DISTRICT COURT
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
JUDGE DICK SC
No 16 of 2009
| ALAN MARK FISHER | Appellant |
| and | |
| NEIL ANTHONY HANSEN | Respondent |
| BRISBANE ..DATE 15/06/2009 | |
| ORDER |
1-1
| HER HONOUR: This is an appeal against a sentence in respect | 1 |
| of two sentences, both imposed in the Richlands Magistrates Court. The first sentence was imposed on the 11th of December 2008, and was a sentence in respect of one count of wilful damage of a Corrective Services facility and one count of |
10
breach of a suspended sentence in respect of a sentence
imposed in June 2008. The second sentence was imposed on the
18th of March 2009 in respect of wilful damage of Corrective
Services property. That appeal was made orally here today.
20
In relation to the sentence on the 11th of December 2008, it
is my view that the Magistrate acted upon a wrong principle in
failing to take into account two important principles of
sentencing, one being totality, and the other is - the other
being the fact that a crushing sentence should not be imposed.
30
He cumulated the sentences not only on the present sentence but on each other and I do not think that that was necessary nor do I think it was a proper exercise of his discretion.
If he or she had applied the appropriate principles then in my
40
view the sentence should have been, for the wilful damage, a
sentence of six months cumulative on the present sentence.
There would be no argument that three months of the suspended
sentence should be imposed but in my view that should have
been activated immediately and be served concurrently with the
50
sentence for the wilful damage.
The second appeal comes about because the wrongful sentences
imposed in December were then the basis of the sentences in
1-2 ORDER 60
| March and the sentence in March was a three months cumulative | 1 |
| sentence. There can not be any argument that that was manifestly excessive or erroneous because that occurred shortly after the December sentence, but parole eligibility dates were affected because the magistrate added three months |
10
to the then existing parole eligibility date. As I am about practical effect for the appellant unless I deal with the ones in March.
to change that parole eligibility date, the appeal on the
20
So, my orders are as follows. The appeals in respect of both sentences are allowed. In respect - I will just go back a step. The appellant has a relatively long history. A lot of it is street offences. He has some moderately serious
30
property offences but really - and one serious offence of
indecent treatment of a child along with a deprivation of
liberty - but much of his present situation has been brought
about by his behaviour in custody. He has now been
incarcerated since the 14th of April 2007 and is currently
40
serving a total period of four years and two months and 13
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fisher v Hansen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] QDC 175
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate applied the correct sentencing principles and whether the sentences were manifestly excessive or erroneous. The court had to determine if the cumulative sentencing was appropriate and if the parole eligibility dates were correctly calculated. The appeal was made on the basis that the Magistrate did not consider the totality of the sentences and the need to avoid a crushing sentence. The appellant also argued that the sentences imposed in December 2008 had an impact on the March 2009 sentence, leading to an incorrect parole eligibility date.
Judge Dick SC allowed both appeals, finding that the Magistrate had indeed applied a wrong principle in sentencing. The court held that the Magistrate should have imposed a six-month cumulative sentence for the wilful damage, served concurrently with the three-month activation of the suspended sentence. The parole eligibility date was set at 29 February 2009, and the full time discharge date was set at 30 December 2010. For the March 2009 sentence, the parole eligibility date was fixed at 29 March 2009, resulting in a full time discharge date of 31 March 2011. The court's decision addressed the errors in the original sentencing and corrected the parole eligibility dates accordingly.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case, Fisher v Hansen [2009] QDC 175, involves an appeal against two sentences imposed by the Richlands Magistrates Court. The appellant, Alan Mark Fisher, appealed both a sentence imposed on 11 December 2008 for wilful damage to a Corrective Services facility and breach of a suspended sentence, as well as a sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 for wilful damage of Corrective Services property. The appeal was heard in the District Court in its appellate jurisdiction. The appeal was filed following Fisher's argument that the sentences were imposed based on incorrect principles of sentencing, particularly concerning the principles of totality and the avoidance of crushing sentences. Fisher argued that the magistrate should have considered the sentences concurrently rather than cumulatively. The court agreed with Fisher, finding that the Magistrate had erred in imposing cumulative sentences and adjusted the sentences accordingly, allowing the appeal in both instances and modifying the parole eligibility dates.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Magistrate erred in failing to consider the principles of totality and avoiding a crushing sentence when imposing the sentence on 11 December 2008.
2. Whether the cumulative sentencing approach taken by the Magistrate for the offence on 11 December 2008 was a proper exercise of discretion.
3. Whether the three-month sentence for the breach of the suspended sentence should have been activated immediately and served concurrently with the sentence for the wilful damage.
4. Whether the appeal in respect of the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was valid given it was based on the wrongful sentences from December.
5. Whether the three-month cumulative sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was manifestly excessive or erroneous.
6. Whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 11 December 2008 were correctly ordered by the court.
7. Whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 were correctly ordered by the court.
Held
1. Whether the Magistrate erred in failing to consider the principles of totality and avoiding a crushing sentence when imposing the sentence on 11 December 2008.
