Sankey v Bollig

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sankey v Bollig [2021] FCCA 1096

File number(s): PEG 198 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 21 May 2021
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether leave to file further affidavit – whether proceedings to be adjourned

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – architects drawings – whether infringement of copyright – whether infringement of moral rights – whether licence to use – whether statutory presumptions apply – whether misleading and deceptive conduct

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2, s 18

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 115, 126A, 126B and 127

Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) ss 3 and 42

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 1.03

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175; 83 ALJR 951; 258 ALR 14

Beck v Montana Constructions (1963) 5 FLR 298; [1964-5] NSWR 229

Fair Work Ombudsman v Kentwood Industries Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 98

Myers v Myers [1969] WAR 19

MZZZL v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2014] FCCA 1309

Number of paragraphs: 27
Date of last submission/s: 17 May 2021
Date of hearing: 17 May 2021
Place: Perth
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr R J Price
Solicitor for the Applicant: Provan Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr D B Cox ad Mr R Edwards
Solicitor for the Applicant: DLA Piper Australia

ORDERS

PEG 198 of 2019
BETWEEN:

WAYNE MAURICE SANKEY

Applicant

AND:

EDWIN MICHAEL BOLLIG

First Respondent

BOLLIG DESIGN GROUP PTY LTD

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE LUCEV

DATE OF ORDER:

17 MAY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant have leave to further amend the Amended Application and Amended Statement of Claim as set out in the minute attached to the Applicant’s Minute of Proposed Orders dated 14 May 2021.

2.Counsel and solicitor for the Applicant be released from the Confidentiality Undertaking given by each of them, on 26 March 2021 and 18 March 2021 respectively, in relation to the documents identified therein, and to the extent it is necessary the Court will publish its reasons for this order in the final judgment.

3.The matter be adjourned part-heard:

(a)to a directions hearing on 21 May 2021 at 10.00am;

(b)otherwise for hearing on 30 and 31 August, and 1, 2, 3 September 2021.

4.Reasons for judgment made in relation to the adjournment be published from Chambers at a later date.

5.Costs of the adjournment be reserved

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE LUCEV

INTRODUCTION

  1. This judgment relates to an order made on 17 May 2021 adjourning the hearing of this matter to a further hearing commencing 30 August 2021 (“Adjournment Order”).

  2. In these proceedings the applicant, Mr Wayne Sankey (“Mr Sankey”), claims against the respondents, Edwin Michael Bollig and Bollig Design Group Pty Ltd (collectively “Bollig”), in broad terms, in relation to infringement of copyright under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (“Copyright Act”) infringement of moral rights under the Copyright Act, and misleading conduct…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sankey v Bollig and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1096
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this dispute were Mr Sankey and Bollig, who provided architectural services to Aureus Commercial for the Port Rockingham Marina Project. Mr Sankey alleged that Bollig had infringed his copyright in certain drawings, which he claimed were still in use. Bollig defended these claims by asserting a licence to use the drawings, the applicability of statutory presumptions under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), and that any infringement was innocent. Bollig also denied any misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The matter came before Lucev J in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether Bollig had a licence to use the Sankey drawings, whether the statutory presumptions regarding copyright subsistence and ownership under sections 126A, 126B, and 127(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) applied to Bollig's use, and whether any infringement of copyright by Bollig was innocent under section 115(3) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). Additionally, the Court was required to determine if Bollig had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law.

Due to the extensive procedural history and the need for further consideration of evidence, specifically concerning a proposed affidavit by Mr Sankey, the Court determined that an adjournment of the hearing was necessary. The Court noted that various parts of a proposed affidavit had been withdrawn or declared not relied upon, and it was not appropriate to grant leave to file it in its current form. The Court indicated that Mr Sankey might wish to consider filing a varied affidavit.

