Sarina v O'Shannassy (No 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 8) [2025] FedCFamC2G 1651

File number(s): SYG 1339 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE CAMERON
Date of judgment: 9 October 2025
Catchwords: DEFAMATION – assessment of damages  
Legislation:

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) ss. 33, 34, 35, 38

Defamation Amendment Act 2020 (NSW) sch 1 items 33, 34; sch 4, item 7

Cases cited:

Carson v John Fairfax and Sons Ltd (1993) 178 CLR 44

Hockey v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (2015)  237  FCR 33

Jameel v Dow Jones & Co Inc [2005] QB 946

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

O’Shannassy v Sarina (Appeal) [2024] FCA 880

Praed v Graham (1889) 24 QBD 53

Rush v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (No 7) [2019] FCA 496

Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 5) [2020] FCCA 2911

Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 6) [2020] FCCA 3422

Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 7) [2024] FedCFamC2G 102

Sarina v O’Shannassy [2021] FCA 1649

Division: General
Number of paragraphs: 43
Date of last submissions: 14 May 2024
Date of hearing: On the papers
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr C Bolger
Solicitor for the Applicants: Kalantizis Lawyers
Respondent: Appeared in person

ORDERS

SYG 1339 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

CLINTON SARINA

First Applicant

MARTIN GREEN

Second Applicant

AND:

JOHN O'SHANNASSY

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE CAMERON

DATE OF ORDER:

9 OCTOBER 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.There be judgment for the first applicant in the sum of $30,000 plus interest of $7,000.

2.There be judgment for the second applicant in the sum of $30,000 plus interest of $7,000.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 24.04(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2025 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 24.04 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2025 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE CAMERON

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicants, Mr Sarina and Mr Green, commenced this proceeding on 11 May 2018 alleging that the respondent, Mr O’Shannassy, had defamed them in an Email.  The procedural history of the matter is:

    (a)in their statement of claim filed on 11 May 2018, Messrs Sarina and Green alleged, relevantly, that they had been defamed by Mr O’Shannassy in the Email which he sent on 20 December 2017 to Andrew George and Bryan Coleman, directors of a company called Fleur de Vie Beverages Pty Ltd;

    (b)four interlocutory judgments were delivered by this Court over the duration of the action at first instance;

    (c)on 30 October 2020 the action was dismissed:  Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 5) [2020] FCCA 2911 (Liability Judgment);

    (d)on 17 December 2020 orders for costs were made:  Sarina v O’Shannassy (No 6) [2020] FCCA 3422;

    (e)the applicants appealed to the Federal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sarina v O'Shannassy (No 8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1651
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Sarina v O'Shannassy (No 8), the applicants sought damages for defamatory statements published by the respondent in an email. The allegations included claims of fraud, association with a standover man, and involvement in significant financial crimes. The trial judge found that the email conveyed serious and defamatory imputations about both applicants. The case was remitted to the court for a retrial limited to the assessment of damages. The applicants argued for substantial damages due to the impact of the defamatory statements on their reputations and business relationships. The respondent argued for lower damages, citing the limited audience and lack of economic loss.

The court considered various factors in determining the appropriate amount of damages. These included the seriousness of the defamatory imputations, the impact on the applicants' feelings and reputations, and the absence of any apology or correction from the respondent. The court found that the defamatory statements were actuated by malice and had caused significant emotional distress to the applicants. Given the nature of the defamatory imputations and the lack of mitigating factors, the court awarded each applicant $30,000 in damages, plus interest. This decision reflects the need for an appropriate and rational relationship between the harm sustained and the damages awarded, as mandated by the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

