Sands v The State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

SANDS v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2010] SASC 244

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

10 August 2010

EVIDENCE - FACTS EXCLUDED FROM PROOF - ON GROUNDS OF PUBLIC POLICY - AFFAIRS AND DOCUMENTS OF STATE

Defendant seeks a permanent stay of proceedings in the matter - defendant claims it is unable to plead a defence as pleadings would reveal confidential information - public interest immunity claimed - affidavit was filed in support of the stay application - plaintiff sought to cross-examine on the affidavit - confidential affidavit expanding on reasons provided to judge - whether leave should be granted for cross-examination on the filed affidavit.

Held:  Leave refused. Cross-examination on the affidavit would lead to dissemination of the information on which public interest immunity is claimed.

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS - DEFENCES AND COUNTERCLAIM

DEFAMATION - PRIVILEGE

Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Act 1998 (SA); Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth), referred to.
Pulic Transport Ticketing Corporation v Integrated Transit Solutions & Anor [2010] NSWSC 607; R v McKelliff (2004) 87 SASR 476; Woodroffe v National Crime Authority (1999) 107 A Crim R 384; Beneficial Finance v Commissioner of Australian Federal Police (1991) 31 FCR 523; Hilton v Wells (1985) 59 ALR 281; Attorney-General of New South Wales v Stuart (1994) 34 NSWLR 667, applied.
Young v Quinn (1984-85) 59 ALR 225, discussed.
Sands v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd (2009) 104 SASR 452; Sands v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd & Anor [2010] SASC 202; Australian Securities Commission v Carro (No 2) (1992) 32 FCR 427; Sankey v Whitlam (1978) 142 CLR 1, considered.

SANDS v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2010] SASC 244

Civil

ANDERSON J.

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff in this matter alleges defamatory statements were made by members of the South Australia Police Force (SAPOL) in the course of investigating the murder of Corinna Marr.

  2. Corinna Marr was shot dead in her home on 4 July 1997. Later in the course of the investigation the plaintiff was one of the persons interviewed by the police. The investigations by the police so far have not resulted in the charging of anyone in relation to the murder.

  3. It is alleged by the plaintiff that SAPOL published information to The Advertiser or alternatively advised them of the existence of court documents as a result of which The Advertiser published stories on 28 February 2004 and 3 March 2004. In addition there was a press conference on 3 March in which the media were advised of an affidavit sworn by Detective Keane.

  4. The articles and press conference relate to the actions taken by the police under the Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Act 1998 (SA) in the course of investigating the murder. At the press conference Detective Superintendent Symons made statements related to Mr Keane’s affidavit and referred to information which was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sands v The State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sands v The State of South Australia involves a dispute where the plaintiff, Sands, seeks to cross-examine a defendant on an affidavit that was filed in support of a stay application. The defendant, the State of South Australia, argues that allowing cross-examination would lead to the disclosure of confidential information protected by public interest immunity. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had established a need for cross-examination on the filed affidavit and whether such cross-examination would lead to the disclosure of confidential information. The court had to balance the plaintiff's right to a fair trial against the public interest in maintaining the confidentiality of certain information.

The court found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated a legitimate need for cross-examination on the affidavit. The topics identified by the plaintiff for cross-examination were likely to lead to the disclosure of confidential information that the defendant sought to protect. The court noted that the issues could be adequately addressed through submissions without necessitating cross-examination. Furthermore, the court held that the plaintiff's disadvantage in not knowing the specifics of the confidential information was a common issue in such cases, and the court had the authority to prevent disclosure if it was clear that there might be serious injury to the national interest.