The court concluded that the Magistrate did indeed err in not considering these principles. As a result, the appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. Whether the cumulative sentencing approach taken by the Magistrate for the offence on 11 December 2008 was a proper exercise of discretion.
The court held that the cumulative sentencing approach was not a proper exercise of the Magistrate's discretion. Consequently, the appeal was allowed on this issue.
3. Whether the three-month sentence for the breach of the suspended sentence should have been activated immediately and served concurrently with the sentence for the wilful damage.
The court concluded that the three-month sentence should have been activated immediately and served concurrently. The appeal was allowed, and the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
4. Whether the appeal in respect of the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was valid given it was based on the wrongful sentences from December.
The court found that the appeal was valid, as the wrongful sentences from December influenced the March sentence. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
5. Whether the three-month sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was manifestly excessive or erroneous.
The court concluded that the three-month sentence was not manifestly excessive or erroneous, but the parole eligibility date was affected. The appeal was allowed on this issue to rectify the parole eligibility date.
6. Whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 11 December 2008 were correctly ordered by the court.
The court concluded that the parole eligibility and full time discharge dates were incorrectly ordered and made new orders to set these dates.
7. Whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 were correctly ordered by the court.
The court concluded that the parole eligibility and full time discharge dates were incorrectly ordered and made new orders to set these dates.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The District Court Appellate in Fisher v Hansen addressed several significant sentencing issues arising from two sentences imposed by the Richlands Magistrates' Court. The first sentence, imposed on 11 December 2008, pertained to wilful damage and a breach of a suspended sentence, while the second sentence, imposed on 18 March 2009, related solely to wilful damage of corrective services property. The court's reasoning in this case involved a meticulous examination of the principles of sentencing, cumulative sentencing approaches, and the calculation of parole eligibility and full time discharge dates.
The court found that the Magistrate erred in failing to consider the principles of totality and avoiding a crushing sentence when imposing the sentence on 11 December 2008. The presiding judge highlighted that the Magistrate did not properly apply these principles, leading to a cumulative sentence that was excessive. The principle of totality dictates that the total punishment should not be disproportionate to the offences committed, while avoiding a crushing sentence ensures that the punishment does not unduly devastate the offender. The court concluded that had the Magistrate applied these principles correctly, the sentence for the wilful damage should have been six months cumulative on the present sentence, and the three months for the breach of the suspended sentence should have been activated immediately and served concurrently.
The second major issue was whether the cumulative sentencing approach taken by the Magistrate for the offence on 11 December 2008 was a proper exercise of discretion. The court found that the Magistrate's approach was not proper. The decision to cumulate sentences on each other was deemed unnecessary and an improper exercise of discretion. The court emphasized that the sentences should have been applied in a manner that adhered to the principles of sentencing, specifically the principle of totality and the avoidance of a crushing sentence. This error had practical implications, as it affected the calculation of the parole eligibility date and the full time discharge date.
The third issue addressed whether the three-month sentence for the breach of the suspended sentence should have been activated immediately and served concurrently with the sentence for the wilful damage. The court agreed that this was the correct approach. The immediate activation and concurrent serving of sentences would have ensured that the total punishment was proportionate and not unduly harsh. The court's decision to order concurrent sentences aimed at correcting the imbalance created by the original sentencing approach.
The fourth issue was whether the appeal in respect of the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was valid, given that it was based on the wrongful sentences from December. The court found that the appeal was valid. Although the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was not manifestly excessive or erroneous, the wrongful sentences from December had an impact on the calculation of parole eligibility and full time discharge dates. Therefore, the court needed to address these issues to ensure practical and fair outcomes for the appellant.
The fifth issue was whether the three-month cumulative sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 was manifestly excessive or erroneous. The court concluded that it was neither. The sentence was a proper response to the offence of wilful damage, though it was contingent on the earlier wrongful sentencing. The court's focus was on correcting the implications of the December sentencing errors.
The sixth issue involved whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 11 December 2008 were correctly ordered by the court. The court ordered a new parole eligibility date of 29 February 2009 and a full time discharge date of 30 December 2010, correcting the earlier miscalculated dates. The seventh and final issue was whether the parole eligibility date and full time discharge date for the sentence imposed on 18 March 2009 were correctly ordered by the court. The court set the new parole eligibility date as 29 March 2009, with a full time discharge date of 31 March 2011, thereby rectifying the dates based on the court's revised sentencing approach.
In summary, the court's decisions in this case underscore the importance of adhering to sentencing principles, particularly the principles of totality and avoiding a crushing sentence. The court meticulously addressed the errors in the original sentencing, ensuring that the revised sentences and associated dates were fair and practical. The ratio decidendi of this case is that sentencing decisions must be grounded in established principles, and any deviation from these principles requires correction to ensure just and proportionate sentencing outcomes.