Sandalciyan v International Development and Construction Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sandalciyan v International Development and Construction Pty Limited

[2010] FCA 1145

Citation: Sandalciyan v International Development and Construction Pty Limited [2010] FCA 1145
Parties: ARAM SANDALCIYAN v INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION PTY LIMITED (ACN 050 293 608), EDWARD JOHN O'BRIEN, PAUL TOM CUBELIC and NIKOLA VELCIC
File number: VID 276 of 2010
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 22 October 2010
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – whether, in an oppression suit, the plaintiff is entitled to restrain by way of interlocutory injunction the payment of the defendants’ legal fees by the corporation in respect of which the plaintiff  alleges oppression – relevant principles and discretionary considerations discussed – interlocutory injunction refused

COSTS – whether the plaintiff, being the applicant for the appointment of a provisional liquidator to the corporation in respect of which he alleges oppression, should pay the costs of his application for the appointment of a provisional liquidator in circumstances where he abandoned that application – relevant principles and discretionary considerations discussed – application premature – plaintiff ordered to pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to his application

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – case management – mediation and/or reference to a Court appointed referee – underlying disputes not likely to be resolved by the current proceeding – mediation protocol suggested by the Court 

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 127(2), 232, 233(1), 234, 461(1)(e), 461(1)(f), 461(1)(g) and 461(1)(k)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 54A
Cases cited: Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Limited (2001) 208 CLR 199 applied
Power v Ekstein (2010) 77 ACSR 302 distinguished
Rickus v Motor Trades Association of Australia Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (2010) 265 ALR 112 followed
Sellar v Lasotav Pty Ltd; In the Matter of Lasotav Pty Ltd (2008) 26 ACLC 1,533 followed
Date of hearing: 15 October 2010
Place: Sydney (via video link to Melbourne)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 102
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr S Wilson QC, Mr W Lye
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Findlay Arthur Phillips
Counsel for the Defendants: Dr C Mantziaris
Solicitor for the Defendants: Macpherson + Kelley

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 276 of 2010

BETWEEN:

ARAM SANDALCIYAN
Plaintiff

AND:

INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION PTY LIMITED (ACN 050 293 608)
First Defendant

EDWARD JOHN O'BRIEN
Second Defendant

PAUL TOM CUBELIC
Third Defendant

NIKOLA VELCIC
Fourth Defendant

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 OCTOBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (VIA VIDEO LINK TO MELBOURNE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Process filed by the plaintiff on 27 May 2010 (including the costs of the appearance before Foster J on 15 June 2010).

2.The Interlocutory Process filed by the plaintiff on 26 July 2010 be dismissed.

3.The costs of the Interlocutory Process filed on 26 July 2010 be costs in the proceeding.

4.The proceeding be listed for directions at 9.30 am on 1 December 2010 before Foster J.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sandalciyan v International Development and Construction Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sandalciyan v International Development and Construction Pty Limited involved the plaintiff, who was an architect, and the defendants, who were investors in a property development venture. The plaintiff sought a declaration that a memorandum of offer was invalid and an order that the defendants purchase his shares or wind up the company. The case included a dispute over the costs of the first interlocutory process and the plaintiff’s claim made in the second interlocutory process. The court had to decide whether the plaintiff's application for a provisional liquidator was justified and whether the defendants were liable for the costs of the first interlocutory process.

The legal issues before the court included whether the plaintiff's application for a provisional liquidator was necessary and whether the defendants were liable for the costs of the first interlocutory process. The court needed to assess the plaintiff's claims and the impact of appointing a provisional liquidator on the company's assets and the ongoing project. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriateness of the costs awarded in the first interlocutory process.

The court found that the plaintiff's application for a provisional liquidator was not justified as it could have jeopardised the orderly disposition of the apartments. The court also concluded that the defendants were liable for the costs of the first interlocutory process. The court cautioned the plaintiff against taking drastic steps that could harm the company's interests and noted that the legal representatives of the parties were attempting to reach a satisfactory arrangement. The court awarded costs to the defendants for the first interlocutory process, emphasizing the importance of rational and orderly proceedings.