The court refused the plaintiff's application to cross-examine the defendant on the filed affidavit. The parties were instructed to prepare for the argument on the stay of proceedings, and the costs of the application were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
Topic 11 relates to a delay point which in my view is not relevant in any event as the stay application was taken out promptly following the making of the amendments to the statement of claim.Conclusion The plaintiff suffers from the disadvantage which all parties in this position encounter, namely, that they are required to speculate entirely as to what information might be disclosed in the confidential information provided to the judge. That has been dealt with in many of the authorities cited to the extent that it has been pointed out by Bowen CJ in Young that the court itself “may be obliged to prevent the disclosure of a document even though no claim for public interest immunity has been made, if it is clear to the court that there may be serious injury to the national interest”. Mr Trim submitted that it must first be determined whether the plaintiff has been able to establish any need for cross-examination on the affidavit claiming public interest immunity. In my view it has not. The topics revealed show that exploration of those topics would indeed lead to the dissemination of the information which is sought to be protected. In addition the matters referred to by the plaintiff in relation to the topics related to the forensic procedures and alleged statutory breaches illustrate how these matters can be dealt with in the absence of evidence and by submission. Mr Heywood-Smith suggested, by way of compromise, that cross-examination could be allowed in a closed court. This would still result in disclosure, and for the reasons discussed by Wilcox J in Hilton at 293, I do not regard that as appropriate in this matter. I have not found it necessary to go specifically to the confidential affidavit. I do, however, have a broad overview of the information sought to be protected. Should it have been necessary I would have been satisfied on the basis of the information contained in the confidential affidavit that there should be no cross-examination on the affidavit. This is not a case where I would seek more information in further confidential affidavits. That is not necessary because the confidential affidavit and the attachments are in sufficient detail. For those reasons I refuse the application of the plaintiff to cross-examine Mr Burns. The parties should now prepare to argue the question of a stay of these proceedings. I will hear the parties as to the timing of that hearing and any related matters. In my view the costs of this application should be reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J

His second point is that cross-examination on some of the topics identified by the plaintiff would achieve nothing and that the points to be made by the plaintiff in relation to its defence of the application for a stay can be simply made by submission with no cross-examination necessary. This aspect is accepted to a degree by Mr Heywood-Smith.Consideration I have taken into account what the plaintiff says about the topics it has identified for cross-examination of Mr Burns. I have read the correspondence in which the parties have attempted to crystallise the issues and I have examined the schedule produced by Mr Trim to compare it with the arguments put by Mr Heywood-Smith. The topics were identified by numbers. I will refer to the numbers for simplicity. I am satisfied from having performed that exercise that in relation to topics 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 that the stated purpose of cross-examination on those topics reveals that, once allowed, cross-examination is likely to lead to disclosure of material which Mr Burns claims is confidential. The plaintiff claims in topic 6 that matters of “investigative methodologies” have already been revealed. This includes the use of telephone intercepts and listening devices, the use of undercover police officers and the use of DNA and fingerprint sampling. If that is so, those matters can surely be dealt with by submission and there is no need for Mr Burns to be cross-examined on them. Topic 7 is also directed at cross-examination which would likely lead to the disclosure of the confidential information sought to be protected. It relates to the new allegations of breaches of the statutes covering telecommunications and forensic procedures. As to topic 8, these matters only arose as a result of the latest amendments to the statement of claim and relate to alleged inconsistencies with the approach in the Channel Seven action. It is not helpful to compare them with the matters previously argued in the Channel Seven action. I do not consider them to be legitimate topics of cross-examination. Topics 9 and 10 relate to a suggestion by the plaintiff that the claim for public interest immunity is unrelated to the causes of action pleaded. These are matters, in my view, which can appropriately be dealt with by submission and there is no need for cross-examination. Topic 11 relates to a delay point which in my view is not relevant in any event as the stay application was taken out promptly following the making of the amendments to the statement of claim.Conclusion The plaintiff suffers from the disadvantage which all parties in this position encounter, namely, that they are required to speculate entirely as to what information might be disclosed in the confidential information provided to the judge. That has been dealt with in many of the authorities cited to the extent that it has been pointed out by Bowen CJ in Young that the court itself “may be obliged to prevent the disclosure of a document even though no claim for public interest immunity has been made, if it is clear to the court that there may be serious injury to the national interest”.