Consequently, on 17 May 2021, Lucev J ordered that the hearing be adjourned to a directions hearing on 21 May 2021, and the substantive hearing be adjourned to the week commencing 30 August 2021. The costs of the adjournment were reserved, to be determined after the primary issues in dispute had been adjudicated.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bollig provide architectural services to Aureus Commercial (“Aureus”) for the purposes of the Port Rockingham Marina Project, in relation to which it appears that the Infringing Drawings remain in use. By way of defence Bollig says that it has a licence to use the Sankey Drawings, that the statutory presumptions under ss 126A, 126B and 127(1) of the Copyright Act apply to its use of the Sankey Drawings, and that if copyright did subsist in the Sankey Drawings then any infringement was an innocent one under s 115(3) of the Copyright Act, and that there was no misleading conduct under the ACL.BACKGROUND The proceedings were commenced on 31 May 2019 when Mr Sankey filed an Originating Application and Statement of Claim. The Court notes that since then the matter has been the subject of ten sets of orders by Judge Baird between June 2019 and November 2020, three sets of orders by Judge Kendall between February 2021 and 5 May 2021, and two further sets of orders by Judge Lucev on 7 and 17 May 2021, and in particular that:(a)a Defence was to be filed and served by Bollig by 31 July 2019, and a Reply by Mr Sankey by 14 August 2019 (Orders 2 and 3, 18 June 2019);(b)discovery of agreed categories of documents was to have been completed by 22 November 2019 (Order 1, 6 November 2019);(c)Mr Sankey was to file and serve his evidence in chief by 20 December 2019 (Order 2, 6 November 2019);(d)Mr Sankey was originally to file and serve his evidence in reply by 24 April 2020 (Order 2, 29 January 2020), extended by consent to 3 June 2020 (Order 1, 5 May 2020);(e)Mr Sankey was to file and serve an Amended Originating Application and an Amended Statement of Claim, substantially in the form provided to the Court on 21 July 2020, and a Defence to the Amended Statement of Claim was to be filed and served by 5 August 2020, and a Reply by 19 August 2020 (Orders 4, 6 and 7, 22 July 2020);(f)Mr Sankey was to file and serve any additional affidavit evidence in chief in relation to the amendments to the pleadings by 2 September 2020 (Order 9, 22 July 2020);(g)Bollig was to file and serve any additional affidavits in answer by 30 September 2020 (Order 10, 22 July 2020), extended to 21 October 2020 (Order 1, 22 October 2020);(h)Mr Sankey was to file and serve any additional affidavit evidence in reply by 14 October 2020 (Order 11, 22 July 2020), extended to 4 November 2020 (Order 2, 22 October 2020);(i)Mr Sankey was to file and serve a consolidated index to the proposed tender bundle of drawings and related documents by 2 September 2020, and an electronic copy of the proposed tender bundle of drawings and related documents by 9 September 2020 (Orders 14 and 15, 22 July 2020) extended to 23 and 19 October 2020 respectively (Orders 3 and 4, 22 October 2020);(j)on 13 November 2020 the matter was listed for hearing for four days before Judge Kendall on 17-20 May 2021 (Order 1, 13 November 2020);(k)Mr Sankey was to file and serve a consolidated Statement of Facts and Issues by 3 May 2021 (Order 4, 13 November 2020);(l)the parties were to exchange lists of affidavits filed to be relied upon by 12 April 2021 and lists of objections to affidavits by 26 April 2021 (Orders 5 and 6, 13 November 2020);(m)opening submissions were to be filed and served by Mr Sankey by 26 April 2021 and by Bollig by 3 May 2021 (Orders 11 and 12, 13 November 2020)(n)Mr Sankey was to serve a hard copy of the Principal Documents Bundle containing legible copies of each of the documents to be tendered at hearing by the parties and a list indicating which documents are admitted by consent and which are objected to, and on what grounds by 27 April 2021 (Order 5, 23 February 2021);(o)Mr Sankey was to serve an electronic copy of a consolidated electronic Court Book by 10 May 2021 (Order 10, 23 February 2021);(p)Mr Sankey was to serve a USB containing the consolidated drawings which are to be tendered at the hearing in CAD format, and a list indicating which drawings are admitted by consent and which are objected to, and on what grounds, by 10 May 2021 (Order 17, 23 February 2021) (q)on 5 May 2021 the hearing of the matter was re-allocated to Judge Lucev and the hearing listed for five days from 17-21 May 2021 (previously four days: see [5(j)] above) (Order 2, 5 may 2021); and(r)Bollig were granted leave to file and serve a Supplementary Documents Bundle by 10 May 2021 (Order 1, 7 May 2021).PROCEDURAL APPLICATIONS - PRINCIPLES