The court made orders for the defendants to pay the costs of the first interlocutory process. The court also determined that the appointment of a provisional liquidator was not necessary at that time, given the potential harm to the company's assets and the ongoing project. The court's decision highlighted the need for careful consideration of drastic measures in corporate disputes and the importance of protecting the interests of all parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In addition to dealing with the costs of the First Interlocutory Process, this judgment determines the plaintiff’s claim made in the Second Interlocutory Process. I will also deal with the question of costs arising from my decision in respect of that Process. SOME BACKGROUND MATTERS IDC was acquired by the plaintiff and the second, third and fourth defendants (the investors) in August 2002. At that time, each of those persons acquired 9,999 ordinary shares in that corporation. At the present time, all of the issued capital in IDC is held by the investors in equal proportions. Each investor has retained the 9,999 ordinary shares which were issued to him in 2002. The second and third defendants were appointed as directors of IDC in August 2002. The second defendant is the Secretary of that corporation. The fourth defendant had been a director of IDC prior to its acquisition by the investors. He resigned as a director when the investors acquired that corporation. The plaintiff has never been a director of IDC. IDC was acquired by the investors in 2002 for the specific purpose of purchasing and redeveloping a property known as 28 East Crescent Street, McMahon’s Point (the property). The investors’ plan was to demolish all existing structures on the property and to construct in their place eight luxury residential apartments which would then be sold. The acquisition and redevelopment of the property was then and remains the only business conducted by IDC. The property is located in a highly sought-after suburb of Sydney on the northern side of Sydney harbour. When constructed, the apartments were to have views of the harbour. Each of the investors brought particular expertise to the project: The plaintiff is an architect who was to draw the plans for the development and to monitor construction as the supervising architect and as a quasi-project manager; the second defendant is a finance broker who was to organise the finance for the project; the third defendant is a builder who was to construct the new apartments; and the fourth defendant is a solicitor who was to provide legal services to the project. It seems that, in addition to sharing in the profits of the venture, some of the investors were to be remunerated appropriately for work done on the project. It is not necessary for present purposes to discuss in any detail the precise arrangements pursuant to which investors were to be remunerated. I gather that, to some extent, those arrangements are now disputed. The plaintiff has rendered and been paid some fees for the architectural and project management services provided by him to IDC. He says that additional fees are due to him, some of which have not yet been rendered. He says that, in August 2007, he agreed with the other investors to defer payment of the balance of the fees due to him until after the completion and sale of all eight apartments. The third defendant has also made claims for and been paid substantial sums for the building work carried out on the property by his firm and its subcontractors. The third defendant claims that he is owed further sums for that work.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The final relief sought by the plaintiff in his original Application was a declaration that the Memorandum of Offer dated 17 March 2010 was invalid as being contrary to the terms of s 127(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) and an order that the second, third and fourth defendants be required to purchase the plaintiff’s shares in IDC or, alternatively, an order that IDC be wound up. He based his case on ss 127(2), 232, 233(1), 234, 461(1)(e), 461(1)(f), 461(1)(g) and 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act. Although Piper Alderman had hinted at concerns on the part of the plaintiff that the third defendant (the builder) had been paid moneys to which he was not entitled, they did not demand at that time to inspect the books and records of the company. ISSUE 1—THE COSTS OF THE FIRST INTERLOCUTORY PROCESS At the hearing before me on 20 May 2010, the interlocutory injunction which had been granted by the Court on 19 April 2010 was discharged. An interlocutory injunction in the same terms was then granted by me. The defendants did not oppose the grant of such an injunction. For present purposes, it is not necessary to explain the circumstances in which the original injunction came to be discharged and immediately re-imposed. On 20 May 2010, Counsel who then appeared for the plaintiff told me that his client wished to make an application to the Court for the appointment of a provisional liquidator to IDC. Apparently, he had informed Counsel for the defendants of that fact just before the matter was called on before me on 20 May 2010. Counsel for the plaintiff wanted that application to be heard in early to mid June 2010. He submitted that I should make orders for the filing of evidence by all parties in respect of that foreshadowed application. When the matter was before me on 20 May 2010, Counsel for the plaintiff did not mention to me that Mr Gronsbell-Luntz, an accountant who has been retained by the plaintiff to provide expert accounting assistance to him in respect of his disputes with the defendants, had inspected the books and records of IDC on 4 May 2010 accompanied by the plaintiff and his solicitor and had sworn a second affidavit for use in the proceeding only the day before (19 May 2010). This second affidavit sworn by Mr Gronsbell-Luntz was filed in the Registry of the Court on 20 May 2010, presumably after the hearing before me on that day had concluded. It was served in the morning of 20 May 2010. When Counsel for the plaintiff raised in open Court his client’s intention to make application to the Court for the appointment of a provisional liquidator to IDC, I expressed concern at this turn of events. I cautioned the plaintiff against taking such a drastic step unless it was absolutely necessary, given that the appointment of a provisional liquidator to IDC might trigger default provisions contained in the securities held by Investec and thus jeopardise the orderly and rational disposition of the apartments which were soon to be completed and put on the market. Counsel for the plaintiff informed me that the legal representatives of the plaintiff intended to discuss the need for protection of the assets of IDC with the legal representatives of the defendants and attempt to come to some satisfactory arrangement pending the final hearing of the proceeding.