A notice published in the NSW Government Gazette No 224 of 6 June 2025, declared $500,000 to be the amount specified for the purposes of s.35(1) of the Defamation Act as from 1 July 2025.BACKGROUND In their amended statement of claim the applicants alleged that the Email contained defamatory matter which:… in its natural and ordinary meaning conveyed or was understood to have conveyed the following defamatory imputations:(1) The second applicant is under investigation by the legal services commissioner for fraud. The second Applicant had so conducted himself, as at 20 December 2017, that the Legal Services Commissioner had a reasonable suspicion that the second Applicant had engaged in fraud and was investigating him for that conduct;(2)The second applicant is a fraud;(3)The second applicant is one of standover man Michael McGurk's two closest confidants;(4) The second applicant was knowingly involved in a $150m loan fraud;(5) The second applicant has been charged with fraud;(6) The second applicant would have gone to gaol if he had given evidence at his fraud trial;(7) The second applicant is a fraudulent business man;(8) The first applicant is a fraud;(9) The first applicant is one of standover man Michael McGurk's two closest confidants;(10) The first applicant was knowingly involved in a $150m loan fraud;(11) The first applicant has been charged with fraud;(12) The first applicant is a fraudulent businessman;(13) The first applicant has further supreme court proceedings against him for fraud;(14) The first applicant went to gaol for 6 years. It was alleged that the defamatory material was read by the applicants as well as by Messrs George and Coleman with whom the applicants were seeking to go into business. The evidence indicates that the proposed business was the sale of bottled water through Fleur De Vie, in which Messrs George and Coleman were investors and of which they were directors and shareholders. The outcome of those allegations was tabulated in the Liability Judgment as follows: As Rares J recorded in the Appeal Judgment:15.The trial judge found that the matter complained of conveyed the following three common imputations about each of Mr Green and Mr Sarina, namely:(1)he was a fraud (imputations 2 and 8);(2)he is one of standover man, Mr McGurk’s two closest confidants (imputations 3 and 9); and(3)he is a fraudulent businessman (imputations 7 and 12).16In addition, his Honour found that the matter complained of conveyed the following separate imputations about, respectively, Mr Green and Mr Sarina:(4)Mr Green had so conducted himself, as at 20 December 2017, that the Legal Services Commissioner had a reasonable suspicion that the second Applicant [Mr Green] had engaged in fraud and was investigating him for that conduct (Imputation 1).(5)Mr Sarina has further supreme court proceedings against him for fraud (Imputation 13). Each of the imputations that was proven was found by the trial judge to have been serious and defamatory. Further, the trial judge found that the defamatory statements made in the Email had been actuated by malice as they had been made without proper support in terms of evidence or argument and had been propounded with the intention of embarrassing the applicants in the eyes of the directors of Fleur de Vie.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As recorded earlier, Rares J allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to this Court for a retrial limited to the assessment of damages. In that connexion his Honour observed:(a)damages were unlikely to be very large, publication of the defamation of each appellant having been to a limited audience of two, possibly three, other persons; (b)although there was likely to be evidence of hurt feelings and impugned reputations, there was no suggestion of economic loss or an ongoing commercial relationship between the appellants and Messrs Coleman and George; (c)nonetheless, this was not a case for nominal damages. Mr O’Shannassy’s imputations were very serious ones which he had sought unsuccessfully to justify at the trial. In this connexion at [99] his Honour cited Lord Esher MR’s statement in Praed v Graham (1889) 24 QBD 53 at 55 that: … the jury in assessing damages are entitled to look at the whole conduct of the defendant from the time the libel was published down to the time they give their verdict. They may consider what his conduct has been before action, after action, and in court during the trial;(d)the appellants were entitled to some damages for their hurt to feelings, their anxiety over the uncertainty of the trial, and the various meetings and discussions they had with people with whom they were in business arising out of Mr O’Shannassy’s allegations; (e)although not justifying aggravated damages, Mr O’Shannassy’s persistence in his failed defences could be taken into account in assessing general damages; and (f)together with damages for hurt feelings and anxiety surrounding the uncertainty of the trial, the appellants are entitled to compensation for further damage caused by Mr O’Shannassy’s conduct throughout the proceedings. EVIDENCE The parties relied on evidence that had been adduced at the trial and did not seek to lead or tender further evidence. ApplicantsMartin Green In his affidavit of 10 March 2020, Mr Green deposed to a conversation with Mr George and Mr Coleman in November 2017 concerning “serious allegations” that Mr O’Shannassy had made against him and Mr Sarina. Mr Green deposed that Mr George asked to meet with him and Mr Sarina which they did about a week later at which time Mr George had said words to the effect of:O’Shannassy says the two of you have