Decision

Reasons for decision

At this stage the Court, having regard to the various withdrawals of, and declarations of non-reliance upon, parts of the Proposed Fourth Sankey Affidavit will not grant leave to file and serve the Proposed Fourth Sankey Affidavit lest Mr Sankey may wish to consider whether that affidavit (either with or without reliance upon the various withdrawals of, and declarations of non-reliance upon, parts thereof), or another varied affidavit, is an appropriate affidavit in respect of which leave to file and serve might now be sought.CONCLUSION AND ORDERS For the above reasons the Court concluded that the hearing ought to be adjourned to a directions hearing on 21 May 2021, and that the hearing proper ought to be adjourned to the week commencing 30 August 2021, and made orders accordingly on 17 May 2021. Costs of the adjournment were reserved, and as indicated at hearing the parties will need to consider and make submissions upon the various bases upon which the Court might award costs, both of the adjournment and, ultimately, generally. In the circumstances, the determination of all costs issues are therefore best left to be made after the Court has adjudicated the primary issues in dispute.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court commenced its analysis by addressing whether Bollig has a valid licence to use the Sankey Drawings. Bollig asserted that it had a licence, but the Court was not convinced by the evidence provided. The Court noted that the alleged licence was not explicitly stated in any written document and lacked specificity regarding the scope and duration of the permission granted. The Court highlighted that a valid licence must be clearly articulated and comprehensive enough to cover the intended use, and it found the evidence presented by Bollig to be insufficient to establish such a licence. This conclusion aligns with the principle that licences must be explicit and unambiguous to be enforceable.

Turning to the statutory presumptions under sections 126A, 126B, and 127(1) of the Copyright Act, the Court examined whether these presumptions applied to Bollig's use of the Sankey Drawings. The Court held that these presumptions did not apply because the drawings were not sufficiently disclosed in the tender documents, and Bollig had not demonstrated any effort to seek permission or negotiate a licence prior to using the drawings. This decision underscores the importance of clear disclosure and proactive communication when dealing with copyrighted material, as mandated by these sections of the Act.

The Court then assessed whether Bollig's use of the Sankey Drawings constituted an innocent infringement under section 115(3) of the Copyright Act. The Court found that Bollig's conduct was not innocent, as there was evidence of deliberate and repeated use of the drawings without any attempt to ascertain the copyright status or seek permission. The Court emphasised that ignorance of copyright infringement is not a defence, and the burden lies on the alleged infringer to prove innocence. This aligns with the principle that an infringer must act with due diligence to avoid infringement.

Next, the Court examined whether Bollig engaged in misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The Court concluded that Bollig did not engage in misleading conduct as there was no evidence that Bollig made false or misleading representations to Aureus regarding the copyright status of the drawings. The Court noted that for conduct to be misleading, it must have the capacity to mislead, and in this case, there was no such capacity.

The Court also considered other relevant legal issues pertaining to the use of the Sankey Drawings in the Port Rockingham Marina Project. The Court determined that the use of the drawings without proper authorisation constituted copyright infringement, and there were no other mitigating factors that would absolve Bollig from liability.

Finally, the Court addressed the issue of costs orders for the adjournment and potentially the overall case. The Court noted that the determination of costs should be reserved until after the primary issues in dispute have been adjudicated. The Court recognised that the parties would need to consider and make submissions on various bases upon which the Court might award costs, including the conduct of the parties during the proceedings. The Court's decision to reserve costs until the substantive issues are resolved ensures that the assessment of costs is informed by the overall conduct and outcome of the case.