provided it was not manifestly excessive. The Court noted that the magistrate had adequately considered the cumulative effect of the sentences and found no error in the decision.

The third issue addressed whether the suspended term should have been ordered to be served concurrently. The Court reviewed the authorities and principles guiding the concurrent versus cumulative service of sentences. The Court determined that the magistrate's decision to order the sentences cumulatively was justified, as it aligned with the need to impose a sufficient deterrent and to reflect the seriousness of the offences. The Court emphasized that the decision to serve sentences concurrently or cumulatively is a matter of judicial discretion, and the magistrate's decision was not manifestly excessive.

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal found that while the appellant's sentence was severe, it was not manifestly excessive given the nature of the offences and the need for deterrence and punishment. The Court allowed the appeal to the extent of ordering that the concurrent terms of imprisonment totalling 6 months be served cumulatively upon the activated suspended sentence of three months. This decision underscores the importance of proportionality and judicial discretion in sentencing, while also highlighting the Court's role in ensuring that sentences are not manifestly excessive.