been involved in fraud, that Clinton has been involved with McGurk and that Martin has been struck off as a solicitor. Mr Green deposed that both he and Mr Sarina had sought to refute those allegations but Mr Green had nevertheless been worried about what would happen to the project with Fleur de Vie. He felt sick, anxious and depressed. On about 21 December 2017 Mr Coleman sent him a copy of the Email which he had received from Mr O’Shannassy on 20 December 2017. On 21 December 2017 he received a call from Mr George who seemed to be treating him with suspicion. Mr George asked about the fraud matter and during the conversation Mr Green became lightheaded and felt ill. He was very embarrassed. After the telephone call he felt seriously ill and that night could not sleep. He became anxious and depressed and was very embarrassed to have to explain himself once more. He had been very upset by the allegations and between that call and Christmas, the worry and concern made it very difficult to sleep.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the circumstances of the publication of the defamatory statements, namely that they were found to have been actuated by malice and were not followed by an apology, justify an allowance for aggravated damages. CONCLUSION It is not apparent that the impact of the Email on one applicant has been greater than its impact on the other. Consequently, there will be:(a)judgment for the first applicant in the sum of $30,000; and(b)judgment for the second applicant in the sum of $30,000. The applicants are entitled to interest on those damages which I quantify at $7,000 in each case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) as it stood in 2018 applies in this case.[1] Relevantly, it provided:[1] Defamation Amendment Act 2020 (NSW) sch.1 items 33, 34; sch.4, item 734 Damages to bear rational relationship to harmIn determining the amount of damages to be awarded in any defamation proceedings, the court is to ensure that there is an appropriate and rational relationship between the harm sustained by the plaintiff and the amount of damages awarded. 35 Damages for non-economic loss limited(1) Unless the court orders otherwise under subsection (2), the maximum amount of damages for non-economic loss that may be awarded in defamation proceedings is $250,000 or any other amount adjusted in accordance with this section from time to time (the maximum damages amount) that is applicable at the time damages are awarded.(2) A court may order a defendant in defamation proceedings to pay damages for noneconomic loss that exceed the maximum damages amount applicable at the time the order is made if, and only if, the court is satisfied that the circumstances of the publication of the defamatory matter to which the proceedings relate are such as to warrant an award of aggravated damages.(3) The Minister is, on or before 1 July 2006 and on or before 1 July in each succeeding year, to declare, by order published in the Gazette, the amount that is to apply, as from the date specified in the order, for the purposes of subsection (1). …38 Factors in mitigation of damages(1) Evidence is admissible on behalf of the defendant, in mitigation of damages for the publication of defamatory matter, that:(a) the defendant has made an apology to the plaintiff about the publication of the defamatory matter, or(b) the defendant has published a correction of the defamatory matter, or(c) the plaintiff has already recovered damages for defamation in relation to any other publication of matter having the same meaning or effect as the defamatory matter, or(d) the plaintiff has brought proceedings for damages for defamation in relation to any other publication of matter having the same meaning or effect as the defamatory matter, or(e) the plaintiff has received or agreed to receive compensation for defamation in relation to any other publication of matter having the same meaning or effect as the defamatory matter.(2) Nothing in subsection (1) operates to limit the matters that can be taken into account by a court in mitigation of damages. A notice published in the NSW Government Gazette No 224 of 6 June 2025, declared $500,000 to be the amount specified for the purposes of s.35(1) of the Defamation Act as from 1 July 2025.BACKGROUND In their amended statement of claim the applicants alleged that the Email contained defamatory matter which:… in its natural and ordinary meaning conveyed or was understood to have conveyed the following defamatory imputations:(1) The second applicant is under investigation by the legal services commissioner for fraud. The second Applicant had so conducted himself, as at 20 December 2017, that the Legal Services Commissioner had a reasonable suspicion that the second Applicant had engaged in fraud and was investigating him for that conduct;(2)The second applicant is a fraud;(3)The second applicant is one of standover man Michael McGurk's two closest confidants;(4) The second applicant was knowingly involved in a $150m loan fraud;(5) The second applicant has been charged with fraud;(6) The second applicant would have gone to gaol if he had given evidence at his fraud trial;(7) The second applicant is a fraudulent business man;(8) The first applicant is a fraud;(9) The first applicant is one of standover man Michael McGurk's two closest confidants;(10) The first applicant was knowingly involved in a $150m loan fraud;(11) The first applicant has been charged with fraud;(12) The first applicant is a fraudulent businessman;(13) The first applicant has further supreme court proceedings against him for fraud;(14) The first applicant went to gaol for 6 years.